Fantastic pizza and service ..... beyond that we had the best server, Heather, and a wonderful chat with Jimmy, the owner. Back to the food - pizza was sensational. My husband had a small pepperoni and sausage. I had a small veggie. Both were great. We, also, shared the tossed salad with a tasty celery seed dressing. Just great food, great service and wonderful people. read more

The meat lovers pizza was terrific! Very attentive wait staff. Good value for the food quality.

I've been coming here since I was a kid, it's so worth the drive because the pizza is unique and hand made. Super cheesy. Amazing calzones - I love them even more than the pizza. read more

Friendly service. Taylor helped us get our order in quick so we could make it to our movie. We had a medium Taco Supreme it was amazing. Would get again! read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Taco Supreme - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Ohio

Great local spot not too far off I-80. We were on our way to Chicago and wanted pizza. This place was quick and efficient. Pizza was good but a style we were not familiar with. I was in the mood for more of a NY style but this tasted good all the same. read more

We ordered a pizza to take home because we had our dog with us. It only took about 20 minutes to receive our order. We got a pepperoni and sausage medium pizza. It was really good! There was plenty of cheese, almost to the edge. If we are traveling through Milan again, I would definitely eat at Jim's Pizza Box. read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Pepperoni and Sausage Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Ohio

See all

Ordered takeout Pizza while traveling through. It was about 2 miles from our hotel. Anyway, as soon as I placed my order I was surprised it said it would be ready in just 15 minutes? Ordered a large supreme pizza and cheesy bread. Showed up and the place was very busy but food was ready, place looked really cool, old school building, very clean. I asked if I could have some paper plates because we were staying at a hotel, the staff totally hooked us up with plates, forks, napkins, red peppers flakes and Parmesan. Extremely friendly, pleasant and professional. Got back to the hotel with the Pizza and it was a hit with the family, crust was great, lots of cheese and toppings, the sauce was awesome. My in-laws seen someone carrying a box from a Marcos chain and everyone remarked they were so happy with Jim's pizza box because it was a huge upgrade compared to any chain restaurant. And it was pretty cheap considering how much food we got, we were happily eating cold pizza on the road all the way to Maine. If you're traveling through town, check this place out! It's awesome, you won't be disappointed! read more

Visiting and heard about this local spot in Milan. Apparently the owner is well-established in the community and supports the local high schools! Only ordered a large calzone but wish I also got a pizza. The calzone was yummy - loved the dough In this location, there is the pizza place with lots of seating. But it is also connected to a full bar! read more

Jim's Pizza Box - a pizza box on a table - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Ohio

See all

We arrived at 7:00 on a Friday night expecting a wait, since the Yelp reviews are SO good. We were shocked to find the restaurant had hardly anyone inside. We stayed and are glad we did! The service was good, the pizza was absolutely delicious, and the homemade ranch was superb. The owner makes frequent rounds chatting with patrons, it's adorable, so small town and genuine. I loved it! If you're in the area make a stop. I wish we had had more time to walk around this hidden little downtown. read more

Such a cute place! The town is adorable and the food is delicious. Very friendly staff, too!

The food was really good. Baked Rotoni was amazing. You can tell this is the local.hangout for all ages. The girls that served us were kind enough to tell us the difference between Cinci chili and how they all like it. Would definitely come here for a great meal read more

See all

The crust was good. The issue we had is they put colby cheese on top of every pizza (or in the calzones). We thought we'd give it a try but learned it is simply not for us. The flavor of colby overpowered all the other flavors - note we did do veggie based pizzas, so no sausage or pepperoni to stand up against the colby; that said the sauce flavor couldn't be detected either. read more

The pizza was burnt. It was done on the inside. The toppings were next to nothing. You couldn't even tell there was any sauce on it. I was very very disappointed. I all the way from Fremont to come to your establishment. It used to be the best pizza don't know what happened, but it was really disappointed. read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Ohio

See all

WOW!!! We got the meat-lovers pizza! It was absolutely delicious!!! My daughter said if we ever want pizza in the future, we're making the three hour drive from our home in Michigan to come here! Definitely will return!!! read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Medium meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Ohio

One word: HAPPY. This place was awesome! It's in the cutest little square of town. The place is a lot bigger on the inside and there was plenty of room to sit our party of 11 though the place was packed. Our server was so sweet! She was on it even though she was being pulled in a million directions. The menu is huge, I had a hard time deciding on what to get but in the end chose the eggplant Parmesan sandwich and I'm so glad I did. The eggplant was perfectly battered without getting lost in the cheese and sauce. It came with potato chips and a pickle. My daughter loved her pepperoni pizza and even did the "happy dance" while eating it. They had really good cocktails as well- I had the pink polka dot and if you're like me and don't care for the taste of alcohol, this one is for you! Next trip to northern Ohio, we will certainly make it a point to stop here! read more

See all

I love their Pizza, meat lovers for me! The service is always great and the ambiance is good with lots of TV's and very clean.

Beyond amazing food! We have been 4 times now over 8 months and are always happy. We always get pepperoni pizza which is great but this last time we took friends and ordered wings and the taco supreme. Our minds were blown away. I can't stop thinking about the Yukon gold wing sauce and the taco supreme was something I would never try and now am craving all the time. Well done! read more

See all

We were in the area - just taking a drive - and looked up pizza places. This seemed like a pizza place everyone enjoyed so we picked up a taco pizza and an Asian salad. We enjoyed both and will definitely order from here again if we are in the area read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Asian Salad - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Ohio

See all

There are a lot of Italian restaurants in the area, but you won't find a better tasting pizza or calzone in Milan. The staff is very friendly and there's definitely a small town mom and pop feel to this joint. It's always a great stop when in the Milan area. read more

Good pizza. Had somewhat of a pizza hit crust. We did take out so not much to write about the interior. Service was good.

We ordered takeout for a late dinner while traveling - shortly before they closed. The staff was super friendly and accommodating. The pizza was terrific. We had a Hawaiian and a build your own. Both were great! read more

For $5.99 the garlic cheese bread is GREAT value for the money. The sauce is steaming fresh. Milan, Ohio is a great little town. The statues in my pictures are of a young Thomas Edison, born in Milan. The restaurant is on the town square, I ate my food on a bench in the square. read more

See all

Taco Supreme pizza lived up to the hype. Delicious. Pep, mushroom, banana pepper and ham pizza also was great. Took others advice and got it extra crispy. Crust was perfect. Went on a Saturday afternoon before the rush. read more

Passing through Milan, OH and needed to grab food before stopping for the night. Ordered wings and a supreme pizza and both were excellent. Definitely give this place a try if you are passing through town! read more

Absolutely fantastic pizza. I suggest you ask her to be done extra crispy. Super good place grade ingredients super fresh we will be back! It. read more

Just passing through Tryon on my way back to Michigan from Cleveland. The front desk at my hotel suggested Jim's pizza box for a great pie. I love small-town America... From the gentleman that took my order over the phone, he actually thanked me for my order. To the gentleman that delivered it to my hotel room. The pizza was as good as anything I've ever had in 35 years of traveling throughout the Midwest! To know that I can support a small town Business person is satisfying. Great food great people, what else you need?! read more

I think I'll begin by saying the service was fabulous. The staff seemed abundant, friendly and energetic. Next I'll say that the menu was extensive. So much more to offer than just pizza. We went there for pizza, so pizza is what you'll read about here. My expectation is that a really good pizza should take at least a half hour to bake. With that expectation, and the fact that we were pretty hungry, we ordered an appetizer first. The appetizers were expensive. For this first experience, though, we were willing to dump out our coin purses. The sauerkraut balls were at our table in less than 5 minutes. Not even a fancy presentation of the 8-10 pieces that cost $12.99, but they tasted fine. When she brought out the appetizer we ordered a medium deluxe pizza, which miraculously arrived before we even finished the appetizer-- so much for my expectations of cooking time! The pizza was just ok, it was a bit of a thin crust with the toppings going all the way to the edges. I sprinkled hot pepper flakes on my piece to give it some flavor. The dining room was clean with soft ambient lighting. There were TVs for watching and keno to play. There was a pretty nice looking bar in a nearby room but we didn't sit there. The space was family friendly with tables for large groups, and cozy booths for first dates. Customers of all ages were dining in and carrying out in the less than 40 minutes we were there. I'll finish by saying the place didn't live up to the hype. For two waters, an appetizer and medium pizza, we paid $32.01. We weren't stuffed, and there were no leftovers to take home. Don't get me wrong, it's a perfectly fine place-- if you have an unlimited budget and don't mind that every server calls the customers "you guys" read more

Staying the night in Milan for business. Visited the adorable city square and then went to Jim's Pizza Box for dinner. Had a medium thin crust pizza with extra pepperoni, black olives, and cooked well done... and it was absolutely outstanding and delicious!! And all of the employees behind the counter, as well as the chef who brought out my pizza, were super friendly and nice. Five stars for excellent customer service, also! read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Medium thin crust pizza, extra pepperoni, black olives, cooked extra well done. It was delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Ohio

Jim's was on the list of restaurants that would deliver to our hotel. I was happy when I called and ordering was quick and easy. When our food was delivered one order was wrong (no bbq on one order of boneless bbq wings) we got an extra Caesar salad which I did not order and there were no condiments. The food was ok. We had the chicken Caesar salad, steakhouse burger and boneless barbecue wings. Maybe the pizza was the way to go. Be sure to ask for condiments if ordering for delivery. read more

Having a meal at Jim's Pizza Box is always an excellent experience. The food is always good and the service is prompt and correct. It is consistently a friendly environment. Definitely worth the time and money. read more

We tried Jim's Pizza Box after reading some of the amazing reviews on Yelp and it was definitely as good as advertised!! We had the hot honey pepperoni pizza and it was unreal; honey will now be my go to pizza topping. We also had the taco supreme pizza and it was delicious! We even got to meet Jim himself and he brought us out a free plate of his spaghetti with their signature sauce; it was so good!! Will definitely make a return trip!! read more

Phenomenal family owned business! We were in town for the week! This place is a gem! My hats off to the people and the chef! Thank you for the wonderful experience! read more

Very welcoming restaurant. Excellent service and friendly staff. Great food. Lots of good menu choices.

Best place to eat in Milan!!! Jim is always friendly,as is his staff. He comes out of the kitchen to talk to his customers and really supports the community!! read more

Local favorite. Weekly pizza specials. Friendly staff. Small town quality, at fair prices.

What a wonderful pizza spot!!! We are traveling from Indianapolis to check out cedar point and thought we would check Yelp for a local pizza place. This place was absolutely amazing!! We all had different calzones and everyone's was delicious!! Salad was all cut fresh the same day and the dinner rolls were great!! Would definitely recommend this pizza spot to anyone!! Thank you read more

Excellent pizza. I would definitely visit again. Bacon and pepperoni and then bacon and peppers. I would absolutely get get this again.

Awesome pizza, Very nice people on the phone. I ordered from Super 8 motel and they were Very accommodating. Got it here fast and Hot. Good job guys. Thanks again. read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Hit the spot. - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Ohio

The owner walks around talks to everyone. Knows their names. He brought a free garlic bread while we waited for our food. The bus boy is super super friendly. The food was amazing and different. They had soda bottles the I have never seen before. We loved everything! Almost makes me wanna move to Ohio!!!! read more

Best pizza we've ever had. Everything was cooked to perfection- the crunchy bacon topped on the pizza was AMAZING. Got to meet the owner while enjoying a drink at the bar and he was so nice! The bartender was also amazing- super nice, attentive, and fun. We also met a few of the locals and we're so welcoming and friendly. 10/10 would visit again read more