This was amazing. I had the pistachio custard. They only have a select amount of flavors they make each day or you can get the premade pints. The flavor was impeccable and it wasn't overly sweet. Definitely worth the try while in town. A small was almost $6. There is some seating around outside or in the park across the street. The staff are young and decently friendly. read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - Pistachio small cup - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

Nice local spot for homemade custard!! I love coming here when I am back in town. The sundaes are HUGE! They could easily be split between two people in my opinion. The employees here work really fast and have great service. Deducting a star because of the AI slop menu. Please just use canva read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

See all

I do have a soft spot for ice cream, more specifically frozen custard. So when I saw that Hibbard's had frozen custard we just had to stop. I ordered a chocolate (I know, boring to some) but it's my go-to flavor for custard. I always, when possible ordera cone, upside down in a cup. Less chance of spills. I was happy to see the cone holder had a big rim actually eliminating the need for a cup. Good to know for next time. Anyhow, the chocolate was good & my tummy was happy. Me too. 2025-72 read more

See all

Quick, friendly service. They only have take away or outdoor seating available on a deck with a decent amount of space between seats. They offer 7 options daily of their house made custard 4 core flavors (black raspberry, chocolate, vanilla & pistachio) and 3 specialty flavors that rotate daily. They also offer a variety of Perry's hard ice cream flavors. I ordered a small custard and was able to choose two different flavors. I chose butterfinger pecan and choco PB cup. They were smooth and flavorful with a good amount of "pieces" in them respective to their flavors. It was $5.50 for a small, which wasn't that much custard, but you do have to take into consideration that it is house made and small batch.. not something mass produced. I would visit again next time I'm in the area & see specialty flavors that pique my interest. read more

See all

Hibbard's is a must stop whenever we come to Lewiston. We love how there are so many fun flavors that rotate daily. My husband loves the Cookie Monster. I like to try a different one every time I come and they never miss! read more

Returned to Hibbard's for a birthday treat for myself. I had a taste of the Lavberry- lavender & blueberry, but the taste was too complicated for me. I got a vanilla, it was very tasty. I think vanilla is the flavor that is the best! read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - Vanilla cone in a cup - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

Who doesn't love ice cream?! Not me! I adore it! And Hibbard's didn't disappoint. We would definitely stop next time we are in Lewiston. read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

See all

Doesn't get better than Hibbard's! Homemade custard hits the spot every time. They serve Perry's along with a variety (usually 4 to 8 various flavors) of homemade custard. Small parking lot but lots of street parking nearby. They have a few picnic tables and there is a nice park across the street. I've never had anything but great custard every visit. Definitely worth the stop! read more

We stopped here after being referred here by someone working at the visitor center in Niagara Falls. It was worth the stop! Such yummy custard! We enjoyed sitting out on the patio eating our ice cream. read more

See all

Ice cream is good but I asked for a cone 2 times and received a dish and also got the wrong amount of change back. Outdoor seating is kinda cooled even when it's hot. read more

Hibbard's is the place to go in Lewiston/Youngstown for a summer ice cream treat. They serve a good selection of Perry's Ice Cream as well as soft-serve, and a variety of other dessert options. Priced fairly, good parking room for their location, and plenty of outdoor seating to cool off from these outrageously hot days we've been having. read more

The Black Raspberry Custard is a must. The custard is unlike any other and I love going here all summer long. The lines may be long but they move quickly and the staff is always ready to serve. read more

The homemade custards here are amazing. The pistachio custard is especially good and addictive. Hoping they will have the banana custard on the menu again next time I go back. read more

Paying seven dollars for a pint of toffee crunch It was a bit disappointing because it was basically a pint of vanilla custard with microscopic pieces of toffee maybe 20 of them. no crunch to be found read more

Serves a cone that had over half the ice cream on the cone/falling off...watched the employee just attempt to smear it on better to the side of the cone with the scoop & still thought it would be a good idea to serve to a customer. Shockingly made it less than 5min before falling off the cone completely & falling to the ground. read more

Creamiest custard I've ever had!! So many flavors too. Check their website to see what flavor they are featuring that day. They have 4 core flavors that they have daily. Vanilla. Chocolate, Black Raspberry and, Pistachio. Then each day they feature an additional 3 flavors. Worth the trip! read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - Summer is almost here! - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

I went to Hibbard's on my day off from working at the cemetery and there was only one worker there, a woman who was very nice. I happened to bring my cousin who is 31 along with me and is paralyzed from the waist down. He asked the woman what the coldest flavor was, and instead of getting mad at him she laughed and gave him some suggestions. All around wonderful day that we capped off with skydiving. Would definitely visit again. read more

No better way to beat the heat of the dog days of summer than with some homemade custard! Hibbard's fell on my radar of ice cream places to try since they make their custard right in-house. Typically, ice cream stands use a pre-made mixture and pour it into machines, so I was intrigued by the concept of custard made by hand. They have seven custard flavors every day (four staples, and three from their rotating menu) and a lineup of hard scooped ice cream. I opted for vanilla brownie with rainbow sprinkles, my boyfriend went for the black raspberry. Mine was some of the best custard I've had around WNY! The vanilla flavor was so rich and the brownie bites mixed throughout were a nice, chocolatey balance. And, of course, the sprinkles were good too. If I'm ever in the area again, I will definitely be stopping back to Hibbard's. Such a unique shop, it'll be hard to say no to it in the future. read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - Vanilla brownie custard with rainbow sprinkles - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

So glad we saved room for dessert! Was with friends from the area who have been going here for 40+ years and now we know why. The line (social distancing) was long but sooooo worth the wait. The chocolate, vanilla and black raspberry custard (though on the soft side) was outstanding, delicious amd fairly priced. It was celebrating its 80th year and the crowds show their support. This treat will not travel well unless prepackaged and frozen otherwise meant to be enjoyed immediately. Enjoy! read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - Family time - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

Hibbard's a Local frozen custard stand in village of Lewiston across from Academy Park. Great soft custard.and black raspberry is my favorite. read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - Hibbard's frozen custard Lewiston - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

The soft serve ice cream here is amazing! The custard they make is some of the creamiest and most delicious I've tasted. If you're a housemade soft-serve custard fan, definitely make the trip out to Lewiston to come to Hibbard's. I came and grabbed a blackberry ice cream and it was perfect. The fruity flavors, the cone and the service were all top notch. The only suggestion would be to have more flavors. There were only about six soft serve flavors to choose from (and the harder ice cream was from Perry's). I went for the housemade custard, but would have loved some more creative flavors like lavender, etc. All in all - a great place - definitely worth the drive to Lewiston even if you live in Buffalo. read more

This was some of the best ice cream I've ever had! It was extremely creamy and you can definitely tell that it's homemade. The flavors apparently change daily. I had the cherry vanilla and black raspberry and I would say black raspberry was my favorite. Definitely going to go back to try more flavors! read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - Cherry vanilla - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

Went here last night, and boy, what a classic ice cream joint, I am hooked! They have a private parking lot so it was easy to get to the place. We walked up to the window and the girls were super friendly. They have three sizes for their famous frozen custard; we order the large (under $5) which allows for up to 3 flavors. We tried the raspberry, vanilla, and chocolate--and they give you a lot! The raspberry and chocolate were so tasty with outstanding mild flavors. The vanilla didn't have much taste to it. We were really impressed how all of the frozen custard flavors has an excellent chewiness to it, and no poor aftertaste. There are tables directly to the right of the place where you can eat at. Can't wait to come back here for more! read more

See all

Excellent experience and the quality was outstanding. This is a throwback to simpler times and doing things the right way!

We travel to Western NY about once a year. When we are there, we go to Hibbard's for their frozen custard almost everyday!

I have an ungodly love for this ice cream. It's unique, special, and sticks out! I hope this place gets a great future! The only thing wrong they did was never being in my taste when I was born read more

Good ice cream except for the staff. I asked the girl if i could have mint and she was just like "no we are out of mint" and then I went back to the board to look at the other flavored and she was annoyed. I asked for another flavor and she rolled her eyes. Once she handed me my ice cream I said thank you and got no response. read more

Hibbard's Custard is so rich and creamy! This was my first time there and I noticed they offered puppy cups and the millennial in me needed to get my dog some ice cream since he is the best boy. I of course had to also order some for myself because that's the only option. The custard was delicious and I loved the topping offerings. I went with cookie dough because it's delicious! They offer large servings and it took me a while to finish it but it was worth it. Truman enjoyed his puppy cup as you can see in the picture! read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - Puppy Cup - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

See all

Old school since 1939. It was a rainy cold day and that didn't stop us or other customers from stopping by to enjoy a sweet treat. The ice cream scoop was almost the same price as a Strawberry Sundae so I went for the sundae. We enjoyed our dessert and all the toppings tasted fresh and the ice cream was so creamy and flavorful. read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - Old school since 1939 - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

Okay so I travel full time and I'm always looking for good local ice cream or frozen custard spots. Hibbard's but far is my favorite of the 28+ states I've visited. I bought the Key Lime pie in a cup and a Chocolate Marshmallow pint to go. This was hands down the BEST key lime pie frozen custard. Perfect blend of creamy and tart. They also added honey graham pieces for the "crust". My only wish- that I had bought multiple pints of this!!! The chocolate marshmallow was good. I wish it had more marshmallows but after the delectable Key Lime pie- it just didn't equal a grand slam for me. read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - Key Lime Pie - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

I have been familiar with Hubbard's but I never stopped by to try it. A few coworkers were shocked when I said I'd never tried the place before. They kept ranting and raving about the peach cheesecake custard. So, I made it my duty to make sure I tried it. I Hibbard's on social media and waited for them to post it as one of the flavors of the day. It finally came around after a month of waiting and I couldn't be more excited. I called them up and asked for two pints to be put on hold until after I got out of work and they gladly obliged. I was happy to pick up my pints immediately after work. They were worth every penny. I now understand why everyone raved about the custard but specifically the peach cheesecake. It was absolutely amazing. I loved every single bite. I'm glad I got two pints. My boyfriend and I dusted off an entire pint in one sitting. Worth every single calorie. It was the epitome of guilty pleasure. I wish I would have gotten more. Now I'm on the look out for the next round. I hope I can get more before the summer is over. read more

If you want to splurge on a small ice cream cone that costs more than an entire 1/2 gallon of ice cream at the grocery store a block away, have at it. Between Silo and Hibbard's, we choose Hibbard's. read more

Their custard definitely lives up to the hype. I had a scoop of chocolate and vanilla. I really liked it. The vanilla might be the best vanilla I ever had. My wife got some ice cream. They have homemade custard and Hershey's Ice Cream which is a nice change of pace from the Perry's Ice Cream every other place serves. Next time I'm getting a gallon of that vanilla! read more

Absolute best custard in the north! It says it wants at least 50 characters. So I will say again that it is the best. Rich, silky, dense, delicious. read more

See all

It's Hib to be Square. But if you keep feeding me custard this good, you're gonna make me cone in my pants. What to get: Vanilla Custard, Chocolate Custard, Banana Custard. What not to get: A different kind of banana. Not in public anyway. Not at Hibbard's. Why: There are kids here. How to improve: Put a location in Buffalo for us! So the region can see what real custard should taste like. Also do better advertising, get the word out. I'm unin-hibbard-ed, I have absolutely no shame. So there's no shame in saying I was wrong. I thought this custard was decent, average at best. Turns out it's some of the best custard I've had, and certainly my fave in the Buffalo area. And all the flavours are just as good as each other. This review is a lesson to me that I need to keep going back and trying places and re-assessing them, because it took me literally years to give Hibbard's another try, and only when I did, was I able to realize that this is easily, clearly the best custard in the WNY area - probably better than the standouts of Rochester too (LuGia's and Abbott's, the latter of which has 2 Buffalo area locations), and that everyone who likes custard and frozen treats should make the trek north to Lewiston to give this place a try. Service is okay, but the custard is so good, you'll want to expose yourself, at which time the Lewiston Police will show up and take you into custardy. read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - I'm uninhibbardted - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

Cool little icecream spot in the village. It gets very busy during the season but the staff works quickly and is always very pleasant. The prices are reasonable and the portion sizes are good. I wish they had more flavors though, such as rum raisin and red velvet icecream( hint hint) especially since they are the only flavours I eat. Nonetheless, Hibbards is a great spot to take your family for a sweet treat! read more

See all

Best best frozen custard in the world. My favorite is the black raspberry. I can't help myself every time I stop by I get a pint.

I was really hungry and thirsty and I came to Hibbards and a friendly man named Mario answered my plea for help. He got me a tasty strawberry smoothie while keeping our conversation professional and spicy. I would come here again. read more

Hibbard's Custard & Drive In - Strawberry smoothie by mario - Fast Food Near Me - Lewiston, New York

Yes, after my disappointing lunch I so wanted to hand out five stars to this custard stand on Lewiston's main drag that harkened me back to my childhood. What a fantastic start!!! The young lady inside the window beamed her beautiful smile at me. Her counterpart shared how he blended two flavors to customers' delight and he never stopped smiling!! Service is such a key ... Caring about customers with a smile so important! They have it figured out here! My first bite/lick into the black raspberry custard made my smile match those of my young servers!! They know how to create creamy delicious flavors mmmmmm But you see four stars. How in the world could the heavenly drop a star. ICE - yes in my smooth delicious custard I found icy pieces that just shouldn't be in great custard. Yes, if given the opportunity this would be 4 1/2 stars but that's not my option so it's a four. But, if you are near Lewiston and hungry for sweet deliciousness plus great service ... Head here!! Get the custard!!! They also carry Perry's ice cream but you can get that at your local grocery store. Mmmmm so good!! read more

See all

Wow do they have great custard. My friends who live in the area took me here and hyped up the place which had me worried but it lived up to the expectations they set. I had an almond chocolate custard which was chocolate and a hint of marzipan paired with snickers. Creamy and delicious and not overly sweet. read more