Jimmy John&#x27;s

The store is a hole in the wall, which can be a great sign of being a local spot and not touristy…read more The guy at the counter was very friendly, but the prices are way too high. I tried the samples but nothing was worth the prices they were charging. I didn't buy anything but if you're looking to try different flavored cheeses, you'd probably find a good one here.

We stopped in yesterday while in Lake Geneva. I saw it pop up on yelp and then we happened to drive…read moreby. I had to stop! There's ample parking right in front, so easy to pop on in real quick. The inside isn't very big, but they really pack in lots of stuff in there. The staff is so nice! They of course have a ton of assorted cheeses. I opted for cheese curds from one of the refrigerated areas. They also have an assortment of beers. Also as you check out, they have some samples on the counter for you!

Salted Caramel Cookies.....so good!

See all

Outside

Lake Geneva Country Meats

4.4(86 reviews)

4.3 mi

Was wonderful. They have great produce. I bought some duck eggs. Looking forward to cooking with em…read more. A beautiful sprig of Rosemary. Everything felt like it was picked that morning .

I took a chance and ordered a turkey to try something new. Drove out and picked up today. First…read moretime in the store. The store is fully stocked with plenty of food, sauces, spices, deli meats, fridge items and frozen items. Wanted to try the ham so ordered some of that as well. And they even have dog treats. The staff is very friendly. The facily is clean. Transaction was fast and smooth. Prices are reasonable.

See all

11/2025

Bell's Liquor & Deli Store

4.8(5 reviews)

4.6 mi

Stopped her along our way back to the hotel to grab some food and drinks for the road. I'm happy…read morethat this place is open late at night and it was actually our late night hero. This place featured a decent amount of snacks and munchies since we were looking to have a a little party back in our hotel. The price is here are below average and you're not paying the Tourist price. I do think that this establishment is a little bit outdated but it serves as purpose. Great hours, staff here was very friendly. Please keep in mind at the late Geneva area does have weird laws when it comes to liquor so please read up on it before stopping here because I promise you that you're cashier is not trying to screw you over. This more so applies to people that do not live in the area

Bell's is a deceptively small store - it's easy to drive past and think of it as just a humble…read morelittle shop. However, you really do have to get inside before you miss out. It's easily the best selection of liquor for miles, including some pretty pricey stuff. On my last visit, I salivated over a few bottles of scotch with three-digit price tags. It would be wasted on me, though. Better to let someone with a more-refined sense of taste buy it. Anyway, in addition to a wide variety of wine, beer, and spirits, there's a decent grocery selection, too. It won't rival Sentry, but given a choice between a huge grocery store with a decent liquor section and a great liquor store with a decent grocery section, I'll choose the second one eight days a week.

Hill Valley Cheese Shop & Cheese Bar

5.0(13 reviews)

0.3 mi

My mom and I were pretty excited to visit a cheese bar, as big fans of great cheese and wines and…read morecraft cocktails. We were not disappointed. But call, the hours on Yelp are not the bar hours, which are extended. The space was formerly a little cheese shop for Clock Shadow. It was pretty basic. The atmosphere has really ascended. There is a small retail section and cheese case for shoppers. The bulk of the small space has been transformed with moody, chic wallpaper, a classic old school bar and tables. The staff are all friendly and knowledgeable. Service is very good and not intrusive, but you will learn a thing about what you're experiencing. The pairings are eye opening. The cheese is exquisite. Although the cheese itself is on the expensive side, the flights are reasonable for what you get. The pours on the wine are fair and there is enough cheese to share. Dried fruit and corn are added as a pallet cleanser. Loved it! Everyone needs a cheese bar with drink pairings. The wine and beer menu as suggested pairings for cheese as well. They also have some interesting craft cocktails. Street parking can be an issue, so maybe prepare for a little walk during popular times.

This wonderful cheese deli and bar is a fantastic stop if you are visiting Lake Geneva. My partner…read moreand I stopped by on a weekend afternoon and we were SO pleasantly surprised by the experience. The shop is split into two parts: the deli counter where you can sample and buy cheeses, and the cafe/bar where you can sit down and order cheeseboards and wine flights. We started in the deli and the young blonde woman behind the counter (I'm sorry, I didn't catch her name, but she was incredible) gave us such good recommendations. The Luna and the shallot herb cheese were to die for! The Luna won 3rd place internationally in a cheese contest, and you'll see why when you taste it. So complex and nuanced, with little crunchy crystals of salty goodness from the year and a half it spends aging. We then went to the cafe part, which has a good number of tables, and ordered a couple cheese plates. Again, our girl delivered--she made our cheese plates so that the accompaniments were all different and so we could try as many crackers and side dishes as possible. So thoughtful! The price was also very reasonable. Would not hesitate to come back here again. Fantastic service! And try the Luna!

See all

Build your own cheese board with accompaniments

Stinebrink's Piggly Wiggly - Lake Geneva

3.1(45 reviews)

1.1 mi

Bakery dept is amazing. Store is clean, however sometimes waiting for the sale prices is the best…read moreway to go. It's a pretty expensive store. Produce is fresh which is always a bonus

Premium prices, poor service .Saturday morning got to the checkout only to find no cashiers asked…read morean employee when do the cashiers start not until 10:30am on a Saturday morning are you kidding me. Put my refrigerated items back and left.

See all

Potbelly

3.3(68 reviews)

0.1 mi

First timer for us in potbelly. My sister described it as a nicer Subway. And I agree. This store…read morehas big seating space inside and some tables outside looking at the main street and a little bit of the lake. It's pretty nice eating outside. The day we were there, something was wrong and smokes were all over the inside of the store. The staffs were suffering from the smoke but they were still trying their best to work. Very friendly staffs. The $7.99 combo meal was perfect. You get a half sandwich, a bag of chips and a drink. Food was good. We tried the meatball, the Mediterranean. Good flavor. It's a nice place for lunch.

This was probably the least clean Potbelly I've ever been to. Food all over the floor, table was…read moresticky, bathroom toilet paper looked like this. There were also multiple flies inside and a bunch of cardboard boxes in the dining area. Service took a while and if this is how the dining area looks, it makes me wonder if the kitchen is even worse. Perhaps they need more staff to keep things clean!

See all

Nick’s On The Lake

2.8(1.2k reviews)

0.1 mi

When you walk in it feels like you in a pirate ship. Very coastal themed. Big space…read more The waitress was nice and attentive. We had the Ribeye and it was really tasty. We ordered the 12 oz. but I think they gave us the larger one. This ribeye was really thick, cooked perfect and absolutely tasty. Just an fyi, this place used to be called Popeyes, and now it's named Nick's

Pretty basic fried food plus "barbecue" and some pasta dishes…read more Food is not the best option. Should have realized when it wasn't crowded.

Indoor space.

Pretzel bites with cheese

See all

Outside

Walgreens

2.0(33 reviews)

1.1 mi

•$$$

Extremely disappointed with my recent experience at the Walgreens in Lake Geneva. I placed a photo…read moreorder for my daughter's first birthday -- a big day for our family. I picked up what I thought was a completed order, only to get partway home (with a cake and melting ice in the car) and realize the photos hadn't been trimmed as they were supposed to be. I had to drive all the way back to get it fixed. When I finally got home again -- now two hours later -- I opened the poster I'd ordered and discovered that it also wasn't trimmed to size. It looks sloppy and unusable. I tried calling the store to avoid another trip, but after being put on hold twice and never speaking to anyone, it seems I'll have to go back again just to get what I paid for. This is not the first time I've had issues at this location -- they've also failed to have prescriptions ready when promised in the past. I understand that mistakes happen, but there seems to be a serious lack of attention to detail and follow-through here. Not worth the stress or wasted time.

The worst i have ever encountered! It is so disorganized there, no one knows what they are doing…read more They dont answer the phones or if they do ur put on hold forever and then disconnected. Their app just keep sending you updates that make no sense at all and gives you no details either. The website is just as bad. Deplorable service and its clear no one is steering the boat

A lucky penny, from Walgreens! What does the FG signify on a penny like this, it's a 1990

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Cliff K.

45

3

0

10 years ago

The owner owns a few stores, he has a store in mchenry where he allows a convicted child molester who works off the clock with underage children. ...r his is a fact his name is nate...his gf cassie runs the store. ...I would be sickened to know children work with such a beast and the owner and store manager aware of the situation. ....stay away... I r prove me wrong....epic deli is down the street read more

Andrew T.

0

1

0

7 years ago

I walked in with some friends who ordered and asked if my friend still worked here. Short brown haired girl responded with "no, he's a psychopath" I have no idea what she was talking about, but that's extremely unprofessional of a worker to say to a customer. Not returning. read more

Ben Guerra

0

1

2 years ago

I am completely outraged with this service and i can't believe this worker named dane would put this in my sandwich

Haidyn S.

0

1

0

2 years ago

The tall skinny kid that works there idk his name was very disruptive and wouldn't listen to his higher ups

Claire P.

37

3

0

4 years ago

most terrible sandwich I had in my life. Don't bother ordering from them try Subway

Jimmy John's - sandwiches - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin Parking near Jimmy John's

BEST of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin Restaurants near Jimmy John's

BEST of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin Desserts near Jimmy John's

BEST of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin Things to Do near Jimmy John's

BEST of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin Coffee near Jimmy John's

BEST of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin Pizza near Jimmy John's

BEST of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin Breakfast near Jimmy John's

BEST of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin Shopping near Jimmy John's

BEST of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin Lunch near Jimmy John's

BEST of Lake Geneva, Wisconsin Smoke Shop near Jimmy John's

Best of Lake Geneva

Things to do in Lake Geneva

Browse Brands

Jimmy John's

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Jimmy John's also viewed

Subway

3.4

(20 reviews)

Love this location! Always friendly, clean and stocked. Always greeted. Food is made fresh…read more Best part is they give back and do so much for the community. They support our local schools and teacher events. They always partner with fundraising events. Very giving and supportive!

Super slow. Incompetent to multiple task. Super slow. Not…read moreaccurate with service and quality.

Cousins Subs

3.2

(13 reviews)

Love the subs here, the bread is always very fresh as are the veggies and meats. A little higher…read morepriced vs. subway but a much better sandwich hands down. My only gripe with this location is its somewhat awkward floor plan. The drink station is located behind tables and when there are people sitting at those tables it feels really cramped.

Iv been here multiple times and ordered the pepperoni melt because that's my favorite. With no…read moreonions and no mayo. And EVERY TIME COMES WITH EXTRA MAYO AND ONIONS! Even in person! Worst cousins I know!

Sammy's on the Square

4.1

(175 reviews)

As in the name, Sammy's under square is under square in Walworth. Only negative part of this review…read moreis the parking as it's very limited or you'll be walking a little bit. At some point, they expanded the restaurant so it can easily handle over 150 people and I'm guessing anywhere is up to 180 people. Was very clean inside and appears that it had been painted not too long ago. Our waitress was Alaina. Hope I spelled, her name right. Very good waitress and made sure she took care of us. I had a few questions about the food on the menu and she had all the answers. I got what I think was called the sweet potato brisket skillet. My girlfriend had just eggs, toast, hashbrowns with bacon. She said the coffee was OK. She's a little fussy with the coffee so we've had a few places where it's been great. She says it's drinkable and she liked it. Good enough! They give you generous portions of food. The bacon was cooked crispy the way she likes it and the eggs were done perfectly. Hashbrowns taste fresh and good and never cooked perfectly. They under utilize salt, but there's probably a good reason for it and that's why you have salt at the table. The skillet I had, however, was real good! Generous portions of brisket and the sweet potatoes were cut strips and grilled and tender. It had chunks of green peppers which were grilled and you could tell they were fresh. Fresh grilled onions and chunks of tomatoes inside. It was loaded with cheese too. My eggs were done to perfection and I had the sourdough toast. Their sourdough toast is Home made style bread. I don't believe it's baked in the restaurant, but it was very good. Once again, very generous portions. The place is huge inside with plenty of elbow room. As for the price, their prices were average and in line with other places we've eaten breakfast in the area. The whole staff that is there greeted you at one point or the other. Very friendly staff. They are also open for lunch and dinner. The place is busy for breakfast so I'm guessing that they're Friday night fish fries probably pretty packed. I highly recommend Sammy's on the square.

Pros: avocado was fresh, there was a lot of great options on the menu to choose from, place looked…read moreclean overall Cons: steak cooked so fast it turned out tough, food was good but not super warm, the blueberry Swedish pancakes were watery so I'm assuming the blueberries were frozen It's nice to have a breakfast spot in the area with a variety of options on the menu. This is good if you're looking for a traditional breakfast, but not a place where you'd have a memorable meal. Staff members were friendly.

Brodie's Beef

4.0

(100 reviews)

Greeted upon walking and the staff when ordering is so friendly. We ordered an Italian beef with…read morefries and a cheeseburger (not pictured) the food did not disappoint! Generous portions! The Italian beef is delicious and the fries are natural cut and soooo delicious, with a lil malt vinegar and ketchup too. The cheese burger was also good. Small clean restaurant in a strip mall right off the interstate. Lots of cute quirky signs. Only odd thing was the chairs are all up and it gives the feel they are closing. He assured us they were not and we could dine in.

Any time I get the chance to visit Brodie's Beef, the experience is always great. The food is…read morecooked to perfection and flavorful, and there always seems to be a specialty item. This time around, they had a chocolate chocolate chip cake available for Valentine's Day. It was EXTREMELY affordable, and honestly, they were undercharging for how delicious that cake was. I've never had such a most cake with such light, whipped frosting before. I wish I purchased more of them! While I didn't have them this time around, if you ever get the chance to visit, you have to try the funnel cake fries! They're topped with a generous amount of powdered sugar and make for a perfect post-meal treat.

Daddy Maxwell's Diner & Cafe

4.1

(195 reviews)

Mila the best server ever -- always smiling menu great--…read moreFrench badder pancakes the best always fresh and hot -- homemade donuts the best local favorite

This was my mom's favorite place when she was alive. I've…read moreseen it go through a few operators since and she would be disappointed. Everything tasted like the oil they use to cook it in, just horrible. I saw my waitress 3 times; once to take my order, once to deliver the food and once to drop the bill. No refills offered and no attention paid. When I went to pay, and old timer sitting at the bar complained that his coffee hadn't been refilled and the lady behind the counter said "all you need to do is ask!" This is not my mothers Daddy Maxwell, sadly. I had high hopes for the new operator. Good luck!

Mama Cimino's

3.2

(157 reviews)

Got a 10" ciminos everything pizza with Bosco sticks. The…read moreamount of toppings on there was insanity. It was decent, the service was fine. Cash only, they have an atm. We were lucky enough to witness a 16 year old attempt to complete their hurricane challenge.

Farmer was awesome . Phenomenal service . He was…read moreinformative did not rush us. Very through in explaining. Started off with really great meat balls. So tender and delicious. Everything from scratch. My boyfriend who wasn't hungry had one meatball and two and a half pieces of pizza. Open late night. The owner was very nice, talked about the history of M.C. Will be back

Riga-Tony's Delicatezzi Italiano

4.6

(134 reviews)