Food wasn't too bad. Nanjos fairly close to those rojos from Shakeys back in the day. Bit pricey though for potatos.

Everything is over salted, especially the potatoes, which are also usually raw inside. Food might be alright if they'd just pay attention to detail. read more

They are ALWAYS out of something, today it is carbonation in the soda fountain. It needs updating. I don't feel the owner cares much for his cash cow. A little love and this could be the best pizza in town. read more

I really hate to do this to a local restaurant. We went there today (2/8/26) at noon. Had about 12 people. Placed our order and found a table, BUT - saw 2 roaches crawling on the table. We quickly got up, went to register and cancelled our order and left. They refunded us - no problem. Local health dept really needs to go look at this location and do a deep dive. read more

Large hamburger 16", large pepperoni 16", large nanjos....around 48 dollars. The young lady at the register wasn't very pleasant. Just a body taking orders. Poor thing must've had a tuff day. Bless her heart. The facility was pretty nice with colorful collages of various cartoons. Open setting with plenty of big screens. Nanjos were awesome......pizza...‍....not too bad? Except the sizes are not what I expected. One of them seemed a bit burned (pepperoni). Pictures speak for themselves. read more

See all

Pizza crust was burnt on the bottom, cheese? what there was of it was in the centre of the pizza, leaving the rest (4-5 ")bare with a few splotches of sauce. the only topping there was a proper amount of was onions. Pizza and potato slices = $40 of disappointment. Money is too tight to waste it on crappy food. read more

As always, the pizza and fried mushrooms were delicious. The cook/server was very sweet and made us feel at home. 10/10 read more

Lily's Pizza - Fried mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - San Angelo, Texas

See all

I love their pizza, but every time I come here there's always something not quite right. You order a pizza and they are out of a couple of toppings. Today their soda machine was "out of bubbles." They gave us flat soda for free, not sure if that's a good thing or not. Only two groups are here but we are all sitting without food. They need more staff! read more

Definitely recommend this place for students living nearby or anyone else in general. The pizza was so good, everything was cooked to perfection and I loved it so much. The fried potatoes (Nanjos to be exact) were so flavorful and crispy and everything is just overall fantastic! The service was fantastic and all of our food came out pretty quickly. The owner is a lovely guy who took our order and even came out and greeted us after we finished eating. Totally coming back here again. read more

The place it's nice I like the game and the arcade but I wish they could clean more and also to make better the food we order the fried potatoes and it tasted really bad. read more

It would've been really good if it wasn't black in the bottom. Shame on them for not telling us, giving us the option to buy it or replace it. read more

great pizza and nanjos I'm one stuffed puppy great service and people thank you and I'll definitely be back

Lily's pizza wasn't too bad. We went dine-in for lunch. The workers were friendly and greeted and seated us immediately. Seats were kinda worn out--but they said they're revamping the place. We ordered a medium supreme-type pizza and it arrived in good time. They even gave us a complimentary side dish! They had TV screens turned on and were kinda loud for the 2 parties/4 customers who were seated there. Overall, I was satisfied with the pizza, but I felt it needed more flavor. I'd definitely go back for the owners/worker's kindness and friendliness. read more

Solid pizza joint and sports bar plus sit down restaurant side to it. Huge TV sets in bar area for games. Just opened up again a month ago after 7 month COVID-19 shut down. Never been here before this vist but it seems they have not lost a step at all. Lots of people coming in for take out orders. The Margherita pizza is huge even as a small sized pie. It's absolutely delicious also! The one of a kind fried and seasoned potato skins (nanjos) are awesome as well either classic style or Buffalo style. Service is fast, food is good, owner Nando is way cool as well. Gotta meet this guy! I'll be back here for great day sports for sure with the big bar area, high tables and new TV sets. Also offer 20% armed forces discounts on Saturday all day. They allow BYOB inside as well! read more

Lily's Pizza - Margherita pizza small - Pizza Near Me - San Angelo, Texas

This is what a 13 dollar calazone looks like. There's hardly anything in it. Would give 0/5 stars. Order was messed up, calazone has nothing in it. It's litterally super salty bread. Big let down. Beat ingredients the box says but I'm like where are the ingredients? Buyer beware: take your business else where. read more

Lily's Pizza - Calazone - Pizza Near Me - San Angelo, Texas

See all

Everything from the food, all the staff & cleanliness were amazing! Nando and his son could not be any nicer as well

Our "Supreme " pizza did not have green peppers. No onions or mushrooms. It was not a good pizza. Our Ceaser salad turned out to be a regular house salad when we got home. Our experience was the opposite of supreme. read more

Excellent tasting pizza! Nice fresh alternative to the chain pizza restaurants. Haven't tried pasta. Rojos are yummy.

Been wanting to try this place for a while, and was sadly disappointed. Pizza was really dry. Hardly any sauce on it. Cheese was rubbery. Crust was dry, and tough. I stopped eating it halfway through the first slice, because it was cutting the roof of my mouth, and had TONS of crumbs underneath it. The person taking our order couldn't figure out how to add jalapeños to our pepperoni pizza at the register, but said he'd just add it as a side on our ticket, but put them on the pizza. He didn't. He was very busy, and it looked like only 1 other person was there helping him. We spent lots of time waiting for things like the side of jalapeños (because he forgot to put on the pizza), utensils, a box, etc.. we were patient though, since we saw it was only him and another guy. The "nanjos" were ok. Nothing to write home about. The wings were really fatty. They had gobs of fat on them! I worried for the poor birds when they were alive! Ketchup was too sweet. I don't know what brand it was... but it wasn't good. The ranch too. Was very bland. Best part of the meal was the Dr. Pepper I drank, and the kids got to play arcade games. read more

Lily's Pizza - Arcade games - Pizza Near Me - San Angelo, Texas

See all

The quality of the food was amazing! Service was top notch and the atmosphere was clean. Nanjo's were delicious!! Will definitely be going back!! read more

Supreme pizza and nanjos were good. Needs more seasoning. Service is slow. They forgot to turn in our order. Only two of the kids games worked. ​ read more

Decent pizza, and the place has potential, but they choose not to serve beer or wine.

I rarely leave a 1 star review, but I felt that it was warranted in this case. Two months ago I ordered Lily's Pizza through favor. I was quoted a price and the pizza ended up being over $6 more, for just the pizza. I understand that food prices have increased and that the price of items on the menu need to be increased. What I find unacceptable is to post prices on your delivery partners website, and then charge you nearly double for the same item. I called to complain about this back in early February (February 4th). They apologized and said that the owner needed to make the changes and that they would work on that promptly. Well, I ordered the exact same pizza today (April 9th). I was quoted a price, ordered the pizza and then was charged well over that price. This is deceitful and shouldn't be allowed. If you want to charge more for your product, fine. But, don't then charge your customer a different price, once they have provided their payment method. This is the last time that I order from this establishment and I caution anyone else that is thinking of ordering from them. read more

Lily's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Angelo, Texas

See all

We went at 7 pm - the person at the counter was not friendly and kept rushing us even though we said it would be a bit. We were new to this restaurant. We should have left for that and they had just burned something. There was no ice and the lady there said there wasn't any more?‍. No ice tea. One of us got ice. We ordered a pizza and nanjo's. The nanjo's were great. The pizza was mushy, no crisp crust at all. Just mushy. Atmosphere was old and dingy. Less than adequate customer service, bad pizza and we won't choose to spend $50. here again. I didn't take pictures. read more

When me and my family went there we like it the a week later we all got really sick in pain. The service was alright their drinks taste funky. read more

Food was amazing and the new owners are great people that definitely go the extra mile. Stromboli was absolutely delicious and my wife loved the hot wings. Definitely go eat at this place if you want great food at a great price! read more

Great crunchy crust and the wings are so good, better then any wing place in town! Nanjos aka Rojos, are so good, try the hot sauce and ranch Rojos! ​ read more

This place was amazing! I traveled all the way from Fort Worth to visit. Our group tried the rojos, pizza, wings and fried mushrooms! Everything was fresh and the staff was so friendly! When you go you definitely have to try the rojos!! Can't wait to try again! read more

New owner has taken over and it's been really amazing food! There are now added tvs for sports, a couple arcade games and great pizza! You must try the "Nanjos", also known as rojos. They taste like the ones Shakeys used to make when they were here. I would disregard the other reviews since that was old ownership. You gotta try this place! read more

Went here for the first time this evening. I've been meaning to go for a few weeks but always ends up being Monday. We got a large meat lovers which is enough to fill 4 grown adults fairly easy. I would definitely recommend this place and support a local business. read more

It's a shame a place with good food is completely ruined by lazy service. Waiters all sat at the bar area talking and on their phones while our drinks were empty for 20 mins. Got rushed while eating our food that was messed up because the waiter(bekim zeka) fails to listen while taking orders. Overhead a phone order 30 mins before they closed and the cook yelled from the back "no more orders we close at 9" would not recommend after the awful service we had. Lazy staff, lazy cook and horrible service read more

Service was slow, food was acceptable but the 4% fee added for using a debt card is a deal breaker. Cannot reccomend this restaurant. read more

Lily's Pizza - Non cash adjustment. $2.50 - Pizza Near Me - San Angelo, Texas

The workers were nice, the food came out relatively quickly, the food just wasn't very flavourful. We had the margarita pizza, all I could taste was oil and a little basil but my mom and I weren't thrilled. The potato rounds were delicious though. We would return just for those, it's a cute place and nice workers. read more

Horrible horrible experience! They have changed owners and the new ones DO NOT CARE!!!! I ordered spaghetti and meatballs, the meatballs are mixed pork and beef. The first ones were raw, then it took 30 minutes to get new ones which were smaller and also raw. We were there all of two hours for mozzarella sticks, a ravioli plate that only had two raviolis in it, and the terrible meatballs. Also they burned the toast!! Our waitress said she was apologizing all day her first day back under the new mamagement and that she would be quitting the next day. We even watched a waiter walk out to slice a pizza for another table because the kitchen hadn't done it... PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, GO TO JOE'S, OLIVE GARDEN, OR NAPOLI'S. ANYWHERE BUT LILY'S.... read more

Amazing food and friendly staff! We had pizza, pasta, sandwich and of course Nanjos. This is my favorite pizza place!

New ownership has done wonders for this place. Lunch today was perfect. House salad with crisp veggies that actually have flavor (none of that bagged iceberg cabbage BS), freshly baked bread that melts in your mouth, and HUGE portions. New favorite chicken parm spot. Games for kids and sports on at the bar. This is everything a pizza place should be read more

We called in for a pick up order. An order of Buffalo Nanjos with Ranch on the side and a regular order of Nanjos. The lady I spoke with was nice but she made it way more difficult than it needed to be! She stated that the order would be ready in 20 min for pickup. We arrived, my husband went in and waited for a total of 50 min and the order was wrong! There was ranch all over the Nanjos. My husband mentioned this and the guy said " you don't have to take them!" My husband said " I've already paid for them!" The guys response was " I'll can give you your money back." No apology, no, let me get you another one. Nothing! BTW...this was after my husband asked twice about the order being ready. There were other people waiting and some of there orders were wrong as well. The customer service was awful. He was not greeted when he walked in and employees were walking around with no clear direction on what was going on. We want to support small businesses in San Angelo but this type of customer service does not encourage customers to return! read more

I wouldn't give it a star if possible. The waiter kept forgetting what we ordered, we had to keep telling him what we want because he'd forget even though he was writing something down. When the food came out an item was completely wrong and wrong dish, and the pizza came out cold. Then when the bill came out wrong and then when it came out supposedly right they charged us a fee for using a credit card to pay. It's really sad the old owners sold the restaurant, because this was terrible and don't plan to ever come back. I don't blame the waiter, and I feel sorry for him, he seemed young and inexperienced, I blame management, the owner just walked around on his phone and didn't bother to check up on us. Horrible experience read more

The pizza was delicious. The crust was thin and crispy, without being soggy. The owner is a great guy, who came to our table and greeted us. Very friendly, and hardworking servers. We will definitely be back! read more

I've been to Lily's a few times before the new owners and I've never had an issue. The pizzas were good, service was fast, and the owner seemed to enjoy helping customers and his employees in all the aspects of the job. Just as an owner should. Fast forward to today and under new ownership and management, the service is lacking and the owner isn't even on the premises. I wish I could say the food is good, but even with the restaurant only 20-25% at capacity, it took 5minutes to get served. I'll just say it this way, it wasn't even remotely busy and it appeared the entire kitchen staff was working. I showed up at 12:05 for my lunch hour. So at 12:10 I ordered my food. I ordered a Caesar salad with chicken and some cheese sticks. My coworkers had both ordered Chicken Alfredo. At 12:45 one order of Alfredo was brought out. It was becoming evident we wouldn't be able to finish our meal in the allotted hour we get for lunch. So, I walked up to our waitress and asked if the remaining food to be brought out could be done so in to-go containers. I happened to notice my salad and the second Alfredo dish just sitting there behind our waitress. I return to the table and 3 minutes later she brings my salad and the second Alfredo in to-go containers and brings a 3rd container for the 1st Alfredo. No cheese sticks. When I asked her about my cheese sticks, she shrugged her shoulders and said, "I don't know what happened to them so I took them off your ticket". Now I have a wilted salad with cold chicken, and no cheese sticks. I left the salad on the table and walked out. I am very displeased with the place now that ownership has changed. This is completely unacceptable. I had to find a lunch somewhere else and get back to work. I will likely never return and offer this advise to anyone I can. Stay away. TLDR: Took 40 minutes to get half my order. (Salad and cheese sticks, only got my salad). On a non busy work week at noon. Never returning. read more