We are huge fans of Jersey Mike's restaurants. And we have frequented many across the southeast US. But this is the first time I was so impressed that I felt I needed to drop a review in Yelp. Everyone was welcoming the moment we stepped inside. They took our order, filled the order and presented our food with a smile on their face and very pleasant attitude. Plus, the sandwiches were made perfectly! I never had to repeat any part of my order. The place was spotless, and the crew presented themselves very clean and very efficient. To prove this was not a one off great experience... The next day I placed a mobile order for food I was bringing to a school picnic. The mobile order was 100% correct and everything in the bag was packed with care. I've stopped at other Jersey Mike's in the Tallahassee area just because it was a bit closer and I have always been disappointed. From now on, I don't care how far out my way i need to drive. This is my go to Jersey Mike's in Tallahassee!. read more

I asked for extra pickles and shawn UNDERSTOOD the assignment, much love food is always great

The restaurant was clean and orderly and the service was superb! The sandwich just wasn't that great? The hot Italian was overwhelmed by the pepper relish. Over all it was ok but I was very disappointed! My wife wanted sub in a tub. When I got home she was disappointed too?! JS read more

BEST STAFF EVER!!! Forever the best sandwiches and always so friendly always the so happy go lucky makes my day everytime. Colby and Chance never fail to make me laugh and always are sure to give me the best gluten free sandwiches I can have! read more

BEST STAFF EVER!!! The food is always the best. made with love always and never fail to put a smile on my face!! Colby and Chance are always super helpful and very funny! I have never and I know I will never have a bad experience at this location! read more

Jersey Mike's is still a solid sandwich place for the quantity and price. Fresh ingredients and no cutting corners on quality. Everything has gone up in price, but they are not price gouging like a lot of other sub chains. Great and convenient location. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

Ordered the Original Italian sub... The cheese, pepperoni and salami were as thin as my fingernail and couldn't be tasted on the sandwich.. I only had vinegar & oil on it.. there was none I ended up with a very dry ham sandwich... will not be back read more

Do not go to this location, take the extra 15 min drive to the next closest Jersey mikes. I have been to this location three times in a row they have got my order wrong. Twice I asked for no peppers and onions on my cheesesteak, but I get home to find peppers and onions and the other time they completely forgot the chipotle mayonnaise. Do not got to this location read more

3.75 On our road trip we decided to order Jersey Mike's online and pick it up when in the area. When we went into the restaurant our order was on a cart. My husband checked the name and it was ours. One of the men at the counter asked for the name on the order to confirm before we took our food. While in the restaurant I decided to use the bathroom. I was a little disappointed. It was clean but they had only a little bit of toilet paper and their paper towel dispenser was empty or not working. It needed to be restocked. This time I ordered the Turkey and Provolone sandwich on wheat bread with mustard. It was decent. I would have preferred more turkey in the sandwich but there was plenty of lettuce, tomato and onions. The vinegar and olive oil made the sandwich more soggy than what I am used to. I think they put too much on my sandwich. The wheat bread was decent but soggy. I've never tried the turkey and provolone but I'd order it again. Overall it was a quick way to order and pick up food on the road during a road trip. read more

See all

I just bought a sandwich there at 6pm. This was some of the best customer service I've ever experienced. The young guy taking orders was very nice and friendly. His customer service was top tier. I forgot to get his name but it his customer service was excellent. The experience of ordering there is how other businesses should operate. Kudus to that young man. read more

Stopped by during a road trip for an early dinner. The workers were polite and friendly, and were super understanding with a picky member of our party. Everything was clean, and the bathrooms were well kept, though the floors were a bit sticky. Our food came out very fast, and was still quite hot when we received it. I got a Philly with my usual modifications, and it came as expected. Overall, a great location that lives up to their company's catchphrase, "A sub above." read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #17 Mike's Famous Philly Rosemary Bread & Mayo - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

How do you run out of something when you just opened??? Give me 2/3 pickles & peppers and hair

We came in and ordered 2 cold subs and 1 hot sub. Wife and son got there sandwiches but after 20 minutes of waiting I never got my #43. Staff did not know what to do so asked for my money back and we left. Awful service! read more

I ordered 5 items, 3 sandwiches and 2 bags of chips via Door Dash. Bag came sealed from the store and no chips that I paid for. How do you screw up 5 items when even the receipt attached to the bag has the chips on there?. Other than that, the sandwiches were fresh and ingredients were great. read more

I first want to say my Sub was an absolute joke. It was the smallest sub I have ever seen and the bread was not cut, it was obviously ripped. I ordered a giant and when it got to my home it was only a regular. I decided not to even deal with it bc they gave me the run around on the phone. read more

Went last night for dinner 2 hours before closing, when we got inside the person that made my husbands sandwich and mine was pretty short with us and seemed pretty annoyed we were even there. We also thought it was a little weird that all the meats were already out of the front fridge so far ahead of closing. Genuinely none of this would really matter to me if I hadn't woken up sick this morning with symptoms pointing towards food poisoning. It might just be a weird coincidence, but it's the only thing I ate outside of my usual routine and the meats not being in the fridge kinda makes me think something was off. read more

Fresh food, generous portions, quick service, and excellent customer service. Food is delicious!

Cleanliness: 10/10 Employees:10/10 Service:10/10 Food:11/10 Price: 9.5/10 Selection:10/10 The speed, quality and accuracy of my order left nothing lacking. The sandwiches are high quality in flavor and portions. I ordered the chicken Philly and I was not disappointed in the least. I was in heaven with every bite. Although I split the gargantuan sandwich with someone, my half was a struggle to consume...I was stuffed. The staff greet you as soon as your foot crosses the threshold, and you greeted with professionalism, smiles and staff who wear their uniform correctly. They appear to take great pride in their jobs. They are very knowledgeable about the menu and can make suggestions on the turn of dime. This is one of the cleanest places I've entered as far as an eating establishment. And please do not forget to join their rewards program. One last note, those chocolate chip cookies are to die for! read more

Ordered food for 10 online. All were delicious. My only issue is I asked for wheat and it was on white. We will be back.

This is for delivery, I ordered up a few subs and some drink for delivery. They came within the time period which is a little longer then most but was clearly listed. I got a #20 Grilled Pastrami Reuben (Regular) ,#15 Meatball and Cheese (Regular) #13 The Original Italian (Giant). Everything was good and you could taste the freshnes of the bread, vegetables and meat. Doesn't taste presliced like some if the other sandwich places like subway. You can really taste the difference if the fresh slicing no real slimy coating. I like to have mine topped "Make it Mike's Way" where as my kid just likes it plain with nothing but either way you can go wrong. Quality meats on fresh bread made to order. read more

See all

This review is not about the food but about the general tenor of the staff. Came in before lunch rush, water (condensation) was dripping from an A/C vent on ceiling onto the floor in front of chips rack where customers stand in line. Mentioned to staff that water was dripping and was slippery. They said yes they knew. Mentioned that it was quite wet by this point and someone could slip, but they went about their business, didn't clean up or put a yellow floor sign out, etc. Went to fill my drink at the soda dispenser and found that the Pepsi was out, ie, only was dispensing carbonated water. Told staff, they said it needed to be changed. Ate my whole meal and they never changed it, offered no refund for a drink I never consumed. Will not return to this location. read more

Best sub I ever had . We stop at Jersey Mikey's after every home FSU football. Love their subs.

Love love love the Chipotle Chicken Philly. It honestly may be my favorite sub in Tally. Jersey Mike's makes awesome subs every time I go. As with many chains, you can expect your food to be consistent. Jersey Mike's does both hot and cold subs. For the cold subs, you've got all the basics. I have only ever ordered a cold sub once when I was sick. For the most part I always get one of the hot subs, because that's just my preference. My all time favorite is the Chipotle Chicken Philly, if you didn't guess by the start of the review. I also frequent the Chipotle Steak Philly. Both are great, depending on if you're feeling chicken or steak. The meat is flavorful and covered with melted cheese, peppers, and onions oozing out of it. Mmmm. All subs are highly customizable. You can choose your toppings and they will happily change anything that comes pre set on the menu if you want to. If I haven't already stressed it enough, try the Chipotle Chicken Philly! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Chipotle Chicken Philly - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

The food is acceptable, but I find the staff to be inattentive and the service inexplicably slow.

The best customer service that I have received in all of Tallahassee. I ordered a sandwich and the size was incorrect, they apologized and the manager brought me the right size Sandwich, chips and a coupon for the inconvenience. Such an outstanding experience 5 read more

Just love the Italian sub's here! How can a sub be wrong when they put a salad on top of it with red wine vinegar and olive oil!!?? My husband loves the Philly cheese with onions and peppers...nice and hot. When we are traveling if we can find a Jersey Mikes for lunch...we are there like here in Tallahassee. They train their staff to be friendly and engaging-inquiring about how your day is going etc. Love Jersey Mikes!! read more

Could it be? Could some brilliant mind out there have created a sandwich franchise BETTER than Jimmy John's??? YES, they have and Jersey Mike's is that place!!! Wow, this place rocks my socks. From the PERFECT bread to the fresh sliced deli meat and fresh veggies with their Mike's Way (minus the onions)...everything is perfect here, just perfect. I don't live in Tally anymore but every time I go there (which is quite often), I visit this specific location. It's cleaner than the one on Tennessee Street, the staff knows me and my boyfriend already, lol, and it's a lot less packed than the other one). What do I recommend you ask? The Club Sub. Ham, Turkey, Bacon, Cheese, Mike's Way (ditch the onion, unless you like them.) = PERFECT SUB. I am guilty of not trying any of their other sandwiches because that one is so damn good I could eat it every day! Don't hesitate-JUST GO! read more

We ordered eight subs for a work function. They put our names on the paper they rolled our subs in for ease and had them ready very quickly considering I called it in at 11:45 am! Best Philly Cheesesteak in Florida!! And they have 3 different types of cheesesteaks to choose from! Love it! read more

My two favorite sandwiches chains are Jersey Mike's and Jimmy Johns. I hate Subway. It's better to pay the a little extra for quality. My favorites sandwiches at Jersey Mike's Subs the famous Philly cheesesteak and chipotle cheesesteak. read more

Jersey Mikes has all the basic subs you would expect at any sub shop with some extra flavor! If you want a consistently good sub everytime, this is the place to go. I have tried a variety of their subs and they never disappoint. Their chipotle Philly sandwhiches, both chicken and steak, are by far my favorite choices. The chipotle sauce adds an extra boost to the already good sandwich with meat covered in cheese peppers and onions. If you're looking for a cold sub, I suggest the turkey breast and provolone. As far as the toppings go that's all up to you! They have two sizes, regular or gaint. The gaint really is gaint because the regular is pretty big at about 8 inches! The regular always fills me up. Unless your name is Shaquille O'Neil the regular should suffice. Nom Nom! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Chipotle Philly Steak - Sandwiches Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

So disappointed. I know that a local person opened up a few of these restaurants and had high hopes to support them in doing so. The line was long and slow but everybody was very friendly. I saw some friends in line and they raved about the place so I was excited. I ordered a grilled veggie wrap with extra ranch and was treated to a seven dollar wrap with a bunch of cheese and lettuce. They were absolutely no grilled veggies. None. zero. I'm not kidding, they put cheese ranch and lettuce with one tomato on a flavorless wrap and charged me seven dollars for it. Will not be back. read more

The chicken Philly sub is to die for! Really love the atmosphere and the staff are very friendly and asked if I wanted a cup of chipotle to try out with my sub. if you sign up for the email club they send you coupons via email all the time and they are some really fine people and subs at Jersey Mikes. Highly recommended. read more

The good thing about Jersey Mike's is they have consistent food no matter where you go. This particular location has the best customer service compared to the other locations in Tallahassee. The staff are always friendly and super efficient. Summer, the manager, is likely responsible for this. She's always cheery and very helpful. I've had my points stolen on two separate occasions. She printed out all my tickets and changed my phone number for me. She even called the store in California where the points were illegally used in hopes of catching the perpetrator. If you're a regular like me, you can take advantage of all the specials they run. Sign up for their newsletter for discounts. Go on Monday's for double points, and go on Tuesday's for 2 dollars off. Highly recommend this location. read more

Do not order delivery from this place it took 2 hrs for my food to arrive. The food was nothing special. I really was very disappointed with the quality of the food and the level of the service. All in all a very negative experience. read more

Jersey Mike's is pretty good no matter where you go. The staff at this location are friendly and willing to make a suggestion with a smile. It is hard to find good service like this! read more

The subs are amazing! Not only that, but the customer service is awesome! I love this location and the staff. The restaurant is always clean and they always have the items on the menu! 10 stars to this place! read more

Tallahassee has about a million fast food sandwich places and they are really all about the same...I like Jersey Mikes the best cause they still cut the meat and cheese to order and they have that tasty Hot Cherry Pepper Relish..I usually get the Italian or The Cheesesteak..family member recently got the tuna and said it was pretty tasteless....even though I like that they cut the meat and cheese to order it does create massive back-ups at the point of order and then the whole telling them what you want on your sub and payment area becomes a mass of confused people...that's why I recommend coming when it is not crowded for a better experience..though this is still my favorite fast food sandwich place I have gotten pretty stale bread the last 2 visits so it could drop shortly..would be 4 stars but gets a automatic one star deduction for not having Coke on fountain....ya just can't serve Pepsi in the South read more

Best subs I've ever had, that's a given. The staff make it even better. All are super friendly and Morgan the manager is awesome. Feel so welcomed everytime I come in.. Especially when she knows my order by heart :) great company, staff and food. Thank you. read more

Just came into this Sub shop in Tallahassee after spending 8 days with no electricity and getting ready for night 9. I asked the crew for their fav sub. They suggested the Philly cheesesteak for me to have a hot meal. The grill man and sandwich guy extraordinaire, Matt, a/k/a MT, cooked up a doozy. Meat, cheese, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeños and their specialty house cherry pepper (relish?). He made 1/2 a sub with the relish mixed in cooked & the other 1/2 with the relish on top fresh. Throw in some oatmeal raisin cookies and call it a meal. Ok, I've gotten home and eaten the subs. Awesome is overused, but applies to Jersey Mike's Subs and to the whole crew tonight. I came home to a dark house and a wife eating her veggie meal. I ate like a King. Best Philly Cheese stake outside of Philly! read more

Staff was pleasant however their lettuce was turning brown. I asked for fresh and they accomodated but than they did not replace the old lettuce, they just put it back. A little shady! read more