9/17/2025: Amazing! Updating my review because our last 5 experiences have been great all around!…read moreKitchen consistency is back to amazing again and so are the waitresses. THE BEST steak and prime rib in town without a doubt! Great burgers with a good variety to try! Good garlic butter pasta. The best steamed and buttered broccoli you'll ever have in your life! Nice big portion of spaghetti with meatballs. The meatballs are big and juicy. Good fried pickles. Good beer and drink options. Skilled bartenders. Very very very clean looking behind the bar always. No sticky bar, no dirty cups piled up, no fruit flies, no gummy soda guns, no stale beer smell, no dusty bottles.... very nicely kept. The only disappointment/thing I don't like on the menu is the little frozen premade beer fish fry. They're such a great restaurant, I think they should do their own big hunk of beer battered fish fry dinner instead at least for lent. My 2023 review issues have all been resolved! Yay! I highly recommend them!

Don't let the plain storefront misguided you, there is great pub food and a variety of good drinks…read moreinside! Staff also very nice.

Nice atmosphere for lunch and service was outstanding! Food was very good, had the "Jack Hammer"…read more(Layers of Ham, Pepperoni, & Cooney's Mountain Mustard between two Grilled Pepper Jack Cheese Sandwiches) with French fries and both were outstanding!! Had the mustard on the side to dip the sandwich and fries, recommend that way to enjoy the sandwich flavor without over powering by the mustard. Wife had the Wings and side salad which she said meets her standard (she's from the Buffalo area). Mother had the Philly cheesesteak which was good but a bit sloppy. Recommend this location for at least lunch, will have to try dinner there sometime, apparently they have a Steak Dinner deal on Thursday! Enjoy.

16oz Steak that was highly recommended and also the most expensive meal was a let down it had no…read moresear and was not seasoned at all just a home cooked steak very disappointing customer service was good tho

Excellent excellent excellent!! Very classy place! Will…read moredefinitely go back! My cousin always raved about this place & I finally made it there! Very impressed!

Had the peppermint snowball pie slice because I like the creation of the Oreo (like) crust and the…read moretexture and quantity of that. The peppermint snowball- the quantity is too big for me but also never a disappointment. It is my go to. Chocolate Mudd Pie here is also a fave of mine. The apple pie and Tin roof sundae (if they still offer that) do not stand out for me personally. My sirloin w mushrooms and onion rings was fine and bread was fresh. Salad was reasonably fresh. 4 stars was for service. We got rushed near the end and a relative was still working on putting stuff away in his to go box. We might've taken the piece of lettuce that was on the plate as I am w a group of people who tend to be sustainable and try not to to waste food. Maybe it was too awkward for our waitress that I had dessert first. I wasn't trying to test her but I wanted to make sure I could eat the dessert even if I had to take the main entree home:

An update: Stopped in for a quick bite and sat at the bar. Although the bartender Lisa was…read moreenergetic and friendly, all the other patrons were looking down, staring at their phones. It was the strangest bar visit I've ever had.

3 of us went and sat at the bar to drink and munch only because we had time to kill. Our bartender…read morehad zero personality. She didn't smile once or make any small talk or eye contact what-so-ever with a single person seated around the bar. My first drink had a chip in the rim I didn't see and on my 2nd sip it cut my lip. It makes sense because she slams glassed and bottles around behind the bar. I told the bartender, she didn't even give me a napkin with a bloody lip or apologize for it. She took the chipped glass to her manager who then came out and apologized. She remade it, but still charged me for the remake. This is petty, it's a $1 drink! She then cut my friend off at 5 beers loudly and embarrassingly. We refused to tip her. She literally caused a scene over it, why am I going to tip someone who acts like they hate every customer and coworker? She was terrible and had the personality of a wet paper bag. She only cared about being fast not friendly. Very unwelcoming and loud like she hated being there throwing buckets in the sink, slamming cups down on the counter, slamming bottles around...

My favorite wings in the Olean area…read more You have the most hospitable bar tending staff imaginable. Any issues with food get resolved promptly. A large variety of sauces to choose from and a great menu. Definitely my recommendation to anyone looking for an inexpensive fun night in Olean.

Wow! I thought the half way inn was the best wings in the area until I had wings at the 3rd base!…read moreOur minds are blown! It's more of a cozy friendly dive bar without a nice view like halfway inn, but the halfway in wings, fries, and staff don't hold a candle to 3rd base! The wait staff and management at 3rd base are what make it a Cheers type vibe. Don't sleep on it or be fooled by the unassuming outside. The place is dated, but very clean, fast, super welcoming, exceptional at what they do, a well oiled machine, and delicious! My mouth is watering and I can smell the wings and Cajun fries vividly in my memory while I write this. I'm kicking myself for driving by without trying them for forever. I'm addicted now!

12/17/2025: An update: Great food, friendly service, but there was a roof leak dripping water into…read morea bucket in the dining room.

Food is okay and price is great here. Senior and lodging options and potential coupons for locals…read morework their magic. Perkins is an acceptable standard of food for a positive dining experience with foodie subpar food. I enjoyed my fish, broccoli, and even the portion size, but I didn't love it personally. My friends seemed pleased with their meals. Quality service here- she brought back more To Go containers for a last minute request.

The outside of this building makes it look like a dive. Inside is a cool bar and back patio. Can't…read morebelieve it's not more popular. As a local the outside was discouraging. Now it's our favorite. American with a fusion. Amazing tempura fish tacos with slaw last time. Today we had a pulled pork with grilled pineapple over rice with an Asian leaning any red blooded American would love. Great Mac and cheese with Chinese Gen Tsaos chicken on it or orange chicken. Great pairings. So refreshing to not have things from the deep frier all the time. Best appetizers are the pierogies with bacon and sour cream. Heads up cash is cheaper. Card clearly stated costs 3% more. They have an ATM in their dining area. It's not overpriced. Most meals are the same as Hometown restaurant across the street. They have a whole other side of dining you don't see when you walk in. Would be great for a large gathering. I

A really cool vibe. Good food. More than a typical bar fare. You can tell this is family owned…read more A lot of care went into this place. I had the fish and it was a perfect wow. The fries were crispy and not oily. They are definitely not over using their oil. The bartender is attentive and will keep the pace of conversation so if you want to chat, this is a good place. Also they have some nice selections on tap including a cider if that is your thing. Will stop back here the next time I am in town. Thank you for welcoming a weary traveller

I don't wish to be unkind, but the service at this place is pretty bad…read more 1. Today I ordered a sausage, egg, and cheese on biscuit. When I get home, I see that the sausage patty has been replaced by a burger with grilled onions on it. It was OK, but not what I ordered. And I didn't feel like I should drive all the way back just to return it and get what I ordered. 2. A few months ago, I ordered some special Buffalo Bills deal that they had on the signage for $17.99. They wanted to charge me $19.99. They didn't believe me when I said that their very own sign, so a worker walked out to drive thru to look at the sign to verify what I was telling them. And then they had to manually enter a discount into my order to lower the price. I mean, it's all computerized!! How does this kind of thing even happen? 3. I've ordered oatmeal with the apples and cranberries several times. They keep leaving either the apples or cranberries, or both, out of the order. I had to start ordering 'extra apples and cranberries' just to make sure they would put them in the oatmeal.

My egg McMuffin was burnt and there was egg shells all in my egg this morning, I understand there…read moreis a rush but this could've hurt someone if swallowed.

We're absolutely obsessed with the gyro platter, the Greek garbage plate, the garlic naan, and the…read morebutter chicken! I've dined in with friends and coworkers multiple times while in olean for work, but most of the time we only have time to get it to go. It's a very classy peaceful clean restaurant and bar. Amazing staff all around. They will even work with me on special orders for my dietary restrictions. I'm so grateful! We love them and olean is lucky to have them.

We went to dinner last night and it was wonderful. I was happy to see it busy because it's such…read moredelicious food, and everyone was great. My meal, chicken korma, was amazing as always if not the best I've ever had. Their rice is my favorite and tatziki sauce! Yum! We were so happy with our meals and atmosphere. Can't wait to go back