I ordered a cobb salad and I got something different. Cobb salads aren't all mixed up like a tossed salad but this one was. It had no avocado or hard boiled eggs as it should have. Carrots don't belong in a cobb but there they were! Also grilled chicken was supposed to be in it...not turkey cold cuts. It was passable as I was hungry, but definitely not what a cobb salad is supposed to be. read more

My mom and I dined at Lake Pizza this evening. The Italian Meatloaf was excellent, with just the right amount of spices to make it tasty. The tomato basil soup was equally delicious! We're sure to return soon! read more

Since they swapped out their traditional pizza oven for the conveyor oven, the crusts on their pizzas *always* have a wet, soggy bottom. They've also reduced the size of their large pizzas by a couple of inches, yet the prices also went up. A large pizza has way too much spare room inside their "large" pizza box. There are much better choices for pizza in the Webster area. Unless you like underdone crusts, avoid Lake Pizza. read more

Such a great place to get food, whether it be eating it there or taking it to go. Love their clam strips and any seafood...actually, i love all the food there!! Only problem: time quoting on their take out...one night we were told 10-15 mins and we ended up waiting 45. I understand how you never know when you will get a rush (i was a hostess once before) but still 15 mins compared to 45 is a bit much. still good food though :) read more

The Hamburg pizza is a solid choice. You can't lose with the buffalo tenders either. Service is always great! read more

Ordered from here today for the first time and I have to say I was quite disappointed. I ordered the Captain Jack's seafood platter which came with two sides and chowder. I also ordered a loaded baked potato. Upon opening it, I noticed all of the packaged condiments were on top of the fish. Completely unsanitary! I also noticed my sides weren't there. They forgot my coleslaw and fries. There was a sad looking little dried out potato with a few pieces of bacon, barely any cheese and a package of warm sour cream sitting on top of it. Because all of the cold condiments being on top of my food- it was completely cold. I tried a couple of bites but the food was soggy, over cooked (the shrimp was like shoe leather) and tasteless. The chowder was lukewarm but was good after adding a ton of salt and pepper. Threw it all out after a few bites. The cherry on top was that the prices were not the same online as in the takeout menu. I called and the person I spoke to seemed a little uninterested in what I was saying. He did offer to replace the meal- but I declined. Why would I need to eat the same, dull meal again? No thank you. read more

The Good: Pizza arrived fast! Delivery guy was nice. Reasonably priced. The Bad: The entire thing was flavorless. No seasonings to speak of, probably due to a serious sauce deficiency. The Ugly: Pizza was way under cooked. Still blonde, no crisp to speak of. It was raw dough in the middle, and there was, again, barely any sauce. Ordered a Sausage, Mushroom, and ricotta cheese. The sausage was sliced so thin it looked like deli meat, and the mushrooms were canned. the ricotta was in a few ungenerous blobs around the top layer. Other toppings were generous, but I will not be a repeat customer. Sorry, Lake Pizza, but are you new at this? read more

Food is always awesome, I love the new online ordering system they have, saves valuable time and the order is ready as soon as you get there to grab it I love lake pizza! read more

This was our first visit, we wanted to love it but alas did not. Pizza was very greasy, we will not be back. Locals seem to love this place, not sure why. read more

Poor customer service from the person answering the phone and the manger she put on the phone without telling me. No apology or empathy for delivering the wrong order. Very rude. We will not order from here again. read more

I love the food , favorite bartenders are Valerie and Wendy. They make awesome drinks. The food is always right and fresh. My place after an exhausting, hard, and tough day after work, and out if work with my family! I recommend this awesome place any time!! read more

Lake pizza has always been a GREAT place to eat!!! It has been 1 year since I have been in this area last to eat from there so I am hoping it is extra good!!!! UPDATE- the morning after Dinner was super last night!!!!! & I have pizza left over for today!!!! Yay! Can't wait to visit lake pizza again. read more

My family and I been going here for years and it used to be pretty good and consistent but has been going downhill for awhile. Then, the last time we ordered pizza from here, the cheese was still white, no sign of browning whatsoever, and the crust was barely cooked. You could clearly see that it was underdone, but they cut it, put it in the box anyway and sold it to me. Won't be back. read more

Best burgers around and the beer has ice in it so cold. Pasta dishes are fantastic too

Lake pizza used to be great 4 years ago when we first started ordering/dining in. Lately (the past 10 orders) the food has been soggy, wrong, or we're always missing something (side salad, drink, etc.) it's just not enjoyable anymore. Phone staff is very rude as well. I would go elsewhere if your not looking for a disappointment. read more

We've gotten take out from here a couple times and the price hasn't been worth what you get, especially compared to other area take out places. I like that they have online ordering and the food was ok, but after two tries of paying a lot and getting very little we probably won't be going back. read more

Lunch here Atleast two times a week...great service...nice people...great food. Nice to have a reasonable priced meal and close to work.

Great food, consistent. Nice staff. Been ordering here a very long time and out family loves it. Try the pizza!

I've never once had a bad meal at Lake Pizza. Whether you go for salad, a burger, seafood, wings, etc they've got a good foundation for go to comfort food. And you can top it off with a good Lake Bowl too! read more

Great food bartender was ok more interested in locals than new customers asked for water took a few to get it but when we asked for check instantly also never told us her name makes it easier to ask for something n increases the tip customer service read more

Lake Pizza is basically the culinary equivelant of a toddler wearing his father's clothes. It's what happens when a low rent pizza joint fancies itself as a mid-level restaurant. I have been to Lake Pizza three times since moving to Webster, and I can easily say that I will not be returning. On my first visit I had the chicken alfredo, which was easily the worst Alfredo I have ever tasted. The sauce lacked any flavor, instead tasting like a thick cream. On my second visit I tried the pizza, which wasn't bad. Itn was edible, just not great. On my final visit I tried the chicken parmesian, which was okay. With the exception of thei chicken Alfredo, the food isn't that bad. Whatt makes Lake Pizza two stars is the fact that they are terribly overpriced. For example, tonight I paid $13 for chicken parmesian. A miile and a half down the street (at Northeast Pizza) I can get the same dish for $6.25! There are times when I dong mind paying that much for chicken parm, like when the restaurant uses fresh chicken breast. But when Lake Pizza charges $13 for about 40 cents of pasta, a frozen piece of processed chicken, and a bread stick, I just dint see any reason why I would ever want to pay $13 when I can get the same thing down the road for $6.25. read more

First time visit to this restaurant. Food was excellent. Staff was very professional and well trained. Place was very clean and up to date. I would highly recommend this place to everyone. May have been my first but won't be my last visit. read more

I go to Lake pizza every friday on my way home from work and get a pizza to go. They are always appropriately staffed, My food is always exactly how I order it, and the prices are very decent. read more

We go here quite often for lunch, and an occasional dinner. The pizza, calzones, grinders and such are delicious. Very dependable that it's going to be just as you hoped. The other things on the menu that we've tried, that would be considered "dinner" type plates are "okay". Unfortunately I believe that the vegtables are frozen, and I believe the fries are as well. The fish has mostly been over cooked. Overall we stick with the "sandwiches or pizza" type meals and are never disappointed. I wish they would make all of their food fresh. That would make a big difference on what we order. But again, I can't say enough about the pizza. I live 20 minutes away, and I prefer Lake's pizza over anything in my own area. read more

Our go to pizza place here in town. Lake pizza is by far the best in town. Our favorite items are the Chicken Waldorf Salad, the Wheat pizza with Grilled chicken, and the kids always like the Chicken parm. read more

Last and final time I went here my pizza was soggy. It was like Gandis flip flopps. Everything pizza? More like peppers without the everything. Who the hell wants a pizza with just peppers? Potato skins were raw all the way through but somehow the bacon on top was burnt. It's a shame to see how downhill this place went. I'd rather eat at Marios down the street, they got a prime rib to die for. read more

More like a family style mosh pit with cold beers, pizzas and calzones, throw in tables of people staring at the monitors for Keno, kids running around the tables and guess what? You are in Webster. The only thing missing last Friday night was a brawl at the bar. Guess this is better than most pizza places but, could they class it up a bit. Maybe not, after all, it is Webster. read more

I only give 4 stars because I've only had one item - the lake special pizza. For 16$ the amount of toppings, the quality, and the time it takes to have it ready, I'd say it's a deal! Every time I've gotten the special pie I've been impressed and satisfied. I wouldn't hesitate to try anything else; I just can't stop myself from ordering that pizza! read more

Ordered a pizza delivery tonight. We were told it would arrive within the hour. An hour and 10 minutes later it was at the door, ice cold and soggy. BLECH! I will say it wasn't bad after reheating. Next time we'll eat it there. read more

We made last minute reservations for a birthday celebration for 12 people, not only were we accompanied but our server was very patient with our many questions and request! The food was excellent, from pasta to pizza to seafood to sandwiches! Prices are reasonable and service is great! We are all looking forward to our next time out at this restaurant! Thank you Lake Pizza!!! read more

Yelp reviews right on this one. Excellent food and service. Wraps, subs and pizza were fresh, large portions and reasonable prices. Definately recommend. read more

First time LAST time!!! Ordered baked Haddock and a baked potato with veg, OMG the potato was so dried out it looked like it sat out for a week. the veg was no better! Haddock had no taste and was also dried out. I asked for fries because the baked potato was not good. Waitress brought a plate full but didn't seem to care about the dried out food. I barely ate anything! An older woman was walking around checking on people I assume the owner she asked me if I wanted to wrap what I hadn't eaten, I told her it was all dried out and I didn't like it. She then told me that my husband would it it! No one there seem to care how bad their food was . HORRIBLE to pay $13.99 for their "special" baked haddock that was sitting around for ever is outrageous! I will NEVER eat there again read more

Really good pizza....awful service, awful!....as locals we keep trying this place and it never gets better. I know Pete thinks everting is great, but it's not. He happens to be one of the only average choices we have. read more

I ordered a small meatball sub. It was the perfect size and did not taste terrible but it was cold and so weren't the french fry's my boyfriend got. read more

Consistently good food and great service. The Lake special pizza is a favorite. The calzones are also exceptionally good.

Inconsistent..... Recently placed a really simple order - two steak and cheese grinders. What a huge disappointment. Steak was tough and grissly. Some cheese was slapped on. The sandwiches were cold -- cheese wasn't even melted. I've had dinner there a few times before and although not overly impressed, food was okay. And staff was friendly. What's going on? I'll try once more - but will let them know they let me down with the sandwiches. Maybe they were just really busy that day...... read more

It took approximately 20 minutes after we ordered cocktails to be delivered. The food was good the waitress had too many tables to attend to and we had to wait 15 minutes for her to bring our check and then after 20 minutes we had to hunt her down to pay the bill. Not good!! read more

I frequently eat here and am usually very satisfied until I turned over my pickle and saw that it looked to either be rotting with mold on it or some nice had gotten to it before I did read more

Lake Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Webster, Massachusetts

The place is usually busy but the food is nothing special. I've tried the pizzas and calzones and nothing impressed me. The cheese pizza is barely eatable, especially the next day. I typically love a house special pizza but it's not that great here. I do like the steak calzone but I wish the dipping sauce was better cause this one just tastes like ketchup. read more

Very good pizza. Love there subs. I always get the steak and cheese loaded. Bar is good with some local beers on tap like worm town from Worcester. Very good pasta when you eat in. read more