Man I love this place, a true local gem. Great people making some of the better BBQ I've had outside the south. They make a nice selection of sauces to go with as well. I've tried most of their options and the pulled pork is probably what they do best although to be fair they've gotten better each season so everything is pretty damn good now. It's a little hard to find as it's down off the main road so keep an eye out for the signs. They have limited indoor dining (not currently available) and some outdoor picnic tables but we usually get it to go, they have some good combos where you can get meat and sides for a family meal. read more

Excellent food !! Very tasty great prices. We came to Hershey Park this spot is close to park. Highly recommend this place.

Very tasty. Sauces were flavorful. Mac and cheese was a nice side, unique recipe. Small little shack, a few tables inside, picnic tables outside. read more

It should be 3.5 stars but I will give them 4 just because I see some potential at this place. I went on Friday evening after work on one good friend recommendation. It's a nice little place really clean and as soon as you pull over you can smell the bbq wich to me was a good sign. So inside they have a few tables. They also have some tables outside which it's pretty nice if there's a good weather. But well let's go to the important stuff "The Q" ok so I ordered me a Half rack of ribs and half a pound of Brisket. They come with some pickles and pickled onions and they were really good specially the pickles. Now on the meat side What ruined it for me was that the food was not hot that's a deal breaker for me although the ribs looked really good and they serve you plenty some pieces were dry however the ribs had really good flavor now on the Brisket side this has been one of the worst briskets I have ever tried yeah it was somewhat cold too and unforgivably dry. Yeah I know that why they have sauce and blah blah blah and while the 3 different bbq sauces they had were really good and flavorful nothing could rescue that brisket. I felt sorry for that cow that went to cow heaven in vain. I hope I just catch them in a bad day food wise because I also saw some of the sandwiches they make and they looked really good. So I will go back to see if they can redeem themselves. My point is if you are paying good money for bbq you should get your money worth Every Single Time. Service it's really good and as I've said I see a lot of potential in this place. Enjoy the ride there and may your brisket be hot and moist and the ribs too, heck! read more

Unfortunately this restaurant is closed until spring 2018. It looked delicious but it is very disappointing that it was closed

Nice surprise find! The guy working the counter was very friendly and helpful. Had a few different sandwiches- pulled pork, brisket, and a specialty that had multiple meats. Sauces were just OK. Cole slaw, baked beans, and macaroni and cheese were very good. Very good portion sizes, as well. Nice outdoor seating area with picnic tables. read more

I am a huge BBQ lover! To be fair I have only ever had the smoked pork by the pound, French fries, baked beans, cole slaw and Mac and cheese. Smoked pork is good but they recently seem to be giving less than before. The French fries are phenomenal especially if you get their special mayonnaise based sauce with it and add extra salt of course;) They used to give generous portions of the fries but again not recently. I am a fan of the cole slaw not so much of the mac and cheese. The baked beans are good also. Their homemade hot sauce is good and so is the BBQ sauce. The service could be quicker and friendlier. read more

There was a time when I would have said you cannot find good BBQ in PA. Boy was I wrong. This place does BBQ right. The pulled pork was moist flavorful and falling off the bone tender. The blacksmith sauce was a perfect counterpoint to the pork. Adding a hint of sweetness and pepper without overpowering the taste of the meat at all. The baked beans were smoky, sweet and tangy without being over the top in any of those categories. The Cole slaw was crisp and fresh tasting, with hints of apple and cucumber. The bacon and tomato Mac and cheese was out of this world. If you are ever near here, I urge you to take home a pound or two of this BBQ. You will not be disappointed. read more

The real deal!! To heck w Arby's.....Forest has the MEATS! Solid no-nonsense BBQ! I'm not a smart man, but I know what good BBQ is. Wings-Brisket-Pulled Pork? YEs Yes Yes!! Don't sleep on their sides...Mac & cheese = Food coma bliss! Looking for solid BBQ north of the Mason Dixon? Then look no further! Feed Forrest, Feed Forest, Feed! read more

Awesome all around. You won't regret coming here. Awesome wings and baked beans. Great service!

I wasn't expecting to find excellent BBQ in this part of the country. Happy to be wrong. These guys are great!

Brisket was best I have ever had. Also got the smoked chicken was very tasty. I really liked the different sauces the potato salad was unique Really neat place love the outside tables read more

Everything was perfect. My only complaint was that I ate way too much because the food was so good. Wasn't the easiest restaurant to find, but was totally worth the effort. read more

Good authentic food, good people, totally worth it. I was passing through town to go to the local Hershey attractions. We stopped here because the Yelp reviews were very good and it seemed to be the type of uniquely local spot I seek out. They didn't disappoint. The pulled pork was fantastic. It was soft, juicy and had a great smokey flavor with several sauces on the side. The ribs had a nice bark, smoke rings and a deceptive deep spice profile. A little spice kick in the rub. The meat was great but I would be happy to come back just for the bacon Mac and cheese and fries. I feel like I missed out by not trying all the sides. I would definitely come back if I lived closer. Negatives: 1) Ventilation not great. 2) Limited space to eat in. read more

Cool little BBQ joint. The pulled pork was great and the brisket was good. The highlight of our trip was the French fries and the dipping sauce. Malt vinegar aioli if I remember right. It was amazing. read more

AMAZING! We are in town on vacation from CT and decided to give this place a try based on all the 5 star yelp reviews and Forrest did not disappoint. We had the pulled pork and beef brisket sandwiches, both were excellent. (We liked the blacksmith BBQ sauce best). The coleslaw was great (although I recommend you ask for extra because the small ramekin isn't enough to cover your sandwich). We also got a side of potato salad (YUM) and an order of fries - the special sauce that comes with the fries is SOOO GOOOD. Highly recommend giving Forrest Feed a try if you like barbecue....you won't be disappointed. read more

Forrests Feed Co. Wood Fired Kitchen at 440 Walton Ave, Humelstown PA 17036 - just down the street from Hershey Park, off Route 39 - is a humble BBQ stand that takes smoked meats very seriously, offering up some of the best ribs, brisket, and pulled pork you can find in the Harrisburg area. Great tasting meat served as sandwiches or by the pound that you can jazz up with flavorful sauces and scrumptious sides. You will just melt over the Mac-n-Cheese, made fresh on the spot. This is real food made really good. They are open Fridays - Sundays from 10AM - 9PM. With convenient carry-out or a casual meal outdoors, this is where to get your fill of delicious BBQ all summer long. read more

What a find. Don't be scared of the look!! Food was fantastic. Cooked to perfection, brisket and pork were fantastic. People were friendly and price is just right. Serving sizes could geed two! read more

a bit out of the way, as it is a small place and sits way back off of the street. Found it by accident as we were driving by looking to avoid a national chain restaurant. Pulled pork sandwich was very, very good and reasonably priced with good portions. Dining companion thought the baked beans were very good as well. The potato salad had good texture, but had a spice I didn't like. Next time i'm in Hershey, its on my list of must dos! read more

Really great quality BBQ! I got the pork sandwich and a side of macaroni & cheese - loved both! Their sauces are all homemade, and the pork was super juicy and didn't even need sauce to stay moist. I would definitely stop in here again! read more

Amazing BBQ restaurant. We traveled from out of town and relied on reviews to get us here. So good. It's a tiny place off the road. Eat here. You'll be happy. read more

A group of us were in town for a field hockey tournament at Lower Dauphin Middle School. We are from Chester County near Phila. It was 2:30 and we needed a late lunch. This place was perfect. Nice new picnic tables with umbrella's to sit outside. Bit also a nice small eating area inside. But the BBQ was quality. If the have the half smoked chickens get them. They are great. As we're the rack of ribs. They had other very good options as well but those were my favorites. And they cater I found out so might be throwing a BBQ party at home and importing these guys down. read more

These guys don't play. You don't know what to get split the Forrest and Jenny with a friend. I put on my status about the food "The real deal Holyfield". Parking and Seating is tight due to its location but you find good food no matter where it is. read more

Great BBQ! Had the pulled pork, brisket sandwich, ribs and wings. All were great with the honey bbq sauce. Will definitely be back. Thank you guys for some great bbq. read more

Got the smokestack and it was delicious. Great flavor, cooked to perfection, and friendly service.

Can't get enough of this place! The barbecue is the BEST, the potato salad is out of this world, the mac & cheese is amazing, and the fries with special aioli are to die for. The wings, while not my favorite in Hummelstown, are HUGE. Keep up the great work, guys! read more

They do smoked and BBQ right here. The rustic decor all adds up to the grassroots feel of the place. Take out was complete and correct as ordered. The large portions ensure everyone is getting leftovers. The pulled pork was melt in your mouth good. The smoked chicken wings awesome, too. Don't hesitate this place is the real deal. read more

By far the best BBQ I have ever eaten. Small place with very limited seating inside and picnic tables outside. Also has limited hours as well. All of their BBQ is to perfection...I've had both the ribs and brisket. Sides are delicious as well and the portions are massive. Friendly service. Definitely recommended for BBQ! read more

Everything was delicious. We loved the sauces, the meat was amazing. I am picky and hate when there are too many fatty pieces - every bite here was delicious and perfect! We can't wait to return! read more

A ok. Limited menu and seating. A tad expensive considering fries are xtra. Good sandwiches. Fries were greasy. Cole slaw basic.

Just like being in Texas! Great beef BBQ and red sauce. Extras also great. Try it out! read more

Drove by last night and found the place closed. Made a special trip for lunch before heading home. Was the first customer and got awesome service and great food. Tried a few things and loved it all. Might have been the best french fries I ever had. Definitely coming back my next time in town. Love these off the beaten path places. If you like the vibe and want great food get here for a meal. You will leave here happy. read more

We stumbled on this place after taking a wrong turn. It looked so authentic, so basic, we had to check out the Yelp reviews. We love a good brisket. Well the reviews were awesome so despite three kids that had their doubts we went ahead and gave it a shot. Truly a life-changing BBQ. I am ruined for all other bbq. Same for everyone else. The portions are so big we wonder how they make any money. Beans, mac and cheese, also amazing. Smoked chicken fantastic. Wings were so fresh and meaty. I can't say enough good things about this place. The only sad part is we are probably never going back to Hershey PA... so unless he starts freezing and shipping we won't get to savor the amazingness again. Sniff. read more

This might be the best BBQ I've ever had. Fantastic meats, delicious sauces, best pickled onions and peppers ever. Had the Smokestack sandwich which was enough for two people, potato salad, Mac & cheese and fries. Super fresh food and very friendly service. I can't wait to go back!! read more

Best BBQ in central PA! Moved here from St. Louis, so it's tough to find any BBQ that can compare. Forrests Feed is good though, and my favorite here! read more

Wow. Great food, the pulled pork sandwich was great. The Mac and cheese was as good as I've had and baked beans were really good. Highly recommend. Only a couple tables inside and picnic tables outside. Best BBQ I've had in the north! read more

The only thing that I'm upset about is that I can only give this place 5 stars. This should get 10 stars! This is BY FAR the best barbeque I have eaten. The sides are all likewise phenomenal. It is a little hard to find (watch for the signs on Main St). and in the back alley, but don't let that stop you from trying to get here! read more

They sold only 20-ounce bottled soda & water for drinks, no ice tea. The outside picnic table and overhead canopy we ate our food at was very filthy, the canopy had green stains (tree pollen?) all over it with dirt/leaves/cobwebs hanging down above our plates of food that did not help with our appetite. They just needed to be brushed off with a broom & sprayed down with a water hose at least once a week, but I guess that is too much trouble for their business. My family & I will never be back. read more

Stopped while in the area and it was great! We had the "Forrest and Jenny". It was perfect for two to share. Serving size was generous portions! We will be back! The mac and cheese is amazing! read more

I've gone to Forrest Feed a few times, dating back to their days when they operated in the gravel lot. I wasn't a fan of their brisket. However, their pulled pork and ribs are very good. I also enjoyed their sauces. I hope to see more options down the road (corn bread, chicken, etc). read more