This place has a great atmosphere & really great authentic New York style pizza!! We ate outside on the sidewalk because it was a beautiful day. This was the first place my fiancee' & I ate at when we were looking for a place to live in Forsyth. The staff is super friendly & the prices were great!! read more

Jonah's on Johnston - Nice little outside area to eat in. - Pizza Near Me - Forsyth, Georgia

Anna was our waitress, the bread knots was ok, then we preserved pizza and it was good.

Awesome pizza and service. They had beers on tap, a cauliflower pizza crust that was crispy and tasty. The saucy spuds was really good. Great atmosphere, it was a beautiful day and the people here were really friendly. We saw the meatballs come out at another table and they were huge. When in Forsyth I will be visiting this place again! read more

We we're passing through and found Jonah's on yelp. Great food, friendly atmosphere and quick service. Just off the highway and situated on a cute downtown street with outside tables and vintage brick decor. The locals were there and all talking with one another and loving on Tucker, a big dog who was up for endless attention from everyone! 5 stars all the way around!!! read more

What an amazing place to stop on our road trip !!! Loved the food and the service was amazing!!!! read more

Jonah's on Johnston - Forsyth - Pizza Near Me - Forsyth, Georgia

Stopped here on way back home from spring break. Just wanted a quick bite to eat. Counter service only...only 2 tables eating. Ordered our sandwiches. The bread was so hard. The chicken was very dry. The chips were good. The pizzas look better. read more

Jonah's on Johnston - Pizza Near Me - Forsyth, Georgia

This tiny little Jan was just perfect when we got out of traffic. I recommend the ziti lasagna. You can even eat outside.

The friendliest staff, the BEST pizza and the COLDEST beer! If you're not a pizza fan, the meatball sub and Italian sandwich are delicious!

Jonahs is good! I eat here mostly for lunch. The service is fast and the people are friendly. Their online orders are also very good for people that want good pizza in a hurry! I'd recommend read more

This was some of the best pizza I have had yet. I think the service could be a little more organized but they still served us well. The guys making pizza kept my sons attention as he got to watch them. We had some type of appetizer pimento cheese bread that was absolutely amazing. Never in my life have I had a cheese sauce made from pimento cheese. We will be back for more!!!!!! read more

Jonah's on Johnston - Amazing pizza. This is the Mike Angelo - Pizza Near Me - Forsyth, Georgia

Where pizza meets craft and care in every slice. Daily specials and lots of options. Keto and Whole 30 friendly. Owners are amazingly kind. Veer on off the interstate to sample a slice of sweet life Forsyth. read more

Unfortunately the pizza is not good enough to keep me coming back. This used to be a go to place for great pizza in a casual friendly environment. We came back for the first time in a while this week. Service was lacking and new staff not so great. Salads were soggy. The places seemed a bit run down and just seemed different not really clean. The pizza by itself is still great. However when combined with the inside and the staff we agreed that will be our last trip unless thing change for the better. read more

So, the bad first. This is the first time we've eaten there since they changed owners. We walked in and were immediately seated at a table that apparently was occupied by Cookie Monster as there was tomato pieces in the chairs, half eaten pizza on the floor and crumbs all over the top of the table. The waitress was oblivious to the mess as she left us to clean it up ourselves. I had the meat lovers calzone. It was the size of a travel pillow, but was mostly dough and ricotta cheese. Not much pepperoni or sausage. Overall, bland and not much to like. The best part of the place was the beer selection and the music. I coulda just had another Lazy Magnolia and listened to Ryan Adams rather than the calzone as I sat amongst the grossness of floor pizza. read more

Great sandwiches! Pleasant and friendly staff. Pizza looked amazing. Planning to go back

Good food Portions for babies I ordered half sandwich with soup I can have 3 of them and still be hungry Will post a picture of my sandwich if I can Paying in Cash would give you a cookie!!! But you have to ask for it Good thing you will not feel guilty that you had over eaten read more

Jonah's on Johnston - Pizza Near Me - Forsyth, Georgia

See all

We stopped here to get off the interstate spring break traffic. We had the the meatball app, Greek salad, lemon pepper wings, and the veggie cauliflower crust pizza. It was all excellent. The staff was prompt and friendly. Looks like a place that the locals frequent on a Friday night. The owner, Laurie, even stopped by to give us advice for where to stay for the night. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone who likes good pizza and a family-friendly atmosphere. read more

Well you removed my review on Google reviews, so what do you think a social media review is for? Not all reviews are good.The manager does not like negative reviews. I have been to this establishment several times. Several years back,The first time eating at this establishment my party and I were asked to leave the back room, due to another party coming in for a Jeopardy TV show celebrity who would be dining inside. The only place that they could seat us was outside. The other times I had eaten at this restaurant the food and service was fair. Until yesterday the food was cold, and less than mediocre. 2 soft drinks, a Greek salad, and a house salad were $ 25 for a bowl no bigger then your hand. The manager did ask if there was anything she could do. All I stated was just bring a check and we will leave. Oh as for the manager tipping or waitress Congratulations, that was so classy to put in your review. I only tip for good service. Heres a tip to all future patrons, stay away from this place!!!!!!!!!!! read more

We were traveling and staying off 1-75. Not wanting to get in the car again my husband said he would run and get a pizza. We placed an ordered a 12 " pizza and salad. The pizza was decent, crust was cooked nicely, but......nothing like I was expecting after looking at their delightful menu. The salad was actually pathetic and not even edible (wet wilted greens- the kind that any normal person would throw away) Seriously questioning the quality of the food. We were pretty bummed. read more

Jonah's on Johnston - Pizza Near Me - Forsyth, Georgia

We stopped in on our way home to Alpharetta. Everything was "ok". We had a Greek salad - family size. It was small and had spring mix in it. The pizza was just the right size ... we ordered small. The cheese was delicious but the toppings were very sparse. It's got the chance to be a great business with not too many other pizza places around. I hope they can straighten a few things out and make a go of it. The help (3) all waited on us. It wasn't like we had our own waitress. Everyone just waited on everyone. Very unorganized that way. They can get this I'm sure!! Great potential!! read more

Stopped in for dinner after a long day of driving!!!!! Awesome sandwiches. Beer was good and cold. The wine slushies were to die for!!!! Very friendly, helpful and caring staff!!!! Outstanding service!! Perfect ending to a rough day. read more

This is the Pizza place if you are in or around the square in Forsyth, Ga. The pizza is always cooked the way I like it, with more of a crust on the bottom. Not greasy. Just the right amount of toppings!! The service here has always been too notch. read more

The best crust anywhere!! Their white pizza is the best. And Greek salad. Have had a variety from menu, all excellent. Great wait staff. Go back as often as we can . Transplanted regulars. read more

I stopped by Jonah's to pick up a quick bite while in town for a work trip. I ordered a veggie calzone, and was extremely satisfied with the amount of food for the price. The dough was seriously to die for, and definitely my favorite part. The filling left a little to be desired, there didn't seem to be much seasoning and in my opinion it was lacking cheese and flavor in general. Marinara dipping sauce was on point though, and overall I was satisfied with my meal. If I came into town again I would definitely give it another shot and order a pizza. I also got the greek salad, and was very satisfied with it. Overall, I think it's probably a great place and I might have just not ordered the best thing on the menu. Give them a try! read more

Not the best experience. A friend & I chose to meet here for lunch. It was both of our first time visiting, so we reviewed their website & yelp for the hours. We traveled half an hour there. Upon arrival at their published opening time, we were greeted by a worker posting a sign as we approached the entrance. It read: Blah blah blah routine oven maintenance blah blah blah opening around 12. Strike 1: Your "routine" maintenance shouldn't have to take place during your posted hours. Period. Strike 2: Your server could have been SO kind as to not treat us as though we were invisible when we were clearly there to be patrons. Rude. Strike 3: The food was just okay. Not worth the trip. Here's the bottom line: the hours were misleading, the service was lacking, & the food was ... okay. I won't be back. read more

We are staying in the area for Thanksgiving and looked for a good place to eat. We found this great Pizza and bakery. The staff were great and friendly. The pizza dough is hand tossed and cooked in a brick oven. The pizza sauce was very rich and perfect taste. The pizza crust was so good we ate even the end of the crust. If that was not good enough, the bakery is the best. We got cookies to go for our motel. They make bread too. If you want good Pizza and sweets to die for....this is your place. Happy Thanksgiving read more

See all

Wow, passing through on the way to Florida and found this fanatic local joint, tried the meatball sub and a slice of pizza, excellent on both counts, very friendly staff and the owners really put the hearts into the place! read more

The food is pricey The food is over done or not thoroughly cooked Service is horrible Staff is rude I don't know how they are still in business My family and I have tried to give this place a chance a few times and every time its the same thing.. We won't be eating here ever again and I hope those reading this will take our advice.. You will get better food and service at little ceasers read more

Nice casual place that has a good salad- try the house dressing- and you can get pizza by the slice. Loved the crust! What else could you ask for? Good selection of beers AND it is the coldest beer. Thanks for saving us from the same old fast food dinner while on the road! read more

This review is a little late but, here you go. I traveled to Forsyth Georgia recently on business and was looking for a place to eat lunch. I stumbled across this place off a main street. I was initially looking for BBQ but settle for a slice of Pizza instead. The service was good and friendly. The setting was unique for the city, had kinda of its own thing going. The Pizza was cooked in a brick oven which was a plus. The crust was thin to medium which is how I enjoy my pizza. The taste was pretty good, slightly above average. One slice filled me up pretty good. I was pinched for time so timeliness was definitely a bonus. I would recommend this restaurant if you happened to be in Forsyth. read more

Overall my favorite place in Forsyth! Pizza is great and the service is great! Fun atmosphere. They serve pizza by the slice. The owners are always in and love to please the customers. My wife and so love going here. It is a weekly event. Also have the coldest beers with a great selection! We LOVE JONAHS! read more

Great food, great service, great community support! Patio is perfect for a spring time dinner outdoors!

While stopping overnight from our travels from Orlando to Tennessee, we saw this pizzeria on yelp and decided to give it a try. When we got there on Friday night we were lucky to find a close parking spot. The inside seating was full so we needed to sit at the outside tables. Waitstaff was attentive, with multiple servers asking if we needed anything. The pizza was very good. It's a thin crust pizza so if that's not your thing, it might not be the place for you. We also liked the feel of the downtown area. The courthouse is close by and worth a visit. read more

Came to Jonah's after leaving Fox City Brewery after being told a 45 minute wait although we saw no other people waiting and they had several open tables. We went right down the street to Jonah's and it was great. Good food and beer. This was our first visit and we will be back to Jonah's where we felt our business was appreciated. read more

So while driving down from Georgia to Florida we got hungry and start looking for some really good pizza and searched online and we found this place it was really amazing fresh homemade I was able to make a custom pizza not on the menu which was really really good fresh tomatoes you can tell the use quality product the people were super friendly got to meet the new owners are I wish them lots of success and I would definitely come back here next time I drive up to Atlanta read more

Quaint pizza place in downtown Forsyth. Pizza was excellent especially the Forsythian Altemo. Friendly staff and quick service. We will be back soon. read more

Jonah's on Johnston - Forsythian Altemo - Pizza Near Me - Forsyth, Georgia

The best pizza I've ever had. The staff is friendly and the restaurant is cute. Nice family friendly place to eat. The slices are huge.

When you walk in, before you do anything else, get a cinnamon roll. Bag it up, set it to the side, and ignore it until later. Trust me, do this, because if you don't, then some other genius is gonna come in right behind you, snag the last roll, and you'll shed tears of shame and remorse. When I have newcomers to town, I take them to Jonahs. Most folks use Grits to impress a visitor, but, well, when I leave Jonah's, I'm full...and I have money left in my pocket. Next, order a coke zero (WIN! Everyone should serve coke zero). Also, order firesticks. Sit back, relax, and wait on the firesticks while staring at your brown bag of cinnamon roll goodness. When they arrive, order your entree. I recommend pizza rolls, mostly because they are cheaper than a pizza. If you're in it to win it, then snag yourself a pizza--the one with the spinach & stuff aint half bad for a buncha vegetarian hippy crap. I personally prefer the cheeseburger in paradise. When you finish your meal, walk back up to the counter and pick something out of the case for dessert. EVERYTHING is good. Tomorrow morning, open up that brown bag of cinnamon goodness, and go to your happy place. They should just make entire pizzas that are nothing but this little delicious nugget that is the Jonah's Cinnamon Rolls. read more

Turns out the best pizza in Macon is .... in Forsyth. They got their dough and ovens singing a perfect tune. Light, crispy, chewy and maybe the best pie I've had in a year. The pizza rolls are a great idea for a meal by themselves. Didn't get pepperoni on the pizza ... will try it next time. Fresh baked desserts are worth the calories, too. Funky sort of local atmosphere works well. The prices are more than your average economy pizza, more in line with a specialty pizza place. they make it all in house, and do a really good pie worth the money ... just don't get 10 toppings. Gotta say that the frozen beef pellets were a surprise. The mozzarella/provolone blend is perfect for their pizza They have the most popular toppings on their basic pricing, then specialty toppings list. A lot of my favorites were 50% more, so I will be judicious getting them. Our server was friendly, and knew the menu well, and added to our experience. read more

Very cute little restaurant in downtown Forsyth. Great prices and the quality was also amazing.

Followup After about 6 great stops at Jonah's, my wife and I had issues during our last lunch. First, the pizzas were not as good as previous ones. The pizza crust was not "worked" like previous ones and some seasonings must have been omitted on the toppings. Anyway, the quality was mediocre compared to previous pizzas there. Second, my wife's pizza was burned, but served anyway. My pizza was so burned they had to cook another one. So my wife had a choice: eat before me or let her pizza get cold. She did a little of both. My coffee was good, but barely warm. We will try again during our trips down I-75 and I will report back. Maybe this visit was an isolated event... read more