If you are considering visiting Pasquales....definitely DO! We popped in yesterday for breakfast and were so glad that we did. From the minute we walked in, throughout the entire meal, we felt valued as customers. We were warmly greeted, even though they were very, very busy. Our server, Keegan, was a delight. He was engaging, attentive and really understood the meaning of customer service. Both meals we ordered were delicious and cooked perfectly. All the other meals passing by that we didn't chose also looked great! Every employee here was smiling, friendly and a perfect example of what we should all expect from service at a restaurant. We will definitely be back! read more

Great street presence. Entered from rear a bit confusing. Great fresh fruit and blueberry pancake! read more

Pasquales - Art - Italian Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

See all

I enjoyed the food. The ambiance of the restaurant and the customer service, even on a busy day, was pretty good. read more

Pasquales - Italian Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

Absolutely delicious lobster omelette special! This place has a beautiful view of the water and great service. I would definitely recommend it to anyone visiting PIB! read more

Pasquales - Lobster omelette with hash browns and toast - Italian Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

See all

Amazing food, Amazing service, we had breakfast but would definitely come back for lunch

The friendly hostess, the attentive and friendly servers. The coffee was great, the food was amazing and it was so good that we went back the next day for breakfast again. read more

We love love love this place!! It's always a solid experience with friendly people, delicious food, great atmosphere. We only wish they were open on Tuesday. But worth the wait! read more

See all

Yelp shows this place as not being open on Tuesday- much to our surprise, it was. And so, glad they were open. Great place for breakfast across from the park and we could still see the water. Waitress was friendly and helpful, the food was very good and the coffee was hot! Nice place and would highly recommend. read more

Very quick, cheap, and filling. They sit you very quickly, have your food at your table fast, and the food is both delicious and reasonably priced. I stayed for three days and went each morning. It has a nice ambiance and the servers are kind and informative. read more

The food was delicious, but had the most incredibly rude food runner. I ordered the hot mess and you get to choose if you want biscuits or toast with it. Someone else at my table ordered it with toast. When she brought out two with toast, I told her I ordered biscuits. She set it down in front of me and walked away-nothing else was said. A couple minutes pass and I told the hostess who walked by. She said "well I'm sure she's getting your biscuits" and walked away. Our waitress came eventually and I told her and she quickly brought them out but the rest of the food was cold. A man at the table next to us had the EXACT same problem but never got the biscuits. I used to always recommend this place to everyone, but something needs to be done about the staff. read more

Don't go by the hours posted here or on their website. So it was my birthday. We came to put n bay since Cancun was out of my reach. I researched everything from masks to opening/closing to make sure we would be able to do 1 of my fav things. Eat good food, not junk. We were here for 5 days and despite what their website said they were not open 3 of 5 days. I wanted to take a star away for this cause it's my birthday and Im allowed to be selfish 1 time of year. This was it. Covid days so what can you do? Its a 4 star island spot. When its open Made it for 1 breakfast. Small spot so you wait for table outside maybe 15 minutes. It's worth it. Very good breakfast. Wish I could have got it on my birthday like planned. OK I'm over it. Almost. Pancakes sausage, omelet has browns for him. They don't advertise it much but they do have mimosas. They came premixed, not like prior folks pics. Mimosas were OK. Nothing like Frosty next door. Go there for absolutely fab brunch drinks. Service was slow(june) but as I understand they were short staffed. We both came with our patience. I would recommend calling prior to booking the island to know what's open since obviously things are changing daily due to Covid 19 and this spot does not update their website frequently read more

Pasquales - Western omelet hashbrowns - Italian Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

See all

Great breakfast spot. All food items were excellent. French toast one day. Sausage biscuits with gravy the next.

Great breakfast! Great espresso cocktail! Only complaint, don't expect any tweaks. Asked for well done hash browns, they were not near that. read more

Pasquales - Lobster Benedict - Italian Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

See all

My wife and I stopped in breakfast and were pleasantly surprised. The food good and the service good was excellent.

First time here and we only stopped because everything seems to be closed this time of year, but they were serving breakfast. There were 8 of us and we were seated quickly and brought our drinks. The menu has a nice variety of breakfast choices. I chose the eggs Benedict because it's my favorite. Huge mistake! Probably the worst I have ever had. First, the English muffin wasn't toasted, just warmed. Second, it was not Canadian bacon, but some kind of ham. Third, it was not a poached egg, but almost hard boiled. Lastly, lumpy hollandaise sauce with no flavor. Besides that, the hash browns were barely cooked. People that got the omelet liked them, so I made a mistake ordering what I did. Gave it 2 stars because we had good service. read more

Pasquales - Italian Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

Highly recommended by locals and quickly understood why this is the best spot for breakfast on the island. After a night of live music and avoiding over-indulging, I could not resist 'the hot mess' which is all the great things about a savory breakfast combined in a plate. Hash browns, bacon, cheese, sausage gravy, eggs... really great. My companions ordered other options - the bacon is a real star. Thick-sliced, cooked to perfection and solidly in second place behind the great coffee. Great omelettes, that bacon... pancakes... four varieties of eggs at our table and all expert perfection. read more

Very quick and easy breakfast spot to cure your hangover! I got the hot mess and the sausage gravy and bacon was so good. My favorite part was the tots underneath. Definitely filled me up and we got our food out quick!! read more

This was a great place for breakfast! It's set up kind of weird. You order and then go sit and they bring the food to you. But the food was delicious. I ordered an egg sandwich, the Mac Daddy, that was amazing. It had chipotle ketchup on it and I've never had that before but it was tangy and delicious. My boyfriend ordered the breakfast burrito that he enjoyed. You also get tater tots with the sandwich and the burrito had tater tots inside. There's tons of on street parking in front. We went on a Weds and it wasn't super busy and the wait for the food really wasn't bad. The customer service was pretty great too. read more

Pasquales - Breakfast burrito - Italian Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

See all

Atmosphere- located on one of the main streets on PIB, the restaurant feels comfortable. With floor to ceiling windows, the restaurant is bright and decorated nicely. There are roughly 15-20 four tops. Service - we were part of a group of 8 and as soon as we entered the restaurant the staff scrambled to arrange tables to accommodate us. We were greeted warmly and our server was attentive. Food - we there for breakfast and I ordered a ham and cheese omelet. It was served hot and was excellent! The side was hash browns, which were pretty good too. The coffee was just OK Value - considering this is a tourist town, the price was extremely reasonable. Overall, I considered the value to be very good. I spoke to a resident of PIB later in the day who said that the restaurant is her favorite for breakfast. read more

Stopped in for a snack around lunchtime this past summer. Tried the Twisted Calamari: as expected, they were fried squid bits served with a side of Chipotle Ranch. I suppose the ranch was the "twisted" part, or perhaps they are referring to the legs being twisty, or maybe both. Not sure. My date tried the Roasted Cauliflower and Quinoa Burger. She enjoyed it. I thought it was a great vegetarian addition to the menu, but the taste did nothing to excite me. Our server was prompt and friendly and I would gladly return to try some of their other fare. Pasquales is conveniently located on the south side of Perry Park. read more

Great spot for breakfast. Pleasant staff, meal came quickly. Food was hot and delicious. Reasonably priced as well. Kitchen was able to adjust my meal to my gluten free needs. Support this local business. read more

On a Sunday morning we were able to get a table for 4 within 10 minutes. Service was fast and friendly. The Lobster Benedict was delicious and plentiful. If you aren't super hungry, I would suggest sharing this dish with someone. read more

Pasquales - Italian Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

See all

Breakfast was delicious! Recommend "The Visitor"!!! Owner was so kind!!!! Highly recommend!

It's a pretty decent restaurant on the island. All the nearby places are packed, loud and really not that great. This joint is quieter and the pizzas were good. Changing my review from 4 to 2 stars: came back for breakfast. The food arrived cold. Hash browns are mushy and super greasy. The servers were slow and grumpy, just like last night. read more

See all

Great food and outstanding Western Omelet. Recommend this to anyone who wants a good breakfast and is not over the top. At the end of the day it is a very satisfying meal. read more

Pasquales - Western Omelet - Italian Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

We dropped in here to this quaint eatery, ready for some pasta or pizza or something Italian. Well, they didn't have pasta, but they had pizza, and subs, prepared like Italian entrees. I think I had the chicken parmesan sub, which is served with delicious waffle-fries. My sister had the Pasquale's chicken sub, which she enjoyed. We never got to get any pizza from there, but it looked good sitting on others' tables, piled with cheese. The chicken sort of tasted metallic, for some reason, in my sandwich. I couldn't tell if that was because it was so hot, or because of the way it was prepared. The fries are great. They offer take out service there as well, but the hours are not the same all the year long through. They're open daily from June through August at the same time (7am-10pm), but then on limited open-hours in April, May, September, and October (which makes me wonder about the rest of the months. Coming from California, I'm not used to closed businesses during snow months). Great little place to go, and I'll probably get the pizza next time I do. read more

Pasquales - Collage, half and half, outside and inside. - Italian Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

Love this spot! The food was great, we came here 3 days in a row for breakfast and the food was great every time. Pictured is the Skillet omelet, highly recommend! Our only complaint is that all 3 waiters we had were not the friendliest, this place still deserves 5 stars though. Plus I can't say I blame the waiters for being grumpy since they've got to deal with all the tourists lol. read more

Pasquales - Italian Near Me - Put-in-Bay, Ohio

Very limited menu this weekend, which was opening weekend for the restaurant. That said, what was available was delicious: breakfast burrito and sausages with eggs no cheese on a brioche bun. Fast friendly service in a venue with surprisingly few tables, although it was easy to get a table at 8:30am on a Sunday. read more

Delicious foo and great combinations, but everything is separately charged, and gets pretty expensive. They are on top of getting refills, etc. read more

The employees are so sweet and easygoing. The food is amazing I tried the lemon blueberry muffin and it was literally heaven.

Great breakfast!!! Friendly staff and manager. Food comes out quickly. Will definitely eat here again.

Surprisingly decent little Italian joint on Put-in-Bay. It was so stereotypical with the red and white checkered tablecloths that I couldn't help but laugh at it. We had a large party but we were all seated almost right away on a very busy Saturday night. I was excited to sit right in front of the big window. There were at least 10 people that walked by that started conversations with me through the glass. One guy was grabbing his junk. Even my mom thought it was funny. Then his "fiancee" walked by and pointed at her engagement ring and gave us dirty looks. That was the highlight of my evening. Okay, back to the review. Most of us ordered pizza and was pretty darn good. Perfect crust, perfect amount of toppings. I was pleasantly surprised as I thought it was going to be terrible. The sauce was the only thing I wasn't satisfied with. It was too acidic. If you ever find yourself stranded on PIB, stop in Pasquale's. It's not as terrible as most other places on the island. read more

Super cool breakfast spot while you're in the island. Be prepared to wait if you go at prime times but it's worth the wait. The vibe is fun- fast paced environment on busy breakfast times but the food is delicious. Traditional breakfast foods are in the menu and you won't be disappointed. Service was fast and staff members were all very friendly! read more

Excellent dinner here! Try to get a seat by the window as it should be considered a bonafide must-do to people watch here. Our service was excellent, we were seating right away on a Saturday night and the food was reasonably priced. Average cost of wine was $18 per bottle or $5 per glass and beer runs about $3.75. Entree's run anywhere from $7 to $20 and you get a significant amount of food. read more

We stopped in this place on a Saturday afternoon (around 3) for a late lunch. There were three adults and one child in our party. Our service was just ok, she did her job and that was about it. We ordered a variety of food from the menu. A pizza, salad, sandwich, chicken dish, and a kids meal. The salad and the kids meal were the only two meals that were descent. The server forgot about the kids meal and it had it be made "on the fly." As for the other meals, the fries that came with them were cold, sandwich was nothing like what was ordered. Chicken dish had a metallic taste to it and I have had better frozen pizza pizza. Quite the disappontment! read more

Extremely friendly and helpful staff. Eggs Benedict were amazing. I advise you arrive early. The later you go the longer the line.

This is definitely still the best breakfast on the island! I run past Pasquales every morning and smell the delicious breakfast foods and was definitely craving French Toast all week. My partner and I headed over Friday morning and were so excited to satisfy our breakfast desires. The service was quick and pleasant. The food was delicious. The price was great. We stick to our previously held belief that this is the best breakfast on the island. So glad they open early too! The renovation, which is a few years old, looks great. It's so clean and cute. Love it! read more

Had the pizza at Pasquales and it was OK. It was crispy, which was good, but something else just wasn't right. I'm not sure what it was, but I think it was probably the sauce just being a bit bland. Overall, it was an OK pizza. I tried the ravioli from someone else and that was pretty good. The service was also decent. read more

We had a very good breakfast. I had the lobster eggs Benedict, and we shared the apple French toast. Our server was an Ilander, and told us all about growing up on the island. read more

Great place for breakfast on the island. Prices are reasonable and the food was delicious. We didn't have to wait, but we came to the island towards the end of the season and during the week, not sure if that will make a difference for those who visit when the island is busier. Overall, great service and food. read more