Fantastic pizza!! Love the place!!…read moreAlso, have good pasta!! Great ambience!! Highly recommend

I'm not the sort of person that leaves reviews, but the pizza tasted so awful that I have to say…read moresomething. I had the Crazy Italian pizza (take out) and it was the only pizza that I've never finished in my life and I really tried. The pizza was so salty that if you told me it had been dipped in the sea I would not have argued with you. I love pizza. Even bad pizza isn't really a bad pizza. Frozen, fresh bake at home, restaurant... yes, please! I had to throw half of this one away. It was my first experience of Sammy's pizza, and it will definitely be my last, so I can't tell you if my experience was normal or just a one-off bad pizza. Based on my one experience, avoid it like the plague. There are so many better options, even on the same street.

Stopped in here after reading a few reviews. Wasn't quite what I had read about but above average…read more Worth the stop when in GB

If you're anywhere near Green Bay and craving incredible food, do yourself a favor and stop by…read moreOlive's Pizza and Sandwiches. This place is an absolute gem! From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with a warm, welcoming atmosphere, an open kitchen, wonderful smells, and the kind of friendly service that makes you feel like a regular, even on your first visit. The staff is upbeat, attentive, and genuinely seems to care that you're having a great experience. The pizza is phenomenal! It's perfectly crisp crust, generous toppings, and that ideal balance of sauce and cheese. Every bite tastes fresh and thoughtfully made. We had a pepperoni pizza with hand tossed crust, and a mac and cheese pizza with a thin crust! Both were fantastic. We also had the balsamic chicken and arugula flatbread; another winner! Hands down one of the best places in Green Bay for pizza, we look forward to trying some of the sandwiches next time. Five stars all the way! We'll definitely be back!

I've been eating Gallagher's for 40 years. The recipes changed the texture of the pizza, cooking…read moretechnique, and a lot of their ingredients have also changed for the worst. Their fried chicken is totally small. The proportions have gotten smaller and the price has gone up. Although the basic recipe seems to be intact, their cooking technique has been poor. Unfortunately, this seems to be the pattern when a business is about ready to collapse financially.

Gallagher's Pizza West- their food is always an experience each member of the family finds…read morememorable. They have a menu posted on their website that has something for everyone. Our family enjoys their baked mostaccioli, spaghetti with meatballs,baked mostaccioli with meatballs and their deep dish pizza. That's pizza! Several sizes and two types of crusts. They have two dining room experiences, a salad or speciality food bar,a fully stocked drink bar for all occasions, soft music so you can still talk and a courteous wait staff. You can walk in or make reservations so there is no excuse not to visit this restaurant on West Mason SOON.

We visited the restaurant on a Friday evening around 6:00 PM and were surprised by how empty it…read morewas. Upon entering, there was a noticeable unpleasant odor reminiscent of raw sewage. We were seated in a booth and immediately noticed that the cleanliness of the establishment was below standard, with spider webs in the corners and dead flies in the light fixtures. I ordered a Blue Moon beer with an orange slice, served in a bottle. However, the server poured it into a glass without asking, commenting that they thought I would prefer it that way. I would have appreciated being asked first, as I would have ordered it differently if that were the case. For our meal, we ordered the Superoni pizza--a hand-tossed pizza generously topped with pepperoni--and an order of cheese sticks. The cheese sticks were visually appealing and tasted excellent. The pizza also looked promising, featuring a nice airy crust with appealing burn patterns and plenty of pepperoni. Unfortunately, the quality did not match the appearance. The pizza was overloaded with cheese to the point of excess, and the sauce tasted like it came from a can, lacking freshness. Despite these issues, we ate without complaint at the restaurant. However, after returning home, both of us became quite ill, which raises serious concerns about food safety. Based on this experience, we cannot recommend this restaurant and advise others to exercise caution.

This place is horrid. From the food to the management, Will not be going back. I hope they can and…read morewill do better in the future

Neat. Good location... always great pizza! We always get cheese pizza and pepperoni pizza. Pizza is…read morehardly greasy and fresh ingredients.

Ordered customized pizzas on their website. Easy order system. Custom built pizzas and they were…read moredelicious! Our delivery was even 5 minutes early and the delivery driver was friendly and courteous. Generous sizes and toppings very plentiful. Highly recommend!

We have been here several times and always have a great time. The beer is exceptional and the…read moreflights are fun to figure out what you like. The last time we went at 2pm on a Thursday during a heat wave in the summer. It was not busy. we had been out running errands and stopped in for a quick beer and appetizer. Wait staff is always so nice and it was exactly what we needed. They have something for everyone and the food always is fresh and doesn't seem frozen or processed. Definitely one of our go to spots on the west side

Supplier sponsored social hour took place in a private space upstairs. With Berens old fashioneds…read moreat the ready. Cheese curds and lobster and steak sandwiches and do not miss out on the mushroom pizza or chocolate cake or the western medicine cocktail.

Stopped by and was a very nice pizza joint! The service was good and the pizza was pretty darn…read moregood. We got a veggie pizza. I like the sauce and cheese but the crust could use a little something. Had a good crisp but taste was okay. I would stop by and check out Riverside. We enjoyed it overall.

I called and asked if they had thin crust pizza. They said all they had was thin crust. Not even…read moreclose! If you like thin crust pizza do not go here!

Came here with family for dinner before a concert and left with pretty mixed feelings…read more The restaurant wasn't very busy, and we were seated immediately. We chose the patio, which ended up being one of the highlights of the visit. It was clean, comfortable, and well shaded, with a few yard games available that gave the space a fun and relaxed atmosphere. Service started off decent but unfortunately declined as the evening went on. Food took an unusually long time to come out, and to the server's credit, she recognized the delay before we even brought it up. She apologized and mentioned that a manager would be stopping by to speak with us. Unfortunately, that never happened, and service continued to deteriorate from there. We started with the nachos and cheese curds. The cheese curds were actually quite good. Crispy, flavorful, and probably one of the stronger items we had. The nachos were decent, though nothing particularly memorable. As for the BBQ, it was unfortunately pretty underwhelming. Especially considering BBQ pricing tends to come with expectations around quality and portion value. The ribs were the biggest disappointment. They were so dry they were nearly inedible, with meat crumbling apart from being overcooked. No amount of sauce could bring them back. The jalapeño cheddar sausage had a good texture, but flavor wise it was just okay and leaned overly salty without much depth. My side salad was forgotten entirely, and the cornbread, while having decent flavor, was very dry. The burnt ends also missed the mark. Rather than having the bark and caramelized texture you typically expect, they appeared to be stewed in BBQ sauce, leaving them mushy and overly sauced instead of smoky and textured. One bright spot was the BBQ sauce selection. There were several options, and they were tasty with enough variety to complement different meats. Overall, this feels like a place with good potential and a really pleasant setup, particularly the patio. I'm not sure if we caught them on an off night, but between the slow service and inconsistent food execution, the experience didn't live up to expectations. That said, I'd consider giving it another try in the future because the foundation is there.

Picked up some food here on a Sat and although service seemed great the food was quite mid &…read moreoverpriced. Here's what I got: Armadillo eggs: 4.2/10 - really disappointed in these, dry & flavorless coating, and not much flavor on the inside, brisket was bland and there was no flavor burst from biting in. Barely tasted the cream cheese. Came on a good bed of onion strings though. Sat Dino Rib: 7.3/10 -- Really cool they do these on Saturday's and although they look awesome you'd expect better fat rendering/melting for the time cook. Wasn't fall off the bone but decent tenderness. Flavor wise good pairing with their sauces but not really worth the price. Wings (nashville): 8.1/10 -- probably best thing they have, texture & size are great. Got some spicy garlic sauce on side, that flavor is probably the best. The nashville rub is also good but could have more flavor. Mac & Cheese: 7.6/10 -- creamy & solid but nothing out of ordinary for Wisco. Good mac. Coleslaw: 7.8/10 -- Good creamy texture, pretty good slaw, on the sweeter side. Sauces: 8.2/10 -- I really liked their sauces actually, spicy garlic, mustard & pjs were my favorite, made the whole experience a lot better. Their cayenne ranch is great too. Cornbread: 7.5/10 -- solid taste but a little too crumbly. One dino rib, 2 sides, 6 wings and armadillo eggs ran me $60. Even in most major cities I've gotten far better bang for my buck on BBQ.

Delish! Thin crust pizza was delightful - chicken, bacon, pineapple, mmm. Garlic knots were the…read morebest I've had in as long as I can remember. Only complaint is that I wish we had more marinara but besides that.... A post tailgate Heaven.

Went for the lunch buffet. 9.99 sounded like a great value buffet. No drink included though, not…read moremuch of a "lunch" without a drink... Pizza flavor itself wasn't bad but definitely wasn't impressive. I felt the buffet was extremely disappointing. The pizzas they did have out (four pizzas and one cheesy bread) (quite the selection) was pepperoni, a chicken bacon, supreme and Hawaiian. I asked if they bring out any other choices, was told they do but I didn't see any one out. Then asked about a dessert pizza, was told they don't. Salad bar was the only thing I cared for. We wont be going back.