Sat at the bar on a Thursday night. The dining room was packed. Bar empty. Service was excellent. Ice cold dry martini to start it off. Prime rib is available every night. It was textbook supper club prime rib. Expertly cooked and seasoned well. Horseradish sauce and mashed potatoes were perfect accompaniments. My wife's filet was also fantastic. It was our first stop in after driving by so many times. We will be back (frequently). read more

Excellent food. I love their potato crusted cod. Husband loves the steaks. Duck is wonderful!!! Pricing is on par for the area & a supper club atmosphere. Classic supper club vibe. Although I do miss the salad bar with the giant chunk of cheese!! Amazing service that's consistent with each visit. Bartenders, waitstaff, hosts. Never go wrong with Green Acres! read more

Incredible seafood platter! Great New York steak! Wonderful deviled eggs! Rachel , our server, was excellent! And the restaurant was nice looking, busy but even though busy you could easily hold a conversation! Definitely will go back. Their friday and tuesday fish fry sounds GREAT! read more

See all

Terrible! My partner and I finally made our way to Green Acres after driving by and seeing a full parking lot, each time. Unfortunately, this restaurant was not worth the excursion. The steak was dry and had no flavor, and the specialty salmon was blah. So disappointed. The service was also unfortunately disappointing. Distracted server, very confused as to when she was coming around and for what, water, appetizer, taking order, bringing food, or clearing dishes. Don't bother in dressing up. This is casual dining at high price menu items that won't meet your expectations. read more

Green Acres - Husband didn't finish filet. - Seafood Near Me - Sauk City, Wisconsin

See all

Went for Easter brunch. What a disappointment. Not one thing at the buffet is worth mentioning. Way below average. Not even water unless you ask. No spoon to stir your coffee unless you ask. And as soon as you sit down they tell you that you have a time limit to eat. I have lowered my expectations since moving from a city location. But this is the worst. I wish I could sat something good about the place. But sorry read more

Service and ambiance are great. Food quality is poor and tonight my medium well filet was burnt beyond recognition. So disappointed

Food and drinks here are always amazing! A bit on the pricier side, but worth it for special occasions. Service here is always friendly, but can be a bit slow. Such a cute spot! read more

Cool super club experience! Loved the bar and the super club vibe it's giving off. Service was great. Cheese curds were good. Bread was fantastic. Sirloin steak was just okay.....that's why it's getting a 4. Really wanted it to be more seasoned but that's okay. Ice cream drinks good. Overall would go back! read more

Great food Had the seafood platter excellent The BBQ ribs was also fantastic Rachael was a great server Thank you read more

We had the worst experience this evening. The service was slow. The food was not good, and there was no taste, and it was a big disappointment and we will not be back. read more

Feels like a large open homey space.we ate on the second floor. The food was adequate but the prices were exorbitant. If you are going to pay these prices go to Ishnala ( the food is better as is the ambiance) read more

See all

Went for dinner on a Tuesday night. Place was busy so we got a reservation. Turns out they have a fish special on Tuesday's (prime rib too), so five of us got fish and one person ordered the half chicken. Meals started with warm bread, cheese and garlic toast to share. The four of the fish eaters ordered the beer battered version, one ordered broiled. Fish portion was generous, three pieces, and prepared perfectly. Everyone had the baked potato and coke slaw. Clean plate club prevailed. Chicken came to the table lightly battered. Portion was large and looked delicious. Person who had chicken removed every speck of meat on the carcass and had a big smile on his face when done. Bottom line ... I miss the salad bar from the old days. I really do. The meal was very good and the value was terrific. You will enjoy this old fashion supper club. read more

Everything and this fine restaurant is only a couple miles from downtown Sauk City, where we reside. The cuisine, service and dining room are far above average. I grew up in the Hospitality Industry and understand everything about it, including the importance of Cuisine, well-trained and courteous staff and location. We find no fault with Green Acres and frequently dine there. read more

Love Green Acre for a weeknight or weekend fun! Staff are on their game all the time, the drinks are good, food portions are huge. We had a reservation on a Friday that we made a hour and a half before arriving. Have a drink at the bar before eating and request upstairs dining, the ambience is better up there! read more

See all

Food is great at this supper club! Service is very attentive. Traditional décor. Worth the trip!

Except for the Prime Rib that our friend ordered which I tasted was delicious the rest of my husband and my meal was terrible. He ordered the Salmon Oscar- very mushy on the verge of going bad. He loved the French onion soap. We all loved the asparagus cooked just perfectly. Ordered escargot hard to taste it with all the stuff put on top. Very small escargot. The bread served with the meals was hard and cold. The salad that my friend and I ordered with our meal look old and wilted like it came out of a prepackaged bag. My meal was a total disappointment. I ordered the Pan Seared Scallops. Send it back because it was super tough. As my husband and friend were finishing their meal they bought another plate, took one bite and realized those scallops were bad. The restaurant did take my meal off the bill. read more

Wow, this place has gone down hill! We were there on a Thursday night early May. Service & Cocktails were great as usual but the food, what a joke. I ordered vegetable soup, it consisted of corn & some kind of bean in a watered down tomato based broth, just horrible! My dinner was on the special board, salmon Oscar, salmon was good little fishy tasting but overall okay, the asparagus was disappointing thinner then a pencil & overcooked. I could have picked better in a ditch! My husbands steak was served in a puddle of bloody juice that he had to pour off not very appealing. We really miss the salad bar. Might be a while before we go back. Very disappointing! read more

This was a Fantastic Place years ago and has gone down hill BIG TIME. The Salad bar is gone, food quality is much lower and service is not even close to what it was. It is really too bad bad to have such a much love place drop so low. We will not return. read more

Great food, celebration dinner! Short drive to a wonderful location One of the few places that one can order crab legs and they are amazing. The scenic drive just adds to the experience one can have! Call ahead with a reservation- enjoy read more

Great food, very good service. One of my favorite restaurants. Love their fried shrimp and prime rib.

We tried Green Acres on a Thursday night, and waited 15 minutes in the bar for a table. It's a large bar area, but only had one bartender on staff, and he seemed pretty overwhelmed. Once we were seated, we waited 15 minutes for a server, another 15 for our drinks, where one person in our party didn't get theirs, and another received the wrong one. When we got our drinks, we said we were ready to order, but waited even longer for her to come back. I don't know if they were short staffed, but we were one of only 3 tables total up there. The bread basket was amazing, soups and food were good. But overall, I think it was very over priced for what you got. Their prices are the same as Ishnala's, and that place is an entire experience. This was a few hour event, but only because we waited so long in between each part. read more

See all

One of the last supper clubs and always fun, especially at the bar area. Nice selection of specials on this Sunday evening and was a hard choice to decide which one to order. My half a duck was good but not great and the obviously frozen hash browns were on the cold side with the cheese not melted, still in the out of the package square slice. Again, good but not great. The steaks were the same, cooked correctly but not the greatest cuts. Salads and soups were very good and we still enjoyed being here. Salad bar is still not back, unfortunately and instead there is a huge wine cooler where it used to be. Service was excellent and all the employees were friendly and helpful. A fun evening. read more

Bar experience was good. Dinner, eh. Our bread came out cold. Our prime rib came out cold. All of our food was cold. Had to send it back. Waitress was inattentive. When steak came back it was warm not hot. The prime rib taste was good but that was about it. Not sure if we would go back. read more

Excellent steaks! I miss the salad bar! That was the big draw for me. Great supper club atmosphere.. read more

Horrible. Over salted food, bottled salad dressing, horrible service and a dismissive attitude from our waitress. Dark and dank atmosphere, yuck! Bad food and drinks. A super let down for a lot of money. Save your money and your appetite. read more

Green Acres - A $16appetizer, slim Jim, ritz crackers, dreadful, running yoke deviled eggs, processed cheese spread - Seafood Near Me - Sauk City, Wisconsin

Something has happened here the past year and let me share...it's all good! Who ever is in the kitchen cooking, they are doing a fantastic job. Excellent service and well thought out dishes prepared just right. It's very nice having a local place to go that knows how to serve a great meal. From the seafood to the steaks, very well done. Thank You. read more

Been eating here for 40+ years, and rarely had an issue. But since new owners took over last year, the food quality has steadily gone down hill. The baked fish was cooked well, but flavorless and bland. Hash browns were cooked thoroughly, but only on one side. The seafood plater ($66) was borderline cold. The broiled fish was dry, flavorless and overcooked. Scallops and lobster were fine. Calamari was tough and rubbery. Wait staff was half friendly, but always in a rush with really no concern for listening to our questions or concerns. They need a friendly hostess to greet you when arriving. All real supper clubs need a salad bar! Overall it was a waste of $200.00. Very sad, but we will not be back. Too many other restaurant choices around here. read more

Had a bad experience last time we ordered carry out so we thought we'd give it another try to give them the benefit of the doubt.. horrible again. They said our food would be ready at 5:35 so I arrived at 5:40, I still had to wait another half hour before my food was "ready" I live less than five minutes away from the restaurant and when I got home the food (fish, hotdog, fries etc) was cold and soggy. And my daughters hot dog was scorched so she refused to eat it. I'd probably eat the $80 before I'll eat there again. Extremely disappointed read more

Green Acres - Burnt hotdog - Seafood Near Me - Sauk City, Wisconsin

Celebrated hubbies birthday tonight. Staff was phenomenal, from the hostess, Amber, bartender, Chris and Tina our waitress. We had salmon and shrimp for dinner and we were not disappointed read more

Steaks were cold and took forever to be served. Drinks were reasonably priced. The ambiance was ok.

This place is popular. Arrived at 7pm on a Saturday and had a 1 hour wait for a table for 2. But waiting is part of the fun. The bar area has comfy stools, $5 Old Fashioned's (they count as a "rail" drink) and bowls of snack mix. Good people watching and friendly atmosphere. Enjoyed the salad bar. Ordered the prime rib, which was generously sized, though slightly tough. Ended the night with ice cream drinks and everyone had a good time. read more

See all

To compliment the great food all of the staff is outstanding from the bartenders, servers, and even the bussers.

My husband and I stopped here on the way back from the Wisconsin Dells. It was a Monday night and we did not have to wait to be seated. Food: they have a wide variety of food. We had the calamari for an appetizer. It was cooked just right. I would recommend trying it, if you are a calamari lover. I had the jumbo shrimp for my meal. I thought the shrimp would be a little bigger than they were. I had the rice as a side and it didn't seem to be cooked all the way. One weird thing is all entrees come with a salad bar and they will not put your order in until you go up to the salad bar unless you tell them otherwise. Drinks: We had the Canyon Road Moscato. I am a huge mascara drinker and this one is at the top of my list. It is sweet but not too sweet. You can really taste the fruit. Price: This place is on the pricey side. Honestly I don't know if the food quality is worth the price. The food wasn't bad but the pricing was a bit much. Atmosphere: This place is casual. It has an old country feeling to it. It is good for big groups. read more

See all

Traveling through on our way home to California. Prime rib was superb. Waitress pleasant, very nice and efficient. Great place to eat.

Awful experience. We arrived at 5 PM, and got our meal at 6:35 after being seated at 5:30. The place had plenty of empty tables when we ordered. A table next to us was seated 50 minutes after we were and got their meal 5 minutes later than we did. The fried chicken was so overfried that you needed a chisel to get through the crust. Probably was put into the frier when we first ordered. I give them some credit for a fresh salad bar and a decent bartender, but that's it. I should have refused to pay for the whole thing, but I didn't have the energy. read more

This was our first visit to Green Acres establishment. We have always heard good things, so we figured we would try it for ourselves. We spent the day at House on the Rock and drove right past this place on the way home. When entering the restaurant we were immediately greeted with hellos, smiles and seated! Once sat we were told specials for the day, drink order taken and away we go!  I ordered the bacon wrapped shrimp appetizer and crab cakes to share. Both were pretty good and paired with tasty sauces, just needed a little seasoning. We then ordered a rack of ribs for myself and fettuccini Alfredo topped with Shrimp and Scallops for my wife. Yum! Both of us got a trip to their salad bar which was really simple, but really good. Awesome salad, fresh cut veggies, fresh cheese, cottage cheese and toasted garlic bread! We got a loaf of fresh cut bread delivered to our table to eat with our salads as well.  We then got our meals which were cooked perfectly, and very tasty! My only complaint is that everything lacked seasoning or any real flavors. It was all very bland, like they were cooking for a retirement center! Let's jazz that amazing food up a bit with some flavor town! We understand your crowd is older and that what pays the bills, but needs some seasoning! My ribs were tender, not much flavor again and not my preference of bbq sauce. They slathered them in open pit bbq which is a Texas tang sauce and I like a sweet bbq (brown sugar, molasses, mustards) so that ruined the whole experience for me.  Overall it was a clean place, friendly staff, great location, good food, average price for a Supper Club, and a great wine selection! We will be back to try some more food off the menu! read more

Green Acres - Rack of Ribs - Seafood Near Me - Sauk City, Wisconsin

See all

Traveling through rural Wisconsin, we stumbled onto this neat spot for dinner. It was Friday night but we didn't have to wait for a table. Our server was very prompt. My husband ordered the beer battered fish and I ordered the potato cheddar crusted cod. They have a small salad bar that comes with meals. Our food was a little slowing coming out but it was delicious. Most people seemed to be getting steals that seemed to come out faster. Decor is older but nice. We would definitely go back. read more

The building is super cute. We came in at 6:30. The wait was about an hour. My fiancé ordered the halibut and I took a chance and ordered the swordfish (I've never had it before). Both meals came with a salad bar. The salad bar was just ok. Wish they would have had something better than just iceberg lettuce. My fiancé said his halibut was good, nothing special. My swordfish was amazing though! Would definitely recommend it. Glad they also had a vegetable choice for a side (sugar snap peas - were good). Waitress was nice. Nothing extremely special. Would probably come back again, would love to try the seafood platter. read more

Green Acres - A salad from the salad bar. - Seafood Near Me - Sauk City, Wisconsin

See all

Ok let's start with the actual building and setting...... I like that it's old and rustic and needs remodeling....... It feels like a supper club people ! It's all over the media as being a Wisconsin top 10 supper club! Anyway the salad bar was fresh but ice berg lettuce is the only option. Spinach/field greens or something would be my preference. A option of cornbread it rolls vs only a loaf of dry wheat bread would be nice. Our waitress Rachael was attentive, happy and ,on point. I will say she failed to notice our empty drinks on two occasions while the place was not that busy on a week night . I ordered the king cut prime which might not be worth the extra $4 bucks from the petite prime rib which was plenty big. Not to sound cheap but for $20-26 bucks for any cut of meat I kinda think a large baking potato! Not a small one and some type of veggie would be the norm. My prime rib was also a bit cold and they are not served on a heated skillet and cools very fast. The meat was cooked perfectly as ordered (medium) and was flavorful. Don't order prime rib and then complain about it being fatty on Yelp people. It's prime rib! A lot of reviews stated similar complaints about the salad bar and prime rib. The dessert was incredible and the drinks were a decent quality pour. I will be back. Get the few small things addressed and it would be a easy 5 star. read more

Green Acres - Dessert chocolate cake was amazing - Seafood Near Me - Sauk City, Wisconsin

See all

We love the steaks and seafood (fried shrimp) at Green Acres. The au jus is the best around. The steaks are always perfectly cooked and super tender. Only issue stopping this from being a 5-star review is the manager, Amber. She is extremely unpleasant both in person and on the phone. We have seen her treat employees with zero respect on numerous occasions. Working in a restaurant is hard enough without difficult management. read more