Cancel

Open app

Search

Hunter Tavern

4.9 (9 reviews)
Closed • Closed

Hunter Tavern Photos

HUNTER TAVERN ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

Recommended Reviews - Hunter Tavern

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

6 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 2

5 months ago

Fireplace and rustic vibe are cozy. Heart food and solid coctails. Service was slow but still a great spot for a cold night.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

THe food was straight forward and well prepared service was terrific the room was to bright

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 4

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Hunter Tavern

Prospect

Prospect

3.6(136 reviews)
0.2 mi
•$$$

My husband and I stayed at Scribners so we checked out Prospect the first night of our stay!…read more We had a pleasant rainy evening with mountain views, low lighting dim lamps and candles at Prospect. We sat in a corner booth and the ambiance was amazing. Our favorite dish was our starter, sourdough and mango burrata with prosciutto chips. The hamburger was yummy, we asked for it medium but it was likely closer to medium rare. The salmon (market fish) was good but only came with one single asparagus. It was a beautiful dish- I wish the flavor matched the presentation, I likely wouldn't order it again. The smoke and honey cocktail came out from the bartender with a box that was opened in front of us and released smoke, it smelled and was delicious- and I normally don't like bourbon! We had the vanilla ice cream with olive oil and salt flakes. The ice cream was creamy and yummy, I think it was heavy on the olive oil. The combination was new to us and was yummy, but feel as though it was drowning in olive oil. I'm not sure I will find myself in the area again, but I would recommend Prospect to anyone in the area wanting an upscale dinner with interesting and new flavor combinations with a romantic mountain vibe!

I am adding one update- we went to the bar this afternoon (day after original review) for a…read morebeverage and Roberto is amazing, great service, great drink and great conversation. I really want to love this place but I left feeling so underwhelmed. The vibe is cool, decor nice, staff great My husband and I came for our anniversary. We always do a place in the Catskills. This time we are staying at Scribner's, (separate review) but AMAZING. We made reservations for 7 pm on our actual anniversary, we're seated quickly, ordered drinks, they acknowledged our anniversary which was cool. Drinks were good, we wanted to order apps and see where things went, The waitress informed us the chef "doesn't let us do that, you have to place your entire order at once. With all due respect, I'm in the industry, you were slow and now lost out on a lot . We were unsure what we were gonna do so we dialed it back more than we would have since you needed our entire order at once. Apps come- salad is amazing, the bread service was good. The broccoli/hummus was also good. The trout was ok, which it was a little creamier and more spreadable. Flavor was good, just texture. The entrees , I'm not sure what happened, this is where it went downhill and fast. there was a long space between apps and entrees, like we could have chose and ordered by the time they were delivered My pasta was ICE COLD, not warm, like I made this an hour ago and it just sat kind of under a heat lamp . The chicken was just ok, very hot, but bland. Played nicely but no flavor We really wanted dessert which if it's not gelato, you aren't getting it. So disappointed. There was no other option. That being said, server apologized about pasta , she also brought us out a caramel gelato for our anniversary.

Photos
Prospect
Prospect
Prospect

See all

Ze Wine Bar at Jägerberg Beer Hall & Alpine Tavern - Red cabbage salad and fondue.

Ze Wine Bar at Jägerberg Beer Hall & Alpine Tavern

4.3(186 reviews)
0.6 mi
•$$

Went for dinner last night after our drive up. It was such a cozy atmosphere & reminded us of both…read moreGermany & Alsace. The beer was delicious with solid options. We had the raclette, herbed spaetzle and split chicken schnitzel. First, the raclette was so delicious. The cheese was warm and gooey over tender potatoes, and accompanied by various pickled items & crostini. The herbed spaetzle was good, though a touch sweet for my taste. Regardless, it was delicious and warm. The waiter had the schnitzel split for us without asking, which I appreciated. It was juicy and paired with sour/sweet red cabbage and mustard/tangy German potato salad. The meal was very filling and not badly priced. The food here is legitimately delicious, not "just good" for a restaurant near the ski resort. We sat outside on the upper deck with a nice mountain view. After dinner we had a drink by one of the open fire pits outside, which was a cozy way to end a delicious meal. We will definitely be back when in the area.

Fantastic experience start to finish. Staff was super welcoming. It's beautiful inside. The summer…read moremenu is different than what I've seen online but all delicious. Ive been to Germany a few times and can say this is authentic. The chicken schnitzel with jager sauce is so flavorful and rich. The jager sauce is a dark brown mushroom sauce (similar to a Marsala). The name jager means huntsman. Substituted the seasonal vegetable (carrot and asparagus) for the cabbage which was so delicious. The meal is hearty and rich. The staff was wonderful. The Apple strudel was one of the best desserts I've ever had with cinnamon ice cream. I can only imagine how cozy this place is during the fall and winter. Absolutely worth the price.

Photos
Ze Wine Bar at Jägerberg Beer Hall & Alpine Tavern - Bat

Bat

Ze Wine Bar at Jägerberg Beer Hall & Alpine Tavern - Scallops

Scallops

Ze Wine Bar at Jägerberg Beer Hall & Alpine Tavern - Dunkel Rotkopf

See all

Dunkel Rotkopf

Miss Lucy's Kitchen - Brussel sprouts

Miss Lucy's Kitchen

4.3(430 reviews)
15.2 mi
•$$

Amazing amazing amazing, loved everything about Miss Lucy's and wish we could've gone back for…read moreanother visit while in town! Definitely make a reservation beforehand as it was busy! Menu had lots of variety and the dessert specials were to die for. Everything was delicious - highly recommend the calamari appetizer and the complimentary bread was fantastic. I just about licked my dinner plate clean (get the duck breast)! Friends loved the fried chicken and the salmon. Wine list was great and service was wonderful.

We were eager to check out Miss Lucy's as one of the more popular spots in Saugerties. Thankfully…read moreit wasn't too annoying to get a reservation and we found the spot to be busy and popular among locals and tourists alike. Walking in we were seated promptly though we immediately noticed that the interior was extremely dark. Not a big deal but worth flagging for older folks who might have a hard time reading. Our server was friendly and relatively attentive and walked us through the menu. We started off with some classics including their bread and butter (which was tasty and delicious) and ordered their P.E.I Mussels ($19) along with their Fried Brussels Sprouts ($15) to share. The portions were quite large for everything (great if you're in a larger party) but we immediately noticed that the mussels they served seemed a bit off. Many of them were not opened all the way (a sign that they might not be the freshest or recently passed) and had a bit of a fishy taste to them. We ended up not finishing them and flagged them to our waiter. The other items, including the 14oz Ribeye ($43) and baby back ribs ($28) were better, though a bit one-note. The bay back ribs in particular were extremely saucy and the corn bread was dry and a bit tough to eat. I had to use a knife to split it apart as it kept crumbling every time I used a fork. Regardless, it seems like a popular spot for a reason and perhaps we just went during more of an off-night. I'd still recommend checking it out but avoiding the mussels if you go.

Photos
Miss Lucy's Kitchen - Dinning room

Dinning room

Miss Lucy's Kitchen - His Fried Chkn

His Fried Chkn

Miss Lucy's Kitchen - Dinning room

See all

Dinning room

Vanwinkles Restaurant - Chicken parm

Vanwinkles Restaurant

3.1(47 reviews)
0.9 mi
•$$

Highly recommended. The dining area opens at 5pm, but you can be served at the bar if you want to…read moreeat earlier. The pricing is fair, and the food is absolutely delicious. We were visiting the area on a trip for three nights, and decided to eat here two times. The staff was all very friendly and helpful, and the chef even came out to speak with us about their menu, since I have a severe peanut allergy. He reassured us that there were no peanuts in his kitchen, and he even decided to avoid using peanut oil in his fry oil mix, with allergies in mind. If you plan on going late, or on a weekend, you should call in beforehand to see if you need a reservation. Pictured below: Mushroom ravioli with a light butter sauce, fresh sage, caramelized onions, and butternut squash. Overall: A+

We were greeted by Frances, who brought us to a nice quiet table with a view of the sparkly lights…read moreon the trees outside. She was also our server, and I believe was the only hostess and server working the entire restaurant. There were about five tables and we never felt rushed or forgotten. We ordered the special of the night, a citrus flank steak with mashed potatoes and asparagus, and the chili bread bowl. The chili was lukewarm warm but the right combo of spice and meat. Very yummy! While we waited for our food we enjoyed the paintings depicting the story of Rip Van Winkle. The food was good, the price was right (roughly $20 entrees) and Frances really was the icing on the cake for us!

Photos
Vanwinkles Restaurant
Vanwinkles Restaurant - Our bill that was already over $100 for 2 people

Our bill that was already over $100 for 2 people

Vanwinkles Restaurant - Mozzarella sticks

See all

Mozzarella sticks

Hunter Tavern - comfortfood - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...