We were trying to figure out something close by and quick for dinner and Leo's popped up as a choice. We decided to go with them since we haven't in a while. We ordered 20 wings and a cheeseburger sub. It was ready in 20-25 minutes so that was great! They have their own takeout spot which I think is nice so you're not walking into the bar/restaurant space and waiting awkwardly. The wings were good. I wanted cajun on the honey bbq to try to make them a little bit more my speed. Unfortunately we ordered online and it didn't go through the right way so they were just honey bbq. The other 10 were just medium. They're decent wings, but I wasn't blown away with them. The cheeseburger sub was great but the bun wasn't toasted enough on the bottom so it was a little soggy. Everything had great flavor and tasted good. It was a good dinner for us but I think we'll try some other items off the menu and see how they are. read more

See all

The service is always fast and organized. The staff takes their time to make sure they have your order right and the way you like it. The pizza at Leo's in Lancaster is always consistent and the wings are super good. My favorite is the large cheese and pepperoni pizza with single order of medium or hot wings. I always get the pizza cooked closer to well done so the grease is a minimum and the cheese is firm. It tastes to good!!! I like ambiance of the pickup and order counter. Good lighting from the ceiling lights with a hint of natural lighting form the large front windows. read more

Leo's Pizzeria - Large cheese and pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

Bar service and wait staff is great. Bartenders very friendly and welcoming. Food is good. Great place to hang out to watch a game read more

I ordered a fish fry and a royal sub. Had delivery. The fish and sub were over cooked hard to bite into. Fish tasted old . Sub was small overcooked sausage a few shavings of capacola also overcooked. This fiasco cost me over $52. I used to love Leos but you pay more and get less. read more

Came in with a group tonight a friends birthday, the bar didn't have the things to make a espresso martini, had no 7-up, out of pepper dip, everyone order and I ordered a quesadilla and it never came out, asked waitress she said that it takes longer in oven 10minutes later she says it's going to be another 4minutes after it already being almost an hr since we ordered food had her cancel order!!!!!!! Worst experience ever will not return read more

Always a good time!! Bar staff is wonderful food is great!!!!! Will return!! Lancaster location is the best hands down!!! Nikki Rocks!!! read more

Want to give so much appreciation to Nikki and Carrie tonight! We made reservations for a party of 15 and had to be out by 7pm. They were extremely attentive and efficient. The kitchen staff also deserves to be recognized! Food all came out at the same time hot and delicious. Our entire party was able to enjoy each other's company and enjoy great food and exceptional service. Don't sleep on Leo's in Lancaster! Thank you for starting our night right! read more

I like the food at Leo's, but I prefer the Orchard Park location. There is a nice set up in here, tall tables and long booths to suit small or large parties. I ordered boneless chicken wings, and they came out as regular chicken wings. They were good of course, but not what I ordered. I also ordered 2 pizzas to go, with four extra blue cheese. Thank goodness I looked inside the boxes, because I was charged for the blue cheese of course, but I didn't get them. The server should have checked the food before it was brought to the table. Regarding my wing mix up, or my forgotten blue cheese. It wasn't busy, there was no read for it. I've never been to this location, and likely won't be back, even though it is closer to my home. Our server was very friendly and polite, but again, should have checked our orders. We were the only table she had. read more

See all

A quick stop after work on a snowy Thursday. Wow, you would never know how big this place is until you walk in! It looks like a small pizzeria from William street but check out my pics! They put some money into this place by the look of the decor and 2 floor. The happy hour was great and even the regular prices for drinks were reasonable. We had one slice of pizza because that's how I roll and how I like to judge a pizza-based place. It was good, sweet sauce with tasty cheese and flavorful dough. Perfect "cup" pepperoni with the right amount of spice. A little more expensive like a Picassos or Santoras. Great ambience, lovely bartender as well. We will be back soon! read more

See all

Fast and friendly service with so many great options like pizza, calzones, wings, quesadillas, tacos, chicken fingers, burgers, sandwiches and hot or cold subs. I ordered the large cheese and green peppers pizza, it was hot with the right amount of sauce and cheeseyness, so delicious. read more

Leo's Pizzeria - Leo's Pizzeria Large Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Last night my wife and I were wondering where to go for dinner and we thought of Leo's since we had dined there before and ordered take out in the past. We have always been happy along with the last time we dined in. Service was quick, Trinity is always so pleasant. We ordered and enjoyed our drinks we we waited which was not too long. Our food came out, piping hot, fresh and it was absolutely delicious. The fish fry was perfectly cooked and the sides complemented this dish well. Thank you again for an amazing evening since we were looking for some happiness and here we got it. See you again soon. read more

Worst wings I've ever had, sent about 5 nubs with bones sticking out with my order , no sauce, and look at the size of these wings. This was a flat, prolly 1 1/2" in length. read more

Leo's Pizzeria - Crappy wings - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

See all

I ordered a large cheese and green pepper pizza and it did not disappoint. Pizza was hot,the sauce was tasty and very cheesey.Service was fast and friendly, great staff.They also have wings,tacos, hot and cold submarines, salads,burgers,sandwiches, calzones,quesadillas and a fish fry. read more

Leo's Pizzeria - Leo's Pizzeria, Large Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

Didn't like their Pizza No flavor won't order again. Sometimes their sub is good and sometimes it is not. So we choose to go elsewhere now!

terrible wings freezer burned and very small would not recommend. they had white skin aka freezer burn small like a rotisserie chicken will not recommend nor return read more

As a frequent patron of the Leo's Pizzeria on William Street in Lancaster, I felt compelled to say I feel as though I've been duped into paying a bar bill and tipping a bartender for what is extremely subpar service (if it could really be called that), and not aligned to the previous incredible positive experiences I've had ordering take out and sitting down here. Tonight we came into the restaurant at around 9:05 because we saw it didn't close until 10pm and were out late running errands. There were quite a few people at the bar and at a couple tables with drinks and food. To be sure we were still able to order food at the bar, my husband went up to the bartender and asked if they were still serving food. He was told by one of the people at the bar that we'd have about half an hour to order, which was totally fine by us. We're a quick study and get the same thing most of the time. We sat down immediately and ordered a couple sodas, then ordered a small pizza and single order of wings and fries from the bartender once we received our drinks. The bartender put the order in, confirmed with another person working who was back and forth between the kitchen and the bar... and then we waited... and waited, and waited. We waited until 10pm to get our food -- yes, that's when they close! I had a feeling something was wrong when more and more time went by and nothing happened, and this feeling was confirmed. The bartender come over to us, completely sheep faced, gave us the bill, and told us that everyone in the kitchen had left, so no food was made. I truly feel flabbergasted at this experience. No one thought to check in on food that had an order in? We barely touched our drinks because we were waiting for food, so to be charged almost ten dollars for drinks and wait for over 45 minutes only to be told no food was ever made, I really feel like we were only allowed under the guise of someone getting a tip and a bill. Unfortunately, this really takes Leo's off our go-to list. read more

I ordered the stuffed pepper burger which I was so excited about. The burger came raw. Like insides were RED and gooey. I am truly concerned for my health I only ate a few bites. My roommate got a sub with peppers and onions and cheese (cheese was missing) and he received maybe 3 peppers and onion strings on each half. They only got an extra star because their garlic parm fries were decent. Very disappointed read more

Always great pizza! Always on time! Great staff. Location in Lancaster has a nice bar and fast service!

This is our second order from Leo's. The service has improved since my last review. This was a simple take-out order. The cheese and pepperoni pizza was, unfortunately, mediocre in our opinion. The dough was thick, but it was cooked through so that's a plus. However, the sauce was bland and really a non-factor. The small amount of cheese did not justify the surprisingly high price. In fact, the prices here are quite high without the elevation in quality you might expect from a high priced pizza, such as those from Bocce or Imperial. I also ordered a chicken finger salad with blue cheese dressing. The blue cheese was packets of Kraft dressing. Kraft. Even worse than Ken's. Serving Kraft blue cheese dressing in Buffalo is very weak. They are in my neighborhood and I do want them to succeed, and perhaps I will frequent the bar once the pandemic winds down. But as for the food, I can find better in several nearby take-out pizzerias at much more reasonable prices. And none of those places serve Kraft blue cheese dressing. read more

Gave this place another chance after a year. This location has definitely went downhill. Burnt onion rings. The garlic parm fries were soggy in the parm sauce. All three subs were wrong. Nothing was marked. Over priced. read more

We ordered a small cheese & pepperoni pizza and single wings and were very disappointed. The small pizza was small for a small pizza and it was just like frozen pizza from a supermarket..and the wings weren't bad, but the blue cheese was a small container of Ken's Blue Cheese and you had to pay extra for the celery. We will not be going back! read more

Our first time ordering at Leo's was a disaster from ordering to eating the bland cold food. We'll give it another shot since we always try places at least twice (we all know bad days happen) but first impressions don't bode well for our revisit. It started with the person on the phone seeming to not understand anything I was saying. First to ensue was the miscommunication about the sub. I was ordering for someone else who wrote down they wanted the 8 inch sub. To which there was much confusion (to note the menu calls it an 8 inch mini sub). Then I wanted bell peppers on my pizza and I was told "we don't have bell peppers for pizza" wait, what??? She told me to hold on while she checked. I clarified by saying "sweet peppers" before she disappeared. They had those... I asked for onion and was given sauted onion strings- blech. The grilled chicken was good though. The dough was cooked nicely and had a home-made taste (I wish I could tell you what was missing from it, but I'm not sure what? Maybe salt.) There was barely any sauce at all. Overall it was disappointing but not inedible. My bf seemed to like his pizza more, I think he got more sauce but he agreed it was lacking. We also got an order of fries with the sub which would have been good hot. I attempted to order jalapeno poppers to which was informed they didn't have "jalapeno peppers" huh? She asked if I wanted stuffed peppers. Did I? I guess? Maybe they're out of poppers. I called back bc I rechecked the menu and they did offer both and I did not want stuffed peppers. So I tried to clarify I wanted the JALAPENO POPPERS not the stuffed peppers. Again I'm told they don't have jalapeno peppers. I'm being punked here surely, they're on the menu 2nd from the bottom I said. Oh POPPERS! (Yes, how many times did she think I would ask for something they didn't actually have?!‍) We were definitely having an Abbott and Costello moment here. This all of course was just beside the point, clearly this is just a comical misunderstanding (albeit a bit frustrating) that just demonstrates the need for more training on their end. The big issue here aside from some under seasoned pizza is that they told us 25 mins, when my bf got there, paid, had been sitting waiting for 5 or 6 minutes (while part of our order sat ready and waiting not even under heat [sub and fries] he was called up not to get his order but to say they had FORGOTTEN TO PUT OUR PIZZAS IN THE OVEN. ‍‍‍ So after about an hour since calling we were finally eating and my bf's dad unfortunately had a stone cold dinner (whose sub was missing 90% of the cheese and one lone slice of tomato). It bothers me that no one thought to remake the HOT food that had been made and sitting out for 40 minutes. Any manager worth their salt would have offered to remake it while the pizzas were finally cooking... but nope. A small discount or even a coupon for the next time at the very least... but nope. Do they even want people to return?! read more

See all

very disappointed, food was expensive and quality not there. ordered a cheese and pepperoni pizza. there was probably 3-4 pepperoni's on each slice, should have just got cheese. was told 40 minutes, it was an hour, had to sit there and wait for my order. just be honest, if it's going to take an hour tell me that, don't make me sit and wait in a cramped doorway. read more

This place is always are last minute to go to dinner pizzeria. We absolutely love the pizza and we loved the chicken fingers even more! Everything about Leo's is godly amazing but the price is as expensive as Chinese...... it would be amazing if the prices came down a little or better deals or discounts! read more

Clean, good size place to watch a game, many TV's. Food and service was pretty good- basic comfort bar food. Beer prices need to be looked at - com'n man $6 for a bottle of coors light and other regular beers ? They do run buckets 5/$15 during a Bills game - nothing for Sabres or MNF. read more

Leo's is an awesome new spot in Lancaster! Friendly staff, good pizza, and a great bar list... can you ask for anything more?! My favorite thing about this place is that their kitchen is open late, until midnight! My dad is in the restaurant business and we often find ourselves meeting him out late at night. This is one of the only spots he can get a beer and wings after work. read more

Leo's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

We almost did not order based on the reviews. I ordered a large pizza and 20 wings. The pizza and wings were absolutely amazing. We were told it would take one hour for delivery. We actually got the food in 45 minutes. The crust portion of the pizza was cooked perfectly. The sauce was not acidic and had a very slight sweet taste. We like our chicken wings very crispy. Many times when we order from other places we do not get the wings cooked the way we order them. However, these wings were cooked to perfection. Everything was delivered hot and everyone enjoyed the food. The person who took her order was very nice. Most of the bad reviews seem to be related to issues with people dining in? We were visiting family and ordered. I am so happy they are not located closer to where I live. I would weigh 500 pounds within a couple of months lol. read more

I've lived in Lancaster for years and watched the quality of food around here decline. Decided to try Leo's and I've ordered twice this week already. Ordered Players choice subs... made with love!!! Seriously, whoever's not ordering from here, should be! Friendly service too! read more

Ordered a white pizza . Terrible . Was better off with a microwave pizza . Absolutely would not recommend this place . Beside costing $35

I ordered a calzone on DoorDash. Initially looking at it, it looked deflated but cooked. I cut into it and the calzone was cold. I turned it over and almost the entire bottom of the calzone was raw. Hopefully they will start checking their food before it leaves the kitchen. read more

Pizza was ok but showed up to our house ice cold. We also ordered a side of French fries for our 4 yr old son who doesn't eat pizza and it was literally like 20 French fry crumbs...tiny little bottom of the bag type fries. For $4 id expect more there was not even enough that anyone else in my household was able to have a few... read more

Had a couple Draft Beers some apps and a Pizza food was great service was great!! Great atmosphere as we watched the Sunday Football games lots of Tv's not a bad seat in the place read more

Very good cheesy pizza. Probably the best pizza in Lancaster and not as crazy expensive as good, but overpriced Picasso's, is.

We have given so many chances the last time was last night we were on way for trick and treating stopped at 5 for a quick bite ordered a salad and sub showed up 615 with a wrap so confused on how they screw up so many times poor poor management we live close visit weekly and I give up sorry read more

Well....it started out great. My husband and I went in for a few drinks and lunch. We sat at the bar and Julie was great! Very friendly, and made you feel at home. We ordered, me a burger him cajun wings. Although the burger was over cooked, it was tasty and the fries delicious. The wings on the other hand tasted like a salt lick. We have had this wing flavor at another location and they were good. My husband orders this flavor at every restaurant we go, while the flavors vary in taste, they are good. These wings were TERRIBLE. After eating a wing (maybe a wing and and a half) we told Julie they were terrible. She asked what we wanted to replace and ordered them hot crispy...well Dave came out and confronted us asking what the problem was?? We told him the wings were way to salty and he proceeded to argue.... sad to say DAVE WAS VERY COMBATIVE and this visit ended poorly. Not only was Dave rude they presented our check WITH the wings we sent back still on the check. I'm still shaking my head trying to figure out what happened. Save yourself some time. Go elsewhere where they appreciate your business. read more

Leo's in orchard park was always our go to pizza place so we were thrilled when they opened the Lancaster location which is closer to our house. This is our third or fourth time ordering pizza from this location and each time the bottom is burnt. We still ate the whole thing because even bad pizza is good but whoever is cooking these pizzas needs to figure it out and stop burning them. Other than that, everything else-cheese, sauce, and dough thickness is worth 5 stars. read more

Leo's Pizzeria - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, New York

I have had take out and sit down at Lancaster Leo's and both were excellent experiences. The food and service are outstanding. This place is mobbed as recently opened but the staff seems to be determined to make it a great time out for the customer. read more

Stopped for a slice of pizza. $2.50 slice of cheese. I have to say I'm not big fan of cutting a pizza in eight slices. That makes the cheese pizza $20. Definitely not a $20 pizza. A slice pie should be cut in six. The pizza was OK cheese was heavy and the sauce was bland but over all just two stars. Only because I haven't tried anything else. Will stop again for other menu items and reconsider the score. read more

The food and service here is amazing. Very friendly owners and staff. The pizza is the best I've had! And the garlic Parmesan fries will definitely be back to this location read more

What a shame. A slice of cheese/pepperoni used to cost $3 including tax. Now it costs $3.53! The small size of the slice caused some concern at $3, but now - way too much. Do yourself a favor - go to Good Guys for the best pizza around. They are about the same cost, but the slice is twice the size! read more