The best pizza in town. The breadsticks are great. They have a lot on their menu but it's hard to…read morechoose anything other than the amazing pizza.

I know I am weird, but I love crustless pizza. I love how they put it in a nice little metal pan…read moreand it comes out tasting just like a pizza. Today I asked them for extra green pepper and onion and they accommodated. The service was fast and friendly and I love the people who helped me. I just love it when a staff is friendly and you can chat a little bit and they really seem happy to be where they are. Love this location. It is pick up only.

We had a group of 6 and came in on a Saturday evening…read more The pizza was good - the crust was a bit doughy but the cheese and sauce were good, and the toppings were plentiful. The bread appetizer was good, but a bit of a duplicate of the doughy crust. One of our party who wasn't in a pizza mood ordered a grinder and gave a "meh" review to it. There was a huge private party and we were seated near the door - it kept opening - then loud music and lots of noise - then the private party door closed. It happened ~50 times during our meal, and was a bit disruptive to conversation. In hindsight, I would have found seating away from that door.

Let me start by saying that I love Mancino's. The food is always delicious, and as far as taste…read moregoes, tonight was not an exception. I waffled between 3 and 4 stars tonight, because while the pizza tastes good, it's not what I ordered. I ordered a build your own 12" sausage, pepperoni and mushroom pizza with extra cheese and 2 garlic sauces for pick up. It was ready when I arrived and the two sauces I added were in the box. I got home and we dug in only to discover that the pizza was missing the sausage. It was definitely a bummer, since we usually get grinders or pasta, and this was our first Mancino's pizza. It won't stop us from coming back, but if I order pizza again, I'll definitely be peeking under the cheese before I leave.

This is one of my favorite pizza places. It is about a 45 minute drive, but is well worth it. All…read morethe staff we have met have been super nice. We will be back. Pizza is so good!

Came in with two friends after a day of hiking and all I can say is, I love this place!…read more Pros - The atmosphere in the place is amazing and the decor is great! Very fun and unique. - The breadsticks and bagel sticks are great!! - Got the BBQ Chicken Pizza and the Meat Pizza and it was great. It's a unique pizza with the wood fire taste/texture but it's great! Cons None

Moved to New Castle in August, have dined in twice and carried out once. Staff is awesome and food…read moreis amazing!

The food was great, and our service was very good. Our waitress Heather is the kindest, and the…read moreambiance was pretty nice!

Any product there is very good! The staff works hard! It is like a secret gem in Newcastle Indiana!…read moreThey have several varieties to choose from!

I'm so happy we have a local restaurant that serves a large variety of dishes that go from…read morebreakfast to dinner. I have eaten here a dozen times at least and I have yet to be disappointed in any of the food. I would recommend the tenderloin if you're real hungry the nachos are hit with me and the breakfast bowls are outright amazing! If you don't know about LJ's just takes State road 38 or broad if you're local going east and find this hidden gem for a good meal.

I grew up on Pizza King, and even when I moved away, I always made a point to indulge on it when I…read morecame home. So of course I love the pizza. What I didn't know was the Secret of the Amazing Blue Cheese Bacon Burger! Yeah, it's expensive, and doesn't come with any sides, but it's worth it. I cannot attest to any other location having this on their menu, but hat tip to this Top Hat!

waste of money. pizza over cooked no sauce and the cheese pizza I ordered for the kids was so bad…read morethey wouldn't eat it. it had hardly any sauce the crust was hard and there wasn't even enough cheese on it to call it a cheese pizza. I will not buy this pizza from this location ever again I have had nothing but bad pizza the last 3 times I've ordered it. I was able to get it fixed once but this last time I'm not even wasting my time. I just will never eat here again. It's a shame too because it was a convenient location for me but the pizza has been so bad its not worth it.

During this time of the COVID virus we are shopping local…read more This Hut is very friendly and doing their best to be quick. One of the things we have noticed with most Pizza Huts is ... they always seem to have one less person than they need. In spite of this, they are doing a good and steady job of keeping the line flowing. I wish the Gluten-free didn't cost so much. (That goes for any pizza place). Thank you for being here and open and serving our community.

They are super nice and I have been down on my luck lately and they gave me a free pizza on my…read morebirthday. I was shocked when I heard a knock at the door because I had almost no money.

There is a reason they had 2.7 stars before this. App says pizza is ready, it's not. Lady at the…read morecounter is rude, keeps rolling her eyes, gave a lady the wrong order. Yep won't be back.

Food is pretty good as at all locations however the last 2 times I've been here for some reason…read morethey don't ever turn the lights on?