I've shopped a lot at Jos A Banks, but after recent events and poor customer service, I won't be back.
PROS: Their suits are nice, definitely much better than most department stores or Men's warehouse. Also, when a rental suit was sent to Ann Arbor by accident, the staff overnighted it down to Perrysburg, which I thought was just fantastic of them (Thanks, Wendy from the Perrysburg store!).
Despite good things, there were problems with my wedding order, there's a bad taste in my mouth.
ISSUE #1: THEIR TAILORING ISN'T GREAT, IT'S JUST OK. This one is somewhat minor. To do it properly, you should take your suit to a really good, professional tailor. If you're gonna spend the money on a nice suit, do yourself a favor and work with a good tailor to get an incredible fit, which you won't quite get with Jos A Banks.
ISSUE #2: QUOTED PRICES ON RENTALS MEAN NOTHING, AND THERE'S NO ACCOUNTABILITY. I was told that, because Jos A Banks, is a nationwide store, that rental prices are guaranteed to be the same at each store, with some minor fluctuations due to differences in taxes. Specifically, I was told that the rentals would be about $150 (including suit, shirt, shoes, tie, pocket square), and probably about $175 including tax. Great, sounds like a deal. Problem is that people ended up being quoted (and paying) anywhere from $160 to over $200; variations greater than differences in taxes. I called different stores and the Ann Arbor location. Every single time, I get an 'I don't know why' answer, which is unacceptable since I was told it'd be pretty much the same everywhere. The only theory I got was from the manager at Ann Arbor, who said that maybe the $150 quote included a discount when people opened up Jos A Banks accounts or something, which would make for a misleading price quote, if that were the case. All I know is that the guaranteed price meant nothing, and that some people ended up paying upwards of $30 or so more than what I was quoted.
ISSUE #3: CUSTOMER SERVICE IS LACKING. So I ordered different colored ties for the dads and my groomsmen. The afternoon of the day before the wedding, I hear that one of the dads was given the wrong tie color - he was given the same color as the groosmen ties. OK, not a big deal. But I still needed to call and see what everyone was getting, so there were no more surprises. So, I called Jos A Banks (in Perrysburg, OH, because I happened to be there just a little bit beforehand, since I was in Ohio for the wedding), and I just wanted to know which color ties everyone else got, since 1 of them was wrong. I found out the wrong color ties were given to the dads. The salesperson told me to have them bring their ties in for an exchange, I said there wasn't time, that they were driving all over the US to get here, and it just wasn't a big deal. So, I get a defensive response of "Well, that's why we have people pick their suits up 2 days before, so we can take care of things like this." Well you know what? That's why I sat down with someone saying which colors I want everything to be when I made my initial order, so people wouldn't have to come back into the store the day before the wedding because you screwed up my order. Mind, I only called to see what everyone was getting because the colors of the ties were OK by me, but he gets defensive. Importantly, I never got an apology. I would've been perfectly happy with a "We're sorry this happened, what can we do to make it better?" and I would've said we're all good, and this review would've been very very different. My suits with tailoring cost over $1,000, two others bought their suits instead of rented, then everyone else rented. My using Jos A Banks for my wedding brought in thousands of dollars, and they get defensive when they screw up my order and don't even offer an apology? Unacceptable. I wasn't even upset about it, so there was no reason to get defensive.
Two days after the wedding, I go to the Ann Arbor location to return my brother's rented shoes and to get the $40 deposit. The manager says he will charge me $20 for the late return (which is reasonable), and I ask if we can just call it even since the tie colors were off (which seemed a reasonable counter-offer to me). The manager says that Zach (from the Perrysburg store) called him and told him before about the situation the day before the wedding, and then he says to me that I could have changed the tie colors any time after ordering (which is a complete non-sequitur, because the issue wasn't about me not being able to change tie colors. It was about the order being wrong, which I found out about the day before the wedding.). He then reminded me that they ever so graciously offered to let people drive there so they could rectify their mistake. Again, no apology or an "I'm sorry that happened." Just pointing out I didn't take advantage of their rectification.
It's a bummer. I always liked the store and the people in it, including the manager, but I won't go back. read more