My daughter and I had such a wonderful experience at Lebbers Pizza in Atascadero, and the service truly made the night. Nick was outstanding. He knew the menu thoroughly, offered thoughtful recommendations, and spoke about each dish with genuine knowledge and enthusiasm. He was attentive without hovering, polished yet warm. Scarlett also assisted us and was equally kind and professional. It's rare to feel so well taken care of from start to finish. We started with the carrot dish, which was exceptional. The carrots were excellently charred and laid over a silky beetroot purée, topped with burrata and fresh herbs and almonds that fit the dish in such a classic, balanced way. It was refined, thoughtful, and beautifully presented. We shared the Toadhead pizza, a delicious thin crust charred in all the right places. It featured mushrooms, a bright lemon garlic sauce, and thinly sliced red chilies that added just the right lift. Every bite felt intentional and balanced. We enjoyed our pizza and carrots with a glass of their lovely rosé and sat out on the little front patio, which was perfect for this almost-spring evening. This is not your ordinary pizza place. It's a step above, in both food and hospitality. We thoroughly enjoyed the entire experience and will absolutely return. I first learned and tasted this pizza when he was baking in his oven outdoors at Hubba - loved it then, love it still and the brink and mortar location gives him the opportunity to expand his culinary ideas! (Sorry - for some reasons my other pics won't load right - so you're getting only the carrot experience photography!) read more

Lebber's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atascadero, California

Extremely noisy from all the inebriated wine tasters. Slow service on a Friday evening. The pizze were excellent! Wood fired oven! Nice, chewy, Neapolitan style pie Only five pizza choices. read more

Also got the wings which i didn't get a picture of and they were great albeit a bit spicier than i would usually go for but my tolerance is quite low! The pizza was very good, Caesar was decent, cute small place no complaints! read more

See all

This place is amazing! I loved the simple yet stylish décor, and the staff was incredibly friendly. The pizza was some of the best we've ever had. Definitely a must-visit! read more

See all

Best pizza in the county and best salads too! Hidden gem in atascadero! Just Go try it!

We just had the most extraordinary pizza and wings with broccolini appetizer! Pizza was baked to perfection ultra thin crust, super yummy sauce and pepperonis all over with fennel sausage on my side! Wings were served with chunks of blue cheese and pickled celery. A nice crunchy outside with pipping hot meat on the inside. The broccolini was romancesca sauce with pepitas... perfection on a plate. Customer service was epic, and ambiance was way laid back and chill. They also have neat tshirts and hats for sale! read more

See all

Really tasty food. Only reason why I am giving it 4 stars is I have only had take out, and they will only allow a limited menu. They were always helpful, pleasant and attentive when I have been there. read more

After three visits so consistently is considered as part of this review, I whole heartedly recommend Lebbers to any and all pizza freaks. It's definitely quality over quantity when it comes to topping choices. Typically four kinds to choose from each carefully thought out and insanely delicious. Best of all the oven temperature is spot on yielding pizzas that are light, crispy, not soggy. Salads (especially the Caesar) and appetizers receive the same quality and creativity on par with the pizza. The wine list is eclectic and pairs beautifully with all of their offerings. For beer lovers, There Does Not Exist is on tap; best of the best!! Topping it off; service and attitude makes the entire experience extra special. Love this place!!! read more

Walking in the place was hopping and lively. We were greeted right away. We decided on trying the Turfhead pizza. It was good but think I would try something else next time. It is a true wood fired oven pizza with some char marks on the pizza crust. Would come back when in the mood for a wood fired pizza read more

See all

Top tier pizza, salad and all of the apps are killer. Small place but worth the hype. Actually on second thought don't come here... not sure I want to share. read more

Little gem in downtown Atascadero. Not only is the pizza the best for miles around, the rotating side dishes are James Beard-worthy. Great beer on top and mellow vibe all conspire to make this restaurant sing. read more

Been over 2 years since we've been able to get back to Lebber's. Had the caesar salad, pickled vegetables and Toadstool pizza. All are Still amazing. Friendly service and simple ambiance. Must go when you're in the area. read more

Update: dine in, don't take out, and try more than pizza! The pork belly and the persimmon appetizers are so tasty! The pizza crust is delightfully chewy when right out of the oven. And, the service is great at Lebbers. Everyone was welcoming, helpful and friendly. On a very busy Friday night they handled everything with ease and made it such a pleasant neighborhood dining experience. I will be back! read more

Fantastic meal and first experience here. Was introduced to this place by my friend that lives in town, and I was visiting as I am from here. We shared the skewer appetizers, the caesar salad, and a spring pizza! We added on a few glasses of wine and shared a dessert. At the end, the bill was incredibly reasonable. Loved the menu, the service was fantastic, and really loved the overall vibe of the place. Will definitely be coming back next time I'm in town. read more

Visited Lebber's Pizza on a Friday night and it was packed! This spot is such a good addition to downtown Atascadero - delicious pizza, good drinks, great customer service and just good vibes all around. Love supporting local and this little pizza spot is just that. It's small and cozy inside, and exactly what you'd want for a little small town, local pizza joint. 5 stars all around for Lebbers. Can't wait to go back soon. read more

Went to Lebber's recently for the first time. They have some good quality ingredients and pizza here. The menu changes frequently, with some qwirky options. My favorite was an app called Salmon Dip, which was absolutely delicious. I believe I had a Caesar salad which was good. I was not a fan of the pizza I got, which was covered in soggy green leaf veggies and lacked sauce. I had to get up mid-meal and go to the register to buy a side of ranch, for dipping (the crust was very good though!). My wife got a Margherita pizza which she enjoyed quite a bit. Service was fine for a restaurant without table service; friendly enough staff. It has a fun ambiance for adults and kids both, and is located in the beautiful, newly-gentrified Atascadero downtown. We'll be back to Lebber's! read more

Unbelievably great pizza as well as everything else on the menu! Take the time to eat there. You won't be sorry. The owner/pizza slinger used to be the chef de cuisine at one of the best fine dining restaurants in the San Gabriel Valley (Los Angeles). read more

The best Caesar Salad I have ever had. The anchovy and lemon mix is phenomenal!! And the pizza is amazing. Sourdough crust off the chart!! Wish I lived a 195 miles closer. And service and people made it even better. read more

Lebber's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atascadero, California

See all

4th time coming here and continues to be the best pizza I've ever had. I refuse to go anywhere else. So lucky it's close in town! Not only is the pizza spectacular, but had the ice cream tonight..... ridiculous how good it was. Everyone is so nice and welcoming inside as well. Counting down the days until I go again.... read more

Lebber's Pizza - Toadhead Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atascadero, California

See all

I have heard great reviews regarding Lebber's Pizza but of course I had to try it myself. What a wonderful gem hidden in Atascadero. This is not a typical pizza joint. Lebbers has a varied menu that caters to foodies and someone who just wants a quality wood fired pizza and a beer. I tried a little bit of everything and it was all delicious. Caleb, the owner-cook and his lovely wife Kacee, have experience in high-end culinary creations along with quality wine. The pizza was delicious and the appetizers, the sashimi and carrots, were equally impressive. The Caesar salad was spectacular and large enough for two. The casual atmosphere and great service by Nick made the evening special and memorable. I will definitely be back! read more

See all

Oh my gosh. This place is INCREDIBLE! Pizza sooooooo damn GOOD!! And the Charred Broccolini w the Green Pistachio garlicky Romescu is to DIE for people! RUN!! I've been told the Charred broccolini is Seasonal & they're only going to have it for about 3 more weeks as of May 30, 2026! read more

If you think you've had great pizza before, think again. Lebber's is the newest culinary gem in town, and it's already raising the bar for what an upscale pizzeria can be. From the moment you step through the door, the atmosphere strikes that perfect balance between refined and cozy and the menu is a masterclass in simplicity and sophistication. What really sets Lebber's apart, though, is the care in every detail. The service is both warm and knowledgeable without ever feeling pretentious. You can tell this team loves what they do -- and it shows in every bite. Whether you're planning a date night, celebrating with friends, or simply indulging in a perfect meal, Lebber's delivers a five-star experience from start to finish. It's not just pizza -- it's passion, art, and fire all coming together on a plate. We've been twice in a week! read more

See all

Wait time was a little long but they brought us water and 2 cups fir my son and I. Very nice and pizza was good.

Service is quick! Pizzas are truly artisan quality with its wood fired ovens, and the apps are all unique and tasty! This is a great spot for a clean pizza! read more

THOUGHT THIS PLACE WAS A PIZZA PARTY?! Tell you what it is, but you can also drink tasty things and eat weird spindly things like carrots and pickled bits dancing in colorful stuff. Got damn I didn't pay attention to what I ate, but it good. Pizza 10/10. Ice cream to top it off is destination worthy on its own. Service 10/10 I used the bathroom while I was at the restaurant. 5 stars read more

I don't throw around the word "life-changing" lightly... but this pizza has me reconsidering my standards. If loving this place is wrong, I don't want to be right. Also, I'm pretty sure I made eye contact with my slice and we had a moment. Highly recommend. read more

Lebber's deserves Michelin recognition. Full stop, hands down. This place is unreal. We've had the entire menu, and every plate is craveable and worth re-ordering. The team is awesome, and always so welcoming. Will always recommend this place! read more

Persimmon starter was great. Pizza was a little burned for my taste, even for wood fired. Every bite had big chunks of black crust flaking off. Definitely not family friendly, no high chairs which unfortunately for us is a no go. Staff in front could be friendlier. read more

The service was fine. The pepperoni was excellent (would like to know where they source it from) and finally the crust was good but the whole thing was ruined by being burnt. I would like to blame it on a busy Saturday night and leave it at that. Yes I would come back but try one of their other entrees. read more

Oh my! Please support this business Atascadero. We've been waiting over a year to have their pizza again! Very quick & great service. Walk up and order type of place. They've recently painted & remodeled the building, so it's very clean & inviting. The food was so great I forgot to take pictures!! We had the amazing Cesar salad, probably the best I've ever had! The pizzas are so yummy too! read more

Lebber's Pizza - Peeperoni:) - Pizza Near Me - Atascadero, California

See all

Been wanting to try this place since it opened! We were not disappointed! The Brocolinni side dish was insanely delicious, Toadhead Pizza to die for! Excellent Service too This town needed this place! read more

I had such a great experience at Lebbers! The pizza was incredible! Everything tasted fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. The ambiance really stood out too. It was fun, vibrant, and just a great place to relax and enjoy a meal. On top of that, the entire place was impressively clean, which definitely didn't go unnoticed. What really made the experience though was the staff. Everyone was so kind, welcoming, and attentive without being over the top. You can tell they take pride in what they do. I'll definitely be back! Highly recommend checking it out!!! read more

Pizza was fantastic and staff was really friendly! We got the peeper-roni tomato, toadhead pizza, and their Caesar salad. The ice cream was also the best I've had! read more

Lebber's Pizza - Best Ice cream I've had! - Pizza Near Me - Atascadero, California

Awesome food. Best pizza on the central coast. Kind of weird combos but throughly enjoyed the food. Hours are a little weird so check before you go. read more

Hi, Lebbers is all things done well on a small scale. They have a small menu and a small dining room. If you sit at the bar, you can talk to Caleb who makes the pizzas and feel like you have made a new friend...Caleb was called Leb when growing up...hence Lebbers. We have had the lemon cream mushroom pizza, the pepperoni pizza made with locally made pepperoni and the wings...all are amazing. I think that they are open Wednesday through Saturday. Give them a try. You won't be disappointed. read more

Came around 5 on a Friday night and most of the tasting rooms were closing. However, found a this cute little pizza shop that looks like a pop-up with an Italian pizza oven hooked to a trailer. You could smell the wood burning oven and the awesome smell of fresh baked sourdough. Right next door was a winery opened late in Tin City. This is the perfect makings to a leisure late afternoon outing. This place was busy with locals knowing to phone ahead. Our order would be an hour out...no problem. We were not in a hurry. read more

Lebber's Pizza - Shroomy pizza with sausage. Some of the best pizza I've had in a long, long time. - Pizza Near Me - Atascadero, California

Really good upscale pizza! We did the veggie but looking around all the pizzas looked good.

I had the most amazing Pizza meal of my life at Lebber's. The staff, the food, the ambiance... everything was perfect. The owners were so nice and accommodating and they really created a special place for people to gather read more

The pizza was fairly burned and two of them costs 54 dollars. Not bad, but not worth it.

Great pizza and great staff! The pepperoni was insanely delicious! And ambiance reminded of San Francisco!