I stopped at Thirsty Pony in Sandusky over winter break with my daughter and nephew, and overall it was such a fun experience for the kids. The atmosphere was lively and family-friendly, and they had a blast while we were there. It's definitely a spot that keeps kids entertained and makes it a little easier to relax as a parent. What truly stood out was the staff's integrity and kindness. I accidentally left my credit card there, and not only did they go out of their way to mail it back to me, they included a cute little Thirsty Pony drink coozie in the envelope. That was such an unexpected and thoughtful touch. Customer service like that really matters. The atmosphere and the way they handled my mistake absolutely left a positive impression. Thank you to the team for going above and beyond -- that kindness did not go unnoticed! read more

Thirsty Pony - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

We're staying at the Holiday next door and came in for a late dinner after a fun-filled day at Cedar Point so pretty hungry and super thirsty. We didn't get any menus when first sat down so our server was scrambling a bit since the host kind of left us hanging. Our server was really great at keeping our cups full and putting in our order quickly. The food came out pretty fast which was really surprising but tasted pretty subpar. You really should come here for the vibes which were fun and lively! There's also a bowling alley, axe throwing, laser tag, at least 3 different sports bars/betting, arcade, AND a food truck outside with yard games. I ordered the cluck cluck burger which has bacon and an egg. The burger patty was pretty dry but it was saved by the egg. It comes on a pretzel bun which I loved! My nephew ordered a ton of apps instead of an entree and got the giant pretzel (cheese came out pretty dry with a hard top), onion rings, and the cheesesteak fries. He liked the fries the best, onion rings were good, but the pretzel was cold. My husband got chicken wings naked with three or so sauces on the side which weren't very good so I'd suggest getting them normally breaded. He also ordered a burger with sweet potatoes fries that were pretty good but his patty was also dry. read more

See all

Service was friendly & great this weekend. Unfortunately my food was cold (chicken chunks). I mean not even edible..or I would've attempted to eat it rather than complaining to the server. They "remade" my food and it was still cold, and this time drowning in sauce. It was completely inedible so I just didn't eat as I was so disappointed by this point. Everyone else in our party seemed to have more luck than myself! read more

Whatever you do, don't use the men's room. Good food tho espaecially the cream soda. It was amazing read more

Not the best service but great little spot close to cedar point, food is good, bathroom is hilarious! read more

See all

Being this place is right at the entrance to the Cedar Point causeway, you can imagine that it gets busy. I came on a Friday around 2:45 pm. I ordered the bourbon burger and fries. The food took approximately 15 min. That seemed to me quiet fast considering how busy they were. Now the downside, if you are looking for a relaxing environment this is not for you. Being multiple baseball teams it was noisy to say the least with each table trying to over talk the next. This is in no way a strike against this business. Just merely a heads up to a potential customer that it gets loud. Summary = food was good and the burger was a hand patty with fresh toppings. The service was polite and attentive. The environment is busy and with plenty of entertainment from betting on horses to corn hole to a large connect 4. Bring the family and friends and enjoy yourself. read more

See all

Everything tasted like it came from the same deep fryer--seriously, it was like the entire menu was just one giant vat of frying oil. I was not a fan. Our waitress started off slow, and then it got worse. We sat around for 25 minutes just waiting for her to check on us or even ask if we wanted the check. By that point, we had already spent an hour and a half in this culinary time warp. I finally had to get up and hunt down the waitress just to get the bill! It seemed like there were only two waitresses trying to juggle 30 tables, which explained the snail-paced service. They were out of a few Oktoberfest items, which was a bummer, but we made do. The mozzarella sticks came with cold marinara--like, who thought that was a good idea? I've never seen that before in my life! The bang bang shrimp had some shell fragments in it, which was a real letdown. Oh, and they were also out of spinach and artichoke dip, so we had to skip that too. The place felt more like a bar with a menu that was all over the place. You could buy novelty shirts, play games, and even bet on sports, which is kind of random for a dining experience. It was a rainy Sunday night, so maybe that added to the chaos. All I know is, next time we're in town, this place will not be on our list! read more

See all

Shocked by our experience in this restaurant today. Got the apps in 20 mins, and then waited a good hour patiently for the entrees which did not arrive. The waitress never bothered to check or stop by our table once, and when I finally asked for her came by in a few mins with the food - absolutely unapologetic and was rude. The manager topped this by stating food takes time to cook and suggested we can leave and not pay. Later, further the reading the reviews, I see I'm not the first person to have such experience. Just downright racism.. nothing else seems to explain this. read more

Visiting Cedar Point so this establishment was recommended by the hotel staff where I was staying. Great, because it was within walking distance. Came here 3 times, only 1/3 times received friendly and nice service. Was a bartender on the younger side, blonde I think her name was Ashley? I apologize if I got it wrong. Other 2 times, grumpy older women who didn't smile, return your hello, and just looked like they hated life and didn't want to be there. Ordering from those 2 took forever as I just sat waiting to order while they socialized with apparent regulars or friends. Beer was good, but way over priced (paying $11-12 for a seasonal brew is asinine!) Food was decent, nothing to write home about except for the ribs which were great. All in all, would not recommend this place unless you want over priced beer and old grumpy middle aged women scowling at you your entire time there. read more

Had a large hungry group fresh out of Cedar Point. Despite the size of our group, the hostess was very accomodating and got us seating quickly. Atmosphere was fun, the kids had a good time and the grown ups the same. Service was a bit slow but not too bad. When it comes to the food: Do NOT order the pizza. It was bad, which is pretty crazy because it's hard to mess up pizza... but they did. It had a plastic taste. None of the kids liked it and the adults confirmed. Even though the price was right, the taste was horribly wrong. The sides of corn on the cob that came with our sandwiches were also pretty sub-par. The corn had that textured like it'd been boiling for far too long. It was more like mush on the cob. As for everything else - chicken sandwiches, smash burgers, philly cheese steak, mac and cheese - these were all good and everyone enjoyed them. Had the pizza and corn been better, I would have kicked this up a star. read more

As one of the few local places open on July 4, things were super busy. Everyone was having a great time and they seated our party of two within 10 minutes of arriving without a reservation or call-ahead. The food was really delicious and serving sizes were generous. I visited in the winter before and found the summer vibe much more enjoyable. The two things that kept it at were the menu prices and an appetizer that came after the meals. It was provided at no cost, though, which is helpful and appreciated! read more

Disgusted with the service at this restaurant today! The waitress comes by juggling three cups of water with the plates tucked under her armpit !! Never experienced such a thing before. She was wearing a sleeveless shirt by the way :$ . We stayed away from the plates... but still feeling so yuck, read more

It's a vibe. Friendly staff and we also stop through when in the area because the kids love it. Food is consistently great.

Always a fun spot with good food .. Something for everyone .. Great atmosphere and good shot to grab a drink after a long day at the park... Service is always on point read more

Don't bother if you want mediocre food as well as slow service. Party of 5, children and no alcohol. Drinks came out pretty quickly but took forever to get our orders. Sweet potato fries were cold we sent them back and they came back soon but you know they just re-dipped them in the hot oil... Slaw was just like wet cabbage no flavor and couldn't eat it.. Best thing on the plate was the deep-fried dill pickle spear and the dipping sauce for the sweet potato fries. Bun on my burger was hard, and I couldn't eat it. Was really looking forward to this excursion but left really disappointed. read more

Thirsty Pony - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

See all

Pizza was good however it wasnt ready in the 40 minutes they said it would be. On Saturday we called to place a carry out order and I was told that they dont do carry out from 6-9 then was hung up on! Unless you want to go into Sandusky there really isnt much to choose from close to Cedar Point. Such a shame becuase with the right staff this place could be a gold mine. read more

Love this place so much!!!! Excellent place to stop for dinner after a long day at Cedar Point. Here's all of the great reasons why I will continue to come back here when I am in town: - Awesome staff, very attentive and enthusiastic - Easy parking lot - Really good drinks and they're not overpriced - Great food menu - Lots of TVs (watch your games here!) - Gambling and tons of arcade games, bring the kids! - Lively crowd of both locals and park goers If you like a lively bar with good food and drinks, you should definitely stop here. Much better than eating at the park or fast food places nearby! read more

Thirsty Pony - House salad with chicken is a big one! - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

Love the Thirsty Pony! My husband and I like to go at least once when we are in Sandusky, if not twice! The kick'in chicken dip (buffalo chicken dip) is delicious!!! Never disappoints! Their Philly cheesesteak fries are also incredible! I also recommend their chicken, it is super crispy! Their Cajun dry rub and garlic Parmesan are tasty. They taste like they are made in house but I am not sure. Their cocktails are always good and strong! The service is always good and they are quick to help out! The environment is so fun and their are televisions everywhere! You can watch horse races and sports. You also can bet on horse races! Highly recommend this place and while you wait their are games to play outside. PS: this place connects to the bowling alley and laser tag! read more

See all

they only have one type of soup! I hate it and the only thing I like there is the onion rings. Never come here in Sandusky Ohio read more

If I could give a 6 star review I would. The service was awesome for my birthday and gave me and my sister a free root beer float. The wings had so much sauce that made them even better. Also, before our meal our waitress gave us a free appetizer. Overall a great experience. Recommend. read more

This place was soooooo good! Get the snapper sandwich it was the hit of the table.l and the portion was huge! Even the kiddos enjoyed their meals. Although it was a bar we didn't feel out of place with our 2 young boys ages 8/10. The bartender doubled as our server on the floor and he was efficient attentive and had great suggestions. read more

We stopped at this place after a night at Cedar Point. They have great daily and happy hour specials. It's good bar food. We just got a bunch of appetizers and they hit the spot. The pretzel and nachos were great. There's plenty of televisions for games. And there's a bowing alley and laser tag attached to the place. read more

See all

Is a COMPLETE tourist trap. Beers are Cedar point prices. Burgers are over cooked. Plates the kid dishes come out on are burned. Save yourself the money. We were so curious to stop here on our way to CP and will never again. read more

We visited here from Dayton because it mentioned Frickers. We were taken to a table and it was dirty, the floor had something very sticky on it. I was shocked at how high the prices were. 20 bucks and you got like a 9 inch pizza.. Some of it they give you big potions but they didn't taste all that great. They are much higher than Frickers and Roosters but they both beat this place hands down. It was a first time visit and that's fine but it's majorly overrated I think. read more

Luke warm beer. Soggy pizza. Bartender brought in her 5 kids running around. To go pizza box covered in some mysterious substance....

Went here for lunch on Saturday June 21,2025 with a group of 30 plus as a little league tournament was going on this weekend. We were basically told they didn't want to do our order because they were short staffed with 2 waitress's .The waitress's and manager were rude and really seemed not to care, so we left and went to Old Dutch Tavern and were welcomed with open arms. They only had 2 waitress's but they Got "R" Done and were rewarded handsomely. By the way the bill was almost $1000.00 Thirst Pony needs a lesson in customer service and the Manager should be reprimanded. I would not recommend this establishment. read more

Guess the food prices have shrunk the food portions. They had a good deal on Brunch items. But, the portions are smaller. I had a chicken fried steak with potatoes. It was reasonably priced. Service was decent. The whole complex is an all in one entertainment center with a casino, a lodge, a restaurant, and sports watching. Good place to spend a few hours on the weekend. read more

Came here twice while here for a baseball tournament. Only con is that they aren't prepared to accommodate large groups so most of the team left and went somewhere that could. At my table, there was pizza, wings and a salad. The waitress was fantastic, friendly and honest about the menu. All of our food was cooked to order, fresh and tasted good. The drinks were cold and there were plenty of options for both the kids and adults. read more

This place is so much fun with great staff and a fun decor. The food is absolutely delicious bar food and they offer some healthy options as well but we didn't come there for healthy options that night! My one friend is a vegetarian and loved the fried pickles and some other appetizers. I have to admit that they were some of the best fried pickles ever and their onion rings rock! My other friend ordered the Philly cheese steak fries and if I go there again (I live an hour away and was visiting cedar point) I would totally order them. The portions are generous. Everything came out warm and cooked the right way. Their drink menu is also extensive. The place was open late and POPPING. read more

Small menu but the food was so good. Located right at the entrance to Cedar Point. We sat outside and there was a nice breeze. The service was very good. I ordered the frickin' chicken sandwich with honey garlic sauce. The pasta salad that comes as a side was awesome. My husband ordered wings with garlic parm and fries, and the kids got pulled pork and the kids chicken tenders. We also had the mountain of cheese sticks (there's 9 in an order), and the artichoke spinach dip We are all stuffed and uncomfortably full. Would definitely recommend. Almost forgot - the sandwiches came with a fried pickle!! read more

Thirsty Pony - Spinach artichoke dip with red, white and blue chips - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

See all

Pretty good restaurant, food was tasty. Establishment is connected to a sports book, a Hotel and a bowling alley. TVs everywhere, Keno, Lotto as well as sports , horse racing on all large screen TVs. Very busy , Very loud place. In town for tournament so place was packed. Tons of beers, and special margaritas. Service is pretty quick, staff is pleasant. Pricing is fair. Check it out. Typical American fused bar food with some twists....located a stones throw from Cedar Pointe. We went back the second night to try something different. It was located conveniently next to our hotel. read more

See all

Beyond amazing. Service was fast and friendly. A ton of options from wings to pizza to an amazing chicken parm sandwich with real slices of garlic in the sauce! Portions are huge. Flavors are from bright and savory to spicy and sweet. And our drinks!!! We ordered cocktails and the mix was on point. We are picky with our mixed drink prep and these definitely hit the mark. We will be back to try more! read more

See all

Relaxed, casual atmosphere. You beep an old fashioned horn to get the attention of a host when you come in. Service was good, food was just average. Perfectly edible but nothing special. read more

Server was fine. Beer was cold, so was the food. Very slow service and the food came out one at a time over 20 minutes. They should maybe think about renaming the place to the Hungry Pony because I sure am hungry after leaving! read more

Thirsty Pony - Chili Cheese Burger - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

I had high hopes for the Thirsty Pony, but unfortunately the food missed the mark for the most part. This rating is solely based on our food experience. Here is what my family of 4 had: - cheese stick stack appetizer (good) - southwest egg roll appetizer (good) - sauerkraut balls appetizer (it was like a Reuben ball with sausage in it instead of corned beef. It was just alright) - Buffalo chicken dip (didn't care for this. Was too sweet and tasted weird) - I had the mango jalapeño wings. (These were delicious but quite spicy. Definitely made me tear up a little) - lobster bisque in a bread bowl (this was my least favorite thing out of the whole meal. It was this fake orange color and just did not taste good.) - my husband and stepsons all had different burgers and none of them cared for them I do like the feel of the bar and I'm sure it is a great place to go to drink, bet on horse races through their simulcast area, and/or play lottery. Unfortunately, due to an upcoming surgery, I was not able to try any of their many signature cocktails. There is also bowling and axe throwing at this location. read more

See all

This was the closest restaurant to Cedar Point. Obviously we were exhausted, it was hotter than hell out in the sun all day waiting hours in line for everything, the kids were very agitated, and we were all starving! The service was good considering they were extremely busy. Every table was seated but the wait staff did an excellent job getting our order, drinks, food, and bill to us quickly. We were also seated within 5-10 mins. I must say, the staff was AWESOME. For being a little short staffed, they worked as a team efficiently to take care of all the customers not just their own. We ordered wings that were excellent. (SO HOT FRESH AND DELICIOUS!!) They were exactly like Hooters wings back in the day. (The whole vibe actuality mirrors Hooters minus the ratchet girls showing their goods. I'm not trying to see all that with my kids when I'm eating but love the food.) Fried pickles were good, too. It was our first time eating them. We both got burgers that were delicious. Cooked perfectly. Kids got tenders, fries, and Mac and cheese. Everything was fresh not frozen. The ranch is not out of a bottle lol! Drinks were also strong. It's a neighborhood sports bar vibe with all wooden tables chairs etc. Very inviting and comfortable. When I come back I'll be coming here every time!! read more

Thirsty Pony - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio

Great food and atmosphere . The Perch Sandwich is amazing & memorable . The burnt ends appetizer and Large pretzel were wonderful too read more

See all

This was probably the most uncomfortable I've felt going to an establishment. I went here with my girlfriend trying to order some food to go, and was told to go to the bar. We sat there just talking to each other but it became more evident that the bartender would not come up to us. We sat there patiently for about 30 minutes until the bartender came up to us and finally asked what we needed. She came off as really rude and dismissive of us. She then left us again for an extended period of time tending to every other customer with a big smile but us. She never checked up on during the whole time we were there. We ended up leaving never being able to order food even though our money was just as good as everyone else's. I get it, some people may be preoccupied with other things but that doesn't mean we should've been ignored and felt like we didn't belong there. I don't know if it was racism or if it was because we were young or maybe both but I never felt more unwelcome in an establishment. read more

Ok, ambiance might be fun and there's plenty of TVs if you're wanting to watch a game. But if you're hungry, maybe choose some place else? We got wings and kids meals. I even told our server we were really unhappy with our meals and she just said, "cash or card?" Well, alrighty then. Anyway, $60 later, I would not recommend. read more

Service was bad. Sat for 15 minutes and watched customers get served while nobody acknowledged us. Had to flag someone down while they all chatted back. Not to mention, someone's brat kids were throwing trash around the restaurant. Oh, and also, it was the worst steak I've ever had. Wasn't cooked medium rare at all. The seasoning made no sense on it. It was like all bitter pepper. Try any other bar or restaurant around here. We won't be coming back ever. read more

Thirsty Pony - Steak ordered "medium rare" - Pizza Near Me - Sandusky, Ohio