Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    HillGarten

    4.3 (47 reviews)
    Closed 12:00 pm - 11:00 PM
    Updated 1 month ago

    Order HillGarten Takeout or Delivery

    HillGarten Photos

    Business Info

    HILLGARTEN ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Hipster
    Casual
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - HillGarten

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Winter set up
    Kayla B.

    This was SUCH a great surprise and really gives me throwbacks to the German beer gardens. If the weather is nice, HillGarten is entirely outdoors, made to handle big groups of people, and very German-slanted. It's a really cute place. PROS: -I, admittedly, don't really like being out in the sun. There are tons of shaded spots here, even under the full day's sunlight. -They have quite a few beer taps, and they're all numbered on the sign. This makes it a whole lot easier/faster to order the beer you want. They had some German imports too! -Very German menu. They have some neat American takes, but there were a lot of German throwbacks too (like Kasespatzel!). -Pretzel is gigantic (priced so, too, but it made a full dinner for two people without needing a snack later), and the beer cheese that goes with it is good. I'd definitely recommend the extra beer cheese they offer if you're someone who really likes to smother in cheese. -Indoor restrooms built into the kitchen/bar building. You're not in outhouses or barely-there outdoor restrooms. They feel like standard bathrooms. CONS: -Chairs are a little uncomfortable for sitting for long periods of time. I'm not sure if anyone has ever said metal chairs are super comfortable, though, but just something to keep in mind. They have picnic tables too. -Parking might require a bit of creativity. They have a few spots next to the building from the alleyway, but I mean "a few". Like 5. If anything is going on here, you'll need to find street parking. Nearby street parking is free for 2 hour spurts. -Hillgarten is, literally, next to one of the busiest Hilliard downtown roads in the area. Expect the buzzing of cars pretty constantly, but it turns into background noise unless one of those "everyone needs to hear my car!" people drives through.

    Looking from one of the umbrella covered tables towards where you place and pick up your order.
    Miranda L.

    The wife and I got the sausage charcuterie with house sausage. The jalapeno and regular bratwurst were delicious. Nice and spicy. Appreciated the fennel in the regular one. The plain is too plain for me. Casing on the bratwurst seemed appropriately snappy.  It is was served with two mustards and small pickles, a classic sour kraut with caraway seed. Which was delicate but very nice. There were also roasted onions and bell peppers.  There's a grassy area, being reseeded for spring, probs gonna be reopened soon. We saw a dog bowl so these folks are dog friendly.  The restrooms are around back.   A note: It might feel the pricey side but it makes sense. There's a lot of love put into the food. They're on Untappd so you can check drafts. Which are $6.50- $8, affordable. Definitely on par with draft prices around Columbus.  The käsespätzle is SO yummy. It's made to order with crispy onions, fresh onions and green onions. (Like a New American version of Käsespätzle). Definitely spiced well, compared to the other Käsespätzle at hofbrauhaus. It's SO much better here. Seriously, it's so good. I can't wait to make it back out to Hilliard. I'll keep an eye their socials and website for events.

    a table full of food and drinks
    Valerie W.

    It's cute, it's "unique," the food, drinks and service are FINE, but IMHO, it's a HUGE gimmick. At least during the colder months, it might be worth one visit to check out the "igloos" set up in the front, but the hassle of zipping yourself in and out of there, the either freezing or roasting temps (the igloos are heated) and the set up is not the most conducive to hanging out, eating and drinking with friends. The food (some, not all "German-style") the drinks (some VERY good cocktail choices) and the service are all very good. The tiny table in the center of the "igloo" might not have been the best for what my group of 5-6 people ordered. Our (giant!!) pretzels, hummus platter and other assorted apps barely fit on the table, but we made it work, mostly... Service was good, and our group seemed happy with the menu, venue, etc., but I'd only go back in warmer weather, as I didn't really like the winter tent/igloo setup.... Give it a try, YOU might enjoy it... I might see you back there in warmer weather!!

    Such a nice charming neighborhood place. A family friendly casual Biergarten with a nice selection of beers on draft (about 20). A good variety of beer styles as well. They also have cocktails, wines & sodas. The food menu is mostly apps & handhelds but it's perfect for the venue. We had the pretzel & the sausage charcuterie. Both were awesome. The soft pretzel was warm & chewy. The beer cheese & mustard for dipping were great. The sausage board was amazing. The sausages were some of the best I've had. The kraut that comes with it was great as well. The staff is very nice. I can't wait to go back to try some of their sandwiches.

    a wooden fence with a clock on it
    Carla F.

    Wow. I kept driving past this place and finally stopped by to check it out. The customer service was superb. The gentleman working the bar asked us if we'd been here before and since we hadn't, he explained the menu and told us what was popular/his personal favorites. He was kind and patient with us as we decided on what to get. We got a few drinks and some food and sat by the fire place. The fire was nice since it was a chilly night. Although the chairs are made of medal, they have blankets available for the chairs! Even though it was 40° outside, it definitely did not feel like it. I was so warm and toasty. For food, we got the pretzel which was huge! The cheese dip was absolutely scrumptious. The Mac and cheese was also very tasty and had fried onion on it. If you're looking for a laid back outing, with amazing customer service, definitely check Hillgarten out! Totally recommend it.

    Aubrey L.

    Came here for the first time and I really enjoyed my experience! They have a great cocktail menu that's seasonal and lots of different brat options, including a vegan dog!! I ordered the spicy brat and my boyfriend ordered the dad frankenfurter. We also had a side of potato salad and two margaritas. I ordered the seasonal pineapple jalapeño marg and he had an original. It was all fantastic and the place had such a fun atmosphere for a beautiful day. Will be back soon!!

    Jennifer R.

    They have done a lot to make the Hilliard Station area more appealing and this lively little biergarten is such a fun addition. Let me say first.....the staff here were the friendliest and most personable people I have encountered in any establishment serving food since pre-covid times. They restored my faith that great service is not completely gone. You order at the counter and they give you a buzzer to alert when your order is ready to be picked up. They also appeared to be running out some of the food to tables, so seemed to be kind of a mix. The food menu is short and German inspired. It is mostly brats and a few different appetizers. The giant bavarian pretzel seemed to be very popular. The warm potato salad was very tasty. The fall cocktail list had all kinds of things that sounded good. We wanted to try the butterscotch margarita (?!) but they were sold out. I should have taken a picture of the menu, because I cant remember the names of the drinks. They also have an extensive beer selection, of course, and several wine options. There is a large fire pit and some outdoor games. It is kid and dog friendly. The music was a little odd, but you will be too busy enjoying the overall atmosphere to notice.

    Main Menu
    Gretchen T.

    Absolutely adorable little place that was a great addition to Old Hilliard. It's German inspired, hence the food and drink names. They also play some German music (although not all the time). The shining gem here is definitely the bretzel, which is huge (pictured below). I shared it with two other people, and it was so delicious, I still wanted more when it was done! We went through the cheese dip really fast though. Not sure if we could've gotten a refill on that, but that's on us for not asking! The service here is really great and friendly. They would come up to check in on us and then quickly bus our tables, so we weren't all cluttered. We spilled some salt on the table, and they kindly wiped it away for us. We saw an engagement party happening here, so it is clear this is a spot for all occasions. We were just here for a casual afternoon, and I'd definitely come back. Thank you for the amazing experience!

    Bar and patio
    Danielle M.

    HillGarten is a nice outdoor beer garden space for an afternoon drink or event. Lots of seating and for small or large parties. They have a cute fire pit and corn hole. They have both beer and liquor and a small menu of German food. They are also pet and kid friendly. They have a kids menu as well.

    See all

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ray W.
    0
    54
    1

    4 years ago

    I received the wrong beer no big deal. The folks were nice. Service was good. Food was good. We enjoyed the atmosphere.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Great casual spot. Literally all patio, great drinks and solid food. Place is a really nice experience.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Amy G.
    0
    13
    4

    4 years ago

    Absolutely the best outdoor patio in Hilliard! Fab service and awesome music! The wine is amazing and pretzels are bigger than our head!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Amy B.
    0
    11
    0

    4 years ago

    Great beer selection and plenty of seating to hang out with friends. Live music was a nice touch.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - HillGarten

    Review Highlights - HillGarten

    My friend and I went and both got a flight of four beers and shared a jumbo pretzel with beer cheese.

    Mentioned in 5 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Gene's - Tara squash

    Gene's

    4.7(30 reviews)
    4.8 mi

    Top 5 restaurant in central Ohio. Well deserved. Nice menu, but your choices are limited. I was…read moresurprised, of the five entree choices, two were pork (we don't eat pork) and no chicken option. We settled on the steak and black cod, although we really did not want red meat. Our server Kelcie, who was 5* by the way, helped us in navigating all the intricacies to the ingredients. Lots of nuance to the menu. Our choices: lamb appetizer, black cod, sirloin, and chocolate mousse; each were tasty, presented well, and excellent dishes. The potato cake on the steak was very different and well done. Our Old Fashion had a nice taste. The place is very small and reservations are a must. The GM Michael came by and chatted us up...to thank us for coming, and glad they were able to accommodate our food needs. Nice touch. Excellent bathrooms. Thanks for that. Be prepared to spend $100 per person. Welcome to the Columbus culinary scene.

    Was in town for a mom's weekend away and decided after talking to our hotel bartender, Neil that we…read morewanted to visit Gene's. We were nervous at first because no one we talked to knew what Gene's was BUT we are SO SO SO glad we went! From the moment you step onto their property it was such an incredible experience. Who knew such a cute and quaint little restaurant could pack so much flavor and art into their food and such a personalized dining experience. While we had a reservation at 8:45, we decided to eat in at the bar after having the most incredible espresso martini of our lives and talking to John. My sister and I opted to share multiple courses - each of which was better than the last. It was an amazing experience and we were lucky enough to compliment and thank the executive chef in person. We left full and satisfied but not stuffed which is exactly what we were looking for! HIGHLY recommend Gene's if you're looking for an elevated dining experience and great service while in Dublin, Ohio!

    Photos
    Gene's
    Gene's - Croqueta braised beef

    Croqueta braised beef

    Gene's - Outdoors

    See all

    Outdoors

    Novella

    Novella

    4.3(109 reviews)
    9.4 mi
    $$$

    Stopped in on a Thursday for a date night after a friend recommended it! The wait staff was very…read morefriendly and helpful without being overbearing or pushy. I got the house wine and my fiancé got the beer and an espresso martini! All great! We got the crostini (mushrooms and ricotta) as an app - very delicious though the flavor profile wasn't exactly what we expected. The complimentary focaccia that came out was also delicious! For dinner we split the rigatoni (very popular per our waitress and we can see why - delicious and the short rib was tender and plentiful) and lasagna (special for the night and also quite good)! The restaurant was cute, smaller but not too small they couldn't do larger groups. Overall, delicious and would recommend!

    We had a very nice dinner at Novella. The food was excellent. We started with the shrimp appetizer…read moreand the meatballs and both were excellent. My wife and daughter shared the Caesar salad and it was very good. I had the Fra Diovlo lobster special and it was excellent although it wasn't remotely spicy which was disappointing. My daughter had the sweet potato ravioli and it was excellent. My wife had the salmon and she really liked it but my daughter and I didn't loved it. It was very citrus forward . The service was fine but nothing more. We did not like our table as we felt like we were at the kiddie table between the bathroom and kitchen with no lighting and lots of traffic. You could tell it was an afterthought for added seating at a popular restaurant. I was also unimpressed with the wine options and I didn't love the one I ordered. We will go back for sure.

    Photos
    Novella - Interior design

    Interior design

    Novella
    Novella - Novella Crostini

    See all

    Novella Crostini

    HillGarten - beergardens - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...