I've hesitated to write this review as I feel my experience with Japanese food and in particular Kimura's namesake ramen, Tonkotsu ramen, will deter others from going and trying the food here. However, I have decided to give my honest opinion for one reason - when you advertise yourself as "authentic" and say things like, "we don't change the taste for American palates," you open yourself up to criticism if you fall short.
Having spent nearly a decade in Fukuoka, Japan where Tonkotsu ramen originates, and having eaten the real deal literally hundreds of times in various stages of sobriety, I can say unequivocally that this is not proper Tonkotsu ramen. Notice I didn't say that it was bad ramen because it isn't as I enjoyed my bowl of ramen greatly. But when you go around claiming authenticity, you're eventually going to have someone call your bluff.
The one defining factor that virtually every traveler has of authentic Tonkotsu ramen is the smell. When prepared properly, it smells... Bad. Like boiling the basketball team's socks after a double over-time. In fact, often you can smell Tonkotsu ramen blocks away. But this revulsion soon turns into a method of discerning the potential tastiness of the ramen.
Prior to our ramen arriving we ate the cucumber sunomono. This wasn't bad. It looked the part and tasted fairly accurate to the real deal. We both remarked that it was a bit on the sweet side but this is within the scope of a chef's artistic license. In Japan I have had slightly sweet sunomomo but ordinarily it is not.
The ramen at Kimura is the best bowl of ramen I have had in San Antonio. You can tell that the chef and staff put a lot of time and effort into their product. The broth was rich and rather deep in texture although on our visit a number of patrons were complaining that the broth was too salty, for which the server apologized. The noodles were probably the most authentic part of this dish. They were spot on in size and shape although they were a tad tough probably from the broth not being hot enough. Additionally, they were a tad sticky. This, in my expert opinion, is more than likely due to dropping in the ball of noodles without fanning them out. Also, the cooks need to make sure to use their saibashi (long cooking chopsticks) to separate the noodles as they cook. Oh, I forgot to mention that serving miso soup with ramen is a bit redundant and very uncommon in Japan. That being said, my wife and I enjoyed the miso soup very much.
The ramen was esthetically pleasing. The various elements were there such as the chashu (pork), scallions, and nori (seaweed). In Japan, nori is never shredded in ramen but it is when put on top of zaru (cold) soba. Often the chef will just put a big old sheet of nori along the side of the bowl and extending out and up. Also, the fish cake, kamaboko, is never eaten in ramen in Japan but is eaten hot soba and udon. My Japanese wife said that while the kamaboko tasted good, presenting it in ramen is strange. Lastly, with regards to the Tonkotsu ramen I ate, the broth had a very strong bacon taste which seems to have come from the chashu which was not prepared in the traditional Japanese chashu method. It sure tasted good but authentic it was not.
My wife, who is 100% Japanese, ate the miso ramen. She enjoyed the noodles, although they were a bit sticky like mine, but was taken aback by the shredded nori and komoboko in her ramen. Additionally, she stated that she could hardly taste any miso in her miso ramen. One other thing that we both agreed was not authentic is the boiled egg (ajitama). The egg in our ramen was just a plain old boiled egg with just a slightly cooked inner yoke, the way it should be. However, proper ajitama is prepared in the normal manner of boiling, but is then taken from its shell and placed in a bath of soy sauce, sugar, and mirin where it soaks up flavor for at least 24 hours. This also colors the outside and some of the inside a caramel color.
Honestly, I'm split. On one hand, with no prior knowledge of ramen, I'd say this ramen was great. On the other hand, having eaten ramen multiple times each week for nearly a decade, I must address the claims of authenticity and say that it isn't authentic. As I've stated, I enjoyed the ramen personally and I think most others will as well; but when you get a Japanese customer in your shop you might not want to brag about authenticity. The Japanese are very proud of their food culture and have a difficult time acknowledging, for example, that a bowl of ramen is delicious if it isn't authentically Japanese. Another thought is that this ramen is over-engineered. Ramen is a simple food not meant to be froo-frooed too much. Great chefs seem compelled to mess with what is tried and true. This so often leads to a lack of authenticity and higher prices, the latter being one of the biggest complaints of Kimura. So, if you want a great bowl of noodles and do not care about au read more