This local pizza place has a great variety of foods besides pizza that they do well. We have tried steak tips, fish specials and many other things. Their pizzas are always full of toppings. Their wraps are huge and come with french fries for a very reasonable price. If by some chance, they make something wrong they always work to correct it the best way possible for you. read more

If I could give less than one star i would. The food was terrible. Buffalo chicken salad, buffalo chicken was a chicken patty with hardly any sauce on it. Ham and Swiss calzone had lettuc, tomato, pickle and mayo on it as well. Didn't not order a sandwich. Cheese bread was soooo dry and didn't taste good at all. I used to love this place. After this I'll never go again. On top of that it took way longer than stated. Do not order here read more

Good chowder. Decent pizza. Staff is iffy on different days. Always do pickup orders. Delivery takes too long. Seems like most of their appetizers are from a frozen bag and not homemade. Cheeseburgers are not made fresh. read more

Horrible food! I wish I could get a full refund on my delivery. I've given this place several chances. Never again..... read more

See all

First time my husband and I visited here while we were waiting for his car to be serviced, and let me tell ya, we were not disappointed. We got a pepperoni pizza & fries to share. The pizza was DELICIOUS & we can be pizza snobs. The portions are very generous & the staff was very attentive. Our servers name was Cass - she was very attentive & friendly. 10/10 would come back for the food, service & atmosphere for a casual family oriented pizza joint. read more

Lake Pizza - FRIES - Pizza Near Me - Webster, Massachusetts

See all

. Ordered a Chicken Caesar Wrap, the wrap was hard stale and broke into pieces, chicken was maybe 2 1/2 ounces in weight, fries just warm surely did not just come out of the fryolator. Overpriced and not worth the money. As far as for the other sandwich, no where in the same ball park as Golden Greek in Attawaugan, Lake Pizza could take lessons on what a Turkey Club sandwich should look like. $50 for 2 unfilled sandwiches, warm onion rings with 2 $ 4 16 oz sodas should be a crime. Service was good, no issue there. Will never order any sandwiches there again. The 1 star is because of the service not the food!!!!!!!! read more

Lake pizza is OK, it's not as good as Dairy Express in Oxford or Dudley House of Pizza, but it's good. Way better than P&D Pizza in Oxford. I think the grinders are better than the pizzas here. read more

Had a great overall experience with this restaurant. From kind and attentive customer service, the food being excellent and on time delivery for an event serving seniors, i could not have asked for better. Will be doing business again. read more

Tonight we went and had garlic parmesan chicken and chicken gyro wrap with a Greek salad. It was amazing, and I don't give reviews...but this warrants one. read more

Ordered a large half Hawaiian half cheese and they put cherries on it...never in my life have I seen anything like this

There is great service here. I tried the spaghetti and meatballs and it was amazing! i would recommend anyone nearby to go try it out yourself! read more

My 2 sister's and fiance and myself went there for lunch. Service was great. Prices were great as well. The food was regular food ---- cooked just right! The atmosphere is also great, not a tone of loud music so you CAN hear the person sitting across from you! Good for to our table hot and yummy. We will definitely becoming back to eat here!! read more

Not too much to say. I didn't like their pizza at all. The sauce tasted like it just came out of the can. I ordered a grilled chicken pizza & the chicken was very dried out. So I figured I would give them a second chance. Because everybody has a bad day here and there. But unfortunately it wasn't any better the second time around. read more

Literally just ordered 3 take-out meals from here. One was an order of fish and chips with mashed and gravy and coleslaw. Menu says meal comes with 2 sides. Clearly no one checks the meals on their way out the door. No quality control in place. Sadly disappointed. Seems a pretty easy thing to monitor and/or catch. If I could leave zero stars, I would. read more

Lake Pizza - Take out fish and chips - Pizza Near Me - Webster, Massachusetts

The service is always fantastic and the food is never fail. Each time we bring a new group or our grandchildren we are always impressed. One Thursday we sat outside on the patio and participated in trivia night! Always friendly. Always great food. And we will always be back. Thank you. read more

Pizza without sauce? No, I didn't order it this way. There was barely a few drips of sauce in our pizza today. Where's the sauce?!? read more

Lake Pizza - Where's the sauce? Pizza without sauce?!? - Pizza Near Me - Webster, Massachusetts

Amazing food every time. The only complaint was the hostess looked like she didn't want to work. read more

Lake Pizza - Chicken quesadilla w/French fries - Pizza Near Me - Webster, Massachusetts

I called in an order for $98 dollars for pick up.When I arrived home three grinders were missing.When I called to inquire they basically said it was "my fault " .I ordered a Taco salad.It had GREEK OLIVES and the beef was unseasoned and mushy.It went in the trash ! I knew the original 2 men that founded Lake Pizza, they would be embarrassed. read more

Take my advice and don't get pizza with grinders or anything else. Apparently Lake Pizza doesn't know how to cook food so that everything is done together. The pizza was sitting there getting cold as they prepared our grinders. By the time we got home the pizza was cold and rubbery. This isn't the first time. Last time the fish and chips were cold and soggy..Gross! The pizza was hot that time but how annoying. Someone has to eat cold food. What a waste of money. Maybe your cooks need to be trained on how to cook abd serve food! read more

Would give this place negative stars if I could. Worst sub I've ever had in my life. Couldn't even call it a steak and cheese, all there was was a bunch of overcooked steak umms with no cheese or mayo as requested. Never again. Gross. read more

Lake Pizza - Yuck - Pizza Near Me - Webster, Massachusetts

Went to Lake PIzza tonight, Son's pizza was good, my pizza was awful. The bottom crust was tough as could be. Couldn't even cut it. I had pizza with tomatoes, oregano, and cheese, You couldn't even cut it because the bottom was burnt and overdone. I complained to Christine , the waitress and all she did was smile and say all the wheat pizza are like this. I don't think so! 2 cokes cost $ 8.00......just ridiculous.. I will not be advising anyone to go there and we will never go again.......My bill was over $44.00 What a rip off.......... read more

Today, July 20, 2023, I ordered a simple garden salad with grilled chicken. The dressing was wrong, the pepperoncini​'s were old and rotten and on top, the grilled chicken was raw. First time and my last time.... read more

We ordered lake pizza which was a huge mistake. Ordered a pepperoni and cheese calzone which came drenched in grease. Literally pouring out, box soaked. At this point I wanted my money back. Of course, JOHN the owner which is a huge douche bag refused. Now I know why this place has been declining over the past couple years. He offered a gift card...yeah, sorry, we don't want your nasty food anymore. Only place I know that refuses to give a refund when THEY mess up. Be aware of this place! Owner is a huge douche bag with extremely poor customer service. Waste of $30.00 down the drain. Also ordered fish and chips. Fish is frozen and rubbery, fries soggy. What a mess this place is. Here's photos of this grease bomb I received! This is unacceptable read more

See all

I have patronized this establishment for 30 years..it used to be fantastic. However I spent over 30 dollars for three grinders/subs. They all couldn't suck enough terrible no taste at all. Cashier order taker had so much metal rings in her face I swear she could get and radio station within 200 miles. To say I am disappointed and can throw my money away anywhere bit ill never order eat here ever again. read more

We had Carl's Oxford Diner in mind for lunch today, but upon our arrival there, were disappointed to learn that they were closed from 9/5 thru 9/17 (whether it was for renovations or just vacation, we do not know). We considered a couple of places in Oxford and Webster, but finally decided to check in at an old haunt of ours: Lake Pizza. We had not been in over 20 years, and were surprised and happy to see the changes that had taken place there, mainly, the addition of a bar, and the new and improved dining room. The two of us were promptly seated in a very comfortable/roomy booth and served by a very pleasant young lady. Although we found many of the menu items tempting, we knew we wanted pizza. The meatball and ricotta combo we had (loaded with toppings, including an abundance of gooey mozzarella) was quite tasty and too huge for us to finish (we brought half of it home). My companion enjoyed a cold Sam Adams draft ($3.50), and I, an iced tea. While we did have to wait the requisite 20 minutes for the pizza, the service of our drinks was prompt, as was the delivery of our check when we requested it. We would not hesitate to return and venture from pizza to their other menu items when in the area again. read more

See all

I REALLY wanted to like this place. Never order food in, but didn't wanna go out or cook tonight. I didn't want the local, typical pizza chain so decided to try here. 1) Their web link here has VERY different prices than what they really are. According to their link, my order was $20-$21; it was almost $26 but I thought, "okay whatever". 2) The pizza taste reminded me 100% of Digiornos (no joke). I'm not picky when it comes to pizza but neither one of us could eat more than 1 slice. Seriously...that Digiorno taste is still in my mouth. 3) The onion rings!!!! $6 for a bag of grease with mushy, broken rings. It would be nice if they wrapped them in paper, aluminium, anything...or, throw them in a little box or container​, being that greasy. Or ...if they were a little bit ummm....crispy. The bag was dripping grease which got all over my counter. 95% of the rings were inedible. $6 isn't a lot but sucks when it's flushed down the toilet. Needles to say, after $28.50 (with tip), we are still hungry and VERY disappointed. That $ could have gone a long way. read more

Lake Pizza - They fall over on the sides. Zero crispness. All mushy. Had to throw them ALL away. - Pizza Near Me - Webster, Massachusetts

See all

Not the best place to eat but it's good when you need something convenient! We don't normally get takeout here - we go in and eat when we want something casual. The staff is always nice! I think most of the entrees come with a soup or salad. My mom and I both got salads and they were pretty underwhelming but not horrible. I got the eggplant parmesan which was good! But something super weird; the water tasted absolutely awful. Like I don't know if it's just Webster water, but it tastes SO BAD. My mom and sister both tried it too and agreed. Don't get water to drink if you eat here read more

Lake Pizza - Eggplant Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Webster, Massachusetts

I have ordered here many times, both to eat in and for take out. This was actually the first place I ordered pizza from when I moved to MA in '98. this is also where I learned not to order a pie (if you're from NY, you understand) and that I could no longer order a slice. That being said, I am not a huge fan of their pizza. Their food on the other hand is consistently very good. To be honest, I can't think of a time that I received bad service here. What I can remember is that this was the first place I ordered a pizza from after moving to MA from NY the summer of '98. I made the mistake of ordering a pie. OOPS, I then realized I was a long way from home. read more

Lake Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Webster, Massachusetts

The place has changed since the last time I visited. Not my choice in the new layout or menu. Probably wouldn't stop back in.

The food here was simply delicious and very cost friendly. As my husband and I were on vacation we figured why not. The quality of the foods they offer here is better than at our home state. The staff there was very friendly. read more

Yelpers don't lie! I read the mixed reviews on this place and decided to give it a try anyway. The reviews were fair. I was looking for a local place that had a good mix of choices to please my crew. Here's my take: The Good 1. Extensive menu. If everyone in your party isn't on the same page, you could dine/order from here and still make everyone happy. 2. The food. Big portions, well seasoned, hit the mark. Not a culinary masterpiece, but good solid comfort food that delivered on expectations. I would definitely order again. 3. Location. Easy to find, easy to get to in the Blackstone valley, and plenty of parking. 4. Atmosphere. Overall; cute place, clean, good family dinner spot. Comfortable and casual. Friendly folks. The Bad. 1. Service. The reviews weren't wrong. Drinks don't get refilled until you beg desperately. Salads, soups, came outside late we almost forgot about them and were expecting our dinners. Servers seemed to have too large of sections. There was no oversight on the dining room. 2. Management. Having good food is not enough. Someone needs to get into the dining room and know what's going on. Check on your guests, refill drinks, make sure food is getting expedited. This is clearly not happening. I would have given this place a 4 star rating for the food, but the 2 star rating for service brought me to my final rating. I would order take out, but not likely to dine in again. Their carry out seemed to be doing a good business. Listen to your fellow yelpers, we got no skin in the game other than wanting honest reviews! read more

Went to Lake pizza tonight and sat outside. Such a great time and a great restaurant. Food was fantastic. Service was fantastic. And their hostess Emily is the best. She brought in 11 people for dinner tonight! Can't wait to got back such a great time read more

Small portions and bad quality. Sadly not my first disappointment with this place. Went there for a friend wouldn't bother again on my own. Don't get why people even go there read more

They are open for business at 11 on Saturdays, however they didnt awnser their phone nor have the doors unlocked until 1130. Ordered a chicken parm sub it was ok. Not very friendly at the pick up counter. but chicken looked burnt and dry. Hardly any sauce or cheese on it. A little disappointed since I was just visiting my childhood town, & lake pizza was so good back then. read more

If you want mold on your subs, go there. Brown lettuce, that was my sub, my kid wouldnt even eat hers, waste of time money, not happy ,dropped another 1 off, gee thanks, at least that 1 didnt have mold on it, i couldnt even eat that one, kid & I are still hungry, oh wife had to pick thru her brown salad to get a few bites of green lettuce read more

Lake Pizza - a closeup of a sandwich with lettuce - Pizza Near Me - Webster, Massachusetts

See all

Love the atmosphere but please don't play country music not everyone likes it PLEASE!

For the price this place is amazing. Had the honey BBQ chicken pizza (HIGHLY RECOMMEND). Atmosphere and ambience/lighting could be better; but for the price the food and service were great. read more

Sadly this place has gone downhill over the years. The pizza slowly went from awesome to having a flavorless frozen bread dough taste. Our last visit I had the eggplant parmesan. The crust fell off completely and turned the dish into a pile of mush. The eggplant was so tough I couldn't cut it with a knife. If you get stuck going there order a grinder. They remain pretty decent. The restaurant is clean and the service is adequate. One star each for the two. read more

Pretty much the best place to eat in Webster. Lake pizza has a good clean feel when you walk in through the front door which is always nice. Bar is solid but could use a couple more drafts on tap. The menu is Italian heavy but it's solid in terms of choices and quality. I haven't had a bad meal come out of their kitchen in the at least dozen times I have visited. Also a great place to watch a baseball, basketball, football, or hockey game and have a beer or four. read more

Lake Pizza is our go-to for takeout in Webster. Their food is usually consistent (there's been a few bad deliveries here and there.) Their menu has enough coverage to please just about anyone ordering. The pizza is definitely better than your typical "town name" house of pizza shops you come across everywhere and their delivery people are just so nice and timely! We order from Lake Pizza a few times a month and will continue to do so! read more