This is our most fav place that we have become regulars. We are complete nerda when it comes to British life so this place is perfect! The Service is EXCELLENT- The Food is AMAZING!!! The Ambiance is just so adorable, calm, inviting, bright and you are NOT RUSHED. The teas are exquisite, the pace of your stay is PERFECT- we have gone to the Brunch MANY times since we found this place a few months ago- So much so they know us now! Thank you Ryan- our friendly, competent, kind server! Your smile makes me very welcome . The entire staff makes us feel welcome! Thank you @FlorrieKayes Tearoom for making a comfy, delicious and delightful escape for this couple from Newburgh. 10/10!!!! read more

See all

We came out just us girls for a nice afternoon tea. The fam has been bragging about this place and it does not disappoint! The scones are out of this world and so are the teas. They're all Harney and Sons teas which are amazing. We ordered four different pots which was nice to share and try new teas. I ordered the chicken sandwich on cheddar scone and it was so so good! A little spice too which was very tasty. Everyone was happy with their meals. The dining room is decorated like a fancy tea house. The china and everything was mismatched which was great. I loved that. read more

See all

I am SO happy with Florrie Kaye's new location! It's such a beautiful space - separate area for parties and a large outdoor seating in front. Cute bar as well. I attended about a 30 person party here. Having a separate room was great. The staff were so friendly and so kind. There were a few allergens in our group. I am a vegetarian and someone else was gluten-free. I had plenty to eat and there was a separate plate each course brought out for my gluten free neighbor. I would absolutely trust this place enough to bring my celiac boyfriend after how I saw they separated everything! The food was delicious and it was such a great event. Everyone enjoyed themselves, not a single complaint. Highly recommend! read more

Florrie Kaye's Tearoom - Dessert platters for group event! - British Near Me - Brewster, New York

The restaurant itself is nicely decorated. Service is great. The food was "meh". The scones were awful. The supposedly pride themselves on a family recipe. They were hard and tasted only of baking soda. I would hide that recipe if I were them. read more

Such a cute restaurant, perfectly themed for a tea party! Large menu with unique options, as well as an enormous list of teas. They had alcoholic beverages as well. The scone sampler was great and gave us a good taste of everything. I really enjoyed my scone-wich as well. The Royal Wedding tea was also delicious and I am not typically a huge tea fan. Service was a little slow, but they were also quite busy. Was a great place to chat with friends amongst good food and drink. I found prices very reasonable too! read more

Florrie Kaye's Tearoom - Hot Honey Scone -Wich - British Near Me - Brewster, New York

I almost didn't rate this place but as a math guy, I have a pet peeve that when you go to restaurants, the restaurant often knows that you won't bother calculating the tip and tells you what the tip should be if, say, you want to tip 20%. When I got the recepit, I was going to give 20% but instantly noticed that the math didn't check out. If I were to tip 20% on the check, plus the tax, plus being generous and tipping on the credit card fee, the tip would be $22.43 or $22.44. Not tipping on the credit card fee would make the tip lower, and not tipping on the tax would make it even lower, $20.10. The credit card receipt shows $23.08 for a 20%, but this is actually pennies short of a 23% tip. The reason I can't excuse it is, it's not like the waitress did the calculation poorly. The computer does it, so the business does it. The computer itself is programmed to purposely inflate the tip. You'd be surprised how many businesses do this. It's an unreasonable number of them. Tip culture is already getting out of hand. I tip often AND WELL, and I tipped my waitress and actual 20%, but nickel and diming customers in hopes that they don't bother doing the math is not OK. 1 star just for that. read more

Florrie Kaye's Tearoom - Receipt with false tip calculation - British Near Me - Brewster, New York

This was such an undoubtedly successful venue for a recent get together of three close friends that we have committed to visit Florrie Kaye's Tearoom every other month for a repeat opportunity to explore the menu. We had the tiered afternoon tea for three people and we all brought home leftovers. The highlights for me personally were the scones and the tea sandwiches. I am looking forward to trying their soups, their savory puddings, and their pavlova. Love the unique and purposefully varied china settings and pots as well as the tongue-in-cheek humor of the decorating. It's clean, friendly, and well-organized. All the staff was unfailingly polite. Looking forward to the next visit. read more

While visiting Connecticut, I found this place because my mother loves tearooms'. We were not disappointed. Walkin was not an issue, staff was very friendly. Cream cheese cucumber sandwiches and the Cole slaw were delicious. Green hot cinnamon tea was wonderful. read more

Florrie Kaye's Tearoom - British Near Me - Brewster, New York

We had a lovely ladies luncheon this afternoon. The vibe was relaxed and pleasant the food was very good(great tea!). Our server was very sweet. I feel the need to say that I was embarrassed for us as we were told, after being offered dessert, that the next party was here...our pot of tea came along with a "to go" cup. (No gentle hint there). We quite literally choked our dessert down and stood up while the table was being cleared. Very uncomfortable. There needs to be better communication or a better way to handle this situation. We took our party outside and enjoyed the rest of our visit. Thanks but... read more

I love this place so much :) The tea selection is huge, and the scones and bites are so tasty. This is such a cute spot to visit and chat with a friend for an hour or two. They also have a little shop in the back with teas, journals, cards, etc. read more

Delicious and very special time! The staff were very friendly and helpful. They guided us to making the right choices of beverages!

Florrie Kaye's is absolutely adorable. They offer a wide variety of tea options, and having tried their signature sweet and savory scones, I can confidently say you can't go wrong with any of them. The salads are delicious, and the sandwiches are great too. If you're having trouble deciding, I recommend the afternoon tea so you can get a little bit of everything. read more

Florrie Kaye's Tearoom - Afternoon TeaAfter - British Near Me - Brewster, New York

See all

Great selection of teas with very kind servers! Parking is big challenging on a busy Saturday morning but my mom enjoyed her 75th birthday. read more

See all

If you ever want to go to a true English tea...Florie Kaye's is the place you should go to. The English sandwiches, scones with clotted cream, and sweets were amazing. The service was attentive and restaurant makes you feel like you are in England! read more

One of my favorite places to eat of all time. A little background info, England is one of my favorite places to travel to. I love the food there, I'm obsessed with tea time and Harrods. Just everything. Let me tell you, Florrie Kaye's matches that vibe and quality to the T. I feel like I'm back in England. It really is mind blowing how they are enable to encapsulate the flavor in their food as if I was eating it at Harrods. It really scratches that itch if I'm craving it and don't feel like flying across the pond to have that experience. read more

See all

When you walk in you are taking a step into England. They have a large selection of loose tea. They have everything you can think of on terms, of food. They definitely have some English food. Some of the English food has a fusion flare. They inside is definitely formal. read more

Five stars - not just for the afternoon tea, but for the excellent service. We were asked if anyone in our party had food allergies. I told the manager/host that I have a flaxseed allergy and that I just can't eat multigrain bread. She went above and beyond by calling (I was eavesdropping- so I could be wrong) the bakery and perhaps the owner to check that there wasn't flax in the wheat or white bread that our tea sandwiches were made with. I truly appreciated the concern and diligence that were given to my specific needs. Our afternoon tea was delightful. Our server was very attentive and everything from the sandwiches to the scones to the variety of sweets was delicious. I look forward to returning to Florrie Kay's for afternoon tea again. read more

I've been coming to Florrie Kay's Tea Room for years, even before they moved to their new location, and it has truly been a special place for me and my mom. Lately, we've been coming weekly or at least biweekly because we genuinely enjoy the atmosphere and the experience. The tea, presentation, and overall charm are lovely, and Jose especially deserves recognition. He is incredibly helpful, a great conversationalist, and one of the hardest workers there. He always makes us feel welcome, and his service is a big reason we continue to come back. We also make it a point to tip well and support the business, including posting and tagging them on social media when we visit. That's why it feels a little disappointing that after all these years of being loyal regulars, we're still charged a $6 sharing fee when my mom and I split a tea tower. I completely understand businesses having policies, but as frequent guests who consistently support the tea room, it does feel a bit hurtful. We truly love coming here and want to continue supporting them. I just hope there might be some consideration for longtime regulars in situations like this. read more

UPDATE: Before leaving our delightful afternoon tea last week, I visited the cake counter and selected a savory scone and pan au chocolate for my friends, husband, since I kept her so long. The word on the street is that he loved the treats. Must return soon! read more

See all

I'm extremely disappointed with how our baby shower reservation was handled. Cancelling the event last minute due to snow was unacceptable, especially since the snow had stopped early that morning and there was ample time to clear the parking lot. Every other establishment in the area was open. We also had guests traveling from out of state who were already planning to attend. The communication was equally unprofessional. I was left in limbo for an entire day when this could have been addressed sooner. I was told someone would call me Friday night, yet no one reached out until Saturday. On top of that, I received multiple calls questioning guest numbers even though I was clearly and promptly communicating updates as they changed with either you or your staff. Because of the last-minute cancellation, we had to scramble to find another restaurant. Thankfully, another establishment accommodated our group on short notice and provided excellent service -- something we did not experience here. This situation caused unnecessary stress and inconvenience and reflects very poorly on your professionalism and management. I have also read through all the yelp reviews and have noticed when you get a comment that is not favorable you seem to attack that person - thus the reason for the long text message. In response to you below 1. I clearly told your staff and you that this was a baby shower when I called back in November. I shouldn't have to communicate during every conversation that this was a baby shower. You should have it in your notes as a professional. 2. I shouldn't have to tell you where my guests are traveling from when I booked a reservation. Nor did you ask the importance of the event and the consequences of cancelling. 3. You did leave me a voice mail at 9:40 I. The morning asking if I was still planning the event. You also sent a text message to which I responded yes to you. All our guests were still planning on showing up. Not 20 minutes later you responded via text that you were closing the restaurant. However you also called me the night before the event asking me if I was planning on keeping the reservation. I told you yes and you responded that you would get back to me in an hour with you decision to open the restaurant or close. You did not communicate with me until the next day (the day of the event) 4. Yes we had 8 inches of snow which stopped by 8 AM that morning. As we live in the northeast this is not unusual and road crews usually work through the night to keep the roads clear as they did for this snow event. All roads were cleared down to the pavement by 10 AM when I went out. 5. You were not attacked publicly. I expressed my disappointment with your decision to cancel the reservation and the poor communication during the month prior. Instead of taking constructive criticism you take it as an attack on you personally. In order to grow as a business you need to hear the good the bad and the ugly. I also read a review from 12/27/25 where you cancelled a reservation someone had made for their mother's 84th birthday. You told me on numerous occasions that everyone else cancelled except me. Not true I sent you the same text message hoping I wouldn't have to post online but you did not respond to me read more

This is a true UK tea room in the classic style. The location is very convenient, just off route 22 in the quiet Clock Tower Commons with plenty of free parking. The tea selections are varied and presented loosely in large pots, as they should be, and the tea sandwiches are very traditional but with a little creative flair. If you've traveled the UK or Ireland , you know what a true afternoon tea is all about-- and so does Florrie Kaye's Tearoom. read more

If you need your high tea fix, you need to come here! Came here on a Sunday afternoon with a party of 9 and we sat comfortably! The choices for tea were endless. For appetizer we shared one of the tea sandwich towers. The scones were so good! (Pretty sure I would come back just for those). I was the odd one out when I ordered an Arnold Palmer to drink and for my entree ordered the ham and Brie croissant. Bonus: in the back of the restaurant they have a little store where you can buy tea and other British items! I ended up finding a pistachio spread I had been on the hunt for. ($14) read more

Florrie Kaye's Tearoom - Ham and Brie Sandwich - British Near Me - Brewster, New York

Really nice spot! Loved that you can have your own little tea pot and that everyone can try different things. The ambiance was very pretty and the service was fast and attentive. Only thing I did not like was the 3% up charge for using a credit or debit card. Maybe it's stated somewhere but I wasn't a huge fan of that. Id definitely go back but I would keep that charge in mind. read more

We went to brunch on Sunday with 4 adults and 3 children. I have to say the girls were very well behaved. The food was very good. Everything we had was delicious. We put in the big British hats and the girls loved it. The only complaint I had was the staff was very unfriendly. That bothered me when my granddaughters said hello to our server and she could barely say hello. Oh well, i guess she s not into kids. Other than that the food was wonderful. 2 of us had the chicken and waffles which was amazing read more

My favorite place to visit. Always loved going out for tea at spots like these, so when I found out about this spot I was really excited. So cute & fun. Service is always great. If you plan to go you should make a reservation before going most of the time the place is booked solid. I've liked almost everything I've had here. read more

Florrie Kaye's Tearoom - Afternoon Tea - British Near Me - Brewster, New York

This is now one of my favorite places to go with the ladies in my family when I visit New York! The ambiance, food, and service are all wonderful! We have gotten the afternoon tea towers before and those are always fun to get with friends. The tea sandwiches are amazing, but nothing beats the happiness you feel when you eat one of the scones! There are so many tea choices that it can seem overwhelming, but the staff are always happy to help you find one that you will love! Reservations are not required but I highly recommend making one because this place can get busy! read more

Florrie Kaye's Tearoom - The best scones EVER! - British Near Me - Brewster, New York

See all

The food was fresh. The service was excellent. A nice place for a party, family, special tea with granddaughter, or solo. I cannot wait to try their new location. read more

See all

cutest place!!! I came across Florrie Kaye's Tearoom while looking for afternoon tea spots in the area. I was able to make a reservation the morning of on a Sunday. The tea room was so cute, decorated with beautiful china, plants, frames. We ordered Afternoon Tea and Brunch Tower. It was a bit pricey $36 but it was a good amount of food and definitely worth it for the cute experience. They have an endless variety of tea. I love that all of the china are unique and the British decors. The service was fast and great. Can't wait to be back!! read more

See all

We have been here many times before and because service along with food is ALWAYS delicious I forget to post. However, yesterday, Easter Sunday, our reservation for 2 was beyond perfect. Service was excellent and the Chef is amazingly gifted with her talents. Thank you Chef! We ordered their brie appetizer and it was delicious served with beautiful small Italian sliced bread and green apple .. simply delicious. Also ordered their asparagus soup AMAZING FLAVORS WOW!!! That came with a delicious cheddar biscuit OUTSTANDING. Also their prime rib was OUTSTANDING. Not to mention the peach bellini. All so beautifully presented. We couldn't eat another thing. However, I did take a piece of cake chocolate icing, some raspberry filing to go. Arriving home we had it with milk and I wished to had gotten 2 pieces of cake to go!!! This restaurant never disappoints. It is wonderful for 2, 4, 8 ground and now they are open on Friday evenings for dinner!!! Cannot wait to go for dinner. Reservations strongly suggested. In the meantime, thank you All for making our Easter yesterday and everyone's Easter truly special. read more

Simply amazing! It was a wonderful group mother-daughter experience. I'll be coming back with my friends, too! They have a huge selection of interesting teas to choose from, an afternoon tea menu, a children's afternoon tea, a la carte menu items, alcohol, and British sweets! It was a great experience with delicious food! read more

A party of 10 ladies to celebrate my daughter in laws birthday. Florrie Kaye's could not have been more accommodating. The staff was lovely and the food delicious. Fun and different experience read more

See all

Florrie Kaye's tearoom is such a fun place! We came here today for my birthday and really enjoyed ourselves. The whole place is decorated top to bottom in sort of a "granny chic" vibe. The service was great and quick and they were able to accommodate my allergies even on the prefix afternoon tea platter which was really appreciated. This is the perfect place to take any special mom or grandma or little girl for a special event. It's a real treat. They have a cute little gift shop as well which just enhanced the experience because who doesn't love to shop! read more

Florrie Kaye's Tearoom - Afternoon Tea - British Near Me - Brewster, New York

After years of wanting to stop in here, the stars aligned and we were able to have brunch. The inside was cute, bright and decorated with various tea sets and British memorabilia. They have a very wide tea selection to fit any needs and we kept it simple and ordered the Afternoon Tea to get the full experience. The scones were delicious - highly recommend. The tea sandwiches were great but overall the tray was on the sweeter end. After we had ordered we saw some people get towers of just the tea sandwiches and scones on the side - which likely I would do in the future. The baked Brie starter was fantastic and highly recommend. Service was friendly and helpful answering our questions about the menu and providing tea recommendations. This is definitely a pricey experience but we left full and satisfied, so it's one experience I would say is worthwhile if you've been curious. read more

See all

I made a reservation on Monday for today for my mom's 84th birthday. It was for 8 people and when I called they informed me if anyone did not show there would be a $25 fee per person which is fine. What is not fine is that when we showed up today, the tea room was closed. When I called their number to see if I missed something, it said due to the weather they had closed. The roads were fine so I had no idea they would be closed. No one called me to let me know they would not be open. This is unprofessional. We will not be trying this tea room in the future. read more

If you want to feel like you suddenly transported yourself to England and are casually having afternoon tea time with your girl friends overlooking the London bridge. This is the spot! How random is this place? VERY. Does it disappoint: ABSOLUTELY NOT. I had been hear a few years ago pre pandemic and had the most amazing experience. We put on the hats, took silly pics, ordered tea and a few yummy things. My caffeine detox pushed me to come in here to pick up some loose leaf tea for us and to gift some to a friend. Even though it was already the end of the day right before closing time, we couldn't just walk in here and NOT sit down for afternoon tea. We did just that and my hubby LOVED it. It was 5 o'clock somewhere but with a different approach: decaf tea and scones. Sometimes you have to switch things up a bit. We all love to drink and have a good time but here we did just that. They have over 90 tea selections and they're all Harney & Sons. It's so hard to pick but the girls are so nice here and educate you through the whole process. I was so happy with my decaf choice: indigo tea, IT WAS BLUE!!!!!!!!! So obsessed that I took some home. Being a coffee girl tea doesn't really excite me up until now. This tearoom made my life. The blue tea!!! So so obsessed! The best part, they even had a gluten free scone! (Again, worst time to be on a detox from gluten and caffeine, but it was the right spot to come to!!!). It's the best one I've ever had! If you want to brunch, it's a great spot. If you want to afternoon tea it like we did, come on over. During the week isn't as crazy as weekends so I would definitely make weekend reservations if you're planning on coming by. AMAZING tea room! Amazing staff. PHENOMENAL selection. There's also a little gift shop you can buy little gifts to give to a special someone or even just a little detail. It's all about the small things for me. LOVE THIS PLACE. read more

See all

Busy fun place, very crowded for Sun afternoon. Good tea service. Nice touches for kids experience - make their own crown, juice instead of tea, etc. Servers seem frazzled. Even though they were polite about it, didn't like that we were told to leave promptly after paying as others waiting. Had a rez & didn't stay extra. read more

Service was amazing and food was great exceptional! Amazing choices my taste buds was very happy. Cute tea sets too that matches our clothes! Will definitely be back! read more

See all

Oh my goodness, this was really everything I'd hoped for. I tried to take my mom here for Mother's Day but it was booked up. I tried again for her birthday and was able to make a reservation. My grandma was also in the area so it was even more special. I was told they take reservations a year ahead. When you go inside, you feel like you're really in a little tea room. The tea selection is just marvelous. Everything you can think of. They have lunch items and pastries to choose from. We opted on including the "afternoon tea" for the table as well as a lunch dish and added an additional pot of tea. We were able to make one of the afternoon teas gluten free so I didn't miss out on anything. I really wanted everyone to enjoy the full experience. Of course there were plenty of leftovers. We had such an amazing time. It was a fun girls lunch full of bonding and tasty bites. I really loved this experience. read more

See all

Great fun! Our group of 7 included a 4 year old and a 93 year old and 2 vegetarians. We all had a great time!

Okay so I went back in Fall of 2024. This was my top pick of 2023. The food was not nearly as good. But the tea still was! The chicken salad sandwich was freezing cold and served on a bread that tasted only of sugar and molasses. The burger was lousy. The scones were okay. Sorry but had to update! read more