My wife and I drove up from Chicago to have lunch with our Grandson and his family…read more We both agree that this restaurant is deserving of a 5 Star Review for the following reasons: 1. Friendly proprietor 2. Cozy environment 3. Good appetizers 4. Great Pizza We will definitely be back when in Sussex.

Excellent service! Excellent pizza and garlic bread!…read moreBeer was cold! We arrived around 6 PM. We will be back! Great place for the family too.

Awesome thin crust pizza! Got it for pickup but look forward to dining in sometime. Great spot and…read moreservice!

For nostalgia when I return home to visit I usually hit up Rocky Rococo or Ned's if I want pizza…read more This place is the best pizza I've had in Wisconsin. My friends that I shared it with were salivating and asking where I got it. If they're up for the drive, Carol Ann's has new customers.

Just outside of Milwaukee is a strip mall with an unassuming pizza storefront with something truly…read morespecial inside. This is not your ordinary pizza place, as they have pizzas ranging from the Chicken Cordon Bleu (Honey Mustard Sauce, House Blend Cheese, Chicken Strips, Ham & Swiss), Mac Daddy (Creamy Alfredo Sauce, House Blend Cheese & Cavatappi Noodles topped with our cheese and herb shake) and Portabella Lugosi (Classic Sauce, Baby Portabella Mushrooms, Sausage, Red Onions, Basil, Garlic and Mozzarella topped with our Cheese & Herb Shake). If you are an adventurous eater, or are tired of plain old pizza toppings, this is the spot for you. The menu is impressive, and the store has old and new movie poster themed pizzas throughout. This location is smaller, with only a couple of tables, I understand others are larger. However, the food delicious and decently priced. I am bummed we do not have any locations in Illinois. If you're in Wisconsin, check to see if there is a Glass Nickel pizza nearby!

This place never disappoints! The staff was super friendly and helpful as they were soooo BUSY! I…read moreordered for a specific time and they NAILED it! Piping hot and fresh Italian beef pizza, spinach calzone (sadly they discontinued artichoke hearts!!) why? It pairs soo well with spinach! But the calzone dough is pillowy delicious with Marinara sauce to dip. Jalapeño poppers are a bit spicy but plenty of cream cheese. Mozzarella sticks were also on point and pretty standard. Love the Chocolate Shoppe ice-cream! A pint is a great finish to a good pizza dinner. Thank you Glass Nickle for maintaining your quality and service throughout the years!

Three of us had the lasagna and found it very tasty. Two of us had it with Italian sausage and the…read moreother person had the homemade meatballs. I would order it that way next time. Our fourth had a pizza which he said was also delicious. Our server was very attentive and pleasant. The environment is OK could use a little TLC.

Pros: -Good pizza…read more-Nice staff -Easy parking Cons: -Underwhelming steak sandwich -Some items over-seasoned We recently tried out Marty's Pizza on Mother's Day because it was my MIL's choice. She has great memories from going to a different Marty's location for work lunches years ago. Apps: -We started our order with some of the mozzarella sticks, which my wife and MIL liked (I'm not huge on breaded mozzarella sticks, so I didn't try them out). Mains: -Pepperoni pizza (Wife)-- really good thin crust pizza -Spinach lasagna (MIL)-- over seasoned to me, but my MIL seemed to enjoy it -Steak Sandwich (Me)-- not great, one little slice of overcooked, thin steak with some cheese. It also came with a cold side of fries. Overall, I would stop back in for pizza but probably would probably skip for anything else.

When looking for a good pizza in the bay view neighborhood.... Look no further!! Classic slice has…read moredelicious pizza by the slice. They have a rotating slice of the week that is always a great combination of flavor. Service is quick and friendly. And the vibe inside is super cool. Arcade games, and good music fill the space and make for a top tier pizza experience!

I freaking LOVE the Pesto Pie. I want it all the time. But don't order from them anymore. Every…read moretime I call, I am put immediately on hold, so today, I tried the online ordering and the site wasn't accepting online orders. So I call, on hold, the person answering the phone says delivery will take around 2 hours. Several times, I have said "Yes, I will wait for this delicious pizza!" That's only when they say it will take an hour. Never fails, it takes MUCH longer. Sometimes I have wondered if they have forgotten about me. I call them to make sure they are still coming. Oh yeah. They are coming. When they finally get to my house, I am so happy. But then I am disappointed. The pizza is always cold. Then I have to wrestle with whether I am going to tip the driver. As far as I know, the other guys suck and he's doing a great job. But who really knows what's going on over there. Why don't I just pick it up? Because I don't want to leave my house, that's why. I just call the Bay View Toppers now. It's super fast, super hot, very delicious.

Tried the veggie and pepperoni pizzas and the salad for lunch. It was taken to go so I can only…read moreComment on how yummy the food was! I can attest, their pizzas are great!

This was my first time trying Milwaukee Classic Pizza... and I definitely would go back. The pizza…read morearrived in perfect condition and the delivery person was very polite. The pizza tasted great and looked great. The garlic bread was wonderful and very filling. The cheese curds were good. I must say however, the chicken tenders were delicious and were some of the best chicken tenders I've had from a restaurant. You should check this place out.

Very good pizza. Great specials . Friendly service. I definitely recommend it. Location is kinda…read moresmall, but there are plenty of tables still available . They deliver too.

Got the Italian beef with the hot peppers on the double dough crust. Let me tell you, that was the…read moresloppiest pizza I've ever had. First slice I pulled from the pie ripped all the cheese and toppings off. Maybe this was because they put the cheese on top of the toppings? I'm not sure. Usually pizza the next day is desirable, however, I don't think these leftovers will be edible with the amount of grease that was on those tasteless little square slices. Next time I'll toss in a red Barron ‍

Love their pizza!!! It's my new favorite for sure…read more The staff were all very friendly and attentive as well. The prices are also fair.

The only think I can say is they win!! The award for the most awful pizza I have ever encountered!…read more I ordered a full works pizza and all I got was worked over. The crust...tough as grandpa's 10yr old jerky. I have never experienced anything like it in all my years. I hope that was frozen pizza, because if it was hand made.... Send the cook somewhere!! School, Italy, Chicago, New York The hospital to get their taste buds repaired. Some thing. Just don't let them make anymore pizza.