I've had yelp for years and never felt compelled to go through the effort of stringing the words together for leaving a review. This place deserves it. I've been trying to find a good bbq place in Indiana near Muncie for years after being spoiled by bbq down in Georgia. Grill't absolutely crushed it. Brisket was phenomenal. Baked beans were perfect. The sweet bbq sauce was delicious and different in a good way. The only hangup I really had was the seating. There's 2 long tables, and only a handful of short ones. I felt bad taking up a long table for just my wife and I, but that's a pretty minor detail. The guy behind the counter was patient with us stumbling through our order. One of the cooks brought out our food. All in all, incredible place and we'll definitely be coming back. read more

We wish we could give more than 5 stars!! Absolutely fantastic food and equally fantastic service! We will absolutely be back next time we drive to Indy! read more

Grill't - Barbeque Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

Some the best bbq had in a long time, prices are good. Pull pork was great and sweet sauce is good also.will for sure go back.

Legit some of the best bbq I've had! Tips were awesome, wife's pulled pork was fantastic. Fries for a bbq joint were top notch and the Mac n cheese was delic! Lady working, taking orders, serving food was awesome! So friendly, so sweet! Why did it take me 7 months after moving to NC to try this place! Will be back! read more

Wow! What a great restaurant! It's easy to drive past Grill't because it's behind Weenee World. (Lol at that name.) I went with a half-rack rib meal. It comes with two sides so I ordered monster fries (fries, cheese, ranch, and jalapeños) and Texan potatoes. (Yeah, I know. That was dumb to choose potatoes for both of my sides.) There was a slight upcharge to get monster fries, but it was worth it. The food was great! They have two kinds of BBQ sauce: sweet or spicy. If you don't like hot food, don't order the spicy BBQ sauce because it has some kick to it. The sauce was good, but my nose was running. :) The ribs and monster fries were amazing. There was a ton of meat on the ribs! Very filling. The Texan potatoes were good too, but not as good as the ribs and fries. The menu changes slightly from day to day depending on what they have in stock. I got the last available half-rack of ribs at 5:00pm on a Friday so if you want to eat here, it's best to arrive early! It started to get crowded right when I finished my meal. Grill't had the best service that I've received at a restaurant in a while. It's run by a nice Christian family. They are terrific. They work hard to make sure their customers are satisfied. It's hard to get a 5 out of 5 for food quality and service, but Grill't is exceptional at both. read more

Probably the best customer service I've ever received in Henry County - it was found here! The owner of Grill't is so incredibly friendly, I loved her. She kept bringing us samples of things to try and asking us if we needed anything. She's definitely ready to serve her customers & community with the best of the best. It's a family owned & operated business. Everything is homemade! Everything. The meats are tender and juicy, the best barbecue around. The Rodeo Burger is epic. The mac and cheese overload was recommended and super fillling. I could not finish it, although I wanted to. Ha! The baked beans are perfectly sweet. And the Texas Potatoes - extra cheesy with a bread crumble, . Indoor seating is open now and if you order a drink you will be greeted with a huge Ball jar that comes with free refills. Food comes out hot and fast. Order at the counter & they bring to your table. Tips: A banana pudding dessert is coming to the menu soon! Also, they have a rewards program. read more

Grill't - Mac & Cheese Overload - Barbeque Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

See all

Okay.... The food is amazing, but also the PEOPLE are amaazziingggg. We got brisket, pulled pork, green beans, fried pickles, baked beans, and the Mac Overload -- all delicious! If I could only ever eat one thing for the rest of my life, it would def be the MAC OVERLOAD. Don't leave here without it! read more

See all

We love Grill'ts. The barbecue is wonderful. I am sure the sides are good too, but we love the BBQ so much that we never have gotten any sides. The ladies that work in the kitchen are great too. They are so caring and kind. It is a great "feel good" atmosphere. Don't miss if if you are ever near New Castle. Kent K. read more

Hidden behind an ice cream place, we had seen some recommendations and decided to try. This is a DO NOT MISS THIS PLACE restaurant. First, you're welcomed like you're family. Family-owned business, they truly care that you have everything you want or need. Second, the food is so tasty, made with care, nothing pulled from a freezer and thrown in a microwave. My husband had the brisket: I swear, that might be the best brisket I've ever had in my life I had the pulled pork sandwich: so tender, loved that I had enough for lunch the next day BIL who had driven past multiple times: Now I'm mad I didn't come in here before today SIL: regarding the fried pickle sample we were offered, "I'm getting those next time" We all sampled each others' sides, monster fries, mac & cheese overload, baked beans, southern green beans, Texas potatoes, collard greens. Every item was memorable. They also do catering. Hmmm, maybe I should get a pan of pulled pork & the overloaded mac to put in my freezer for "an emergency" And ladies, thank you so much for your hospitality. Grill'T was a wonderful respite from our crazy rush around lives. We will definitely return. read more

Best eatery in New Castle! Excellent meals, sandwiches and SIDES! Love the sides, especially the Collard's! Family owned which shows with their gracious service whether dine in or carry out. Love supporting such hard working people that bring the customers service era back with a smile. read more

See all

Open for dining now. And for lunch some days too! You will never meet nicer people. And the overloaded Mac and Cheese ...omg yum yum yum! Sweet and/or spicy BBQ sauce on the sandwiches or meals. Tasty. Support local! read more

See all

OMG!!! If you have never been here and you love bbq, you are missing out! I ordered a half slab of ribs, a a double order of monster fries! Everything was amazing!!! The service is fantastic and they are so friendly here, and we will definitely be back!! read more

New restaurant in New Castle! This was our first time trying Grill't which has been open in it's permanent location for a few weeks. The owner came out, welcomed us, gave us free samples, and checked on our experience as we were leaving. The food was excellent! We had a pulled pork sandwich, shrimp tacos, and we attempted and failed at the loaded fries. The fries are a meal in themselves and are loaded with cheese, bbq, more cheese, and deliciousness. Everything was very good and you can't beat the customer service. read more

Grill't - Barbeque Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

Excellent food and service. The owner made sure we knew what we were wearing and gave us samples while we waited. My only caveat is to be sure to ask for barbecue sauce and utensils if you have takeout. My husband said his sandwich was even great without sauce, which says a lot for the food and to any meat eater! Note: no shrimp po'boy is on the menu, but you can ask for it! read more

Grill't - Menu - Barbeque Near Me - New Castle, Indiana

See all

Consistently the best ribs in the area! Love their monster fries as well. Service is always happy and quick.

My husband asked me to leave a 5 star review after him and my mom came here to get dinner. He was really impressed with the service and said the food was absolutely delicious! He says he will definitely be coming back next time we are in town! read more

Took a chance on this place on the way to Summit Lake and was so happy we did. The rib tips, pulled pork, and shrimp tacos were fantastic. I made the mistake of not asking for BBQ sauce so didn't have any when we got to the lake to eat, but honestly, I didn't miss it one bit. Gave me time to truly enjoy the full rich smoked flavor and tenderness. Literally some of the best pulled pork I've had. The sides were fresh and tasty as well and my wife loved the shrimp tacos. The best part was the interaction with the owner, Anthony. He was so friendly and made sure everything was personally taken care of. He really cares and the proof was the flavor. I really wish this place the best and can't wait to go get a shrimp po'boy next time. I didn't see it in the menu (yet) and Anthony claimed they are a hidden item, so my curiosity was highly peaked (sorry, Anthony... secret's out.). I will be back for more!! read more

We've eaten there several times since they opened. Some of the best barbecue(brisket and pulled chicken) we've ever had. Ad draw delicious sides. OMG. Grill't is a must if your ever near New Castle,IN. read more

Amazing food!!!! Well worth the deviation off of 70 to have delicious chicken and pork - the Mac cheese was the best I have had in years!!!!!! I would definitely come back here !! read more