This place used to be amazing. I've gone here numerous times in the last year, but since they have…read morere-staffed, the food is not what it used to be. I went and got two Philly cheesesteaks which were made wrong with no cheese when I ordered with cheddar cheese, two hotdogs plain, which were correct because you can't mess something up that's plain And a large chocolate malt that had no malt in it. I will not be going back as the management is not willing to give a refund for the two Philly cheesesteaks that were messed up all they're willing to do is remake the chocolate shake, which is only four dollars After I was offered a refund by one of the staff last night as long as I could come back up. Not to mention the manager that I spoke to this morning was very rude and disrespectful and clearly does not know how to run a store.

Should be less than 1 star. Owners left 1 hour prior to advertised closing with 7-8 customers just…read moresitting down to order on a Friday night!

Best Friday day night fish fry in all the land... might have to wait sometimes, but totally worth…read moreit! And real salad to boot... not that bagged stuff from a store... it's all home made! I hear their ribs at excellent too... I've not had the opportunity yet to try them. Best fried fish this side of the Pecos!!! Lov it!!!

Driving through town near lunchtime. Decided to stop in this local place. The pizza was good. It…read morehad lots of toppings, the crust held up; and the people were friendly.

Ok people, in my previous review, I gave up on Wilmington Pizza. I just now buy good frozen pizza…read moreor go to Aurelio's. My story begins a few Saturday nights ago. A friend of mine came into town and after visiting my fiancé and I, he wanted to go out for some pizza nearby. He started looking at nearby pizza places and he asked me on my opinion of Wilmington pizza. LOL, I had some stories for him. He didnt believe me and didnt believe the yelp ratings. I laughed and said fine, go see for yourself. An hour and a half later he calls me to tell me this: He went in and no one was at the counter. He yelled out as politely as he can, "Hello?". A woman came out and seemed grumpy to him as if he disturbed her nap. Without saying hi, she asked what he wanted. He gave his order and she said it will be about 45 minutes. He said fine and he will be back later. He leaves and comes back and instead of handing him his pizza, she kinda just drops it on the counter in front of him. He pays for the expensive pizza and leaves. He decides to have a slice for the ride home only to find it to be cold. Fortunately he didn't leave yet and he went back in (again she was grumpy for disturbing her for a second time) and told her what was wrong. Well, she gave him some attitude by stating that he took to long to get back and when he defended himself she started raising her voice at him. "What do you want? A new pizza? That will take an hour." He didn't want to wait and left. I told him to leave a review on yelp but he isn't into social media and doesn't want to do the hassle of creating an account and blah blah blah. So I said I would based on principle. Again people....go buy a DiGiorgio pizza. Cheaper, less hassle and pretty tasty. Do NOT patronize Wilmington Pizza. Their deliveries are worse.

The food was ok. Portions were a little small. Waitress was ok…read moreBut we were the only people in the Place. Furnishings were plain. The restaurant is a little hard to find it doesn't face the parking lot. If in town I would go back.

Sllllllloooooowwwwww everything. Slow to get our drinks, slow to get our soup, slow to get our…read morefood. The place was pretty dead when we went. I was wondering if the person cooking the food was also serving the tables because the server kept disappearing and everything was taking forever. Who knows. Food was okay, but it reminded me of grade school cafeteria food or something from a frozen TV dinner. (To be fair, I like those) Two stars because the place was clean... the server was nice.. and the food was decent.

great atmosphere, good drinks, good food and great service. Hannah and Riley rock!!! they always…read morehave food and drink specials.

I have been at the new Gardner location multiple times since it's opened and every meal has been…read moreincredible. Nothing beats Knockin' Boots steak though! These steaks are bursting with flavor and cooked perfectly. The shrimp was fantastic. I forgot how much I loved the grilled veggies and mashed potatoes. $30 for a fantastic surf and turf dinner in small town Gardner? Worth every penny! We also had the spinach artichoke dip as an appetizer. A different take on spinach dip, it was kind of a queso spinach artichoke dip but WOW - delicious!!! Our server, Hannah, was incredibly attentive and kept our drinks full. The updated modern-rustic decor is beautiful, as is the bar and all of the new updates. What an excellent addition to the Gardner community!

Had pizza from this local place in Coal City. It only has it for delivery and takeout. Geo's Pizza…read moreis about the smallest interior of a pizza place there is. Only has a counter to place an order. The prices are pretty good especially for the various lunch specials. Checked it out at lunch, which turned out to be the best time to come here. It's known for the specials at lunch. These are pretty cheap for a pretty good amount of pizza. Of course they have a lot more on the menu. We got a few things. It's about $6 for the Geo's Bread. This is basically pizza dough seasoned with garlic and salt. Comes with a choice of dipping sauce including garlic butter and marinara. It's about $7.50 for the Lunch Special. You can get a pizza with one topping. It's miniature size so it's not a lot. The Geo's Bread is actually a lot bigger than this particular pizza. It's still a good value to be honest. These specials also include calzones and sandwiches if not wanting a pizza. Got to say it's the best pizza around here. It's a small place that only has delivery and takeout. They're open daily and open even later on the weekends.

Ordered a pizza. Been a few years since I had Geo's pizza (moved out of area- now back). Geo's…read moreused to be my favorite. This time I was really disappointed. Sauce did not cover crust completely and crust tasted different. Maybe they gave me a gluten-free crust. If so, that was NOT what I ordered. Sad to see an old friend fade away.

Bread was stale. Veggies were wilted and not fresh. That make the sadwiches soggy. They were…read moreunappetizing. I hated to throw money in the garbage especially considering the price. I did not want to get sick. It took a while for the employees to come out of the back room.

Been here several times for a quick bite or to have catering done at a party. Food is good and the…read morepeople have never been better. Always polite and patient and helpful in regards for catering to be done. My only gripe is the prices and this isn't anyone's fault of course except corporate and inflation. Remember the $5 foot longs? LOL...I know I cannot expect that to ever be like that again.

excellent customer service and great quality food . close to…read morehome and great canoli's Great bones less wincs and good Pricing

I was visiting an old friend in this area during a cross country drive. Was in the mood for pizza…read moreand this place had the deals! We got a Chicago style at $5 off (Thursdays) and it was good and filling. If you priced this thing by the pound it this is a huge bargain. I could only do one slice. The whole thing might have weighed 3+ pounds. The next day we went back for their everyday $10 thin crust special (because how can you not try a pizza for $10 in 2025??) and again it did not disappoint. This is what we would call a bar or tavern pizza on the east coast. Both pizzas used top, fresh ingredients. The sausage is house made according to the menu and my taste buds. The cheese very plentiful and high quality. If you are driving historic route 66 this is a great beginning or ending stop for some quality food. I'm glad I don't live around there because at these great prices I would gain 10 pounds fast. Also, the interior while small, had the classic pizza place feel and the staff very friendly and helpful. Thanks for the great pizza and prices.

service was good, came here with some friends to get some snacks, and every time we have came here…read moreto get snacks they always have nice food and customer service. 5/5 stars

Usually everything is amazing and the staff is friendly and helpful! Today we got supreme pizza and…read morecheesy bread. The bread was a huge disappointment, tasted like it was burned but it didn't look burned, the pizza was good, spicy which is not usual. Not sure what happened today but usually it's a five for us!. Maybe an off day

Food is always good and order is always correct. We love ordering from here. The orders are large…read moreand they will make it to your preference.

Decent but average Chinese food. Ordered egg rolls, an appetizer, plus an entrée for delivery via…read moreDoorDash. No chopsticks. No hot mustard. No napkins. One fortune cookie for 2 people. Not bad food but there is better in this immediate area. I won't be back