All you can eat Fish fry is awesome....thats a 5. Probably…read morethe best in the area. Parm/Beer nuggets good as well. Everything else great for area but unfortunately...that's all that's in the area. (Wouters next door doesn't count...might as well be a toaster over bar) Nice "stop on by" place to grab a bite Sat-Thursday but don't make it a special evening...drive to Green Bay or Appleton for something different. But... Friday is the day you wanna go for fish!

This is a solid family, casual Italian neighborhood restaurant!…read more Atmosphere They have a nice large bar area - separated from the dining room, which is nice! Nice variety of drinks for everyone as well. The dining area is comfortable - not large, but not tiny. There is kind of an exposed kitchen where you can see some people in there. Casual, perfect for a family gathering. Food Something for everyone. Like I said, this is casual Italian dining. A few different pizza crust options - even a Gluten Free one! I enjoy their traditional thin crust the best (but I tend to prefer a thin crust. This isn't the best pizza on earth, but I don't expect that from an Italian restaurant like this. They don't do just pizzas. Solid pizzas though, with lots of variety for toppings. They have some good pasta options, too. Can't go wrong with their baked mostaccioli. Good apps, too! Their apps are definitely like bar-food type apps (lots of fried options). But they'll do the trick. Service Good service - always pretty quick for food and everyone is attentive!

The chairs are extremely uncomfortable. The floor is really un level. The restrooms are right off…read morethe small eating area and there is a steady bad smell. Waitress was very helpful and told of up charges and offered alternatives. Food was so so. Salty so if you have water retention issues, ask them to use less. Burger was extremely dry. Overall the food was just ok.

Literally the best place I've ever had pizza in my life. I come just from Milwaukee just to get…read moretheir pizza. OBSESSED!!!!! bartender was great!

Steak sandwich was really good. Came on garlic bread with grilled onions and mushrooms. You got a…read morechoice of fries or chips I instead got the soup of the day which was tortellini. Soup was filling and had lots of tortellini and sausage in it. Had lots of flavor. We had the sausage pizza and had ordered a pepperoni to go. Pizza sauce had lots of spices and flavor. We had 2 beers on tap as well. Service was fast and server was friendly. Restaurant was clean.

We have eaten there and also take our several times. All our meals have been yummy and the service…read moregreat! The staff is very friendly and accommodating.

People were very friendly and we felt welcomed. The…read moreatmosphere was rustic as expected and the food was great!

This pizza, y'all! I would be ECSTATIC to have this joint near me in Milwaukee and as luck would…read morehave it, it's about a mile and a half from my northern Wisconsin hideaway in the Nicolet Forest. Bear Paw has a lot to offer, including: kayaking, lodging, gear and incredible food. It's in a stunning location, very near the Wolf River. We had a " pub style, plank pizza". It was loaded with fresh vegetables and meat with a medium thickness crust. A crunchy, yet tender crust, at that. I can't wait to go back. Eric, one of the owners and operations manager, was cook, bartender, server and entertainer. He does it all with a smile and makes you feel right at home. I highly recommend you try this place. It's on a stretch of Hwy 55 that winds and dips and while it is fun to drive, is a puke factor "8" out of 10 when I'm driving with my cat. Yeah, I drive with my cat.

We just had Rustique Pizzeria catering our post-elopement reception, and could not have been…read morehappier! Everything was so easy to coordinate! They went above and beyond to make sure we had options for all our guest despite having allergies. They had amazing communication and on the day of, hardly needed a thing so we could have a great time! Afterwards had so many people compliment the food! So grateful we found them and would highly recommend them for your event! Much love from the new Theado's!

Been here quite a few times. Pizza seemed a little burnt and dry. Not enough sauce…read more Was a little disappointed this time. Service was good and we enjoy the atmosphere.

New pizza is good and chicken is good staff helpful Clean…read more,service is great, morning breakfast,lunch dinner and time convince store Hour 5 Am -12Am

if I could give a negative review to Piccadilly pizza I absolutely would. First of all this place…read moreis very rarely open, that's what I've been told on at least 10 separate occasions. second of all, they're beyond rude at ALL times, and lastly they NEVER all of the ingredients to make the pizzas they offer on THEIR menu. That's probably a good thing because the kitchen was filthy when I went in there.

We went with a group and the food came out hot and close to the same time. The waitress did a great…read morejob with the big bunch

Always love their Friday Fish! They have the best fish around, and are generous with their walleye…read moredishes.

Stopped back and dined in, having the Taco Pollo again! It came out in less than 20 minutes, was…read morehot, fresh, and tasty. TV's, games, fire pits, and indoor and outdoor seating. Counter service for food and drink.

I ordered a margherita+sausage for carry out. Signage when I walked in was annoying as I stood at…read morethe "pick up order" spot only to be looked at for longer than necessary until someone finally told me I needed to go to the "order" line. Pizza was good, a little stingy on the toppings but also there isn't much for pizza places in that area so it did the trick.

i always go here when me n the gng go to DC. get the hawaiian pizza it's so good. usually super…read morebusy tho

Wild Tomatoes in Fish Creek is one of those places where you immediately understand why the parking…read morelot looks like a Black Friday event at lunchtime. We went around lunch and it was PACKED with of course limited indoor seating, crowded parking, people everywhere but honestly the food made it worth squeezing in. The tomato mozzarella salad was SO fresh and delicious, and the pizza absolutely lived up to the hype. We got the goat cheese & spinach pizza with hot honey and wow... whoever decided hot honey belonged on pizza deserves a raise. Sweet, spicy, cheesy perfection. Even my four year old loved a kick on the pizza. Now for the reason this isn't a 5-star review: the service. Our waiter seemed like he'd rather be literally anywhere else on earth. We had to ask multiple times for refills, and the overall vibe felt like we personally ruined his afternoon simply by existing. I totally understand places get busy, especially during tourist season, and we also had a four year old that was starving and was quiet about it with us so we weren't expecting royal treatment, but good service and a friendly attitude really do change the whole experience. The food? 10/10. The atmosphere? Cozy chaos. The waiter? Needed a snack, a nap, or maybe both. Would absolutely come back for the pizza alone. Just hoping next time our server likes people a little more. Solid 4/5.

Best pizza in northern WI. This bar/grill is a must stop after a day of swimming at Newton Lake…read more No frills just great pizza. Service is great. Just note this is a cash only establishment.

is this the place that also raises miniature donkeys? were so there in springread more