Pizza here WAAAAAAYYYY overrated. Second time trying it First time was almost too oily to eat. Literally dripping with oil. Fast forward to second time pizza was nasty tasted like reheated day old pizza. This was fresh AND I waited an hour and 20 minutes for delivery. Never been more disappointed. With a pizzeria then here. I can't for the life of me figure out why people love it so much. For me I WON'T be going back that's for certain. read more

A few days ago after getting my nails done I wanted a quick bite to eat. Walked up the block to this pizzeria which had been there for years but I hadn't eaten there in years since I moved. I ordered a Sicilian slice. The best Sicilian slice I've ever had. The sauce had a tinge if sweetness to it, the dough had a bit of sesame seeds and the dough was perfect in texture and crunch. read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

This place is a joke on more than one occasion I've tried to order food 45-30 minutes before their closing time (9:30 on a Friday) and they tell me they are done making that for the day. Well you are done making me anything, because this pizza places food is nothing special compared with the ten other restaurants near it. I'll call any one of their competitors and they'll make a pie just as good, right up to 10 min before they close. I litterly left this place after they wouldn't make a pizza, called a different place and picked it up 15 min later. read more

My kids are quirky with pizza places but they will eat pizza from Freddy's. Lol. We have only ordered from here twice but I think their pizza is pretty good. read more

See all

As a yelp reviewer, I'm here to do my duty of commenting on the food that I've consumed. This was for a party (I was not the one purchasing the food). Pizza was great. Grandma slice with mozzarella, tomato and basil (see pic) is very aesthetically presented. Side Note: Of all the businesses in Whitestone, this one is of one of the very few who are against the idea of leaving a tiny counter-top donation can to support Whitestone's very own 100% FREE Volunteer Ambulance Service. Its very sad and unfortunate that they do not support their own community's free EMS station (which I might add is just ONE block away from them). I think this says a lot about their character and the kind of people they really are. While they have good pizza, myself and many (MANY) others will continue to boycott this specific business and give our money to other local pizza shops who do support. read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

Amazing!! So good! Everything is perfection! Linguine and clams red sauce 10/10. Chicken Francese 10/10, broccoli with garlic 10/10. Been going here for more than a decade and was so excited after ice skating at UBS arena to order from here. Never disappointed. read more

great food i love the extra cheesy pickle pizza and just be careful there is a 6 foot tall springbonnie suit that walks around and abducts children. i think 6 kids went missing here before. like in 85'. there was a full investigation of the pizza place. in the backroom there were strange jars of purple glowing liquid on a counter. there were animatronic suits in the comer of the room and they smelled horrible. not to mention they were covered in blood and sounded like they were whispering some stuff... they think that some kids were murdered there. by some guy named william afton. they place doesnt have good history but the food is still good even though the cheese gets stuck in my braces. read more

Best Pizza around. Been coming here for over 25 years. Consistently great pizza and love their signature sesame seed crust on the Sicilian pie! read more

Gave Freddy's Pizzeria a try after seeing it on a barstool sports review. Their regular slice got a 7.3 out of 10. Me personally I think it should be high 5s or low 6s. Maybe bc it could of been a little to hot but their was to much "flop" and all the cheese slide off, not to mention it was very oily. I also had the old fashioned Sicilian slice, that slice was actually pretty good and all the flavors worked ok but not great. read more

Freddy's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Whitestone, New York

Solid pizzeria. Quality mozz. True football pizza. One bite everybody knows the rules. 7.2 nice underbelly.

Stumbled on this place..ordered their Buffalo chicken slice and grandma Alla vodka slice, one word IMPRESSIVE!

Pros : -Pizza was great! Cons : -An Animatronic Bear followed me home, send help please. read more

The staff is always so nice love the food i have to many plates from them always great thank you

I'm in town visiting my mom and she's been working all day so suggested we order a pizza for dinner. We placed an order of a large cheese pizza, a small Caesar salad, and chicken tenders over 1.5 HOURS ago and are still waiting. I called to check on the order and the man who answered did not even apologize. He said the delivery guy is on the way, but fifteen minutes later and still no pizza. How can it take that long to make three simple items?! My mom has vowed to never order from here again. The food finally arrived and the delivery guy explained he was the only one working today. Still not great that we waited over 1.5 hours. At least he was friendlier than the guy on the phone. The food was also decent and still warm so I'm adding an extra star. read more

I love it . There is pride here ...I havent seen anything like it in many years ... everything is done with great care and the result is a great finished product... try the grandma vodka slice ... it doesn't get much better then that ...trust me .. . read more

Reliably great pizza and Italian food. My favorites are the Sicilian slice (has sesame streets on the bottom!!), buffalo chicken slice, and the eggplant roll. read more

I just had the eggplant Parmesan at Freddy's on the plate was very old disgusting looking. The only thing that was good. Is the pasta that came with it? I told the manager or one of the owners I said this is horrible. He didn't offer to change it. Nothing I showed him. I said look at this food looks horrible test horrible. whould you eat that The pizza is good over there I'm not gonna say no, but anything else I will not take any dishes everything is old. Nothing moves, but pizza, so be careful what you order I should've taken the pictures of the food I did not ... I will probably not go back to get anything anymore. Ruin my dinner. read more

All these years and I have never tried this place. The pizza was nice and crispy and their penne a la vodka pasta dish was huge and flavorful. My daughter dropped her first slice of pizza on the floor. So my friend gave my daughter her slice of pizza. I turned around and she dropped another slice. The guys working there were so empathetic and considerate they gave Liv another slice for free. This time I watched her eating the pizza like a hawk. It's the little gestures like this that makes a store awesome. And for that I would come here every time we do a playdate around the corner. read more

I stopped by this pizzeria for a slice years ago. I had lived in the neighborhood for well over ten years and was going by for the first time. The server looked at me, picked out the smallest slice in the pie, then gave that to me. He must have thought I was an out of town one time visitor. He is certainly right about me becoming a one time visitor. I have never being back. I hope the pizzeria treats unfamiliar customers better these days. read more

Decided to try this place out. One of the best pizzas I've ever had! Everyone's really friendly! Now if I ever have a pizza craving, I know where to go. read more

Pizza was delicious and the owner was kind. Would love to see this place thrive. Will definitely come back.

Didn't expect it but, Freddy's Pizzeria was excellent. 5/5 For atmosphere. Most everything I've tried so far have been quite great. The staff was welcoming and prompt to assist us. Definitely going to go back! read more

I love their vodka square pizza. It has so much flavor with the traditional new york style. You know it's real when the oil separates from the cheese and runs down your hand. Not too many places like this anymore. read more

I tried to call , because I had out of area phone number, they kept hanging up on me, I have ordered many pizza since I lived in Whitestone. The first time I have been treated so rude. It was by the owner Freddy because I always asked him to cut my pizza in squares. If you are looking for customer service, don't order here. read more

The workers were extremely rude. I tried to get a box as a joke because the name of the restaurant is the same as the Five Nights at Freddy's video game. I didn't expect the box for free so I even offered money. They were extremely rude and overall seemed like a grumpy group of workers. Tried the pizza afterward and it was disgusting. read more

Had a pain slice here and 1 was not enough. The slice was so good, perfectly saucy and cheesy. The bread was delicious as well. What a gem!

Hands down one of my favorite pizzerias in queens. For starters they have a good plain slice and a old fashion slice, but the slice that makes my mouth water is the grandma alla vodka. I'm grateful to be nearby and at least having this once a week. read more

Freddy's is an amazing pizza shop. I work in the area and all of my coworkers swear for this spot. I wanted pizza so I decided to give this place a try. I walked in and was immediately greeted nicely. There was a man taking orders and also making the pizzas. He explained the prices and specials to me and I decided to go with two regular slices just to test the waters. Each slice was $2.75 and I got two which came up to $5.50. There was plenty of seating to wait or dine in. The overall store was very clean and inviting. The first bite of this pizza was heaven. Real New York style pizza! I will return and definitely recommend read more

Wanted to re-emphasize that Freddy's is the best pizza in Whitestone. The Sesame seed crust on the Sicilian pie is out of this world. Also really enjoy the old fashioned last slice read more

I was drawn by the 40 year old signage and the Berch Augustine paintings on the windows... It had to be good. My white slice had a great crust to it and the cheeses ended up blending together nicely. Then the sausage and pepperoni fried calzone was awesome. I've only had a fried calzone at House of Pizza and Calzone in Brooklyn, so this got me excited. Ordering both in one shot is not normally advisable with an aging stomach, but it's not often I'm in this neighborhood, so I had to make it count. And it was good. 5-stars is a very high rating. Is it better than Amore? No, I don't think so... but then again Amore doesn't do all the white slices and the other stuff. Is it best of the best? No, but probably best on the block. And it's a dying breed, so they deserve max stars. read more

Freddy's pizza is definitely by far one of the best pizza places in Queens. Their regular slice is absolutely delicious. It doesn't even need any toppings. The natural flavor of the pizza just comes out oh so good. They also make a mean Sicilian as well. When in Whitestone, make a pit stop to Freddy's. You'll be glad you did read more

I had their regular as well as Sicilian slice here. I liked both. I would go back if I was in the neighborhood. I prefer Freddy's slice by a lot than Coppola's in College Point...which is YUCK. read more

I discovered this place by accident some 5 years ago. My daughter & I fell in love with the Penne a la Vodka. We took my wife and we fell in love with the Chicken Caesar Salad (not just because the ingredients are ultra-fresh, but their dressing is to die for). We actually fell in love with everything we tried thereafter... I know this must sound ridiculous (if you've never tried Freddy's), but one of the reasons that I moved back to Queens from Manhattan was to be closer to this gem of a place. I hope they stay open for decades to come, and keep their quality at least the same, as I'd be blown away and almost devastated if they were to do otherwise. Even the guys who work there, right down to the delivery guy, are awesome. We just discovered how excellent the sauteed broccoli is, too! LONG LIVE FREDDY'S PIZZERIA! P.S. - don't go to Freddy's for a fancy, dressy dinner. It's really just a pizza place with a room full of little tables... but the food... wow. read more

Great pizza but their vodka slice is to die for can't go wrong with that. And their staff is always friendly.

We ordered a 'large' pie, half pepperoni, half chicken cutlet on top. My initial thoughts were that it arrived hot, and looked much smaller than most large pizzas usually were. The cheese kept sliding off of the pizza slices which was annoying but I guess that could happen with any place. The pepperoni side was devoured before I got a chance to try it. The chicken side was okay. The cutlet was crispy although a bit bland. The sauce was fairly good. Compared to the other places I've tried in the area, it may be the new go to pizza place. read more

Great old time pizzeria sign- not too often one can see a prime example of color cube tile lettering in this area of Queens. A popular spot for pizza sign enthusiasts indeed! Great sign, great slice. Cant give 4 stars, but if the consistancy is there on my next visit, it deserves it. It the type of place that is very neighborhood based- which usually means a basically good slice, repeat customers and unfortunetly, the opportunity for complancency... not too much competition around here. read more

Its worth the local hype! Seriously. recently got into a Pizza phase..let me check out the old places my mother fed us with on Pizza Friday's. The best day of the week! Greek mothers use pizza Friday to get us to fast meat, and it generally works out well for all. Freddy's was low on my list. I'm anti-hype I figured it's location in the Village, and the decade of Street Fighter II and Mortal Kombat in there beckoning us led to hype. Plus being around so long they must slack off...In my years I've seen cash cow landmark locations of restaurants slack; who cares we own the building, low overhead, etc. I realize now some Pizza places use the canned sauce; you'll know it cause it tastes like every other canned sauce joint. Freddy's is definitely making their own. They have held their own against decades of competition and Brick Oven the last decade. It's NOT resting on reputation the pizza kicks ass. Believe it. My fave is Chicken Parm dinner with the pasta. One hell of a meal. I'm gonna go for the veal Parm soon. I haven't had a veal Parm in many years. read more

Great pizza, especially the sicilian it has sesame seeds that's adds a great flavor to it, nice people, place can use a small update, but it's clean read more

Best white slice money can buy! Always an awesome and consistent slice of pizza. The plain is to die for also. Best pizzeria in Queens hands down!! The service is also outstanding! read more

Great pizza and any dish I have ordered so far. I love the way they deliver and vent the pizza so it stays crisp. They are a team of wonderful people making my family happy. read more