The atmosphere of this restaurant is wonderful. I love the whole look of the place. The wait staff is super friendly every time I've been there. We love it! The food is so good also. Definitely will go back again and again. read more

We recently had my mother in laws 90th birthday here. The atmosphere is great, as was the service. I think there were about 14 of us and everyone enjoyed their dinner. I don't think you can go wrong with anything on the menu. read more

Sat on the patio. It was uncomfortable cold. Heaters weren't all set up. Food got cold very quickly. Servers inconsistent. No salt and pepper on table. Food is normally very good, this time just ok. read more

Great food and service. Our go to for Italian. Planning a birthday party there too in January. read more

The people are very friendly and work to make your visit a pleasant relaxing experience. The food is very good. It is as good if not better than the original location in Mt Lebo read more

Solid meal. Instead of a regular appetizer, we ordered the pizza since we heard people raving about it. It was delicious with a nice crisp and combination of sauce (not too acidic) and toppings. The chicken parm had good portions. The chicken cutlets were lightly seasoned and thankfully not drenched in sauce like some other places like to. The chicken was crispy as a result. Spaghetti was Al dente. The ragu Napoletano was a wonderful assortment of meatballs, beef braciole, and sausage. It was a very satisfying savory meal. The service was fantastic and our server was attentive and friendly. read more

See all

I can't believe I forgot about writing this review! We came here this past Christmas Eve for a family dinner with a prefixed menu. (One of my gifts to everyone). :) Atmosphere/Service: -warm -family friendly Food: Bread -pretty stale and cold Antipasto Napoli -amazing Margherita Pizza -yum Cesare Salad/Anchovies -tasty, although a little light on dressing Eggplant Parm. -good Lemon Chicken -amazing! Rigatoni Bolognese -made with linguini NOT rigatoni and WAY too al dente! Braciole -WAY TOO MUCH GARLIC! Sorbet and Tiramisu -both yum Drinks -some good/some meh read more

See all

The pizza was pretty good and it's a very pretty venue, I will give them that. But my compliments end there. Service was among the absolute worst my family has had in the entire city. The waitress was not very polite and would often offer us things like more bread or water and just never return. At that point just don't offer it? The pasta my mother got was atrocious: It's like they shot a squirt of oil onto the dish from across the room and called it a day. Absolutely no flavor. The ambiance was good but never in a million years is it worth the price. I would highly recommend going to any of the other places in the plaza. This place felt like I was paying for the venue and not for good food. read more

If money is no concern to you, this place is outstanding. Great food, great service, very pricey. I enjoyed my dinner but this is a special occasion type of place, not a "I'll grab dinner on the way home" type of place. read more

My girlfriends and I came here on a Friday evening for dinner. It had been highly recommended by many of my patients so I was excited to try it. I knew it would be a little more pricey but I was willing to give it a try based on its reputation! We arrived at 5:30 and were seated very quickly. The restaurant was not very full - there were more people on the bar side which was the only part of the restaurant that served happy hour. Our waitress filled our water glasses and provided suggestions when we could not decide on what salad to share at the table. We ended up with the Misticanza - a mediterranian styled salad with tomatoes, chickpeas, olives, cheese, peppers and carrots, heavily dressed (almost too much) with a vinaigrette. Despite the dressing amount, it was a super fresh salad and a refreshing, light way to begin our meal. We then were served a basket of bread with a small plate of olive oil for dipping. The oil was definitely Italian as it was very nutty and flavorful. The bread had a crusty exterior with a super soft interior, however I felt it would have been much better warm. It was a part of the meal I could leave untouched. We decided to split two pizzas between the four of us. Per recommendation, we ordered the Bianca Pizza and Salsiccia Pizza. The Bianca was a white pizza with oil, ricotta, mozzarella, and parm - this was hands down the best part of the meal (with a consensus at the table)! The Salsiccia was topped with tomato sauce, very little cheese, and coin sized pieces of sweet sausage. The crust of both pizzas were very thin, very Italian like - the white pizza held up better as the sausage pizza was super flimsy and falling apart when trying to eat it. I was not a big fan of the tomato sauce and wished there was more cheese on it. Because we all shared the items among the table, prices were reasonable per person. However, I would not come here for a $20 pizza on a regular basis, though the white pizza may be an exception. The size of the salad was comparable for its price. The rest of the appetizer and entree items were more than I would want to spend on a typical evening out, unless we were celebrating something. The ambiance of this restaurant is unique and kind of cool. It was pretty dark inside, with fake tea lights on all the tables. The light fixtures looked like tree branches and dark wooden beams adorned the ceilings above. There was a section of the restaurant where the walls were graced with fancy wine racks with bottles and more bottles of wine! Overall, a nice date night feel. I would like to bring my husband here someday as we live so close. I also have heard the pasta is made from scratch so I would not be opposed to trying it. Good service, nice ambiance, just ok food, and steep pricing. Eh. read more

See all

We came from Ohio and met friends here. This is a grand restaurant in almost rural America. We have been to Italy, and we relived wonderful food memories here because everything was so similar. This venue is casual or dress up with a comfortable upscale feel. The food was fabulous. We ordered pasta and sides of meatballs. The sauce was fresh and oh, so good. The pizza was crispy with just the right amounts of ingredients. We shared the Italian charcuterie which had tasty meats, cheeses and olives. The service was immaculate. I can't remember her name...Laura?? Very professional. Answered questions. Smiled. Poured the wine nicely. Served and took away dishes properly. Buon appetito. read more

Unfortunately II Pizzaiolo used to be 5+ star Neapolitan, especially the Mt Lebo location. Started going downhill when they only offered in-house made mozzarella instead of imported DOP buffalo mozzarella. Ron should have learned from past ventures but apparently he didn't. I've been a customer for 20 years and will consider other options until I hear of changes. The last several times we visited the pizza dough has been considerably different. Thicker and more doughy. The sauce is really the only part that's maintained the standards they used to set in this area. Very disappointing. I used to see him regularly in Mt Lebo. I have yet to see him in the two locations up North in 100+ visits. read more

My favorite wine bar to come to for drinks in the Cranberry-Warrendale-Wexford area. I'd change my rating to 5-stars if they offered amazing Happy Hour specials. The ambiance is warm and inviting. The bar area is well appointed with a dozen chairs at the bar, a few high top tables, and some regular tables. Their wine menu includes some nice wines available by the glass ($14-25), you won't find elsewhere locally. A few appetizers or pizza to share and together it makes for a nice girls night out or date night. Not a wine drinker? They also have a full bar including beers on tab. I've been here in the past for large party dinners and the size of the dining area accommodates large parties easily. Best for the still young at heart than actual young adults. read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Bar area - Italian Near Me - Warrendale, Pennsylvania

First time diner for lunch We had a party of 12 Everyone we interacted with was so pleasant and aimed to please Food for 12 came out intermittently but I understand that's difficult to time From salads, pizza, pasta to arancini (which I ordered) was spectacular Will absolutely be back! read more

My husband and I came here for dinner on Friday night. We got in around 5:30, and we were asked if we had a reservation. We did not, and the hostess kind of frowned, even though the restaurant was maybe 1/2 full. She offered us a six top in the restaurant or a two top in the bar portion. We sat in the bar as to not take away from any larger parties coming in. We also totally don't mind sitting in the bar! We ordered the Diavola pizza (we're on a mission to try every pizza place in the area), which was basically a salami pizza with a little kick. It was pretty average. I enjoyed the brick oven-fired crust, but it was quite soggy in the middle. There was plenty of salami on the pizza, and I enjoyed the sauce. We were not totally thrilled with the service, as we waited quite awhile after our server cleared our plates for our check. Meanwhile, she brought and picked up two other tables checks. We will likely be back for pasta, as I saw many dishes on the menu I would enjoy; however, I wouldn't get the pizza again. read more

The only complaint we have is that this restaurant is not in Buffalo, NY where we live! Today we were on the way home from Pittsburgh and really wanted some good Italian food. This place is outside Cranberry in a nice suburban area. One of the owners, Bob I believe, greeted us at the door and stopped to check on our dining experience a couple of times during the meal. I like when the owners are present and working during the lunch and dinner hour. My daughter had homemade tagliatelle with marinara and what she claims to be the best meatballs she's ever had! They were the real deal! I had a wood oven fired pizza with four cheeses. It was definitely authentic Neapolitan style, the crust was light, crisp, and perfect. read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Four Cheese Neapolitan Pizza - Italian Near Me - Warrendale, Pennsylvania

Very good Italian food. Large portions. Everything I've ever had is delicious. Nice atmosphere and professional servers.

Excellent food and ambiance. Solid drink selection. Was perfect for a small celebratory dinner.

Visited again for an early dinner. Excellent choice of wine as well as featured wine, settled on a featured Cab. Ordered the beet salad with a chicken breast on top, as well as meatballs as a side for some extra protein. Food and service was excellent as usual. read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Grilled chicken breast atop a beet salad, side of meatballs in the background, along with bread and dipping oil. - Italian Near Me - Warrendale, Pennsylvania

Amazing service , great food and yummy wine. We found a great bottle of wine, it was actually the cheapest in the menu for $68. A bit pricey for my taste but it was very good. I looked it up online when we got home so we could buy some for our collection and it was only $12. I know restaurants mark up bottle of wine and liquor but that's nearly 6x. I work in the industry , I think that's a big mark up. read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Dinner menu - Italian Near Me - Warrendale, Pennsylvania

See all

Okay okay! My friends and I came here for dinner and the food was delicious! All of my friends liked their meals and drinks. Although, the food took a long time to come out and the waiter was snarky when we asked for "lemon water." Overall a good dining experience. read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Cesar Salad - Italian Near Me - Warrendale, Pennsylvania

We found this restaurant on the site and we were not disappointed! The food was absolutely delicious! All made in house and we saved room for desert. The lemon cake was light and a perfect end to an amazing dinner. Definitely coming back! Our server Veronica was the best, very helpful and super friendly. If I could give more stars, I would! read more

Came out to this cute spot! The atmosphere is stunning! We started things off with aperol spritz, mussels and arancini! All very satisfying and tasty! Moving on to entree's I got the gnocchi! The pasta itself was amazing, the sauce could of been better. My SO got the lasagna, he enjoyed it very much. Our friends got the eggplant parm which was enjoyed. Lastly, the linguine with clams. It was the most disappointing part of the whole night! It was basically buttered noodles in clam juice. Not good at all. Other than that I would give it another go! read more

Il Pizzaiolo - Gnocchi - Italian Near Me - Warrendale, Pennsylvania

See all

I have been going here for years but am done with it. I usually go solo and sit in the bar area Used to be good service for a party of one at a table. Tonight I felt unseen. Bartender gave me a menu and never came back. Not welcoming vibes from her. Second bar tender asked "if I needed anything" after I sat there for what felt like a long while. Yea, I would like someone to take my order. Drink and food were dropped off. No checking in until I ate my food. Asked for the check and was told to "have a good day" (at 8pm in the evening) Service here for one used to be good. I won't be back. read more

The chicken parm is great! The perfect amount of sauce for the pasta and the chicken is super moist. The wine list is decent and they have a fully stocked bar. I look forward visiting again with friends. read more

This is one of my favorite restaurants. The food and drinks are always amazing. The service is great and the owner is super sweet and gives my kids toys every time we come in! read more

Very friendly staff, excellent food but pricey. Great selection of Wine and cocktails.Romantic atmosphere

We recently went here for a birthday dinner with family. The ambiance was lovely, the waitress was so nice and tended to our needs. However, we had to wait an hour for our food. The bread for dipping was dry and tasteless. You would expect warm and tasty bread at the least. The food was hot. We ordered the rigatoni with meatballs, chicken marsala, and some other pasta. The food was hot. The tiramisu was the best part of the meal. When you look at your over expensive bill and see that all you got was a bunch of pasta, it did not make you to ever go back. read more

For the suburb of Pennsylvania, the restaurant was decent enough. It's a place I would go to for a business lunch or dinner. The food was decent enough, although everything was a little heavily sauced. A little less dressing on the Caesar salad and a little less white sauce on the pasta would allow the other ingredients to have presence. It looked pretty! Wait staff was attentive and delightful. Manager was a bit loud, he seemed stressed. read more

Possibly the best Italian meal I have ever had. Seriously the most amazing bread, risotto balls and lasagna ever....and the tiramisu!!! Seriously. Come here and eat read more

See all

I can't say enough wonderful things about this establishment. The food and cocktails are wonderful . But more impressive is the kindness of their staff. Our waitress was absolutely wonderful. The hostess and a gentleman, who I presume to be the owner, were so sweet to my not quite 2 year old. They brought over toy cars, coloring pages, and a teddy bear which absolutely made his evening! This restaurant is great for a date night or an evening out with your family! I will definitely be a regular there now and highly recommend it! The pizza and stuffed peppers are DELICIOUS!! read more

Everything was delicious! Wide choice of items casual atmosphere Service very good! A little pricey but as long as food & service is good it's worth it ! read more

Lovely aroma on the house cab. Smooth taste and an excellent vibe. Restaurant made me feel like Tony Soprano and can't wait to come back. #ItalianMob #SayHelloToMyLittleFriend read more

Il Pizzaiolo - A refreshing sip. - Italian Near Me - Warrendale, Pennsylvania

Went for the first time tonight with high hopes based on what I've heard and read. It was our daughter's graduation dinner and to say we were all disappointed is an understatement. Overpriced menu. Slow service. Bland food. About the only thing this place has going for it is the decor. Spent almost $200 for 4 people. Could have gone to Bravo up the street, spent half as much and gotten better food and service. read more

My daughter and I went to il Pizzaiolo for a girls dinner out expecting a wonderful evening and amazing food. We are frequent customers and have enjoyed the food and service in the past. Unfortunately, tonight was extremely disappointing. We had an early reservation at 5:30 and were seated promptly at a table in the bar area, where there were not many people seated at the time. We sat for about 15 minutes before our server came to our table. We ordered an appetizer as well as both of our entrees at once. The appetizer came out in a timely manner. However, we waited a full hour for our meal. Customers that were seated after us were served and left prior to us even being served. Our server told us that our food would be out in 2 minutes, about 15-20 minutes later our meals arrived and we had already been in the restaurant close to an hour and a half. When our meals arrived I expressed in a very diplomatic manner that we had waited an hour for our meals, and instead of apologizing she simply said , " it wasn't an hour. Your order must have been put in behind a larger party " ( they were SETTING UP for the larger party while we were ordering our food.). At this point we just wanted to get our check and leave. My daughter asked for our check we left disappointed. We have enjoyed il Pizzaiolo many times in the past and celebrated special occasions there. Unfortunately, we will not be returning and will take our business elsewhere. read more

The best Italian food we've had since we visited Italy! We loved the roasted veggie appetizer. So many different veggies and each was seasoned differently and cooked perfectly! The service was wonderful and we enjoyed the Italian wines with our dinner on the beautiful patio. read more

Good food, but maybe next time keep your thoughts to yourself. Especially when I tip better then 90% of anyone that walks in there. Guaranteed not one person tipped more then 20%. Smarten up. Money matters in the food industry not seniority. read more

Unfortunately we had a bad experience at the Wexford location. Service extremely slow. Almost an hour before our dinner order taken. Waiter had too many tables all sat around the same time. When we complained about one of the dinners being heavily spiced to the point it could not be eaten, the waiter alerted the manager. The manager came over, however proceeded to state that the fact the plate was spicy was clearly listed on the menu. We knew the menu did not list this in the description. The manager was very defensive and the encounter was not apologetic in nature. After he repeatedly defended his stance, eventually he stated he would remove the item from our bill. We have never experienced this service, food inconsistency or issues before and have eaten here frequently. We are hoping this was an unfortunate experience that won't happen again. read more

Took my aunt, uncle and mother her for lunch today. I wanted to take them to Off the Hook but they didn't open uni 5:00. I got the carbonara which was horrible. It send pancetta but tasted like bacon, burnt bacon. The sauce was like water and the entire dish had no taste at all. My mom had the pasta with the pink sauce which also had no taste. If you specialize in Italian you should at least be able to make pasta. Will never go back here! read more

Loved the pizza I shared with a friend for lunch. We enjoyed the outdoor seating area. Wait staff were friendly and attentive. Need to get back. read more