WOW! Absolutely amazing. My husband and I have been back 4 times in the past few weeks. There pizza is so good, its like we are back in Brooklyn eating classic NY pizza again. And their small plates are equally as amazing. We have tried almost all the small plates on the menu and I cannot decide which is my favorite. This is by far our favorite restaurant in the area and will keep coming back. Only wish they had a larger patio for the summer! They do get busy in the summer, but they have a very efficient way via texting to let you know when your table is ready, so you can take a nice stroll down the lake across the street! Highly recommend. read more

I always make it a priority to come to Gildas when I'm in town. It's always a great meal and the staff is super sweet and helpful. This time was probably my best experience yet. The specials were delicious and the waitress was attentive and super friendly. Definitely recommend Gildas always!!! read more

Delicious tapas style restaurant with the best wine list of any of the restaurants in the area. Lovely views of the lake, bright and airy decor with excellent and knowledgeable servers. I wouldn't recommend the pizzas (they were too dry for my liking), but the other options were delicious. I especially liked the arancini, meatballs, calamari. I do wish they had a slightly more expansive tapas menu (as opposed to just a wide range of crostini/pizza read more

Super tiny place in Skan so if there is a wait, it's worth it. Friendly atmosphere, good tapas style food & nice selection of beer. Great alternative to overpriced Mirabeau if you've dined there a few too many times during your visit. read more

Best pizza in Skaneateles, check out their special pizzas...always creative and wonderfully delicious. Small restaurant with a great wait staff, always friendly and accommodating for special requests. Highly recommended in Skaneateles area. read more

We stopped in based on YELP reviews. Had a very good Italian meal, in a very pleasant atmosphere, with beautiful location. Service was professional and prompt. A better experience than I had expected, and everyone was glad we stopped. read more

The only downside to this place is that it's too small! We had a little trouble getting a table, but the staff was so helpful. We eventually got the table outside. The food was excellent. Our waiter talked us out of getting too much food. Usually I order my own pizza, but he recommended getting a few items to share. It was perfect. We tried two different pizzas, the clams and some of the other appetizers. Great food, great service, reasonably priced. read more

We love Gilda's but can be difficult to get a table so we usually order take out. Food is excellent, service on point. All the pizzas are excellent, and the cauliflower small plate is my favorite. Worth every penny! read more

I usually love Gilda's, but I may have to rethink visiting again during the summer. The AC did not cool the restaurant and I was extremely uncomfortable. Truly sad because I usually like the treat of a ride to Skaneateles followed by dinner and drinks at Gilda's. read more

Great food, great service, nice atmosphere. Ordered a few small plates and all were excellent! Upscale but casual. Definitely recommend

Two nights in a row and this place continues to impress. Our waiter Phillip was incredible, his advice and recommendations were spot on. The Row Eleven Pinot was shocking delicious especially considering the $30 price. We had the arugula salad and white pizza with the house sausage and they were both perfect. Highly recommend this place read more

Great food! Traditional tapas with lots of interesting choices. Get table by the window and see the lake

Had dinner last night at Gilda's with friends. One of my favorite restaurants any time of the year. The menu is interesting, the food is always well prepared and delicious, the staff is hard working and always welcoming. And they have the best sangria! Only negative was the AC. It did not seem to cool down the small space, were every table and bar stool was occupied. Odd for a restaurant that otherwise pays attention to all the little details that make an enjoyable dining experience. read more

After a full day of boating the lake we parked over by the city hall and easily walked to to Gilda's. A table just opened up and the very friendly staff cleaned the table and sat us. We started with the shrimp and risotto balls. Awesome. Then had we had a margherita pizza. Awesome. The sangria was great and the local hard cider was pretty good. I would go again. read more

Gilda's - Pizza Near Me - Skaneateles, New York

See all

Been here a few times. Always an excellent meal. As the waiter to reco. You want be disappointed. Also take a walk by the late after the meal, makes for an excellent cap to an evening. read more

It was a pleasant surprise to find that this little gem had opened in Skaneateles while visiting home over the summer. Now residing on the East End of Long Island where Rose rules the world come spring, I had to try the local finger lakes Ryan William Rose they were offering. I fell in love! A very attentive manager and exceptional waitstaff. High-end feel that suits the village of Skaneateles well. Small plates and fine wine, this spot is perfect for date night or a Sunday brunch with the girls. read more

Stopped in for a late lunch; enjoyed a Finger Lakes riesling and local cider, the beet salad, meatballs, potatoes bravas, and the stuffed dates. Everything was delicious, and the bartender was attentive and helpful. I'd go back in a heart beat. read more

Stopped in to have some pizza. Was not expecting a lot. Boy was I wrong. The pizza was awesome! They also had beer and wine. I highly recommend this place for casual dining! read more

Best burger I've had in years. I've heard that the pizza is great but I keep ordering that burger..... once you find something you love, better stick with it. read more

Our waitress was great. I came with my family for dinner. The crostini were my favorite part (the white bean and caponata) and the calamari were ok- I've had better. We also tried the quinoa salad and thought it was very good. I liked the arancini- they used a risotto for the inside which made them super creamy. Overall, nice atmosphere and different foods- I would recommend it to anyone who likes trying new things. read more

Amazing arancini, arugula salad and pizza. Nice view of the lake, right on the main drag. Philip was an excellent server. Craft beer as well. Great lunch!! read more

The manager was incredible! They took such good care of us, taking care of our every need, recommending wonderful wines and delicious food. They even stayed open an hour late to accommodate some special friends from out of town. Highly recommend! read more

Fantastic pizza! Crust is to die for! Great atmosphere, super friendly staff, and for a city girl, cheeeaappp!! Loved it!!!

The best food I've had in the Northeast for casual dining. We tried everything. All the pizza, the hamburger, salt cod fritters, arancana and the salads. Every dish has highest quality ingredients and they cook 100pct from scratch (not off the truck). Eat here in person or order for take out. And enjoy. read more

I had the most exquisite dining experience here last month. I stopped in with a friend for lunch and immediately felt like I was stepping into a small cafe in the lower east side of Manhattan or even the French countryside. The decor was clean but not bare and had a slight apothecary feel. The service was genuine and timely and the food was delicious! They also boasted a great selection of Finger Lakes wine, you could tell it was hand selected! We enjoyed a glass of Hosmer Winery Dry Rose with our salad and pizza. The wine was perfect for the season and complimented the light fresh ingredients on the food delightfully! Def a must for lunch or dinner in Skaneateles! Enjoy read more

Very casual, fabulous food, and definitely not your standard pizza joint. We went on Wednesday and loved the half price wine deal too.

This is one pf my favorite spots to go to with friends. They have great small plate options and the pizza is to die for. Service is always on point also! I could eat there every day of the week :) read more

Pete is always there to please and educate in any way he can. The Owner Sam is continually coming up with new creative dishes to satisfy all! A must when visiting Skaneateles!!! read more

Gilda's - Pete one of the best hosts in town serves it up at Gilda's! Food is outstanding and a great variety to chose from and share. - Pizza Near Me - Skaneateles, New York

Charming tiny place, excellent service, great pizza. Lots of attention to detail. And the chocolate pot de creme is to die for...

Service is usually excellent considering the volume of people that come through on a daily basis. The food is always excellent no matter what you order...you really can't go wrong! The pizzas are the best around considering you're upstate...period. The restaurant's overall use of fresh ingredients is the key player in what makes everything so tasty! So if you're passing through town and looking for a bite Gildas is the move. read more

The food was great, prices reasonable the only thing that was wrong was the lack of sound proofing. It was extremely loud my group of 5 had to yell to be heard over everyone else in the resturant. The best thing about Gilda ' s is Wednesday night they offer half price bottles of wine. read more

We went to the Dickens festival and was looking for a place to eat. Most of the other restaurants were full so we tried Gilda's. The food was fantastic! it is a very small place but we were able to get a table for 2 very quickly. My only complaint was that there was too much arugula on our pizza. Will definitely go there again on our next visit read more

Food we ordered was served cold. When we asked if we could get it heated up we got bad attitude from our server. Finally received our order with very mixed reviews. Some was good other dishes(clams) were almost inedible. Would probably not give Gilda's another try. Once was enough read more

really nice ambience- low key, rustic, modern- with a very friendly, helpful staff. love that they give you a jug of water so you can refill as needed. ordered the cauliflower, patatas bravas, lamb meatballs, and funghi pizza with added tomato sauce. The cauliflower was probably my favorite dish. the lemon/butter/garlic marinade is absolutely delicious. the cauliflower probably could have been roasted/sauteed for a few min longer as it was hard to cut but served its purpose well in delivering maximum marinade to my mouth. the white sauce (garlic aioli?) on the patatas bravas was also delicious, as were the fried potatoes (shocker). the veal meatballs were definitely my least favorite dish as they didn't really taste like anything (really thought i was eating tofu at one point). the tomato sauce was also bland (maybe the tomatoes weren't ripe/sweet enough?), but i appreciated that it wasn't over-salted. The sliced bread though was soft and chewy and served me well in sopping up more of the cauliflower marinade. the pizza was....ok. the dough was perfect- like seriously one of the most perfect crusts, but the pizza itself was also a little flavorless. I can't imagine that gilda's isn't using quality cheese and ingredients, but the topping just didn't do the crust justice. overall, would recommend the cauliflower and a non-tomato sauce pizza. despite the hits/misses, would totally return to gilda's try the risotto balls, calamari and a non-tomato based pizza read more

Adorable place with fresh, delicious food. Try the pizza dough sandwiches - like a crispy, thin-crusted calzone! Everything prepared fresh and tastes great. Plenty of vegetarian options in appetizers and mains. Good but small beer and wine list. read more

Google "Pizza recipes". I was pretty surprised that their pizza is actually called pizza. Pizza requires things like...sauce....and cheese. This is bread with a tiny bit of sauce and a tiny bit of cheese. The other apps are okay I suppose. read more

Great light dinner at the bar. Cozy but trendy atmosphere. Friendly service. Good wine and delicious calamari and brussel sprouts. Appreciated the option of great food, but able to not eat too much. read more

This place was amazing. This must be a "must stop at" restaurant. Everything was amazing, from the food to the staff. We will definition be back. Maybe even tomorrow.! read more

The wine list is good, but don't order the Margarita Pizza. It had salty, sour, sauce and very little cheese. My friend had a small, OK, meatball sandwich. Pricey for mediocre food. read more

Cute spot, delicious food, and great service! We split a salad and the Brussels sprouts and fennel pizza... Everything was great! Will be back here for sure! read more