Popped in for some dessert and was treated to a variety of flavors! We got to sample ones we were interested in. The ladies serving were very friendly and answered any questions we had. We got a mint chip and blueberry and a Gorgonzola candied pecan and blueberry both in their homemade waffle coneS. It was very tasty and reasonably priced for how big the scoops are. Try out this local ice creamery as they even make the ice cream across the street minutes from their brick and mortar! read more

LICK - Blueberry and Gorgonzola Candied Pecan in a waffle come - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

AMAZING vegan options. Also, Pro tip: get the waffle cone. It's next level. Scratch-made, hint of ginger, like nothing I've ever tasted before. read more

I love Butter Pecan, this take on this traditional favorite was fantastic. We also tried the Blueberry sweet corn and it was even better. Loved these interesting flavors and the experience at the Garage. read more

LICK - Blueberry sweet corn cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Although I have yet to visit Lick's location, my husband and I buy pints of their ice cream from Moody Meats near our house and WOW. We have tried sooo many of their flavors and have never had one that wasn't amazing. Our favorites have been boozy egg nog, pistachio and rose water (at least, I think it was rose water), and tiramisu. I used to think that ice cream could be only so good - and then Lick flew past that expectation. They have amazing and unique flavors that are too too good - pints don't last longer than three days in our home read more

Be adventurous with your flavor selection! It pays off! Lick has unique ingredients that wouldn't be front of mind for ice cream flavors but they really work! I was so pleased with the lemon poppyseed and I also tasted the cherry chocolate that was great too. Perfect dessert for the end of a meal at The Garage. read more

LICK - Lemon poppyseed scoop in a dish - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Yum! I've seen this place on Instagram ever since the garage opened up. Finally got a chance to try it. Got the honey milk, it was like a fancy vanilla. Loved the tasted but wish i would have tried something more wild The waffle cone tasted just like Cinnamon Toast Crunch! read more

See all

This has been my favorite goto ice cream place in The Garage Food hall on Mass Ave! Their unique flavors make you want to try them right away! I got the lavender lemon and rose water pistachio brittle and loved them both. All of the flavors are amazing and there always seems to be a line for good reason! They have pints that you can buy and take home as well! Parking is paid unless you can get lucky and get street parking nearby. Highly recommend this to those with a sweet tooth! read more

LICK - Lavender lemon and rose water pistachio brittle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We've loved Lick for years, so having a location in Bottleworks makes my life. It's the best ice cream I've ever had! As I'm writing this, I'm enjoying a rose water and pistachio brittle. The wife got the peppermint earl grey which is also mind-blowing. No matter where you choose to eat in Bottleworks, be sure to go to Lick for dessert! read more

LICK - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I have been looking forward to trying Lick since they announced the Garage a year or so ago. About 10 flavor options ranging from more creative flavors (earl grey mint) to traditional (cookies and cream). I got a regular dish for around $5 and split it between Guinness ganache and cedar whiskey. The Guinness ganache was really a great treat. The chocolate and coffee went well with an underlying Guinness flavor. I was worried the cedar whiskey would be too strong, but it also was great and well balanced between cedar and whiskey. At $5 for a regular it might be expensive, but worth the creative flavors, quality ingredients, and a fun atmosphere in the Garage. read more

LICK - Guiness ganache and cedar whiskey regular in a dish. Around $5 - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The ice cream is so creamy and delicious! A good mix of chocolate and fruity flavors, I think everyone could find something for them. It's located inside the garage food hall which can get busy at times but it's easy to grab ice cream and go walk outside. I love that the cones have flavors of cinnamon in them, it pairs so well with the ice cream! read more

LICK - Cookies and cream on a waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Yum! Any spot that boasts a mix of unique and traditional ice cream flavors is a win in my book. Lick, being no exception, offers a great balance of familiar and enticing scoops. I'm a big milkshake fan, so being able to incorporate their flavor menu into a shake was so fun. I got a tiramisu shake & my partner had a cookies & cream shake. Both were fantastic & the perfect size. The milk shake consistency was spot on. The shakes are a bit pricy, but the quality delivers. While we were waiting I watched the waffle cones being freshly pressed -- they looked delicious & like a good option for our next visit. read more

LICK - Ice cream counter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

My all time fav is amaretto cherry and chocolate chip. Yummiest ice cream in indy it's a must visit

I can't stop thinking about how delicious this Lick ice cream is! The chocolate orange combination is the best ice cream I've ever had, and I would eat it daily if I could. The waffle cones smell amazing and were even slightly warm. The cinnamon and sugar flavor of the cones really add to the ice cream. I love that the ice cream isn't made with a bunch of additives. (My stepson noticed that his mint ice cream tasted great but "wasn't green," and it gave us a chance to talk about why!) Everything tastes really fresh and bright, and it's a great treat after visiting a restaurant at The Garage. read more

LICK - Orange and milk chocolate ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

they can do no wrong. every flavor is unique and delicious. i could write a novel on their nuanced ice cream but you should really try it for yourself. read more

After a class field trip to SoChatti located on Brookside Ave. my class ventured over to Bottleworks, and finally The Garage Food Hall where we explored all the different food vendors and learned about the history of the north side of Mass Ave. (Very Fascinating) Like every responsible 23 year old I left my ID in my car, so I settled for ice cream, but settled I was not, I was amazed! I got a scoop of the Munchies, pretzels & chip cookies w/ vanilla ice cream, in a bowl. This might have been the top three bowls of ice cream I've ever had, first place of course is Handel's Homemade Ice Cream & Yogurt. 10/10 would recommend stopping by The Garage Food Hall and getting a scoop from Lick. read more

LICK - Munchies flavor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Stopped here after dinner nearby and ice cream was okay. Not a ton of options and seemed to have funky flavors. Shop was cute tho! It is located in The Garage by Hercules meal prep. ALLERGY: Gluten allergy in party and all ice creams were labeled with allergens (dairy free, gluten free, vegan, etc.) Chocolate ice cream was ordered and was creamy but not super flavorful. read more

Lick is the finest ice cream shop in Indy! All their flavors are incredibly interesting and their commitment to quality is obvious. I have had a fantastic experience every time and I am extremely pleased to be supporting a local Indianapolis business! read more

LICK - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This place is going places. We dropped by their location at the Garage Food Hall at Bottleworks. I was mind blown by the flavors. The attention to detail and craftsmanship in the production of this ice cream is something rarely scene in the Indy food scene. Someone there has a genius palette and a Rolodex of recipes that are worth $$$$. We had the cedar and whiskey in a cup and lemon curd ginger snap in a homemade waffle cone. Im a fat kid who typically inhales her food but I took my time savoring this ice cream. read more

Lick ice cream is the perfect way to end a meal at The Garage! I love supporting local and Lick's is local. The dark chocolate ice cream was simply delicious. Creamy and rich, with just the right amount of sweetness. Their counter has a small display of ice cream scoops including a left handed one. A simple touch that stands out. I'll definitely be back! read more

Tried the milk chocolate and the munchies. Munchies was really good - had bits of chocolate, cookies and pretzels in it. Milk chocolate tasted like a more decedent Wendy's frosty, and that's not a bad thing. The cone was bomb- tasted like it had a hint of vanilla, cinnamon and honey in it, could be way off... but it was GOOD! read more

Great local ice cream shop. They have some really fun flavors that you won't find any where else. I tried the blueberry sweet corn cookie, and it was delicious! read more

LICK - Blueberry Sweet Corn Cookie Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Fast & Friendly Service!! Ice cream well flavored, not as many options as I expected, but the ice cream definitely hit the spot. There were no available toppings and only two cup sizes or a cone. read more

I love Lick ice cream. Their cedar and whiskey vanilla is one of my favorites! The seasonal changes are nice as well.

Such a great variety of unique and interesting flavors. It was so difficult to choose just one! I went with one regular scoop of the ginger snap lemon curd and it was delicious! And massive! Basically what I would consider two scoops. Might have to do a couple mini scoops of different flavors next time. Loved it! read more

This is one of the best vegan ice creams we've had. Some are chalky and others are icy, this was so much like regular milk ice cream that it's hard to believe. We would definitely recommend their vegan cookie butter. 10 out of 10! read more

Tried Lick in The Garage at Bottleworks and was not disappointed. From traditional flavors like mint chip and vanilla bean to more adventurous flavors like Gorgonzola with candied walnuts (highly recommend by the way), this place was an awesome find. Reasonably priced and very friendly service too. Love supporting local businesses during COVID-19! read more

Fingers-crossed that you aren't served by the 'girl with the hummingbird tattoo'. She sighed, rolled her eyes, and gave her co-worker frustrated looks each time we asked for samples (I had 2). I didn't realize scooping ice cream was such hard labor. Ice cream was good but nothing I would purposefully seek out, especially with the hummingbird girl serving me. read more

Some of the best I've cream I have had in ages!! Fully appreciated the interesting and different combinations that are offered. The lemon curd and ginger snap was fantastic as was the tiramisu. The icing on the cake was the homemade waffle cone. Hands down the best waffle cone I've ever had!!!! read more

We had Lick provide ice cream for our wedding, and they were great to work with. They were very responsive, and the ice cream is awesome! We were even able to do a custom flavor, which was a big hit. We received a lot of compliments on the ice cream, and everything was easy to set up and cost effective, too! read more

I'm obsessed with Lick! Their flavors are amazing! My only non-stellar review would be that the waffle cones seem to have gotten thinner. The last couple of cones I had the ice cream was seeping through them. Still the best tasting cone I've ever had! Love the fall flavors!!! read more

This place is one of Indy's absolute gems. Lick is women (sisters) owned and absolutely delicious must have small batch icecream. My personal favorite flavor is the coffee chocolate chip - a staple on their menu year round - and a staple in my comfort food rotation :) but they also have fresh and creative seasonal flavors that will give you a place for icecream adventures when you need them. Don't miss out! You won't be sorry. read more

Ended my dinner with some rosewater pistachio brittle ice cream, started my day with a root canal. Worth it? I think so. I'll be back

I kept hearing "LICK IS SO GOOD", but I figured ice cream is always good... can Lick be that much better? Friends, it is. The flavors are unique, but unassuming, and that TEXTURE. Divine. My favorites so far are the Lavender Lemon Poppyseed and Vanilla Cognac, but I'm willing to bet you can't make a bad choice. You can tell a lot of thought (and love) has gone into each flavor. read more

Love love love this place! The flavors are always interesting and amazing! And the owners are so nice and friendly. They are always happy to give samples at their location in the Garage and we love visiting them! read more

If you love great ice cream you have to stop by Lick. They have some traditional flavors, but most are unique creations they make from scratch in small batches. Love the recent blueberry corn cookie and the peach bourbon - both are amazing. read more

Lick is the best!!! Their rosewater pistachio brittle ice cream is a new favorite. Lemon poppyseed is a close second. Highly recommend if you're looking for unique and creative flavors in Indy! read more

The walk-up window is great, from day one I'm a repeat customer. I got the carrot cake ice cream and the strawberry. I love the vegan options and the polite staff! read more