Peeps..Peeps! After receiving a recommendation from an Italian friend who owns a winery in the beautiful Shenandoah Valley, I had to try this place. What provoked his recommendation was my complaint that, since COVID I haven't been able to find any old family style restaurants that serve creamy polenta and a great Bolognese.. and without hesitation he said, "Giannini's in Pine Grove!" So, the next night I was there.
Walking through the door into this softly lit old nostalgic Italian diner almost floored me. Now this is what a family style old school Italian restaurant should look like! The only item missing was Pacino sitting in the corner table. The staff was so pleasant as they sat me down at that "corner table"!
On this occasion I ordered the baked ribeye (nightly special main course), but I could see on the menu that it included a polenta (creamy) appetizer with a beautifully soft rustic bread. I had brought my own wine (Barbera from Cooper Vineyards) corkage fee included (typical), which would pair nicely with the polenta that was accompanied by a great (smooth low acidic) bolognese. The polenta was like my mom used to make it, not too spicy yet creamy and... with the Bolognese and wine I was in another universe and for me I could have walked out of the restaurant totally pleased...but...I wasn't finished yet...So then came the "chilled" dinner salad with various Italian style veggies along with the only dressing fit for and "old school Italian", wine vinegar and oil, what else? Pretty satisfied at that point! But....as I finished the salad and looked up there was the sweet waitress standing there in front of me with a bowl of minestrone soup, which I needed to make room for in my already full and happy stomach. I've been to a lot of Italian restaurants over the years and this soup was perfection which included zucchini, carrots, celery, potatoes, small portion of tomatoes and spices with a wonderful stock. After couple of sips of wine, I proceeded to dip my airy Italian bread in the soup, OMG. I could have left the restaurant at that point totally satisfied, but the best was yet to come (except for the polenta) and that was the special which was a baked ribeye in an au Jus (perfectly seasoned) with peas and onions. The ribeye was tender and cut fairly thin, which I appreciated. At that point I was so so full I had to box the remainder of the ribeye with the last of my sliced bread since there was no room remaining in my contented stomach for coffee and dessert.
Ok, Happy yes! I had just stepped into the 1940s, 50s, 60s, and 70s and in a world today of too much complexity, I found the simplicity I was looking for in a great old style Italian restaurant that is located 1 hour from where I live. Thank you to my Italian friend for directing me to this traditional and "handed down" family restaurant. read more