Flanders Bay BBQ is an unprepossessing place off Route 1 in Sullivan, and despite my 20+ year hunt for decent bbq in Maine (which is the culinary equivalent of the Holy Grail), we have been driving blithely by them for a while now.
But yesterday we were in search of a late lunch, and my husband suggested them. We had - again - driven by them a few hours earlier, so we knew they were open.
They have a limited menu, but that is a very good thing, apparently.
Rather than trying to be all things to all people, they seem to concentrate on doing a few things really well.
And I mean REALLY, REALLY WELL.
I don't know whether it was due to Covid considerations or not, but the proprietress met me outside the building and took our order. And, because of Covid, we only do takeout, anyway. My husband got the pulled pork sandwich and I got the brisket. I generally shy away from brisket because it can be unpleasantly fatty, but I had a taste for it this time, so I took a shot that it wouldn't be.
We each got a side (which are a la carte) - mac and cheese. I was going to get the cornbread, but it wasn't quite ready.
There was very little wait, and I put what there was of it to use - at the owner's suggestion - gathering silverware and filling some containers with their regular bbq sauce as well as one called "Mud", which my husband liked. I preferred the more typical sauce, but they have two others, I think, at least one of which was mustard based.
When the food was handed to me, I considered the bag to be small, frankly. We'd just been to Dystart's in Hermon a couple days before, and we literally got one of those big paper grocery bags with the handles CRAMMED FULL of food.
But I reserved my opinion as best I could as we went to a nearby water spot to eat.
And I was NOT disappointed at having done so.
The mac and cheese portions came in those Styrofoam bowls with lids, and it was literally the perfect size portion to go with the sandwich. And it was also the perfect accompaniment for the sandwich, too - nicely warm and cheesy, not too salty or too anything, but just right.
The sandwiches were about palm sized, the meat bookended by an innocuous white bread bun. The proprietress had mentioned that the sandwiches didn't need sauce, but, to me, the addition of the roll inherently calls out for sauce.
I cannot tell you how amazing that sandwich was. The strips of brisket were generously portioned - like thick cut bacon and then some. It was incredibly tender, and had that perfect amount of smoky flavor that hits the back of your mouth as you're eating it. And I'm amazed to say this - because I really don't like fat in/on my meat - but it was cooked so perfectly that the thin layer of fat atop the slices of brisket literally melted in my mouth, adding a burst of flavor and surprisingly pleasant mouth feel that took the whole sandwich to another level entirely.
My husband thoroughly enjoyed his pulled pork, too, of which I took a small bite, and it was great, too.
But I have to say that I probably won't ever get anything but the brisket (I am nothing if not a creature of habit in regards to food).
I am amazed to say that I have finally found the Holy Grail of truly excellent bbq in Maine. Outside of what I had (pre-Covid) in Texas last winter, this was easily the best bbq I've ever eaten. The only way I could be enticed not to order the brisket sandwich again would be if my husband wanted to split the sampler platter - where you get to choose several meats - with me. I'd definitely be into that.
The prices were absolutely spot-on for the exceptional quality of what you get for your dollar. We had two sandwiches and two sides, and I think we spent, like, $21 before tip - well worth every. single. penny.
One thing I didn't ask about but would like to see offered would be the bulk meats some bbq establishments offer. I'd be perfectly happy to take home a pound of brisket and spend an evening in the wonderful haze of a self-induced meat coma. In that instance - eating just the meat - I think I could easily eschew the use of sauce.
The meat is really that good.
Seriously.
Of course, this is fall in Maine, and the owner mentioned that that weekend was their 2nd to last before closing for the season. They're only open weekends. Check their FB page for days/hours.
I can't stress this enough: if you like really excellent bbq, get yourself to Flanders Bay BBQ.
I promise you won't regret it. read more