I had one of the worst experiences I've ever had at a Jersey Mike's location today. I've been a loyal customer and have eaten at Jersey Mike's across the country, including in Hawaii, and have never been treated this poorly. The young man behind the counter spoke to me in a way that was disrespectful and condescending. It was upsetting enough that I asked him to stop making my order and left the store. This interaction felt completely inappropriate, and frankly, I do not believe he would have spoken to a male customer in the same manner. I will be reporting this to management directly. As someone who works in media, I do not take experiences like this lightly, and I intend to make others aware. read more

I've ordered subs from this shop ( in Middletown) for MANY years, and today might be the last time! I bought a "giant" #5 "Super" sub, which I believe cost me over $18. I brought it to work with me and I can't leave or I would take it to them and ask if it was a joke! This sub was so scantly filled that I would have to take the "guts" out of two sections and combine them to make a "normal" looking sub! I just called them to see if the manager is going to be there when I get off work, and she won't be, so I told him about my problem and he said they're hearing that a lot, lately! Apparently they don't mind losing business! He told me to go on the app where I ordered my sub and put my complaint in there. I will, for sure! Here's a photo of my barely there sub! Buy your subs elsewhere!!! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Chintzy sub!!!! - Sandwiches Near Me - Middletown, New Jersey

I don't understand how it's a difficult task to make a sandwich properly. Im not asking for a 3 foot hero, but something with more than 5 slices of meat and bread thats not fresh...isnt too much to ask for. Jersey Mike did NOT have his way this time around. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - ITS A BREAD SANDWICH - Sandwiches Near Me - Middletown, New Jersey

Ordered chicken Philly, asked for mayo and to substitute the American cheese for provolone. Got American cheese and no mayonnaise. Ordered another sandwich and asked for pepper on it, got no pepper. Guess the two girls working tonight decided they weren't going to read the requests on the order. Sandwiches were still pretty decent but not how we wanted them read more

Sandwiches were very light on the toppings. Barely anything on them at all and we ordered a giant and half of it was nothing except bread.

Best BLT wrap I've ever had. I love that they have mini subs too. Service is always friendly

I was in the mood for a cheesesteak and needed to bring dinner home quick before my husband had to leave. This is a go to place for us for the best sandwiches. My favorite part is that they cut the cold cuts to order. It's fresh. I have also seen towards the back the employees preparing fresh veggie by slicing in up in store. I have read others complain about price but I would pay a little more for something that is fresh and not preserved in a container and shipped to the store. The bread is also baked fresh in the store. This visit I feel like the cheesesteak was much better on a fresh and very soft roll. I ordered one chicken and one steak sandwich. The meat for those sandwiches were also cooked to order on the grill. I didn't mind waiting a little longer for that. The employees are always very nice and greet you when you walk in. This location is great and always come back because of the quality of the food and great staff. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Middletown, New Jersey

I would give zero stars if I could. I placed an order for delivery through the Jersey Mikes app on 11/11. When delivered, half my order was missing and the chips I ordered were expired. I ended up having to go to the restaurant after work and exchange the expired chips as well as pick up what was missing from my order. EVERY single bag of chips out for sale had been expired for at least a month. The employee had to go to the back to get me a fresh bag. I reached out to online customer service regarding these issues. They have not answered my numerous emails from 11/11. Poor customer service at every turn. read more

I eat here regularly on Sunday after having my meal I had to use the bathroom only to be informed it was down how do you run a food establishment without a working bathroom read more

The sandwich was really juicy and tasteful. The service was quick and friendly. The atmosphere at this location was super chill and clean! Great job to the team here! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #44 Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak - Sandwiches Near Me - Middletown, New Jersey

Best Sub in the America ! The number #14 vege is the Best mikes way ! Staff is always friendly and fast Please open one in Lake Placid, NY read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Middletown, New Jersey

The service was great, but just got a $18 sub and it had hardly any meat on it. you are better off going to Middletown if you want Jersey Mike or just go to D A subs down the block read more

$11 for a regular sub with no meat place is a rip off asked them to put a little more meat on sandwich which literally had 5 slices on regular sub and was charged even more money. This chain is becoming a joke with prices which I don't mind paying if the sandwich had a little meat on them. read more

We have been here twice and the staff is very forgetful or doesn't listen close enough. Every time we order a sub in a tub they forget and make it on bread and we have to remind them we ordered a sub in a tub. When I ordered #9 Club Supreme they didn't include the bacon and I didn't realize until I got home to eat it- I shouldn't have to remind them about adding the bacon if it's listed on the menu. Hopefully this location gets better over time. read more

Husband got aggressive food poisoning after eating a sub from here. Will never order again PERIOD

Tried our new JerseyM in Cliffwood today. Had BOGO coupon. Very disappointed. Had roast beef n provolone sub. Tasteless. Doctored it up with hot pepper, more onions. Nothing helped. Bread detracted also. Sooo disappointed. Wanted this to be a hit cuz in our neighborhood. Usually get subs from Ray's Real pizza when we order. Their bread is nicely toasted n sub is yummy. Will keep going back there but JM is off the list. read more

Amazing customer service, consistant, and ALWAYS on time when mobile ordering. In a time when nobody is working and good help is hard to find, these guys always have a smile on their faces. favorite spot for lunch during the work week! read more

The store Manager Tom is exceptional people and knows how to help and support local groups looking to fundraise or in need of a big cater meal. Subs are always great, but the people running this franchise are GOOD PEOPLE. read more

I just got a tuna sub from this Jersey Mike's. DON'T. I ordered lettuce, onion, provolone, and vinegar on it. No onion, and two skinny skinny pieces of provolone. The tuna was watery dark meat, sloshing off the bread in its gooeyness, and even though it was grossly watery, there were still blocks of dried out tuna stuck together in it. I've had a turkey sub from here and it wasn't bad but this tuna was horrible. Plus you end up feeling like you got a bread sandwich no matter what you pick. read more

The subs there are decent enough. The chicken cheesesteaks were a little bit on the greasy side, but I suppose that's to be expected in a cheesesteak sandwich. The restaurant itself was really nice, spotlessly clean, and the staff was friendly too. All around a good local chain if you need some hero sandwiches, but nothing legendary. read more

Consistently good. Attentive staff. Quality product, good parking , clean . Good place for a Sub

I drove over an hour to try and find a deli that Yelp had said was awesome... alas we couldn't find it (address was wrong) so as a last ditch effort for a quick bite to eat before a concert we stopped at Jersey Mike's. I have to say that I was impressed at the quality of the sub. Everyone was happy with their order, and I especially liked that you can choose to have your sub without bread (yes I know, sounds sacrilege) but it is a great option for those that are gluten free or just want something lighter. I had the buffalo chicken and it was really good - nice chunks of chicken with a good heat level, blue cheese, and fresh lettuce and tomato. Pretty much a win considering we were stressing over getting food before the show. read more

First of all, let me start by saying what an absolute rip off this place is. Spent just over $10 on a combo for a sad looking sandwich, chips and a drink that lasted all of three sips. During on of my visits there, I had asked for a chipotle cheesesteak without peppers and onions. What did they give me??? A ton of peppers and onions. It was a disgusting sloppy mess. It was almost inedible. I went back thinking I'd give them another chance and got the chicken club. The woman making my sandwich was obviously a trainee, but my issue was that there was absolutely no one looking after her. I had to repeat myself several times of how I wanted my sandwich because she was so easily frazzled and confused, which became frustrating. My sandwich had more oil than vinegar. The two measly strips of bacon I received were burnt. The sandwich was pathetic. This place is overrated. Go to a real deli and get your money's worth. read more

Delicious sandwiches. Roast beef sandwich is amazing. Best takeout-in the area. Nice atmosphere.

Extremely annoying that this place shuts down before their advertised closing hours. They should say that they lock the doors at 8:50pm rather than 9pm. read more

I've been getting subs from this particular location, or rather my family in Middletown has, for years. Always fresh, staff is always friendly & we've never had issues with our orders. We get them 'Mike's Way'. read more

Sandwiches have very little meat. Basically a lettuce sandwich. Employees are all high school kids that can care less about your meal. Could definitely be better. read more

I have been ordering from the Middletown location for well over 10 years now. They have yet to disappoint. If you come in to place an order on a weekend around lunch time, expect to wait in a long line, although the line does move rather quick, and it's worth the wait; you won't be disappointed. The bread is always fresh, and the meats are cut right in front of you. You can watch your sandwich being made so you know it's what you want. read more

For a newly opened shop, the service was fantastic, very friendly attentive staff, they slice your meats right in front of you, it doesn't get any fresher than that, I ordered a #5 and the only issue I had was that they really go heavy on the oil/vinegar, I'm certain that next time I order that I will tell them to go easy on that, they ask if you want extra condiments so it turns out to be a truly custom sandwich. Oh, yes, let's not forget the bread, forget all those so called competitors that say "we bake the breads fresh" this is the real deal, excellent bread freshly baked the way it should be. Best sandwich shop in town (it used to be Immediato's but they're no longer in business) read more

Jersey mikes in Middletown has great cheesesteaks and amazing service!

I have no night vision but I know NJ so I drove to find this spot with yes, wait for it, my husband who was gripping the armrest. Whoever was working that night was friendly and professional helping us when we got loss. All I got to say about the italian sub is it is a darn fine sandwich!!! Worth braving the dark!!? Definitely a must if your in the area. read more

My whole family loves Jersey Mike's. Simply the best subs. The food is always fresh and we can count on a delicious experience. Friendly, customer service oriented. When we were traveling to South Carolina last year, our GPS noted a Jersey Mike's along the road, a bit out of our way. We traveled the extra miles just to get a Jersey Mike's sub. read more

The shop used to be better. They put very little meat and/or cheese on the sandwich. If you go in on a Monday, you always get old bread left over from the weekend. I've tried other Jersey Mike's - they make a better sandwich. read more

The middletown location is the BEST JERSEY MIKES EVER! I usually frequent the store on weekends and the two ladies that are usually on are by far and awesome duo. Very friendly and and fast service. My subs are always so perfect.... read more

GREAT sandwiches! Highly recommend their cheesesteaks. Staff I is very kind and I love all of the options!