Over an hour to be delivered and cost $57.66 with tip and delivery charges. Would be fine with that if it was hot and tasted good. Was hoping this was going to be good, might try the Indian Pizzas because the flavors might help the crust, but pick it up. read more

Good Fellas - XL Sicilian Hawaiian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Virginia

See all

Great service and delicious pizza. The restaurant sitting area was on the smaller side but some clean and friendly. The restrooms were great indicative of how well they maintain the establishment. The pizza was fantastic. Tasted fresh and very yummy. Will definitely be going back! read more

Not a bad little place, mushrooms were tasty and hot and came with marinara sauce. The chefs salad was not as much meat and cheese as they showed online but it was still fresh and came with garlic bread. I'd definitely try this place again to give an updated review. read more

Good Fellas - Fried mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Virginia

See all

I wanted to like this place. I ordered a half hawaiin pizza and a half double cheese, with mild wings and garlic bread. When I go there for pickup it was a whole hawaiin. The man said Ill make you another with no apology. I was made a new pizza after waiting 10 minutes. I asked if I could add a canned soda which he added for $1.69 which he made me pay for...whatever. i get home to have my mild sauced wings and this is what I get...completely charred and burned wings for little to no mild sauce. This is a 40+ order...do not eat here. This is pretty sad for an uncomplicated order. read more

Good Fellas - Charred mild wings - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Virginia

Pizza is horrible I'm Italian worst pizza ever my Nona would spit on it you need to go back to YOUR Nona & get her recipe! You need to step your game up on the pizza bcuz it sucks! I'll never order again - only good thing the Italian sausage read more

Expensive. Ordered the Sicilian with high hopes. The dough was processed and inedible. One of the worst takeout pizzas I've ever had. Any frozen pizza would be better. Will not recommend to anyone. read more

Maybe I was thinking of Godfather's Pizza when choosing this restaurant. My husband loves UNOs deep dish. That's why we choose this restaurant and ordered their Chicago deep dish meat lover's pizza (and chicken wings). The Yelp reviews were good. Disappointed. The pizza totally missed the mark! It was meat on top of dough, topped with dough, topped with mozzarella cheese, tomato paste and a little sprinkle of parmesan cheese. The pizza crust was doughy but burnt on the bottom. The tomato sauce/paste was bitter and just weird on the top. Reheating didn't help. The chicken wings weren't cooked hard enough for us. I like my Buffalo wings fried crispy then tossed in sauce. The restaurant too far from us. Better options closer. read more

Good Fellas - Mild Buffalo Wings - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Virginia

See all

We had the Chicago deep dish (not on the menu) and it was delish, even great as leftovers in the oven, definitely go there!

AWFUL PIZZA AWFUL SERVICE. I recently ordered a medium pan pizza from here and the pizza arrived burned and inedible. I called to tell the manager the problem and he told me to call back anytime and order a new pizza and tell them David the manager said it was free. I called on a Saturday and I was told the mgr wasn't there but I couldn't get my free pizza on a Saturday. Then he said he would call me back when I mentioned I would also order other items I'd pay for. No call. Still trying to give them a chance I call on Wednesday night. The guy said he'd get the manager and hung up on me! I called back thinking it was a mistake and they hung up again. I ripped up my menu and threw it out. Don't get Goodfellas pizza. Their customer service is beyond awful! read more

HEY! GOODFELLA.... you want some pizza? Look no further!! This is our go-to pizza spot and they deliver fast! They've consistently delivered our food under the time quoted and it's always been hot. We're a fan of the pizza and wings so far but look forward to exploring the rest of their menu soon. I'm from Chicago and have a high standard for pizza... personally I like a good thick pizza! Their Sicilian pizza is very tasty and reminds me of both NYC and Chicago! The crust, the sauce and the toppings obviously make the pizza, but the crust is really what puts Goodfellas ahead of competitors. Then you layer a tasty sauce on top of the perfect crust, toss in perfect toppings and voilà! You have a very tasty pizza - we've even frozen the leftovers and they've tasted like fresh delivery! If you have to drive to pick it up, it's worth the drive! read more

See all

This is new our go-to for take out food. Food is clearly made when you order it and has always been accurate. Flavor is excellent across the board - pizzas, calzones, cheesesteaks, salads - it doesn't matter! On top of that, these guys smile at you and are clearly hustling which means they value you as a customer. Let them know if something is not right or if you have a suggestion. They've never gotten anything wrong with our orders but I've had great conversations with them. Dining in is limited. Outside dining is available but not a lot of it. read more

Cold pizza that arrived 30 minutes past the time it was promised. Ordered through a delivery service and when the delivery service called the restaurant to ask if anything could be done in terms of either a refund or partial refund, the restaurant was unwilling to anything. Gave them a try for the first time. Will not order from them again. read more

First time trying this pizza. Ordered through pizza app. Picture on app for Sicilian pizza looks much bigger than what I recieved. This is a $40.00 pizza. My opinion it's a little over priced for 1/2 the pizza I received. Taste is good. I would not recommend this pizza. Delivery was on time. read more

Good Fellas - Sicilian pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Virginia

See all

Really not good. Tried a couple times now for lunch since its pretty close to my job and each time I'm disappointed. Will not go back. Its a shame merones is not open anymore for takeout :( :( read more

Ordered some pizza at this place and wasn't disappointed. The crust was crispy and the pepperoni was tasty. They had other items on the menu to include pasta, subs, and wings. Definitely give this place a try. read more

See all

Pizza is great and roasted garlic wings are amazing! Always get your pizza well done. Best pizza in the South Riding area in my opinion.

I've only been to Goodfellas twice. My first experience was great. I had their Chicago style deep dish veggie pizza and it was really authentic to Chicago style pizza in NoVa. Fast forward to my second experience and I can't believe it but they changed the pizza. It's called Chicago style but it isn't. Their is no sauce on the pizza. It's just crust and cheese and veggies. It tasted awful. I called them because I was so shocked and I thought they made a mistake, but the manager said no we changed it and this is what it is now. So sad I just hung up the phone as he tried to explain why but it made no sense. Too bad honestly. I would not recommend. read more

One of the best restaurants in the area they got variety of food like pastas, pizzas and subs. onwers are Really friendly will be back for sure. read more

Good Fellas - Indian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Virginia

Ugh. Don't order from the slice app or on a Friday night. It's been 1.5 hours and we still don't have our food. We've called twice and we're told 'he's leaving in 5 minutes' (which was already 10 minutes after it was supposed to be here) and then we were told 'we are really busy, he will be there any minute'. 15 minutes later and he's still not here (btw it only takes 15 mins to get to our house from GFs). So it's been 45 mins since he was supposed to have been leaving 'in 10 mins'. This is our third time ordering from them and it will be our last. The first time everything was fine, but the zucchini sticks were super bland. The second time the pizza was horrible and had zero flavor. Hoping the pasta and calzone tonight are worth the 2 hour wait. read more

Been going there for quite some time. Kids love it. Wife loves it. Everybody we invite over to our house loves it. We're now regulars, so perhaps I'm biased, but there's a reason why we're regulars. Pizza and desserts are definitely their strengths. They'll accommodate custom requests too. Every pizza place has their own distinct flavor (think Dominoes vs Pizza Hut for example), and Goodfellas tastes awesome in their own way. Highly recommended. I'll upload photos next time we place an order. read more

First time having Goodfellas and we loved it! Great sauce, pizza was delicious, good garlic/cheese bread and spaghetti was awesome as well. Definitely ordering again! read more

It was really good. Me and my boss work right down the road so we thought we'd give a try. The staff was friendly and quick. I ordered a pepperoni calzone. It's the best one I've had in this area. The dough was crispy on the outside and the perfect amount of doughy on the inside. The marinara sauce was delicious. They added a little red pepper which brought a little spice which kicked it up a few notches. I definitely recommend it. My boss got a steak and cheese. He said it was pretty good. He didn't care for the fries as they left a little to be desired. Maybe a crispy crinkle cut fry would set them off the right way. All in all the service was fast and friendly. Will be coming back to try more. read more

Great local mom & pop pizza place in the same complex as Dulles Kabob. Fast, friendly service. We were pleased! read more

Good Fellas - XL Pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Virginia

See all

crust typical of fast food pizza. flavor, okay, but for the price, unacceptable. pay less for better pizza.

not sure if something has changed or it's the specific items we've ordered but it seems like a lot of the proteins are made from frozen.. got the grilled chicken salad and it is very obvious its made from frozen chicken strips just dipped in buffalo sauce. Paid $10 for a sad salad. Also it's all iceberg lettuce, the lowest cost and least nutritional lettuce available. Blue cheese dressing tasted sad also, only flecks of blue cheese. Daughter order a cheese burger and the patty appears to have been a frozen patty which was extremely dry along with my son's chicken tenders, made from frozen. I've ordered from here before and I don't remember it being this bad. I wanted to take a break from cooking tonight only to order food that I barely want to eat, it was so very disappointing. :( read more

Good Fellas - "Grilled" Chicken Salad with Blue Cheese Dressing - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Virginia

Was really looking forward to getting a pizza from this place. I grew up in Chicago, so I'm kind of a pizza connoisseur. Looking at their menu and photos, their pies resembled Giordano's from the Windy City. When I called to place my order, this is when things went sideways...the gentleman that answered the phone could not answer any of my questions without calling his manager on the other line. It was very frustrating, and to be honest I just ended the call. Had to settle for a frozen Home Run Inn thin crust from Harris Teeter. I really miss the great food Chicago offers. DC is not a food town. read more

Tried the meat lovers Chicago style pizza, garlic knots, fried mushrooms and Goodfellas Supreme pizza. All were well worth the price we paid. Highest recommendations for delivery and pickup. My new go-to pizza shop. read more

Awesome steak and cheese,pizza and bacon cheese burger keep it up good fellas you guys are awesome

We've come here three times now, and love everything we've gotten. The crust is crispy and we'll done. The toppings are fresh and flavorful. Our favorite so far has been the spinach and chicken Alfredo pizza! The staff is always friendly and helpful. They even let us try a dessert the night we picked up a pizza. I highly recommend this place! read more

This review is strictly based on the Order of garlic knots i got yesterday. While the knots are a little smaller than I'm used to getting in Florida, there were covered in melted butter and garlic so really no complaints. read more

We always order Goodfellas for our pizza night. They never disappoint. Pasta, pizza, subs, apps, etc., it's all delicious. We also love how fast their delivery is any night of the week. read more

I tried the meat calzone and was not disappointed. It was cooked perfectly, and was not overly greasy; too often are calzones still mushy in the center from being cooked unevenly, or overly greasy from the ingredients. The calzone at Goodfellas, however, was delicious. The star of the show was their sausage, which was very flavorful and unique. Also, at about $9, the price is perfect for a quick pick-up for dinner. I am interested in trying their specialty pizzas in the future, especially the Indian style ones. read more

First time ordering here... put the order in at 4:54 and was delivered at 7:04, the pizza was cold, there was a card on top of the pizza. Cheese was cold and dough was tough. And now on hold for over 20 minutes trying to get a refund which they are arguing NOT to refund. Will never order from here again. read more

See all

Wow so I called into this place at 11 on a Saturday when they close at 12 and was told sorry, everyone has gone home and every other pizza place closes at 11. Sorry but you just lost my business for good and I will let everyone know. Horrible customer service. read more

Hot and delicious brick oven pizza. The owner is especially kind, generous and has been perfecting his pizzas for over 40 years, one of a kind. Ordered delivery and the pizza still got here hot and crispy. Definitely my go-to pizza shop. Goodfellas is 5 stars just like the movie. read more

The food is awesome. Very friendly staff. This has become our go to pizza place. Very satisfied.

Its a good pizza spot they do by the slice as well. Right off 606 near the Allstate and the Mcdonalds. If you haven't tried it stop on by, the owner is a good guy. read more

Ok Goodfellas is my new go to Pizza shop. I'm from Paterson NJ and this is the closest thing to a NY slice I've had in a while. It's delicious!!! The boneless chicken wings are THE BEST AROUND HANDS DOWN!! Their delivery time is impeccable! The longest we've had to wait for delivery in Brambleton is 30 min. I'm glad they left that flyer on my door! Thanks Goodfellas!! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND EVERYONE TRY THEIR FOOD!! read more

I noticed this place had opened not far from my house so I decided to give it a try, so glad I did. I ordered a meat calzone and it was delicious, probably the best I've ever had. The calzone was made fresh, didn't take long and served with a smile by the guy who had prepared it. You for sure gained a new customer!! read more

Good Fellas - Meat Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Virginia

From someone from Queens..This is the best pizza I have had in a very long time. The cheese pizza is just right and the the Sicilian is NYC worthy. I also agree on the calzone comments here. Not only extra cheesy but the garlic crust is excellent and takes it over the top. No menu item has disappointed yet and I don't think they will. Five stars. read more