Food is fine. However, the Greek Salad doesn't include stuffed grape leaves, which to me isn't a true Greek salad. Service is very good and their locations are good, especially their Amenia location. read more

Very nice place inside, clean, & friendly staff! Was there with a large group for a pizza party, however the pizza was lacking to me. Tasted like fast food pizza. Crust was fluffy and sauce was a little sweet. I prefer traditional ny style pizza but this was almost like a dominos style. I'm sure other things on their menu are great, but just wasn't a pizza fan. read more

First rate experience here. Stopped in for lunch with friends. We sat on the patio, which was lovely. Ordered Carbonara and a pizza. Probably some of the best versions of both dishes I've ever had. Our salad was great as well. There's also an adjacent drive-in theatre and a mini golf course which seemed fun. I'll bet the place is fun in the evenings! Def a great spot in Upstate NY! read more

See all

Never been to the area, decided to go here and the waitress older women was so short with us and just gave the impression as if we were bothering her and I did not like that.. it was a nice place food was good the service ruined the whole thing. read more

My family has been going to Four Brothers Pleasant Valley since they opened years ago. It was always our "go to" place. NO MORE We all loved their fried chicken. So for the second time we went to have their fried chicken dinner which is on their menu as "country fried chicken dinner". Again NO fried chicken. So disappointed we ordered something else. It was okay. But then we were ready to leave ready for our checkout was to!d computer down boss has to fix. We waited a half an hour for our check ! If you do not make fried Chicken, please take it off the menu. read more

Just got A Meatball Parm sub. Very very disappointing. A meatball sub should have meat BALLS on it. NOT sliced meat. Probably 2 meatballs on the whole grinder where it should have had at least 4 balls on it. I realize meat cost more but don't try to trick the public. Also...a tiny thin slice of mozzerella, if that's what it actually was on it. Won't be going here in the future... Sorry... You lost my buisness! read more

With many years of living in PV including the Hudson Valley, you can't go wrong with Four Bros. The pizza speaks for itself, unique, Greek taste, and wonderful crust. We've been doing takeout orders for pizza dating back to my youth days, oh yes! Ordering a pie is at a reasonable price. We've dinned in a couple of times, offering a lot on the menu. I've once or twice had their burger which was decent. I've never tried their salads, but one day it will come. You're in for a treat and won't regret it. read more

See all

Wonderful family lunch on the way back from skiing. We had chicken fingers and a half margarita half pepperoni pizza. Everything was delicious ! read more

My mother recently went to pick up an order I had placed, but unfortunately, she was treated very poorly by the waitress. As a person of Hispanic descent, I can't help but wonder if this played a role in the treatment she received. Based on what my mother shared, I feel deeply saddened by her experience. She explained that the first waitress seemed to treat the situation as her social hour, ignoring my mother entirely and being rude to her. Thankfully, a second waitress eventually stepped in and treated her with kindness and respect, which I truly appreciate. This experience is especially upsetting because I have been a loyal customer of this establishment for years, and my mother has been going there for even longer. As someone who works in the food and wine industry, I know how important it is to treat every customer with the utmost respect. It's always been my priority to be kind and professional, regardless of the situation. I hope this experience serves as a reminder of the importance of providing respectful, attentive, and equal service to every customer, no matter their background. I do not want to seem like a "Karen," but I just want others to know what I experienced recently. Thank you. Side note: the salads and dressings are amazing! The food is respectively good. read more

We order gluten free pizza from here and it was not gluten free. I have been sick for three days. please if you are celiac or just gf please be careful. read more

I called ahead to check if they had a certain item and they said yes but when I went only 2 hours later there was none (I called at 2:00 and got there at 4:00). Also I was the only person there aside from 1 family of 4 and had to wait almost 35 minutes to get my receipt and was told that the computer was down and during the time I had to wait the family got their receipt and left and I had to wait another 10 minutes for my receipt. read more

I stopped here as I am not in the area usually and soooo glad I did. The pizza is just as delicious as I remember and the greek salad is sooo good, the homemade greek dressing seems extra tangy now but its still good. It was so nice to see nothing has changed and it is still one of the best pizzas ....so cheezy.....!!!!!!! Also bought some of their special greek dressing to go and a homemade choc chip cookie which I will try later....too stuffed....stuffed and very happy! read more

Amazing pizza & food. High quality, and great service. You can't go wrong with the meat lovers or veggie pizza

One of my favorite places to get pizza hands down. Always consistent and good pasta never hurt either. read more

Four Brothers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pleasant Valley, New York

Picked up a large cheese pizza and a large greek salad for takeout. Pizza was overcooked (dark brown), and dry. There was very little sauce on the pizza. The dough/crust tasted like cardboard factory made, the kind you would find in a boxed frozen pizza. Their "famous" Greek salad was okay. I ordered a large salad @ $15.75, it came with one small container of their "famous" Greek salad dressing. I asked for another small container for the large salad. So they hit me for an additional $2.25 for additional small container of dressing. Hardly anything to rave about here. First and last visit to Four Brothers for me. read more

In my first visit back here in at least 15 years, possibly longer, I felt right at home again. The menu is revised, the staff has changed, but everything else felt so familiar - the layout, the decor, and those oh-so-delicious aromas. I felt comfortable ordering what I tended to order every time I came here. That included their "small" (i.e., dinner) salad, and trust me, it's not that small. I'm addicted to that dressing, and I'm surprised I didn't go through withdrawal in the past. That also included a pizza with my favorite toppings - love that Greek crust! I brought out-of-state friends here for dinner, and they were quite eager after they saw the portion sizes of dishes going to other tables, and equally satisfied after we finished ours. Four Brothers Pleasant Valley, oh how I missed you! read more

Four Brothers Pizza - Their Dinner Salad, i.e. their smallest salad, isn't that small. - Pizza Near Me - Pleasant Valley, New York

See all

Excellent food, great service, nice waitress. Very nicely decorated for the area. We have had fried chicken and my go to is the chicken and eggplant parmesan dinner. I would gladly eat here multiple times a month if inflation was not so bad these days. I wish they delivered but it isn't a long drive so to call and place your take out order isn't really a big deal. A friend tells me their pizza and Greek salad are excellent but I have not tried them. She's extremely picky about her food so if she said it was excellent I am sure it is. read more

ABSOLUTELY STUNNING INSIDE! Four Brothers took the opportunity to renovate the interior which is something that was sorely needed. The outdated, tacky decor has been replaced with a fresh, modern, welcoming design. I was FLOORED when I saw this for the first time. It doesn't even look like the same place inside. Food was outstanding as always. I cannot rave highly enough about this. Greek salad was a rock-star, pizza was wonderful, and the side of meatballs pleased the crowd. We won't be dining in anytime soon but that won't stop me from enjoying the food and admiring the decor. Please support this locally-owned business! ***Photos I took have been added separately. Please check them out! Those of you who were regulars will not believe your eyes. read more

Loved this place! Extremely clean and the decor is beautiful! Our waitress was very nice. Food was delicious! Definitely one of the best cheesesteaks we've had! Wish they were closer to us so we can go again soon! read more

See all

This is the best pizza in the world. Hands down. NYC has nothing on this place! I have flown from LA just to get this pizza once.

Seriously sooo good!!! Got a vegetable pizza, regular pizza, and greek salad all delicious! curbside pickup was super easy AND SAFE they bring to car and put in trunk. Also great prices. I will be back! read more

Four Brothers, you will always be amazing! I have been going to these restaurants since my friend introduced me when we were in high school (roughly 16 years ago, yikes) and it's still just as amazing. I was sad to hear the Poughkeepsie location closed, but excited to learn there was another location not too far. My friend and I came to the Pleasant Valley restaurant when I was up visiting recently. We of course had to go old school and order what we used to order: large pizza with fresh tomato and artichoke hearts, a large greek salad, and this time two glasses of red wine instead of two diet cokes. It was oh so good! Hit the spot, brought back memories and luckily we had leftovers so I could have some again the next day! And of course I left with a purchased bottle of their salad dressing. Great pizza and salad! Thank you! read more

See all

Consistently delicious! Friendly staff! I love their Greek salad and house dressing. Literally been a fan since childhood! My grandparents always took us here as a special treat growing up. Still just as enjoyable! read more

If you have to eat gluten-free, this is not the place for you. Tried musclan salad and I got iceberg lettuce. I hate iceberg lettuce. Have come a few times because my husband can eat like a regular person and he loves it. It's always a big disappointment for me. But the only decent thing is a GF pizza. read more

This is grandpas favorite pizza place and has been for years, so I always make a stop when I visit. They have great salads and desserts too.

The food was good. Ordered a chicken wrap with fries. The fries were really good. However, I got the potato salad. And the potato salad came in a very small cup kind of the same ones you get when you get ketchup for dipping Very very small..... Other than that it was "ok" read more

As good as it gets for such a simple tasty meal. Chicken parm and pizza. All so darn good! Such nice service and friendly people! read more

So the food was really good and I will come back. The reason I gave the space 3 stars and not 4 was the chicken parmigiana sub I got was on the dryer side. They also give you a pickle with the sandwich which is an odd combo but I didn't mind. How they packaged it was what I took a star off for. The placed the pickle directly on top of my sandwich which dill pickle and tomato sauce do not go well together. Next time I go I will ask for no pickle and extra sauce but they should consider maybe placing parchment paper between the pickle and sub so it's not leaking juice into the sandwich. Still very good food and my friend who had the pizza said the pizza was very good! read more

Absolutely LOVE Four Brothers! Have been going since I was a kid. It was always my grandfathers favorite and now also mine. I grew up in Poughkeepsie but have since moved to Boston and at least every other time I'm home, I go here to enjoy the salad (usually bring a dressing back to MA with me!) and their pizza! Delicious! Only complaint is that sodas aren't free refills =/ read more

Great Salads. I have gotten pizza, salad and many other dishes from Four Brothers in Amenia, Hillsdale, Dover and Pleasant Valley. I have recently been surprised (LAST 6 MONTHS OR MORE) how much their salads have improved. The salads are made to order with the freshest ingredients. I live very close to the Pleasant Valley location and have become a regular. The flowers and exterior has been improved and updated. The interior has been renovated and is very nice. read more

Best Pizza Ever!! You have to know how to eat it right, with a Greek salad, extra feta, and drenched in their homemade dressing... Nothing beats Four Brothers! read more

What a great place for the whole family to enjoy a great meal. The staff members are awesome.

Left questioning the authenticity of their pizza.. I will first let it be known I'm only rating this place for their pizza. I ordered a large plain pie, the best way to judge a place in my opinion. The only way I could be more certain this dough isn't homemade is if I were standing in the kitchen watching them. Just looking at the pizza I knew something was up. It looked like it was baked in a Pizza Hut pan, first red flag. It was cut into 12 slices, second red flag. There was a cardboard circle underneath the pie, like the kind you get when you buy frozen pizza. The dough had the taste and texture of Red Baron's French bread frozen pizzas, which are terrible. I was tempted to call them back and ask what brand dough they use so that I can avoid it going forward. I will absolutely never order pizza here again, what a mistake. read more

By far my fav place at the moment clean, friendly, the food is delicious. I promise you won't be disappointed.

This was by far the WORST Margherita pizza and eggplant parm I've ever had in New York. The crust of the pizza is wanna be Pizza Hut. It's dry and tough and a total disappointment. The eggplant was soaked in so much sauce I couldn't find any of the actual vegetable. And served with no pasta for $15?? Are you kidding me? Total rip off. Caesar salad was sub par and the dressing tasted like it came out of a plastic bottle. I will not be going here ever again. read more

I've dined repeatedly at Four Brothers and the quality has been consistent each time. Four Brothers offers the Platonic Form of a chicken Caesar wrap - the moist and tender, excellently flavored chicken is a delight. And the pizza's are excellent as well, including the chicken ranch and the available custom options. And not only is the Greek salad delightful, you can buy a bottle of dressing also. The staff are friendly and helpful, and we've always had a great time. read more

We ordered from here while playing a local college in a soccer match. They were accommodating to our order of 25 assorted grinders that we ordered at 3:30pm and needed for 9:00pm the same day. Every person we spoke to went above and beyond. They don't normally deliver but dilevered our food to the field on time. The food was fantastic and the girls loved it. Thank you so much for a great experience!! Highly recommend !! read more

I loooove their pizza and salad. Their pies are pretty good too. In the warmer months, they have a GORGEOUS garden outside. It's beautiful. Great outdoor seating too. read more

Let me start by saying, I'm from Chicago so I know pizza. I believe Chicago has some of the best pizza places. Once I tried 4 brothers pizza, it was hands down the best pizza I have had in NY state period. It is always nice and cheesy, nice and hot and the crust is nice and buttery. It's just perfection. Great pizza!!! read more

If you are lucky enough to find yourself near one of the Four Brothers restaurants, you should absolutely give them a try. Their pizza has a distinct taste that cannot be found anywhere else. And their Greek salad, with their own Greek dressing is amazing. You can even purchase bottles of their dressing to bring home. When we go (or order out), we usually get a plain or margarita pizza and a regular greek salad. For the two of us this gives us enough to eat and gives us a full meal of leftovers, which always seems just as good as the first time. read more