What we like about Shellhammer's - good bar atmosphere, sports on tv's in bar area, and high tops. What we wish we liked a bit more - food and service. Both have been consistently average each visit. But when we're nearby and want to stop somewhere for a cold beer and a couple apps, it checks the boxes. read more

Horace Shellhammer's - Bars Near Me - Newark, Delaware

I came here for a late dinner with two coworkers. The staff was very attentive, but the food was just mediocre. We started off with the crab dip, which was served cold (tepid at best), with dry and stale bread. It had a funny taste and was also very fishy. I got the chicken caesar salad, which was doused in dressing. It was ok, but the lettuce didn't taste fresh. One friend got the turkey burger which came with a side of guacamole, which was completely brown. Overall, although the wait staff was good, the quality of the food was lacking. read more

Horace Shellhammer's - Outside - Bars Near Me - Newark, Delaware

See all

Ok, Shellhammer's is back off our list. It is just too inconsistent. The last 2 times we were there the French Dip and the London Broil on the caesar salad were chewy. Gross, the food has definitely gone downhill. I have been coming here since maybe 2007-ish, and we loved stopping here because it's open late. It's always been inconsistent, but now it's just bad. This is where we discovered cheesesteak egg rolls, but we found some better late night options elsewhere. read more

See all

Great food.. young lady tending bar was super great.. perfect personality to tend bar.. i asked if i can bring my service dog in. Everyone. Staff. Patrons also loved ripley.. we sat in corner staying out of way. Not to upset ppl not happy with animals. Hamburger cooked perfect.. Even a little burger with 3 pcs of french fries for my little one. Ambiance was great.. friendly .almost felt like family The owners has to be thanked. Employing the right crew. 10 out of 10 . read more

‼DO NOT GO TO THIS RESTAURANT FOR FOOD‼if your going to a bar it's ok just don't go for food your better off walking to Wendy's drunk then having the food here it's straight hot DURRUU wouldn't feed this to a homeless starving child my chicken sandwich was burnt to a crisp and they put a dab of buffalo sauce on it the fries where stale like they were left out I wish I had a picture but I threw that shit out not even worth a picture in my camera roll read more

Great food, not a typical bar selection. I have only been here about 4 times and I have only had burgers. They also have a variety of entrées that sound good but the $10 burger special on Wednesday is amazing for the quality. The service is good and attentive, especially with clearing and refills. The overall feeling of the establishment is comfortable and friendly. read more

See all

Came for a reserved lunch with friends Our waitress was amazing and personable! The pot sticker appetizers were so good! I ended up getting the Chicken Florentine for my entree. It was tooo cheesey for my likes in the end. And I suppose, a combination of the cheese and shells made it almost have a strong smell also. The chicken breast in the entree was moist Plenty of free parking infront of restaurant If I'm ever in the area in the evening, I would love to come back and check out any happy hour vibes read more

See all

It was okay. The buffalo chicken wrap was pretty good. It was pretty low key overall and not too noisy. Server was friendly but could have been a little more attentive. read more

R.I.P. Shellhammers We've been coming to Shelly's since 2006. We like the location the people, and the menu. Today the food was terrible. The hamburger had a strange consistency and did not taste like beef. We sent it back. The key west caesar (my "go to") was overloaded with caesar dressing, shrimp under cooked, romaine over chopped, and pasta cold. Had it re-made. Still awful. Asked for a bowl of romaine and made my own from what i could salvage. Sad. read more

The service is always good and the food top notch. We usually have lunch there and everything is excellent. I do highly recommend this place. read more

One of the worst bars I've ever been too. Food is great sure..if you even get it. Service was a nightmare. Super bowl Sunday and 6 people at the bar and you can't even remember to ring in my food? I ordered their tuna. And when I asked for my food almost 30 minutes later and I was told i didn't even order food and I was rude for asking even though the bar guest next to me confirmed I ordered the tuna. Meghan (or Megan) and her old and decrepit bar back (name I do not recall or care to know, lucky her) proceeded to completely ignore us and only serve the people at the other end of the bar. While openly talking about how they know we didn't get our food and "f*** us" and saying they'll "eat our food" to who I believe were their friends and also UNDERAGE. there is no reason for this kind of unprofessional behavior. All I wanted was my check and leave. I will never be back. And I hope you guys get inspected soon. this was appalling. read more

Appears to be hit or miss. Been here twice, 1st visit a blast! Great food, team was into the vibe, then next time was like someone pulled the plug on the vibe and the food was barely edible. Looked like taken over by regulars who don't like it when people they don't know dare intrude. Save yourself the disappointment. read more

Visiting from out of town, went here on decent reviews. The wings were tasty but I asked for well done and they werent,, skin was soggy. Caesar salad way overdressed and too salty, so basically did not eat it. Onion rings were decent but burger wasn't good at all! Asked for medium, came out well, dry, small patty and tasteless There was supposed to be cheese on the burger, there was a little, it was white and couldnt taste it. Waitress was nice but never checked on us once the food was served. read more

As I tried to eat, some big Spanish man hovered over me to talk to the guest on the opposite side me. He had no spatial awareness. I then watched the bartender cut someone off and after some conversation I'm assuming he decided to serve the person anyway. Otherwise the food was good and all the servers were great. read more

Me and my wife were on the way to Philly and were starving. I asked her to look up a spot on the way and she found this place. Me, her, and our 8 month old son were seated promptly. The staff was very hospitable. I had the burger which I felt was the perfect size. I don't like pattys that are too thick. I asked for a medium cook which it was. My wife had the chicken florentine. The pasta was amazing and the breaded chicken was still crispy underneath that sauce. Highly recommend this place! read more

1430 hrs, Sat @ My waItress Stephanie O is Terrible. # Upon placing food on my table, she walks away instead of asking if I'm ok. # She never checked on me during my meal. # If you ever have Stephanie, I suggest you get another table @ The chili isn't the best, more liquid than meat. She needs re-trained read more

I've had my eye on this place for a couple months. I knew I was going to fin my way in here and I finally did. Well I ordered to go but still enjoyed my experience. First off the customer service here is awesome. Everyone speaks, very friendly and attentive. I come from the city where that's not always the case so that was a plus for me. I called and the phone was immediately answered. My questions were acknowledged and answered with no issue. I ended up ordering the Cheesesteak and wings. Both of which were very good. The cheesesteak moist and not dry which I love. Wings were cooked just the way I asked (rarely happens). Only thing missing was a little seasoning on the cheesesteak but that was an easy fix once I got in the house. $16 for a cheesesteak and wings, I was happy. You can't beat that. I will definitely be going again. They also have specials during the week and Brunch on Saturday and Sunday. read more

See all

$6 Cheesesteaks all day Mondays. And it comes with fries or coleslaw. Good solid bar cheesesteak. The fried onions gave it a lot of flavor. Decent COVID compliant crowd and everyone sounded like they were having fun. read more

See all

Oh man, this is a get what you see kinda place. Not a cute date night and the area is a bit sketchy but it definitely gets the job done if you're looking for bar door and a drink. Our server seemed absolutely annoyed we were out for drinks on a Saturday so that was fun. Honestly our group had a good time anyway and the snacky bar food was fine read more

Shellhammer's is a great under the radar bar and restaurant!! The staff is amazing. They are a lot of fun and knowledgeable about the food and beers on tap. Their brunch, their ambiance, their specials, their cold beer, and their food are all worth the visit read more

Horace Shellhammer's - Downeast Pumpkin and Cider donut!! - Bars Near Me - Newark, Delaware

Excellent server - Mallory, speedy and friendly. Aside from the great service, the Blackened Salmon was beyond excellent. Gently cooked and wonderfully seasoned, tender, fresh and flavorful. Kudos! read more

Bar was not busy and only 1/3 full. Waited 20 minutes at least to be served and then some. Not sure what this group of employees hanging behind and at the end of the bar talking and not serving the customers thinks they are so special about? Snobby for sure. I am sure if the owner of Shellhammer's were there and not the Manager who was part of the problem, maybe a customer could get served within 2 minutes of sitting down. That is the industry standard. Never did get served at the bar. Had to take a table for 4. Oh, then the hostess for seating was missing and not in the restaurant either. read more

My husband told me the food was great when he visited last time so I ordered to pick up to try. But the picked up food disappointed me. The burger bun and the fries were soggy( I understand it. It happens for food in pick up containers). Burger tastes just mediore. For buffalo wings, chicken was a bit dry. Blue cheese dip was great though. read more

Horace Shellhammer's - Bars Near Me - Newark, Delaware

See all

Food and service were great! Would definitely go again. I do wish we were able to change some of the tv channels, but that wouldn't stop us from going back. read more

The outside area is well set up and decorated with nice plants and greenery. I tried looking online for their happy hour menu but was unable to find it. When I got there I wasn't handed a HH menu either. After getting one I ordered Crab Toast and it was "okay." The soup on the other hand was spicy and delicious. I do like it here but HH wasn't anything to write home about. read more

Horace Shellhammer's - Crab Toast - Bars Near Me - Newark, Delaware

See all

Decent local pub with late hours. Food is all pre made food service food. Not horrible but not anything special.

Noooooooooooo! They are changing and not for the better....no more rewards cards, the wing sauce and blue cheese has changed for the worse. My nightmare has come true read more

I absolutely love this restaurant. Been coming in here for the last 6 years. The bartender was on point with my markers and cherry coke. With extra cherry and a lime. Food came out in a timely manner and was delicious. I had there snapper sour with Shelly and I had a NY strip with mash and vegs. read more

Horace Shellhammer's - This is a mushrooms risotto, with seasoned flank steak with a spicy basil pesto onto - Bars Near Me - Newark, Delaware

A pleasant surprise, with this being my first time here! Shellhammer's serving food in Delaware for 23 years. I'm always looking for a fresh culinary experience and I found one. Mango margarita, crab toast, and the best meat loaf, spinach, mushroom gravy, fresh mashed potatoes just like I remember it from mama cooking in her Bronx kitchen! read more

See all

It's great! Good food, drinks, atmosphere. They have outdoor dining also. Will go again!

I have lived in and around this area for many years and had never been to this restaurant. My sister was in town and we were trying to get eat at places we had not tried yet, so we chose Shellhammers. My goodness -- we were in for a treat. The menu is delightful, and we had no trouble choosing our meals. We had a wonderful waitress, and the service was outstanding. I will now add this to my places to eat at when I am not cooking. Enjoyable. read more

Worst bartender ever. The worst old fashioned I ever had in my life. It was pink . The worst manager ever with zero people skills. Don't waste your money here. read more

Shellhammers is the best!! $8 cheesesteaks are amazing on Monday's!! Great beer list, great ambiance, great staff, great brunch!! There is nothing that I can think of that could possibly make Shellhammers better!! It's amazing!! read more

See all

Great place to get a late night meal and a drink. Our server was great--very personable and helpful with a menu recommendation. The bar area was a fun and inviting area. I would definitely return if we lived here. read more

The food here is excellent and fairly priced to boot! The one thing that makes me deduct a star from my rating in the service. The waitresses seem to be very hormonal, all three times I've been so far they are constantly gossiping or complaining about something instead of doing their job. Although it is entertaining, it can be a bit frustrating as they are distracted with their own drama while you're trying to order your meal. read more

Good bar food. Good service. Decent drinks. They do a late night Sunday app special "reverse happy hour" they call it, half off all apps. We ordered the crab nachos, Texas chili cup and mex egg rolls. All were expectedly good, nice amount of crab with fresh jalapeños! My favorite. The egg rolls were pretty good and what made it was the smoky sweet dipping sauce. The chili was good as well, it was all really tasty flavorful tex mex food with Delaware flare. My drink was way too sweet, country lemonade with rosemary simple tasted exactly how it sounded but it was just sickly sweet. It became bearable once most of the ice melted. Overall, great ambiance and hang out spot any night of the week. read more

Horace Shellhammer's - Tex mex egg rolls, crab nachos, and Texas chili - Bars Near Me - Newark, Delaware

The staff is friendly and I love their crab soup (warning, it's spicy) and their fajitas are the best. It is a nice local place to have drinks and good food. read more

This was a cool find. The atmosphere is laid back and a neighborhood feel. The service was friendly and the food tasty. I had a catfish po-Boy and he had meatloaf. His only complaint was his beer was warm. The meatloaf came with mashed potatoes and spinach. The spinach was so good. I ate most of it. My po-Boy could stand a little more seasoning or sauce but it was still good. The crab toast appetizer was ok. The toast needed more toasting in the middle. read more

See all

In our past two visits in the last week, the service has been 10/10! Quick, everyone's so friendly, efficient, etc... food was just as great! The Wednesday burger deal will definitely have us coming back for more! read more

Horace Shellhammer's - Hamburgers and fries - Bars Near Me - Newark, Delaware

Great burgers and special menu items. Wish the would get back the eggs Benedict Chesapeake. Great service and servers