Second visit to the Barn & this one was much more memorable (first time I'm thinking was…read moreoff-season). First of all - the atmosphere is really cool - I mean it's a barn! The interior has kind of a lodge feel to it - there's also a terrace with a good view ..we opted to eat in the main area as it was nice & cool. We received our drinks quickly and we ordered the House Bread as an app (AWEsome). For the main course We had Smoked Pulled Pork Eggs Benedict & the Stuffed French toast - both were a hit. Pacing of the meals was just right & it was definitely a relaxing experience. We'll definitely be back!

So, we had lunch reservations on Sunday for 11:30am. I was looking forward to it since many people…read morerecommended it. It looked popular but they were seating everyone. Not sure what was happening with staffing. It took a while to get menus and even longer to get our order put in. The waiter did check in on us to apologize for the long wait but it took over an hour to get our food. We saw other people waiting forever too and next to us, they were frustrated waiting a long time just to get their bill to pay. Another party had a woman finally flag down a waiter telling them no one has even taken their order. Where was upper management? It's not necessarily the waiters fault. Are they over-seating for short staff? The kitchen isn't keeping up with the orders, want to comp something from the bar maybe? One hours for food to come out is really disappointing. The food was good but not amazing or unique. The drink was suppose to be a blood orange old fashioned but tasted horrible so, probably not going to return for any mixed drinks. Scenery was very pretty bd relaxing. Ambiance was nice but restaurant service was so disappointing.

Cayla was attentive and fun! Highly Recommended for a fun date night or ladies evening!read more

My husband and I sat at the upstairs bar and Morgan was the best. We had the salmon and the…read morecheesesteak pizza,Both of our meals were also amazing. We'll definitely be back!!!

Lovely venue! Food was fabulous, and so was the service. Ambiance and atmosphere were awesome!read more

Decided to have a nice dinner out on a Saturday evening, so we came here. The atmosphere is really…read moreneat and old-times. You can visualize a bit what the building used to look like many years ago. They have tables all over the building so it feels very large, and most of them were full. The server was very friendly and happy to walk us through the menu, and provide recommendations. It felt wrong to order a burger at a more upscale place, but it sounded good since it had some unique ingredients together. Overall, the flavor mixture was good from the toppings but the meat itself was a little dry, so it put a damper on the overall taste. The person I was with for a pork chop and said it was "alright" but "not special". For the price, I was hoping to be impressed, but I wasn't. The Mac was good, though, as most others have said. Highly recommend that. If I could do half stars I think 3.5 is probably about right, but I'll round up since the service was really great.

We ate here on Christmas while visiting PA. Excellent service and the food was great! Very comfy…read moresetting and friendly staff. You must have the Lobster Fingers, we had to get a 2nd order because we ate them so quickly. So many things I wanted to try since we were visiting from FL. Great menu, try it.

I've been here a few times over the years but didn't leave a review because I couldn't decide if it…read morewas a 4 or five star experience. One time it was 5, then 4, and finally tonight, a resounding 5 stars. The chocolate braised short rib put it over the top. At $38, it was really delicious and a large portion. Also had 5 onion soup and the wife's lobster fingers along with two drinks at the bar where we had prompt service for a quick exit. (Places to go!) Really nice restaurant with excellent food, highly recommended!

Absolutely a gem! This locally-owned place elevates the quiet downtown of Carlisle. Everything we…read morehave tried is delicious with complex flavors that complement each bite. The service is consistently great and very attentive to allergy concerns! This is our go-to date night and always our first recommendation for hosting and visitors.

My wife and I had dinner at One13 Social while we were in Carlisle for the Corvettes at Carlisle…read moreevent. The restaurant was very busy, but we were seated right away. One13 describes itself as upscale casual, which I think is an accurate description of the atmosphere. We started with the Clams Casino and She Crab Bisque. The Clams Casino were very good and quite different from what I'm used to. Rather than clams topped with bacon and breadcrumbs, One13 serves them more deconstructed, in a bucket with broth and diced bacon accompanied by toasted bread. My wife had the She Crab Bisque and enjoyed it. For our entrées, we both ordered the Salmon Caprese. They didn't ask how we wanted the salmon prepared, but I would estimate it was cooked to medium. The salmon was very good. One interesting part of the dish was the cauliflower purée, which was served cold. There was nothing wrong with it, but when something looks like mashed potatoes, your mind expects it to be hot, so the first bite caught me by surprise. My wife had a Pinot Noir with dinner while I had a Sauvignon Blanc, and both paired well with the salmon. Overall, we had a very good dinner at One13 Social and thought it was a great choice while staying in Carlisle. We parked in the nearby Comfort Inn parking garage, which also gave me a little more peace of mind about leaving the Corvette overnight. We would definitely return next year when we're back for Corvettes at Carlisle.

Seems basic but the food and service is amazing!…read more Some as simple as fries were the best crispy exterior with light and fluffy interior with a sweet double fried finish The burgers and cheesesteaks were some of the best for a pub The dinning in the deck was perfect with live music from the town square Great service too!

Mexican street corn dip 7/10 There was like a weird…read moregas/lighter fluid taste at the bottom of the dish? The rest of it was decent. I would have liked it to have a little more of a Mexican flavor- whether it be like some green chiles or tahin or something. Boneless wings 10/10 Cooked great. They were coated with sauce just enough too. Honey BBQ was pretty good. Little on the sweeter side obviously. Got blue cheese for dipping and it was not good at all. Chocolate chip Cookie skillet 7/10 So this wasn't an entire skillet like you'd think, it was a slice of cookie cake basically with some ice cream inside a small skillet. I don't think this even had any chocolate chips? I really only tasted nuts. But the cookie in the center was warm and a little gooey, so that part was yummy.

Great atmosphere, friendly and engaging employees, quality of food is superb. Menu has a good…read morevariety of choices.

I will start with - we have dined here at least a half dozen times and realized i never reviewed…read more This is one of the best restaurants in the York area we have been to. They are a class act! Every staff member we have interacted with have all been professional & friendly. The restaurant has warm inviting decor & we love the bar area. Lots of great choices on the menu & wonderful daily specials. We love this restaurant so much that we hosted a baby shower may of 2026 in one of their upstairs private rooms. The event planner was great to work. She had wonderful suggestions on menu & set up. We chose a brunch buffet & added some of their appetizers & fresh fruit. We had rave reviews from all who attended on the venue, staff & food. We will continue to dine here and would highly recommend the space upstairs for private events. Ample parking - but one suggestion is make a reservation, as they are always busy

Friendly staff. Good food and drink. Nice atmosphere…read more Sat at bar and was served quick.

My wife and I had an opportunity to visit Sidney Tavern this week for the first time. It was our…read moreanniversary and we are always looking for a fine dining restaurant that doesn't require us to drive to Frederick, MD. The place was pretty quiet; we only saw 3 other parties during our visit. My takeaway is that this place is fine, but not great. Our server was friendly and attentive. We started with cocktails (tiramisu martini and a spicy margarita) and they were outstanding; probably the highlight of our visit. You have to pay for bread here so we ordered an assortment of breads before our main courses. Three different breads were sampled, including an olive bread and jalapeño cornbread. The breads were all good although the cornbread was dry. My wife ordered a pork shoulder dish with spaetzle. The pork was quite tough, although flavorful. I had the beef short rib and it was fine, although not outstanding. We went to order the pumpkin cheesecake for dessert and they were out. We ordered the plum tart and that was also unavailable. They substituted an apple tart with cinnamon ice crème and it was nice. All in all, our dinner was fine, but not outstanding.

Nice place for lunch. Food was above average. Views were great. Service was good…read more Nice place for lunch. Food was above average. Views were great. Service was good

Location -off the side of a mountain road this restaurant…read moreoffers panoramic views of nature -it has it's own dedicated parking lot so parking is not a problem Food -prices are on the steeper side but the meats are cooked well -I got the lamb lollipops which were seasoned and cooked to perfection -I also got the day's vegetables which were a plate full for $4, it was on the plainer side but again cooked well. -If you are on a budget and want a healthy meal I would recommend my combo above. They give you a bowl of bread for free as well so you have your carbs covered Service -I was quickly seated and server checked on me frequently enough, took a while to get my check though -but server knew the menu well including off menu options Venue -they also feature live music, at least when I went on a weeknight -they have bar seating and regular booth and table seating

Oh boy was this good. Additionally they have Penn State Creamery available. Need to make one more…read moretrip while I'm still in town.

We love Sarah's! The cream is delicious and fair priced. Sometimes a cone, sometimes a sundae but…read morealways good. Plus it's a very clean and personable establishment! Great friendly service!