The flavor of the pizza was good, but the crust honestly reminded me of a cardboard insert from a frozen pizza... there was also so much cheese that every bite the toppings would come off. The breadsticks weren't bad. They were really big but a bit doughy. Needed cooked longer. The staff was friendly and the food came out quick though. read more

Frosty Bar - Pizza Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

This is a long standing local operation, and it's a breakfast/pizza/bar all in one. We came for breakfast, which was a nice and peaceful vibe, which was greatly needed after an evening of island shenanigans. Food was great/ I loved the health nut plate, especially the chia pudding. My gals enjoyed the eggs Bennie, and the other said the gravy on her biscuits was the best she's ever had! My liver would not permit any breakfast cocktails, but my friend really liked the frostini! Our servers were all great. read more

See all

We were at Put-in-Bay before the busy season and I think this was the only place open for breakfast. The waitress was very sweet and they had enough options for breakfast, but they weren't able to accommodate my request for egg whites. That's fine but the toast was a little burnt too , so I didn't have the best breakfast. My friend enjoyed his breakfast so all was fine. Next time I'll come when the island has more restaurants open for breakfast. read more

Frosty Bar - Biscuits and gravy - Pizza Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

See all

Frostys has been a tradition. I'm from Ottawa county so it's an institution. It used to be the affordable place with terrible pizza that soaked up the days alcohol. Today we went and ordered 1 Busch lite and a Mom water and they told me $18.70. I am used to island pricing but that is ridiculous. I asked the bartender the cost of each drink which totaled about $15 I said so where's that total come from and he said I don't know tax. This isn't the 1st time. Ive been over charged here by the staff. Busch fooking light man! Come on! The novelty can only take you so far. read more

Frosty Bar - $19 for those. Fostys used to be traditional. I think we'll pass from now on. F that. - Pizza Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

Bacon egg and cheese on croissant was delicious! Thankfully they served breakfast cause on Monday and Tuesdays , nothing else was open for indoor dining at 8am read more

See all

The High on the Hog BBQ was the bomb!! Service was excellent and she checked on us from time to time! The atmosphere was great music, tv's and just great people! read more

If you go to Put in Bay, you have to have Frosty's Pizza, it's like always on the list of things to do. We had a 12" deluxe pizza and three of us shared and still had slices left. I wished the veggies were a little more cooked but didn't stop me from eating it! I also ordered the chips w/queso and salsa. It was good but may or may not get it again. One of our group ordered the Mambo Nachos, or named something like that, and that would have fed our whole table of 5 by itself. Ambiance is always fun and upbeat with a great variety of music. I want to go back for more! read more

Frosty Bar - 12" deluxe pizza, nachos - Pizza Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

See all

What an all around disaster of a restaurant. We asked to split the bill before we ordered and the server said yes. The food was bland and tasted microwaved. After we ate, the server messed up splitting the bill 3 times. 3 times.... And while we tried to get it fixed, she was extremely rude to us and seemed like she did not care at all. While talking to the manager, the manager was rude and condescending towards us and treated us like 5 year olds. The manager also berated customers for not having online payment to Venmo the now (NOT SPLIT) bill. For a group of people who all work in customer service, we were forced to make amends for the mistakes they made. There is no plus side to this restaurant unless you have a want to be yelled at and looked down upon. :( read more

Frosty's bar has been a favorite of my family's. It had delicious food, the pizza was delightful, and breakfast was very good as always. The outdoor seating was very enjoyable to eat dinner at. The servers were kind as well and very accommodating. read more

Service was fast. The food was terrible, asked if they could make a change to a sandwich that I asked to be heated (they assured they could) served it cold. I asked if they could replace the sandwich. Cara the manager denied it. Besides the minor misunderstanding, she was extremely rude and disrespectful, could've handled the situation professionally. My association provides annual business trips to frostys, never experienced this kind of unprofessionalism especially from a manager. read more

Frosty Bar - Manager Cara feels texting is more important than servicing her customers waiting in line. She doesn't care about the customer at all. - Pizza Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

Only place open for breakfast today. Casual place to pop into. Service was great. Super friendly and fast. I ordered Eggs Benedict which were good but not great. The Canadian Bacon was over cooked and the hash browns had a funny flavor from the oil they were cooked in. I had to use a lot of Southern gravy (ketchup) to make them palatable. I would come back. Bit next time to try pancakes or French toast. read more

Between the dj and the pizza this place is a winner! We were just looking for some quick food before we started in at the bars... this had both! Was defiantly a good time.. had a dance floor, dj, food and drinks. Definitely had something for everyone. Was a great place to start our night! read more

Frosty Bar - a neon sign on a table - Pizza Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

See all

We had breakfast there two mornings. Great food and service each time. Love seeing diverse young adults working hard.

The pizza here is amazing. We were struggling to find a place for lunch for a large business meeting and with the island winding down for the season Frosty's came through. We got 12 pizzas and every pizza looked amazing. It is on the pricy side but the quality of the ingredients I think your getting what you pay for here. read more

Great breakfast . The green chili salsa is a must add - so flavorful with a kick . Service was friendly and prompt and portions generous . The breakfast sandwich and home fries were so good my mouth is watering just thinking about it . Will definitely go back next time we visit PIB read more

Frosty Bar - Breakfast sandwich and home fries ( extra bacon on the side) - Pizza Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

See all

Pizza and service was great. The place wasn't busy so we We sat outside which I wouldn't do again because of the bees. Not the restaurants fault just a tip if you eat there read more

Frosty Bar - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

Ice cold beers in frosty glasses and the best pizza around!!! When we come to PIB it's a must stop every time.

Such a great place. Great food, SUPER cold beer, great music. Definitely more casual than other places in the area. One of the most fun places to eat, drink and be merry! read more

Although visited put in bay in the off season, we still enjoyed a great meal at frostys bar. My wife got the gluten free pizza which was amazing with a cauliflower crust and I got the standard pepperoni thin crust. Everything tasted great! Highly recommend trying this based on the pizza alone. The service was kind of slow there were only about two other tables and we were seated outside in the bar area. We visited during the off season so they were out of a lot of beverage options especially on draft. Would eat here again based on food. Definitely worth your time to try for great pizza. read more

See all

Stopped in for breakfast two days in a row and they are Awesome!!! Fast friendly service and staff. Everyone pitches in and helps each other to make it a success! Very impressive and our waitress Brenna was personable and professional with great hustle. I will come back again for sure. The quality of food is also very good, just like home! read more

Frosty Bar - Brenna servin it up! - Pizza Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

Best pizza on the island, gotta get some every time I'm here. Service is awesome and fast!!!great little place!!

We came to Frostys for breakfast. Being on the island during the week doesn't offer many breakfast choices. We were not disappointed. My husband ordered a traditional eggs Benedict and I got the country Benedict. My Benedict had a sausage patty on a biscuit with an over easy egg and covered with sausage gravy. The gravy was homemade and legit!! I am picky about my sausage gravy. The hash Browns were nice and crispy (the only way to be) we also tried their homemade hot sauce which was like a salsa verde, it was delicious! We ended up putting it on everything. Service was quick and friendly. Definitely will be back (probably this week!) read more

See all

The Mexican food here is the worse I have ever had. Who knew you could completely mess up tacos. They looked amazing but had absolutely no flavor read more

The good: service was timely and polite, our server was great with bringing food, drinks, and table water fast. The bad: The food was terrible. Our table ordered the chicken wrap and a 12" Buffalo chicken pizza; the wrap was slimy and poorly made. The pizza was smothered in onions, featured chicken and crust that was very burnt, and for a disturbing price of $30. Look elsewhere in PIB for a better lunch/dinner experience. read more

Great service but the pizza were not good -- slimey, undercooked. Expect $$$. 3 small pizzas and and a side $100 (soft drinks, not alcohol). I also edited this review, and I'm taking off an additional point, because they have written at the bottom of each receipt... "For the mathematically challenged " and suggested tips. If you insult your clients, they might leave you 2 star ratings. read more

The food was void of any flavor. The ham and eggs were overdone. We ordered a biscuits and gravy to share and I'm not kidding the gravy was cold. We sent it back and it came back still not very warm. The server said they'd remake it but it seemed like they just put it in the microwave. My food was barely room temperature and there was almost no hollandaise sauce at all. Overall not a great meal. Other tables around us were also talking amongst themselves about how unimpressed they were with their meals. read more

Frosty Bar - eggs benedict - Pizza Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

I just cannot say enough about the pizza! Awesome! Only bad thing is I don't live closer to order it all the time! Server was very friendly and on point! Can't wait to go back to PIB for more pizza! read more

Frosty Bar - Pizza Near Me - Put In Bay, Ohio

My first time at Put-in-Bay over the age of 21 and I was told Frosty Bar was the place to go. Sadly, I was told very wrong. All of their food is overpriced. Buffalo Chicken Ranch Pizza sucked so bad I would rather go through ACL reconstruction a third time than eat it again. Drinks are reasonable and service was good. I'd probably spend my money anywhere else, though. read more

I am not one to complain about food but the Frosty mug in put-in-bay Ohio had gave me watered down liquor first of all which I will show the photos of the drink was supposed to be a 7&7. Then the boneless wings where soggy and tasted like turkey and the pizza was hard and chewy would give the Frosty mug a negative score if I could! read more

See all

$3.99 for a glass of milk + very lazy wait staff. Could not even be bothered to ice my drink but managed to get the next table some ice on theirs. Never going back there again! Very over priced and low quality of food and poor service! read more

Walked in and asked for a rum punch. Bartender poured it out of a tap(wtf?). Orange juice was immediately identified as sour; returned it and got a supposedly "double Bacardi and coke". Next order was same, and the bartender served me a drink that was 90% coke syrup. Absolute GARBAGE drinks here. They might be able to fool a bunch of drunk marines and bachelorette parties, but this place sucks big time in the drink department. read more

The Drinks Were Good But Food Left A lot to be Desired. Friendly staff but probably wouldn't come here again

Seriously not sure who else is reviewing this place with anything above 1 star! I wish zero stars was possible! Lets start with the appetizer: stale chips, tomato and onion salsa, orange queso (WTF!), and some bean crap that had to be poured straight out of a jar! Oh and you have to pick that up yourself because the waitresses don't deliver anything?? What the Hell is their job then? Then came the pizza, well I had to pick that up too, they don't deliver that either! We ordered the supreme and we got a supreme piece of crap. I swear it was a frozen Jack's pizza with extra crap put on top! Garbage! Don't be confused by the picture with missing slices, there was 4 of us and we all grabbed a slice but none of us had a second! Absolutely terrible! Only bright spot??? The beer was cold. read more

See all

NEVER GO TO FROSTYS!!! This is the worst, most disrespectful establishment that I have set foot in for a good few years. Bad food, bad prices, bad people. Nothing of interest for anybody of any age. I am disgusted to know this place exists and people like the employees behind the bar wake up everyday and go to work for this sorry excuse of a bar. I am a 21 year old who went to put-in bay for fall break with my friends expecting to have a relaxing vacation, and we were treated disrespectfully and were victims of harsh agism by both the employees and management of frostys. My friends bought 2 pizzas and were not told the prices before and were then charged $61. That is unacceptable . Not to mention the fact that I had to show the bartender 3+ forms of identification to get a pint of Miller lite, even after I answered his punitive questions regarding my identification. IF I COULD GIVE THIS PLACE 0 stars I would do it. Not only were we victims of discrimination due to our age, but we were overcharged, stared at, intimidated, and the servers were relectuant to serve us. NEVER GO TO FROSTYS! read more

Came for breakfast on a rainy Friday morning, place was packed, tourists escaping the rain. Ordered blueberry pancakes. I have never seen fork tines bounce off the surface of a pancake. Tough and rubbery. Was going to leave one star but earned a second when waitress took pancakes off the check. Flag code violation, bar flying American and Canadian flag on the same halyard. read more

We came here with a big group of ladies for a bachelorette party. The waitress was rude and kept forgetting things. She messed up a couple of the orders multiple times. I ordered the macho nachos and they were stale! When I mentioned it to the waitress she didn't offer to take them off the bill. I told her I wasn't paying for them (didn't even eat them they were so disgusting). She rolled her eyes!!! Worst service ever. Also, the AC unit was dripping condensation all over our food and drinks the whole time. Yuck. I'll never recommend this place! read more

Their breakfast is awesome. I had the Eggs Benedict and it came out incredibly good. They were however packed tighter than sardines with people. Yet despite how busy they were, they got us our food in like 10 minutes. Very impressive really. read more

We just got pizza and salad. It was good but not great for the price of $32.00. There was really nothing special about the pizza that stood out to us. They did have several TVs which was great cuz we wanted to keep tabs on a few of the football games. read more

Frosty's pizza is the 8 you bring home from the bar and find out later she is a 5. Definatley a market for this in society (especially on an island), but best enjoyed intoxicated. Upscale frozen pizza, and very salty. Drink up amigos! read more

Among the best stops on Put-in-Bay. Three spaces: -- Sit-down restaurant (order your food up front) -- Indoor bar area -- Backyard patio (weather permitting read more