Circles Ice Cream is the best ice cream in Indianapolis. Nothing compares. There's no physical store- they have freezers placed in several restaurants that you buy the ice cream room using a QR code. Each pint is $13 but it's well worth the price. I got 3 flavors: 1) tiramisu: AMAZING. I wish I was eating it right now. This tasted exactly like tiramisu. The subtle coffee flavor was perfect. The crumble throughout the pint made every bite taste like actual tiramisu cake. 2) peppermint bark: the PERFECT amount of peppermint flavor. It was so rich and soft. The crushed candy cane on top (and throughout the whole pint) made for a nice flavorful crunch. 3) Mexican wedding cake: what made this flavor perfect is that there was actual dulce de leche & cake crumbles in the pint. It was so sweet and every bite had enough of the toppings. Their flavors are so unique and they are always coming out with new ones. I definitely recommend anyone living in Indy to try it! read more

See all

This local ice cream is so good! My husband became aware of this local ice cream on social media. They have some seasonal flavors that we really wanted to try. Once we looked at their website, we realized there were tons of flavors that looked delicious. One interesting thing is that they have standalone freezers in different businesses all over Indianapolis. You can go and scan and pay online, see these attached photos for one of the freezers at hotel tango in Zionsville. If you look at their website or social media, you can find out all the locations of the freezers. I am not sure if they have an actual location elsewhere. We have tried the seasonal carrot cake ice cream, which was the best ice cream I have literally ever had! It had tons of toppings and layers of cream cheese icing throughout the pint. We also tried banoffee pie, which was really good. I believe the cost was $13 per pint. I know it sounds a little expensive, but totally worth it and I love supporting a local business. read more

See all

Some of the best ice cream I've ever had! As I have gotten older I've realized I have an intolerance to dairy. I was thrilled when I saw that Circles made a dairy free option. The chai pistachio was so delicious! Thank you Circles for making some incredible ice cream! read more

Circles Ice Cream - Chai with pistachio. So delicious! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Honestly I dream about this ice cream! Not gonna lie, I am a girl who tries to watch her calories but when it comes to Circles Ice Cream I don't even think twice! This ice cream is worth it!! I got to try Circles Ice Cream for the first time two years ago at the Yelp Christmas Bazzar, after that it was a done deal and I was hooked. I love the creative flavors Wes and his team comes up with and it's always exciting when they collaborate with other local Indy restaurant/food locations. You won't find this ice cream in a store, they deliver to you on Saturday. Pre-COVID he would sometimes set up shop at Hotel Tango or other locations around town and you could buy pints, and I'm sure that will come back one day. I'm not a chocolate lover so I have stayed away from those flavors, otherwise I would say everything is incredible! (I know chocolate lovers love those flavors as well, or so my family members who have become hooked have told me) Come Christmas time you NEED to get Gingerbread as it is one of my top 3 flavors. Next in that list is Mexican Wedding Cake, and then after that it is currently a toss up between Strawberry PB&J and Blueberry Muffin! However there are still many flavors I haven't tried. Anyways do yourself a favor and buy this incredible ice cream for the next Saturday delivery! read more

Circles Ice Cream - Lemon Meringue Pie! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I'm addicted. I only get Circles icecream now. My favorite flavors so far are the Creamsicle Cheesecake, Coffee Milk. Pretzel Toffee. They've had a few coffee ones that ate great too, Coffee Cake Crumble and Tiramisu. They have a new setup at Wildwood Market where you can go in to the icecream case on the left of the store and scan a QR code to pay, pull out what you bought, and leave. It feels mischievous but you know you paid! Haha. Follow their Instagram to get sneak peeks on upcoming flavors and when they drop new loads at Wildwood. read more

See all

There's a lot of great ice cream in Indy -- heck, in the Midwest -- but I'm not sure there's one that's better than Circles. Circles has perfected a dense, layered ice cream that is both decadent and innovative. Every flavor is a winner, and the seasonal rotations are always augmented by new creations. One of the best things about Circles is the way you get it. Freezers can be found at local grocery stores, bodegas, even distilleries like Hotel Tango. You just scan a QR code, grab the pint you want, pay for it, and off you go. Circles used to be a delivery-only operation, and this method makes way more sense. Circles also does incredible dairy-free ice cream -- I usually don't even know it's dairy-free. If you haven't given it a try, the price point can sometimes scare people off, but it's absolutely worth every penny. read more

Wow!!! I found out about them on social media and that also helped me find where they are located. It's confusing because when you map them it brings you to a store only open on weekends. So follow them on Instagram and they will post a story or post about where they put a cooler full of amazing ice cream or where they restocked. I have gotten watermelon sugar high and cookie milk and they were delicious!!!! They have layers of extra toppings throughout and come in cute pints you can take home. You buy them using a QR code on the cooler. Go get some! read more

Circles Ice Cream - Cookie milk (right) and watermelon sugar high (left) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Circles is my shizzzzzz! Ice cream and local businesses are two of my all time favorite things so I was immediately drawn to Circles. I first tried a few flavors at a Yelp event and was instantly impressed with the quality of the mix-ins. They were just as flavorful and well-made as the ice cream itself and added the right textures to make each spoonful more addicting than the last. The collabs with other local businesses like Hotel Tango, Tinker Coffee Co., and New Fangled Confections make this the ice cream of choice for Indy lovers. I've tried several flavors by now and am always blown away. The creativity and quality demonstrated by the makers behind Circles exceeds that of Ben and Jerry's... I'm not kidding, it's that good. The packaging of the pints and the social media presence is also super trendy and eye-catching. I only wish it was easier to get your hands on a pint since it's not sold in stores (yet?). They do offer delivery on many Saturdays, but I haven't tried that yet. They occasionally have pick up days at Wildwood Market and at events like the Yelp Bazaar and other makers' markets. I'm proud to be a supporter of Circles and can't wait to watch this business grow! read more

I was sold after the first bite. Pretzel toffee is my dream flavor and tastes like it was made just for me. The little pockets of honey in the cornbread and honey really got me and I can't get enough of them! Sweet potato pie is another flavor that I don't think you can get anywhere else and it's worth a try for something unique. Visit circles website to schedule a delivery or pickup! It's so easy and Wes does an amazing job of figuring out something that fits your schedule! I picked mine up at Wildwood market and it was SO convenient. I can't wait to see what new and exciting flavors circles comes out with, especially for the winter! read more

See all

One word: creative. I get excited when I see flavors that I've never heard of. Circles Ice Cream does a great job of constantly creating inventive flavors, while also making them flavors that you actually want to purchase. Some of my faves: - Hot Chocolate (there's a touch of pepper in the flavor that leaves your mouth feeling warm) - Thai Peanut (a hot twist on a classic peanut butter flavor) - Coffee Cake (featuring Tinker Coffee beans - mmmm so yummy) - Carrot Cake (chunks of cake, creamy base, mmmm again) AND MY FAVORITE OF ALL FAVORITES: - Peach and Biscuits: chunks of peach + chunks of homemade biscuits= joy in your mouth The owner Wes is super passionate and even does door delivery on various days - check 'em out! They currently sell at Wildwood Market in Fountain Square. read more

Circles Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

First, do yourself a favor and scroll through all of the photos on this page. Pretty captivating, amirite? Second, get your butt to Wildwood or Tyner Pond Market and buy a pint of Circles Ice Cream, maybe two. Third, sing your praises about this sweet biz on a social media platform. The world needs to know just how good ice cream can be. read more

Top 5 favorite ice creams I've had in my life. Period. S'mores campfire, yes. COOKIE MILK, YAS. key lime pie.... In the words of my friend, "it'll make your tongue slap your brain" and I think it did. Truly amazing ice cream. Only downside is the price so be prepared to pay more for a pint than usual. But it is worth it. Key lime pie and cookie milk is a must. Thank you. read more

Forgot to take a picture of my ice cream but it was amazing!! The campfire smores is an amazing flavor and so is the coffee cake crumble. I used their instagram to find local shops that have the freezers with pints! read more

Slapping. I'm not sure if there's a better level above that but it is my fave ice cream in the world. Above Ben an Jerry's, Graeters, Humphrey Slocombe, Bi Rite, Salt and Straw...if you haven't heard of the last three y'all need to get out more. Don't spend it on ice cream...go traveling. My fave so far is puppy chow. I like my ice cream full of stuff. So if you don't, this ain't the ice cream for you. read more

Wow. It's the most basic level of excitement I could give but also simply states how I felt about my ice cream. WOW. Not only was the online ordering process a breeze, Wes was super helpful and accommodating when i needed to slightly amend the delIvery window it was no issue whatsoever. Oh, and also - no delivery fee! Don't balk at the price tag, it is SO worth it. I got the special collab with Indy Dough (Cardamom Doughnut!) and the Coffee Cake Crumble. Both are truly an amazing flavor profile with the toppings mixed throughout. I cannot wait to order more! Sold at Wildwood Market and Tyner Pond. read more

Circles Ice Cream is, hands down, my new favorite locally made ice cream. As of this writing, they are currently offered for sale at Wildwood Market in Fountain Square but they are delivering on certain days of the week and looking/hoping to expand into other markets around the Circle City soon. That being said, if you get a chance to meet the owner, Wes, say hey and get to know more about his passion for his products. It'll make you fall in love with the ice cream even more. Everyone has their own flavor profile, but my favorites have been the Coffee Cake Crumble, White Chocolate Pretzel, the Peaches and Biscuits, and the Carrot Cake. Honestly, they're all amazing. Even if one doesn't sound like something you'd like, give it a shot cause you'll probably enjoy it. Oh, don't forget the peanut butter and dark chocolate: deliciously salty, creamy, and rich all at the same time. Other reasons to love Circles: - minimal Ingredients so you know absolutely what everything is that's going into the products; - Wes's passion for ice cream shines through; - the creative flavors; - the branding (can I get one of those sweat/t-shirts please?!) - everything that goes into the ice creams are homemade (aside from when there's a partnership, ie Tinker Coffee) - they're all insanely delicious. If you see them on the shelves, try them! The price tag can seem a bit hefty at first but you'll quickly realize how yummy they are and can't stop after taking the first bite. read more

See all

Hands down- the Cookie Milk ice cream is the best ice cream in Indianapolis. $12 may seem like a high price, but it is a wonderful special treat and nothing beats supporting local business! read more

Some of the best ice cream I've ever had! They had a pop up at Metazoa Brewing Company, and I got to try their Cookie Milk and Bourbon Apple Pie flavors. Highly recommend both! Kind of pricey, but definitely worth it for the quality of the product. I'm looking forward to trying more flavors in the future read more

Ice cream delivery. Something I only dreamed of, has finally become a wonderful reality. I have been following Circles on Instagram for months, drooling over the flavors and ice cream magic they've been creating. I finally decided to take the plunge and order this bespoke delicacy. I ordered the Cookie Monster and s'mores for home delivery. I was counting the days, minutes, and hours until the confections were at my door. I got a text a few moments before delivery and paid via card when Wes arrived. I swear he appeared from thin air, I saw no vehicle, and his cooler was empty but for my two pints. Not even an ice pack, and still they were frozen solid. I don't know how they do it, but they make amazing ice cream. Their Instagram doesn't convey the creamy deliciousness properly- and the photos are great! Both pints were gone by Tuesday, and my husband and I barely shared with our sweets obsessed 3 year old. Though, when the Cookie Monster was all gone he did sit on the kitchen floor and cry. I wanted to do the same, but was able to restrain myself. I believe we will order these treats again very soon, worth the price! read more

Game. Changer. I can't even with how delicious this ice cream is. There is a lot of good ice cream in this city - heck, even the cheap stuff is good-ish; so for ice cream to be great, it has to be really special. I was introduced to Wes and Circles at a Yelp Elite event, but loved it so much I followed up and placed an order of my own. Circle is a small, handmade batch ice cream company, so while they don't have a storefront, they deliver most places in Indy once a week! Who doesn't want delivered ice cream? Bye bye, diet! Their flavors are incredible, and each type I have tried has blown me away. Between the creamy, quality ice cream, and interesting, unique crunchy layers of yummy goodness (cornbread with honey, crumble with coffee cake, etc.), my mouth and my mind are one big ball of impressed. read more

Saw the interview with the local owner on TV and LOVE supporting local businesses. So, I placed an order that same day. Their menu has very unique & creative flavor pairings. Their cream has a very smooth, consistent taste. However, the add-ins fall short. I was so excited to try their Peanut Butter and Strawberry Jam ice cream. What I got was a pint of great ice cream and a layer of peanut butter and strawberry jam on top. So, once I ate past the "add-in cap" I had a pint of vanilla ice cream. Had they swirled the add-ins in the ice cream it would have been a much different experience. This seems like a small thing to bring up but at $12 a pint there's a level of expectation that surpasses good vanilla ice cream. read more

My wife and I had Circles for the first time last night, and oh my goodness, it is amazing!!! We elected to get the Penguin, and honestly it was some of the best ice cream we've ever had. It featured black chocolate ice cream, white chocolate ganache, and salted chocolate cookie dust. Each part complimented each other perfectly, especially the salted chocolate cookie dust. $12 a pint should yield such positive eats, and in this case it certainly did. Based off the other reviews on here and the experience we had last night, Circles will be on our ice cream rotation in the future. Great stuff and can't wait to try more! read more

I can't recommend Circles highly enough. I am not being hyperbolic when I say this is the best ice cream in the Circle City. What I love most, is how they balance the sweet flavors with a touch of salt. The crumbles are perfectly proportioned in each pint, so just when you are bummed that you've eaten them all...you reach a new layer and there are more. The unique, yet familiar flavors are another draw. I hope they are able to open a storefront in the near future because this ice cream is phenomenal. I am truly passionate about Circle Ice Cream. read more

Ok. This ice cream is legit delicious. Just picked some up at the Yelp Bazaar yesterday. My husband and I tried a couple samples at the Bazaar and we couldn't wait to take our pints home to have more! The flavors we chose were the Peppermint Bark and the Bourbon Apple Pie. Sweet baby Jesus this is some good ice cream. I love Peppermint ice cream during the holidays and their Peppermint Bark is the BEST I've had! It's really cool you can have it delivered! With the holidays coming up, I definitely want to get the Peppermint again for family to try. The one downside is that it's pretty expensive. I'm a little bougie when it comes to food and I don't mind spending money on something delicious, but I think $12/pint is a little pricey for ice cream. But I guess if they deliver it, that's not a bad price. I forgot to ask if they have a delivery fee or how that process works. I checked out their website and couldn't find any info on it. Anyway, it is awesome. You should try it! read more

Innovative, delicious flavors! I can't remember where I first sampled Circles Ice Cream but I am a bonafide stalker Follow Circles on social media to find out their current flavors and upcoming events. Once you're hooked, Wes makes it easy to become a regular with his home delivery! Coffee Cake Crumble, Lemon Meringue Pie, Caramel Brownie...and the return of the holiday flavor, Peppermint Bark is the holiday flavor I am counting down the days for! Check them out! read more

Local, small batch ice cream, delivered to your door should I even say more? Yes I will because Circles deserves so much praise. First, the owner Wes is such a nice guy and a hard worker. It makes me love his ice cream even more. He often switches up his menu so that's super fun! I think my favorite has been this salty cornbread honey ice cream he did during the fall. It was so good! I've had a lot of his flavors and it's always a treat. Can't wait to see him expand in the future! read more

Literally worth EVERY calorie! The owner Wes said I was out of their delivery area but he would still deliver to me after he was done with his other deliveries, umm that is beyond amazing and just awesome. So far the carrot cake and cookie milk have been " tested" lol and they are definitely going back in the freezer wrapped in a broccoli bag. Give it a try, you will not be disappointed read more

Just had this ice cream for the first time day and OMG!! Its so good!!! Had the smores and blueberry muffin. Just WOW!! They deliver it and text to make sure the drop off time is still good, then to let you know they are on the way, then to tell you it was dropped off. So awesome! read more

Phenomenal Ice cream! The best I've had in Indianapolis for sure. Worth the $$$!! Locally made and beyond delicious.

I had the opportunity to sample 5 flavors and I really have to say that hands down the ice cream was the best I've ever had. I consider myself to be somewhere of an ice cream snob and there's really only one or two brands I'll even consider getting from the store and Circles' flavor just puts the rest of these high-end ice cream makers to shame. 100% worth your time, attention, and dollars. read more

This ice cream is amazing! The first time I had it was an event with hotel tango. It was a 4 birds bakery cookie (best cookies on town) topped with their coffee cake crumble ice cream. It was too die for and I knew I'd have to get my hands on this stuff again. We just went to one of their pop-up shops at the Hot Room yoga downtown and were able to sample the 3 flavors they had tonight- coffee cake crumble, lemon meringue pie and cookie milk. All of them were so tasty but we went with a pint of the cookie milk. I am blown away by the amount of cookie crumbles through the whole pint. The top of it was covered with a layer of crunch, salty cookie crumbles but there were also huge pockets of the delicious crunchiness throughout the whole thing so no bite was lacking the delicious flavor. Half way through the pint there is basically another whole layer of crumble!! Hands down my favorite local ice cream and willing to splurge on this delicacy. read more

Circles Ice Cream - Half way through the cookie milk pint and still so many toppings! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana