Quick update on Leo's: one of my favorite parts is getting their weekly Sunday emails with coupons. This week's buy one, get one tacos for Cinco de Mayo was an easy win. Two decent-sized tacos for just ~$9 felt like a solid deal. Nothing overly special, but it made for a fun, stress-free dinner and was surprisingly filling. They did forget the tomatoes on the side, but it wasn't a big deal. Staff was very friendly both on the phone and during pickup in the takeout area. read more

See all

We just wanted simple personal pizzas and other places didn't offer those. We just moved so we tried this. The personal pizzas are good size but the pizza itself isn't good. Taste like salty dry cardboard. The chicken fingers are big but they are terrible. They're SOOOO salty which makes it unenjoyable. To make it worse they didn't offer just a small side or small order of fingers. You had to get the whole dinner. Waste of money. We'll be trying other places around town instead. 2nd star is because they had personal size. Otherwise, pass. read more

The most amazing hot subs! Love eating here! The Italian sausage and the Royal sub is the best.

Use to like Leo''s but the last 2 Times the pizza was horrible. Almost no sauce three weeks ago. I called told them I'm going to give you another chance put some sauce on the pizza. My son went to pick it up and was made with wrong ingredients. Management tried to make it up by saying you can have both sheets one price. The sheet was taken home and was slop. The mis-made one was actually better. You couldn't pull a slice apart without loosing toppings. It was all grease. I couldn't believe how bad the pizzas were. Lost my business at the EA location for sure. read more

Went to the Lancaster Location never again ! Not the place for Wings on Monday!!!! 50cent wings were really bad ,1 order was freezer burned completely dried out and the smallest I have ever been served , The second order was not good either , You cant serve product that you can see is freezer burn and they need to be cooked better paid my tab but not going back yuck read more

Leo's was so good, first of all our food great, the cheese on my pizza was stretchy and warm, second the drinks, very refreshing and PERFECT, third the service was great, our waitress Olivia, super quick , kind and AWSOME, Olivia was on of the BEST waitresses. Also gave her a $12 tip for service. They really deserve a 5 star review. read more

Solid pizza shop serving the south towns area, with really friendly staff. Consistently puts out some of the best pizza, subs , etc you can get in East Aurora/Elma/Holland, et. To go orders are quickly ready and even if you stop by for a beer and a couple slices to go, they can have out the door in 15 mins. They've def had some issues with the product in the past but I'm purposely leaving a review today to acknowledge that they've been on point in the last 6 months to a year and us villagers are lucky to have them. read more

Just ordered 2 stingers. They were the worst subs I've ever had. The rolls were burnt. The sub itself was the driest and blandest sub I've ever had. I cannot believe how bad they were. I will never go to the East Aurora location again. read more

Calzone (pepperoni, banana peppers, mushrooms well done) pick up order. Cut into the center and a rush of wet runny ricotta cheese flowed out with all toppings to the middle. Completely uneatable. Runny Ricotta cheese was all you could taste. This location went downhill. Do not recommend. read more

Leo's Pizzeria - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - East Aurora, New York

I'm at Leo's Pizza now. Service sucks bartenders have no respect for customers is it close this place down? read more

Leo's Pizzeria - Bartender - Pizza Near Me - East Aurora, New York

Food is okay but delivery stinks. They have the longest wait time whether picking up or delivery. Food arrived tonight after an hour and forty mins. The guy shows and could care less. Food was cold... not doing that again. It's happened several times. read more

Leo's is a great place but based on my last few times here's it's been 50/50. One thing I can say is the service is ALWAYS terrible. I went there yesterday with a party of 5. There was only 1 other party in the restaurant and our waitress never came over to our table without being flagged down. It got so bad that I had to ask the bartender 3 times to retrieve the waitress so we could order, get cutlery, and cash out our bill. The food is normally really good, however yesterday the kitchen must have been off, the poutine came out with refrigerated cheese curds on top and soggy fries; as if it had been sitting for too long. The burger I ordered was great and I can always count on them for a great slice! Thank goodness for an awesome bartender yesterday or we would have probably walked out. read more

Leo's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - East Aurora, New York

Wow! Possibly the worst pizza we've ever ordered. To start with, the super thick dough wasn't fully cooked, this was obvious because there was hardly any cheese or sauce so the bare spots were easy to see. They did put a fair amount of the worst, cheapest tasting pepperoni ever made, on. And a few thin slices of mushrooms. The sauce was super sweet. With so many good pizza places in Buffalo we would definitely not eat here again. read more

Leo's Pizzeria - a half eaten pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Aurora, New York

I am impressed by the sweeter sauce and the excellent crust! If you're in East Aurora, Leo's is a great choice!

Every time I go here, I'm so disappointed by the price I paid, the amount of food I got, and the anger of the workers. The management must treat them terribly. There is no incentive to go here when Pasquale's is down the road. read more

First - and last - time ordering from here. Terrible pizza. . Runny cheese, burnt crust, pepperoini was way too spicy.

Hands down the best mozzarella sticks in WNY that I've had in a long time. I encourage everyone to try these deluctable divine deep fried orgasmic treats from the heavens. Leo's Rocks. P.s. Kyle Brovloski is a little bitch Jew and cannot be trusted. Ha ha ha go to hell Kyle. read more

I have never had such a mess of a sub in my life! The bun is soaked, it's inedible. The whole sandwich is falling apart and mostly consists of raw tomatoes, onions and sauce. Truly amazed they serve this to people... read more

Leo's Pizzeria - Gross chicken finger sub - Pizza Near Me - East Aurora, New York

See all

We ordered 2 gluten free pizzas. One was very well done and the other had sauce and toppings on 2/3 of the pizza. The top of the other 1/3 was bare crust. We had small kids that were waiting to eat so we did not want to hold them off any longer so they ate it. Thing that got me was there was no explanation for a very obvious blunder by whomever made the pizza. I wish I had taken a pic. read more

The BEST pizza, wings, salads, calzones everything!!! Consistently great food and service!! Their staff is amazing too, very hard working!!

Stopped in for lunch. Place was very dark and COLD. Ordered a burger and a slice of pizza. The order came in at the right time, was cooked correctly. The pizza was hot, but flavorless. The toppings on the burger was a mess to eat with the mayo globbed on. Water glass had lip marks on it and we had to send that back for a new clean glass. Waitress was nice and friendly. Won't go back. To cold, to dark and dirty glass was enough. read more

Crappy food cold, soggy and tasteless Will not order from them ever again. The only positive is that they deliver.

I want to thank you for saving my Christmas Eve dinner. I don't want to say what they did but they deserve above a five star. Merry Christmas!! read more

Ate here again and had their chicken finger and stuffed pepper pizza. Easily top three best pizzas I've ever eaten. They also hosted an awesome morning party for the Bills Jags game in London. They usually give away shirts, coozies and necklaces during games. read more

pizza was good subs were good I ordered breadsticks but it was garlic bread there is a jukebox there as well

A buddy and I were the only people in the Leos establishment at around noon saturday feb 8th I ordered a small mozz pie and he ordered a chicken finger sub. The food took over 40+ minutes! and the waitress tells me "my pizza burnt", "Do you want them to make you another one?" We were the only ppl in there!!! How do you burn one small pie in 40+ minutes! His sub was cold, cheese not melted, the wait time on our empty drinks was 10 minutes. My buddy would of ran up that bar tab and generated some revenue for Leos, but the waitress and bar tender thought it was social hour. Wearing crox with socks exposed. What server does not wear some type of non slip or more professional shoes? Therefore , I didnt get to try the pizza and after that experience I do not want to try anything that comes out of there. I mean its called "Leos Pizzeria" you think they would want to impress upon their branded product. Not so much read more

A perfect location to grab a drink, food, or both. We went in a Tuesday afternoo. Tim was the only employee on the floor, covering the bar and the tables. He did a great job making sure both bar and restaurant were being taken care of. Great selection of drink option. read more

My mom and dined on the front patio on Memorial Day and had the sun to ourselves. We both ordered personal-sized pizzas and were not disappointed: one white pizza and one veggie pizza. Our server was friendly and efficient. I liked the puffy crust. First visit but not the last. I'll be back to try the macaroni and cheese pizza. Prices are good and food quality is high. We took home half of our pizzas. read more

Good pizza, needed a bit more sauce. The sauce did taste great and there was a lot of cheese. Cup and char pepperoni is great too! $36 for a sheet cheese and pep. read more

Leo's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - East Aurora, New York

Would give this place 0 stars if I could. My wife and I came in Saturday evening for dinner and the service was horrendous. We were told to seat ourselves, found one of the few tables that appeared to be bussed, only to notice that it was filthy. The table was covered in cheese and there were balled up dirty napkins shoved into the corners of the booth. Not a huge deal - we gave it a quick wipe and sat down. The waitress came and took our drink order. We received our drinks promptly. She took our food order and we did not see her again until she brought out our food nearly 50 minutes later. Before our food came, both mine and my wife's beer had sat empty on the end of the table for 15 minutes until thankfully the other waitress on duty came over to offer us another round, as our waitress was nowhere to be found. When our food finally arrived, my calzone was clearly charred, black, burnt, and inedible. I asked to speak to the manager, who's response to the burnt calzone was "I like it that way" and "we are very busy". Seriously? There were four other tables in the dining room, who all had already received their food order. By this point, we just wanted to get our bill and leave. The manager apologized and offered to make me a quick sub but we didn't want to sit and wait any longer. We will not be returning. read more

If I could write a negative stats I would. The nicest part of our order was Shannon who answered and took our order. The food was awful and management is clearly non existent. The owners need to reassess this location for sure. We will never order or eat at Leo's again. Its sad when management runs the crew, we could tell immediately when we picked up. Negative stars for sure. read more

Bad food and bad take out service. One of the worst pizzas I've had, they make Pizza Hut look good. Terribly sweet sauce and super greasy crust. This is likely a regional taste, not universal. Save your stomach the trouble and order somewhere else. read more

Something is consistently off about the dough/crust of their pizzas. The pizza quality doesn't match the dozens of other pizzerias in the same area. read more

The food wasn't great, or even good, it took a long time to get, the waitress wasn't friendly at all and it is not a place for kids. It's more like a bar these days, with guys dropping F bombs as they socialize at the bar. Its not even a sports bar as half the Tvs just had sitcoms on with no sound. As far as the food goes, was craving chicken finger sub, and I even mentioned to the waiters for the roll toasted, but it was soft as bread, it couldn't even hold the two small chicken fingers in it, it was just pathetic, she never asked us how our food was either, it wasn't very busy as far as other tables being there.idk. Never going here again. read more

Charlotte is the best bartender, she has the best butt ive ever seen. Ive been coming here for years and i always get fantastic service. I also enjoy the pizza. read more

I get takeout from here all the time. Their pizzas are very good and I love their BBQ wings and chicken fingers! I have always had good and prompt service at the takeout window. read more

Moved out this way recently and have been struggling to find a fish fry our family likes without having to drive towards Hamburg/the water. Luckily we were suggested this place. Hands down our favorite fish fry in this area. We've become regulars. read more

Worst dining experience in the 9 years I've been dining in East Aurora. I'm giving this 1 star because Yelp doesn't permit 0 stars. Came as a party of 5 and were seated immediately, as we were the only other table in the dining room, save for an 8-9 top. We ordered our drinks and, after the orders of the large table were taken, our beers were delivered one at a time. The waitress took our order and, while doing so, two 2-tops were seated. After we ordered, both of these tables also gave their order. While waiting for our food, the waitress never returned and we had to go to the bar to order more drinks. The large table received their food and the two 2-tops received theirs, too. Finally, after about 30 minutes, our food arrived and we immediately realized that two of the chicken sandwiches were ice cold. The sandwiches were sent back and came back out less than 3 minutes later at the same temperature. The sandwiches were again sent back. We told the waitress that we no longer desired to eat there. No apology, no explanation. The food was taken away and the waitress did not return to check on the rest of the food. Thankfully, EA has other great restaurants that I'll never have to return to Leo's. read more

I'm updating my review from May 2016 based on my more recent visits. I stopped ordering pizza from here entirely, due to the cheese falling off in globs and sliding right off the dough. But recently I stopped in looking for a quick slice from the carry-out counter and couldn't believe the garbage I was served. The pizza slices had to have been sitting in the warmer for at least 3 hours. The cheese was hard and the dough was like tire rubber, impossible to chew, totally inedible. This is a decent sports bar to just enjoy a drink but there are much better pizza options in EA. read more

This place has awesome pizza and food! Love that I can get it delivered to work and I'm obsessed with their fries and chicken fingers!