The chicken noodle soup and broasted potatoes were also 4 star!!! Pizza is consistently good, saucy and flavorful - we always get the plain cheese. Super consistent! read more

Our sandwiches were great! Service was great too. What wasnt so great were the 1.50 charge for sliced hot pickle peppers. Like huh and if you get any extra topping is 1-2.00 more. I didn't realize this until I got a hamburger with let tom mayo pickles and onions! My turkey wrap with fries was over 22.00$. Got same thing at big Y for 7.99 so shop around. read more

If I could give zero stars I would. Rude, demeaning attitude from not only the waitstaff but the owner himself. Ive been ordering from here for years, the food is good but sadly after this experience I will no longer patronize this establishment. read more

I'm not Dave Portnoy but I would give this pizza a 3 out of 10 someone told me it was very good I can no longer take any food advice from this person again lol only reason I gave them a 2 star is because at least the server was nice read more

Since the new ownership, it isn't the same quality or quantity food. We used to get the broasted chicken dinners a few times a month. Tuna salad salads once a week. The chicken pieces are smaller and greasy. Salad has less tuna, cheese. Higher prices doesn't help. The pizza is fair at best. We will probably stop ordering from there. Sad because we have been a customer for 20 years. Hope they make improvements. read more

Decent, but not overall great. One of those pizzas where it's not really good or bad. Would probably give it another chance if in the area, but overwise I would pass. read more

See all

We wanted to grab a quick bite before our hike around Quinebaug Lake. Johnny's Pizza was close and had good Yelp reviews. We called in an order to go, and it was ready in about 20 minutes. We weren't sure where we would be able to eat, so we opted for wraps instead of pizza. We selected: * Cheeseburger Wrap * Chicken Caesar Wrap These sandwiches were both served warm, and included a plethora of hot fries. They were very nicely prepared and tasty! The cheeseburger wrap appeared to have two patties, and was so substantial, I could only eat half. The sauce tasted mayo based and there was an abundance of melted cheese. Somehow, they were able to prepare this without creating a leaky mess. Nicely done! The Chicken Wrap was also tasty, warm with a delicious, mild sauce and an abundance of chicken. My co-diner could only finish half of this wrap, and we each consumed only half of the fries. The pizzas that were coming out of their ovens looked great, I'd like to try one of those. Everyone was masked, hand sanitizer was on the counter, the place looked clean and tidy. It's in a strip mall, so ambience is limited, but the food looked good. We'd be happy to return. read more

Johnnys Pizza - Huge Cheeseburger Wrap & Fries - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, Connecticut

See all

Very good menu. Delicious food. Great service. Friendly staff. Prices are fair, but Lousy coleslaw.

I do take out from Johnny's at least once a week and we think it is great. My wife and I love the marinara sauce to dip her chicken tenders and my French Fries in. I always get a Chicken Parm Sandwich which I truly enjoy. My wife gets the the Chicken tenders and a small basic salad and she always enjoys both. My son always get the Buffalo Chicken Pizza which he loves. Always great services by Julia and all the cooks and owner are super friendly. Highly recommend!! read more

Even though we live in RI, my wife and I have been ordering grinders take-out from Johnny's Pizza for over a decade and always loved it! I have no idea what has happened in the past few months, but the food quality and quantity have gone downhill drastically. We ordered this past Saturday 8/2 and for the second time in a row, we were extremely disappointed. This is a photo of their steak & cheese grinder, whereas they barely spread steak on the bread, we couldn't even taste or find any cheese on it, and the taste was very bland. In the past, there was seasoning, and the bread was absolutely filled with steak. We felt like we were ripped off, paying $17 for a bread grinder and soggy onion rings like this, plus neither grinder was even toasted as requested. Why I even left a good tip for take-out is beyond me, but we'll never return. So disappointing, I guess we'll just look for another place to order our grinders from now on. read more

Johnnys Pizza - Steak & Cheese Grinder aka Bread Grinder - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, Connecticut

Service was outstanding. The broasted chicken is very good. It is a lot less expensive than that other chicken practically next door. Once you try it, you won't go to the other place. It's a small, very clean restaurant. While we were eating, many to-go orders were being picked up. read more

I've been a Johnny's pizza lover for years, they even made us a bunch of pizza for our pre wedding party the night before the Big Day!

Not as good as when Johnny was there manning the till. He made sure the food was the best it could be. It was a matter of pride. The place was bought by 2 brothers and it went downhill fast. Now, it's back being run by the family, but it definitely needs a good review by the OG. The steak sub is made with a lesser quality of beef, but it is still reasonably good. The servers aren't giving out a warm welcome either. The Everything Pizza is still good, but not great. I do believe the love is gone. read more

Update: same thing again. The broasted chicken is just plain disgusting. The fries were black from being dropped in old oil and the chicken was pretty much the same. All done with this place. We usually get the broasted chicken and its the best take out or eat in fried chicken around. It is cooked in coconut oil if I am not mistaken. The past few times have been sub par. It is either being refried in used dirty oil or you be the judge. As soon as I brought it into my car the smell was a dead give away. Burnt dirty oil. No offense but it now seems to be all kids in there running the kitchen and check out. I don't think the owners or cooks I always saw there would approve. read more

Johnnys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, Connecticut

Last 4 times I called they hadn't had a driver to deliver. I finally get them to say they can deliver and we are 3 mins down the road from them and they state they can't deliver to our whole street !! Even tho we are in there area to deliver. How can we not get a delivery due to another house on our st. This place is so unprofessional the woman Veronica says oh well sorry we can't deliver even tho you have before because states not to deliver to anyone on our street. What!!!???? Who and what place does that. read more

Don't order delivery from this restaurant. They load their drivers up with way too many deliveries, and if you're one of the unlucky ones whose order shows up cold, an hour late, they refuse to refund your order. If you get your pizza fresh, whether from eating in, picking it up yourself, or winning the delivery roulette, the quality ranges from decent to really good. Unfortunately, it seems to depend on luck, so you'll just have to hope you came in on a good day.​ read more

Once again- perfect!Pizza was excellent; Chocolate cake-yummy! You can't go wrong here! Don't care for the Broasted Chicken!howeverKeeps me coming back! read more

If I wanted microwaved food, which I don't. I'd do it myself. Also dining in staff is rude like I was an inconvenience. Next time I'll spare the visit. No thanks. read more

This was our Friday night spot growing up. Different owners now but I have seen no difference in the foods quality or taste. Hands down my favorite place to get either a tuna grinder or a special pizza. Coleslaw is just the way I like it. Fries they're okay. read more

See all

This review has two parts ordered a large mushroom pizza- a friend recommended Johnny's so I decided to try it. Here is my review: Taste - D- Appearance- C The pizza was bland, had no distinctive flavor whatsoever. The pizza just was not very good at all and I would not come back again- The more Important reason I won't be back is because multiple staff members right in the area pizza was being made and prepared had masks on but pulled down below the mouth- completely against CT Gov Lamont's mandate that all restaurant staff need to wear masks covering nose and mouth. So when covid finally hits the place because their managers were too ignorant or just didn't care they will only be able to blame themselves. I'm telling all my friends and reporting them to the Governor's office as well as state police read more

Love their pizza would highly recommend it .! Yummy to my tummy lol .! Chicken parmigiana grinder is the best .!

We just started going here the waitress, and the people running the place are very nice family. The pizza is excellent and, homemade delicious rice pudding . read more

Pizza was good touch on the greasy side but overall it was pretty good. Friendly service as well

Ordered on Slice app at 456pm 11/13. Arrive at 525pm. @530 pm online Status showed order ready for pick up. Gave my first name. Was told not yet ready yet. Waited for 20 more mins. Asked them to check the order, came out with wrong food. Showed my online receipt then came out with the order. Food was sitting there all along. Got it home after 6 pm, and it was barely warm. Not a good experience. Was upset with Johnnys. Need to do a better job at counter and kitchen. read more

Stopped here when we were in the area. This place was pretty busy when we came which is always a good sign Typical pizza place menu. Tried a sub, pizza, chicken parm, steak wrap, and spaghetti and meat balls. Food came out hot and was delicious. Staff is friendly and attentive. Space is clean. read more

Johnnys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, Connecticut

See all

It used to be very good. I believe new ownership has taken place. Your prices are awful and the food quality and quantity are not there. My husband and I used to order from you folks on average of 2 times a week. we have not ordered that in almost a year. read more

Clean place, good service nice people, never a bad experience eating here. I absolutely love their calzones and bacon feta pizza they make the BEST bacon feta pizza in CT no cap. Great subs and pasta too. read more

Wow. I barely have the words...last night I ordered a pizza from Johnny's for the first time..and when it was delivered..the bill came to $25..I handed him $40 and he looked at me like I had 10 heads..it wasn't like I handed him a hundred dollar bill..I processed to ask for my change..the delivery guy had no change for my two 20's...so he went downstairs and brought up a few ones and a bunch of coins! He just assumed I was tipping him $15! So today I called to complain and ask for the rest of my change..the manager seemed annoyed and kind of rude and just blew me off asking how much i wanted back...not too long after a different guy showed up at my place gave me the change I was owed and told me I was no longer aloud to order food and they will not be delivering to me! This is how the manager of this establishment handled this situation. First of all...the amount I tip someone is MY choice..and second I should not be basically forced to tip you extra because you didn't bother to have any $5s and $1s on you..which as a delivery service you are kind of expected to have to make change for your customers. Bravo and a real thumbs up on the customer service. I think it goes without being said I will no longer be giving them any of my business whether I am on the "no delivery" list or not! read more

Really good pizza with a super flavorful sauce!! I think this is the best pizza in Northeast CT! So good...

Haven't tried the food yet. But was horrified to see a worker in kitchen preparing food with no mask. Also a delivery driver walked in past the line and into the kitchen no mask I said something to him as he was leaving and he said According to government he only needs one when he's within six feet of somebody which he just was numerous times Sad to see that some businesses aren't taking covid - 19 more seriously read more

On Friday night I ordered 8pc broaster chicken & joe joe's, I got 8pc and 5 1/2 joes the chicken was dry and seemed burnt and only 5 1/2 potatoes an insult for $19, never again. read more

There are pizza places closer to me and I've tried them all. I'd rather just call in my order and drive a bit farther, it's done when I arrive. They do not skimp on the toppings. You order chicken and its full of chicken. Peppers and onion - full of peppers and onions etc. The crust is light and crispy. It's not a greasy type of pizza. Good flavor and fresh ingredients. Some chain pizza places have ingredients that are bland so everything is a different texture but there isn't any real taste. read more

Great friendly staff. Wonderful girls greet you at the door. Good atmosphere. You can enjoy your food here, or take out. The pizza is outstanding, and they are very generous with all the toppings, and the grinders, and chicken are huge , and tasty . You can't go wrong with Johnny's. read more

A solid crispy crust and very generous on the toppings! The salads are big portions for the price! You can't go wrong there! The salads are typical to most pizza places, iceberg lettuce from a bag, but it's fresh and crispy. Pick-up is ready in about 20 minutes, even on the busiest of nights. The food, quality, portions have stayed very consistent. A great place to take out! read more

To me, there is nothing more satisfying than a good hearty Italian grinder (a.k.a. Italian hoagie) when the tangy craving hits. Johnny's pizza serves up a clean honest Italian grinder about the length of my arm (for a large). At JP, you get exactly what you ask for: layers of meat, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and condiment. So far I've ordered it three times here and each time I make new additions/modifications. This time it was Italian grinder with lettuce, tomato, cheese, fresh onions, oregano, and vinegar & oil, not toasted. Next time I will request extra extra vinegar/oil to turn it into my little taste of heaven. I ordered the small size this time, and it's perfectly portioned for a filling meal. Also, another reason I keep returning here is that the owners/workers seem so friendly with the customers, exuding the undeniable small town charm. read more

See all

i called in an order, the girl on the phone talked so fast, i could not understand her, i kept asking to repeat herself, she was getting put out. She asked for my text, i said i don't have texting on my phone. she said they would call, i waited 45 mins. in their lot no one called.i went in a girl on her cell phone sitting in a booth slowly walked up, still looking at her cell phone. i told her what i ordered, it was sitting there, they could have called! i payed and walked out with a cane in one hand, balancing a pizza in the other. a year or two ago, they would have opened doors, and sometime brought the purchase to my truck.she never looked up from her phone and went back to her booth! A restuarant is only as good as the wait staff, this person i would not have working for me. People like to be greeted, not barely acknowledged, with your face in a cell phone! place has changed! won't be back. After getting home i noticed the Mulitiple topping Large pizza, which cost me almost 30.00 was lacking cheese on top! all the toppings were sitting on top of it loose! They took no pride with this ! Not acceptable, Johnny would have their ass for operating like they do! read more

Awesome the pizza was amazing and the bbq wings was to die for. Omg I would so recommend them and the girl was awesome, she brang my food outside to me. read more

Johnnys Pizza - Amazing bbq chicken yummm and the pizza is yummm yummm yummmm 5 - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, Connecticut

See all

It was at first hard to find. Tucked away In a shopping center off to the side. I had pasta with a meatball and sausage The meatball was large and tender but it Had little taste , the sausage was over cooked and hard . The sauce was o k Not great. I would give them a second chance , Because I only had one item there But I'm no hurry , there are other places Around to try first. ( only had take out ) read more

This place used to be so good. Not sure what happened. The last few times I was disappointed. And tonight was was my last time ordering there. Ordered a burger med rare. Burger came out super well done. It was crumbly it was so over dove. fries were so soggy. My son got a chick parm grinder. The bread was so wet and nasty. He took th chicken out and was still nasty. We had left overs for dinner. Not sure what has happened to this place but it is horrible especially for the price u pay. read more

Love Johnny's Pizza we order delivery several times a month. They now allow you to order online. Great food. Nice atmosphere in the restaurant and friendly staff. read more