Fonta's Pizza

Wow! This was my first time eating here and it was so good!! The crust was absolutely perfect. Just…read morethe way a pizza should be. And I'm so so picky. We won't be getting pizza anywhere else from now on. And their specials are pretty good!

I've eaten here a few times over the last decade or so while staying in g Greeley. The pizza is…read moregood, thin crust style pizza. At some point, they eliminated Hawaiian from their menu, so if you like Hawaiian style, you're SOL. It used to be one of their best pies. We ordered some large orders of 8 or more pizzas a few times for business meetings and they got our order wrong every time. Calling to resolve issues was tedious, but they did get is taken care of. They're ok in a pinch, but I wouldn't recommend them

Greek & 1/2 Pep 1/2 Cheese

We ordered a 1/2 cheese 1/2 Canadian bacon and pineapple, whoever made the pizza couldn't figure out how to put that all on one pie.

See all

Ice cold pizza.

Santeramo's Pizza House

3.9(161 reviews)

1.3 mi

As always the food is excellent. In this review I would like to point out how amazing the wait…read morestaff is. I have had the best experiences with the wait staff. Always friendly, funny, personable and making the dining experience simply the best.

The food service and ambiance was excellent as usual. Great pizza, salads and an excellent glass of…read morePrimitivo Red Zin wine. The service was fast friendly and excellent.

Patio looking at front of restaurant

Baked Shrimp Alfredo Pasta Alfredo

See all

View looking out on patio

Marco's Pizza

3.4(48 reviews)

2.4 mi

Stopped in to the Greeley location to order a few pizzas to take home…read more We were looking at the posted menu board and one of the items listed (a pizza) was way cheaper than the others so we asked if that was accurate and the guy had a snarky, rude tone and said give me a break - isn't it obvious that is an error! Actually no, I would expect the business to have the correct menu and prices displayed and that they would correct it if there was an error. So condescending and rude! If this was the only pizza place available, I'd never have pizza again because I don't like being treated poorly when I'm spending my hard earned money.

I have eaten pizzas from at least 10 states, each from at least five cities in each....this pizza…read morewas about as lack-luster in flavor as most any other, eaten. Not close to flavor quality, as anticipated, therefore not worth the money. May be that this location missed the flavor train.

See all

Pizza Street Greeley

3.6(23 reviews)

2.4 mi

First Time ordering and pizza was very good - lacking nothing, Wings were the best we have had in…read morea very long time (wing street being the worst) Delivery time was overestimated and a very pleasant surprise when delivered and every thing was hot (wings hot enough to burn fingers)! Thank you! Doreen Hayes, 3414 Trinidad St, Evans, CO

This place is way over priced for the pizza they sell, 2 10" pizzas almost $40.00 pretty…read moreridiculous. First time and last time I'll order from here again even if the second pizza was half price.

Belly-O Sandwiches

Cheesy Bread

See all

What a delicious spread!

Original Roma Pizza - 16th St. Greeley

3.6(184 reviews)

1.0 mi

Romas has always been our go-to place for Carolli's- I have been eating here since high…read moreschool-where my best friend got me addicted to them. As expected, their prices have gone up, so make sure you print out a coupon from their website that allows you to save 40% off. Another tip...order spaghetti sauce instead of the Carolli sauce-you won't regret it!!

This was once a place I regularly recommended, which makes its recent decline particularly…read moredisappointing. While the specials remain one of the few bright spots, the broader experience is less than impressive. The kitchen was notably slow, the pizza arrived with a burnt bottom crust, and service is inconsistent. Most concerning is management's response to a routine question regarding a service charge... rather than addressing it professionally, the matter was handled with unnecessary hostility and followed by an inappropriate private message. A restaurant's leadership sets the tone for the entire operation, and based on recent experiences, that tone appears to be contributing to the establishment's downward trajectory. I hope they are able to make meaningful changes. Update: After posting this review, the owner texted me: 'Don't EVER come here again. You are not allowed and police will be called. Have the day you deserve.' Screenshots retained. Readers can draw their own conclusions regarding professionalism

They forgot the sauce. The chicken was funky and not edible.

Burnt calzone

See all

Cheese Pizza

Bravos Philly's & Pizza

4.3(56 reviews)

0.9 mi

Great place with a variety of casual food menu options. Today, I had the Chicken Gryo with fries…read more An excellent lunch. Fresh. And served almost instantly. Owner was working behind the counter and is always friendly.

I wanted to like this place, but the overall experience fell short…read more Food-wise, it's just okay. I ordered a cheese slice, and it wasn't anything memorable. The flavor was very bland-- mostly just tomato sauce and cheese without much depth-- and the crust was overly doughy, almost undercooked. The bigger issue was the service and overall operation. They're listed as opening at 11 AM, but when I arrived with another customer, the doors didn't even open until 11:10 AM. Even then, they clearly weren't ready to be open. There were no slices available, and it didn't feel like they were anywhere close to being prepared for customers. The atmosphere didn't help either. The interaction felt somewhat rude and dismissive, with a lot of excuses instead of solutions. There is a sign stating "no public restrooms," which I initially didn't realize also applied to paying customers. During my visit, two different people came in asking to use the restroom-- want to use it in another just to wash their hands-- and both were returned away. After the second request, the employee put "out of order" signs on both of the restroom doors, which felt misleading. Overall, the experience felt disorganized and underwhelming. The food is mediocre, and the service doesn't make up for it.

Full menu.

Regular Philly cheesesteak on a great roll.

See all

Front of the restaurant.

Roma West

2.9(83 reviews)

4.6 mi

We LOVED when Pizza Roma was near our home in Thornton and ate there often. Likewise, we were…read morebummed when it closed. We found out there is one in Greeley so called and did a to-go order. Let me tell you. We ordered 17 CAROLIS (calzones) and not only was the ordering super easy over the phone (took less than 5 minutes and the read back was perfect), our order was ready right on time, the hostess read it back to me again and counted them out in front of us. Phenomenal for such a large group. And the food is amazing. Very well done.

As a former cafe owner, I really struggle with this as I know, there are always bad nights…read more I have been meeting a friend at this location for over 6 years and the decline of quality, service and general "give a damn" has declined so much over the past two years. Tonight's experience was the end of an era. We won't be back. A raw Caroli, a server who didn't care (I had to approach her about the raw food after 15 minutes) and an overall terrible experience. Sorry Roma West, why can't Greeley have nice things?! You used to do so much better!

See all

Blackjack Pizza & Salads

2.4(21 reviews)

3.2 mi

For delivery it's okay. Our pizza was okay…read more My boyfriends wings were okay. The lack of napkins brought to our hotel room sucked. But overall it was an OKAY experience. I have had better & I have had worse.

I love their sauce but how is this ok!? Boneless hot wings. More like burnt chicken piecesread more

Burnt pieces of chicken for boneless wings. Ridiculous.

See all

A whole grasshopper!

Bulldog Pub & Grub

3.8(95 reviews)

5.0 mi

I've been coming here for a while now, and there is no question Covid sucked. They did their best…read moreto accommodate everyone, including the employees. Things are back open again and I come here almost daily (a benefit from working from home which is a 10 min walk.) and the quality and taste of the food has not changed. (This means they never cut back on the quality of their ingredients to cut costs during the lock down.) There are many items on the menu I have yet to try as I am a pizza guy and theirs is THE.BEST. As I'm writing this review, the owner is taking orders, helping the bartender and even interacting with the kids that want to see all the Star Wars stuff that is all over the place. :) This has always reminds me of the small pubs back home where community is key and people really do "know your name.". Never stop doing what you're doing. :)

Service was sparse, but understandable for a collegiate football game...our neighbors were cordial,…read morewith great mannered kids. Lacking two draft beers, when this was a planned event, is not what I consider to be quality management of a resturaunt...ill prepared to take care of guests. Will not consider a return trip. After the news that a second requested glass of beer would not be available, we opted out of attempting to order that pizza....not sure we would have gotten that, so instead went home, drank our own beer...not one glass at $6.78/ glass! Our homemade pizza sure did hit the spot, tho!

Parmesan Garlic Bread Sticks

Can't miss us with this vintage piece of awesomeness.

See all

MOD Pizza

4.5(64 reviews)

3.1 mi

Amazing customer service!! MOD pizza was delicious and amazingly helpful!…read more I tried ordering online (through my computer google chrome) and I came across an issue with the payment option. I had a gift card and I was going to pay the remaining funds with a credit card. The computer system would not recognize the gift card as a method of payment. I ended up calling the location. The employee I talked to was so incredibly helpful and very apologetic! She was able to take my order over the phone and still have it ready to pick up and hour later (I placed the order around 545pm and was able to pick up at 715pm). She also offered me a discount for the inconvenience. She said I could arrive at 715pm and use the gift card and the credit card. When we arrived the business had a lot of safety measures in place because of COVID. It made me feel better. We got our pizza and was in and out within minutes! Such friendly and kind service!!! The pizza was delicious! We got a Maddy (cheese pizza) and a Mad Dog (cheese pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and ground beef). I didn't get photos of the pizza (we were starving) but I do highly recommend them! I can't wait to go back!!

The crew is super friendly. The prices are good. I was upset that my pizza was burnt but didn't…read morenotice until we got home. I will take friendly staff over anything any given day.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

St L.

6 years ago

Must be owned by leftist liberals, read on... Went in to Fonta's to buy a take home pizza, I have exemptions for mask wearing, so didn't wear one to walk in to pay. The Counter person was handing me a mask to wear and I explained about the exemptions, 1)Hearing, 2) Medical, 3) Disability. They would not hear any of it. One of the owners I believe threatened me with saying If I didn't follow their rules, they would call the police. I am not sick, would not even go to town if I was sick, They allow people to eat in the restaurant but I can't walk in to pay for my pizza and leave. I gave them my money, and waited about 2 minutes outside for the food my wife and granddaughter were waiting at home for. I will never go to Fonta's again due to their Covid stupidity, Liberal ignorant attitudes and overall poor decision on dealing with a customer. The amount of people in this country wanting to be sheep is growing every day. I pray that they will remember what freedom was once the power's that be have taken it away from them. read more

Natalie G.

9 years ago

I came here for lunch with my family. The lunch specials are reasonably priced and you get a huge portion for the money. I ordered the spaghetti with meatballs lunch special which comes with garlic bread, salad and soda. My aunt had the 1/2 lasagna lunch and my dad had the pizza lunch special. The spaghetti sauce wasn't my favorite but the meatballs were good. I tried my dad's pizza and it was very good although a little too greasy. We all had leftovers to take home. read more

K Janet E.

14 years ago

we are the first to complain if service or food is not as should be. likewise,we are the first to say outstanding when the food is exceptional and the restaurant is consistent in cleanliness and service. we have eaten at Fontas for at least 25 years and our only complaint is that now we have retired to arizona Fontas doesn't deliver. You can not go wrong with the pizza, gyro, spaghetti and their salads are outstanding.casual, smells just as good as it tastes. read more

Fonta L.

14 years ago

since the resturant has my first name which is Fonta....I'm will give you all a five star...I hope that one day I can vist the resturant....the place sounds really good. read more

Ed E.

2 years ago

service is always as good as the food., great family ran business with a good variety of food.,

John B.

13 years ago

Great pizza and nice people, I really enjoy going there.

Chad L.

13 years ago

Best Pizza in Greeley.

Jr S.

15 years ago

Really good food.

Fonta's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Restaurants near Fonta's Pizza

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Things to Do near Fonta's Pizza

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Coffee near Fonta's Pizza

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Desserts near Fonta's Pizza

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Parking near Fonta's Pizza

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Breakfast near Fonta's Pizza

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Dinner near Fonta's Pizza

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Shopping near Fonta's Pizza

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Burgers near Fonta's Pizza

BEST of Greeley, Colorado Movie Theatre near Fonta's Pizza

Best of Greeley

Things to do in Greeley

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Fonta's Pizza also viewed

Santeramo's Pizza House

3.9

(161 reviews)

The food service and ambiance was excellent as usual. Great pizza, salads and an excellent glass of…read morePrimitivo Red Zin wine. The service was fast friendly and excellent.

Really classic pizza. Crust is thin and crunchy, sauce is flavorful without being too sweet. A…read moreslice cost me only $4.60 after tax. Would absolutely recommend!!

One of the best pizza restaurants in town. Dine inside or on their patio or take out.read more

Roma Windsor

3.3

(75 reviews)

My recent carry out experience at Roma Windsor left me thoroughly impressed and eager to share the…read morejoy of Italian cuisine and customer service done right. I order from Roma quite often, probably 2-3 times a month but have never taken the time to write a review . From my online order to pick up, it usually goes off without a hitch. This past time there was a mix up and I received someone else's order. I phoned the restaurant and the person I spoke to was very apologetic and quickly offered to remake the order or give me a credit. Accidents happen and they did everything they could to make it right. This is the first time in probably 30-40 orders. Kudos! It was clear that they take great pride in their craft. We usually order caroli's, pizza and occasionally lasagna. You can count on the food being fresh and great tasting. The food is made when ordered and is ready when they promise. Overall, my experience at Roma Windsor was nothing short of exceptional. If you're craving Italian cuisine made with love and passion, look no further than Roma!

My next door neighbor invited my wife and I for dinner at Roma Windsor. We have never been to Roma…read morerestaurant and we are excited to check it out for the first time. We arrived at 6pm and the restaurant was not crowded at all. As soon as the 3 of us walked in, we were greeted by a young lady hostess with a big smile. She welcomed us in. As she was walking us to our table, I was checking out the ambiance of the restaurant. I noticed that the restaurant is pretty old looking. The ceiling still has the popcorn ceiling design. But, the rest has an Italian accent vibe to it. I checked right away if the dining area was clean. It sure was very clean. Our waitress was very friendly and professional. We told her that my wife and I first time eating here. She was going over their menu since it was our first time. That's very nice of her. We told her that my wife has Gluten allergies and asked if they have any gluten free options. Unfortunately, they only have one option which is their medium size pizza. My wife ordered the GF medium size pizza with Canadian bacon topping. I ordered their Tuesday dinner special, which is the full size spaghetti with spicy Italian sausage and toasted garlic bread. My neighbor ordered the Ravioli and spaghetti combination. Around 25-30 min later, we finally got our food. Everything came out hot and fresh. Our waitress was attentive. She checked on us a couple of times to make sure everything is OK. Now, let's talk about the food. Unfortunately, my wife didn't enjoy her GF pizza. The GF pizza crust was very hard and the pizza sauce was bland. My wife asked me to try her GF pizza and she was right. The crust was hard and the pizza tasted very bland. And this GF medium size with one topping cost $18.25. Overpriced!!! Also, my wife felt sick when we got home. Probably due to cross contamination. It appears that this restaurant has one GF option, but does not know how to prepare the GF food and avoid cross contamination. BEWARE!! Now, my spaghetti with spicy Italian sausage dinner. Tuesday night, the full size spaghetti with a choice of meat and 2 toasted garlic bread is only $10.00. What a great deal!! As far as the taste, unfortunately, it was too bland for me. The spaghetti sauce is definitely not homemade, it's definitely a canned spaghetti sauce. The Italian sausage is supposed to be spicy, but there's no kick to it at all. It was also bland. The sausage was boiled in water, instead of flame broiled or cooked in a flat skillet to give it some charred flavor. Very disappointing. With that being said, we won't be coming back at Roma restaurant. My wife can't try anything else, except their GF pizza options which she didn't enjoy and got sick from cross contamination.

JJ's Wood Fired Pizza

4.2

(145 reviews)

We've known about JJ's for years, finally stopped in and tried the pizza and wings - both were…read moregreat. JJ's nice casual place with quick service. We'll be back.

JJs pizza was very good! We had the Diavolo pizza and a pepperoni and black olive…read more The atmosphere inside is laid back and great. Tons of beer on tap. Plenty of TVs to watch sports games. Their caesar salad could use some work, but that's my only complaint. The food came fast and the pizza guys are very hard workers! JJ's is definitely worth the hype!

Mama Roni's Pizza

3.1

(75 reviews)