I moved to Sayville or year ago June. For the first six months I only ate at the five points Café! During the winter, we had takeout from there. It has such a nice ambience. The staff is always friendly and accommodating. They have the best veggie burger I've ever had.They have an acoustic musician on certain week days/weekends. It's my favorite restaurant. It's a real find and I love it as my regular stopIt's a must try read more

Five Points Cafe - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

Salad was good..They made it as I requested...Steamed shrimp. ..No oil. But I was disappointed that I was charged.fot a refill ...On ice. Tea! $5 for ice tea. Seemed a bit excessive I won't be back!! read more

Average. This is a "dressed up" Diner/Cafe that is a little worn. Think scuffed floors and tables. The menu is varied - Soups, Burgers, sandwiches, and the usual appetizers (Chicken Wings, Sliders, etc.) that we have come to expect. The standout of or entire meal was the large Pretzel that was served with a cheese sauce that had flavor. This was an appetizer - it was served warm and was fresh. The Clam Chowder soup was warm and tasty, the Bacon Cheese Burger was okay and a Chicken sandwich was underwhelming. Overall, nothing was a crave-able standout. If we were to return, we just order the French Onion Soup that appeared to be popular on neighboring tables. read more

I love coming to this place for the food, music and sitting outside. I wish I could give it 5 stars. But for some bizarre reason they put all the tall tables in front of the music. Therefore, no one can see the band. If you all read these reviews, please move the tall tables to the back corners. read more

What happened to this restaurant? Ordered two Southwest salads, boneless chicken wings and onion rings. The salads were floating in water and the chicken in them was so low quality most of it ended up in the garbage. The salads are supposed to come with a tortilla bowl which we did not get. The boneless chicken wings had one or two pieces that actually looked like they had chicken inside and the other pieces were so overcooked you couldn't even get your fork into them, they were just fried pieces of breading and half the pieces didn't even have any barbecue sauce on them. The onion rings tasted like fish, they definitely do not clean/change the fryer oil, they were terrible. The food here used to be decent, it's a shame that not one but all items ordered were terrible! read more

Comfortable atmosphere. There was great live music and although the lighting was a bit low we had a really nice meal. Be warned about sitting near the door on a colder weather day because there is a draft that comes in when it's opened. I ordered a pastrami sandwich with onion rings and a chocolate milkshake-- they were wonderful! Overall a great place to go for a casual dinner with some friends. Will be back soon... read more

Five Points Cafe - Pastrami sandwich, onion rings, and a chocolate shake - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

Great menu with many options. Patio area is large and comfortable with life music in the evening. Burgers are huge and tasty. The most delicious sweet patio fries with dipping sauce. Service always excellent! Great happy hour prices at the bar. read more

My friend and I had heard about this place and we wanted a good burger. Big mistake. We both ordered a specialty burger, I requested medium rare and my friend requested medium. Well there was so much stuff on the burger it took awhile to find out they were both well done. Actually dry, not moist and basically the burger itself had no flavor. If we had ordered a plain burger and not a specialty we would have learned this sooner. Also, the bun is too big. It took a few bites to get to try everything on the burger at once. Such a disappointment. We will not be going back and have shared this with others. The other issue is no parking. read more

Been coming here for years! Awesome food, great service, from management to kitchen staff, everyone makes you feel like family. Live music on the patio in the summer and inside in the winter months. Great cozy neighborhood place. read more

Awesome little place in Sayville for lunch or dinner. Service and food are always good!

I had the best server, Eric. He was so attentive and did a great job refilling our drinks. Food was so yummy and came out fast! Definitely recommend. Thanks Eric for the dining experience. read more

These burgers are the real deal! I don't think I've had a single one I didn't enjoy. Friendly and engaging staff. Live music is audibly pleasant and not too loud like other places. Drink menu is great. Definitely a great place for a night out in Sayville. read more

I love five points cafe. Their food and service are spot on. It's a great place to hear live music too. Love the patio in the summer.

Here for the first time. Everything is excellent. Had a wonderful breakfast. Had "The Riviera" eggs with Pesto and tomatoes. Our server Kate was so kind and efficient. Beautiful atmosphere. We sat outside. Would definitely recommend. read more

Five Points Cafe - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

Stopped by this Cafe last week, had a fantastic burger and a wonderful glass of CHARDONNAY!! Can't wait until my next visit. Highly recommend!! read more

I decided to come here despite the varied reviews, and I think I understand what's going on here. This is a SMALL, Bar and Grill. If that's not what you're expecting, you'll be disappointed. What it delivers on, however, is being exactly what it is. If the bar is packed, and it's very crowded, I would expect slow, and perhaps sketchy, service. That's just the nature of a little B&G. But we experienced neither - we were taken care of efficiently, despite quite a crowd. Started with the home-made chilli, and was VERY pleasantly surprised. This is GOOD stuff - a big bowl, nicely topped. My wife had potato-leek soup, and that was also excellent. The burgers are EXCELLENT, and were perfectly cooked. The only criticism I have, is that the buns are a little too big, and can overwhelm the burger (huge as it is). The meat and toppings were tasty enough to defy the need for ketchup, which is always (to me) the signal of a quality burger. Looking forward to another visit ! read more

The food here is okay, nothing to write home about. I only come here when it's nice out because the outdoor area is exceptional. Sayville has very few outdoor areas for restaurants. They usually have a live musician playing so grab a burger and beer next time it's nice out and you'll probably have a good time here. read more

Been here before, eating at the bar. Cuban was good, bartenders were nice. Tonight we ate in the dining room. Service was ok at best. Very slow to show up for first contact. Drinks took awhile to finally show up. A few empty tables, so I would not consider it busy. Chicken burrito was good. Ribs were good, all 3 of them. A half rack is usually a solid 5-6 ribs. Overall just ok. read more

Nice atmosphere, friendly service. The wait depends on time you arrive. The food is good, burgers, fries and some well put together sandwiches. Beer and wine are standard. Overall a nice place to have a decent beer and a burger. Live music some evenings. Nice to browse through the town after dinner. read more

See all

Nice outdoor seating, had lunch here one afternoon. I had the Grilled Ahi Tuna Salad and enjoyed it. Lots of tuna in this salad and it was delicious. They have a wasabi dressing which I tried on the side and it was great. Really forward with the wasabi flavor and heat. Pretty reasonably priced, I would certainly go back. read more

Five Points Cafe - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

One of my favorite places to sit down grab a burger and watch the game. The food here never disappoints and it's always a friendly environment. It's crowded but not packed which is great to have conversations with friends. I always grab a burger here with sweet potatoe fries. Never come away upset with the establishment. read more

Five Points Cafe - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

OK, I guess the burgers here might be good if you actually get what you want. They messed up the order. I ordered Medium Rare my date ordered well done. Mine was ordered with Cheddar and Bacon, hers American and Bacon. Well, the burgers came out the other way. My date hates pink meat in her burger and I do not like well done. We ended up switching burgers instead of sending them back for new ones, which was offered. Problem was that we had other food on the table and to wait for new burgers to be cooked, well it just didn't seem worth it. PS the onion rings are of the battered type and are really good, cooked perfect, but they need to give you the horseradish sauce with it. In the end, I mean really 5 points? Your a Burger place, you should get cooked preference correct. read more

Worst nachos on the planet.... Too much horse radish in the bloody mary.... Arnold Palmer was alright. In all fairness I did not try any of the burgers..... Hottie female waitstaff is the only good thing....come for one drink and the eye candy then move on.... read more

Another great burger! Downtown burger went down just fine. Sad that I added ketchup cause their "special sauce" is so good and enough to carry the burger without any added condiments. Sat outside with one of the big heaters and it was actually perfect! Even better is the kid treated- Score!!! This is a great Local Place with food worthy of recommending and a great vibe read more

The biggest con of this restaurant is the size. It's tiny, maybe 15 tables and a bar that seats about a dozen. We (party of 4) went after 7pm on a Thursday night and still had to wait 20 min for a table. In the summer, I imagine it's a little better because there is outdoor seating. Food is ok, service a little slow. Prices ok. I'm a die hard Stella Artois fan and there are two different sized chalices. They use the small ones and charge $6 for a beer. Not a fan of that. And the location on the yelp map is so wrong. It's on corner of Main and Railroad. Just west of split with Middle Road. read more

Five points has been a great place to eat and hear great music. Outside dining in downtown Sayville could get any better. Great job Jimmy!!!

Very solid cafe. Sandwiches and burgers are good, the fries are crispy and flavorful. It has a very nice outdoor seating area which is beautiful in the summer. It's right on Main Street so it's an easy stop when you're in town. Friendly staff rounds it out for a great experience. read more

Five Points Cafe - The Cuban with French fries - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

Tom My family and I have been enjoying 5 Points burgers and delicious food for many years. My wife enjoys the creative specials menu! The staff at 5 points is a big reason my family loves going there. They are very good with the kids. . 5 Points is like a second home to us. Oh and of course the fantastic live music.! We always look forward to family nights at 5 Points read more

A very nice restaurant, it had turned into a joke between my gf and I that we will never go on despite passing it so often. We finally did and it is well worth it. We had a band playing the night we were there. They were ok and not very loud so conversation was easy. Great spinach and artichoke dip, we both others the build your burgers and they were prepared as ordered and we delicious. Will absolutely do there again and recommend others to do the same. read more

Service was good, hamburger was raw. I wanted to like this place. They had live music on the patio.

I am a huge supporter of local businesses, but after coming to this establishment, I've lost so much respect for this one in particular. My boyfriend and I have been wanting to go here for quite sometime. We arrived a little after 2pm on Monday, 7/5, and decided to eat in the outdoor area. The crowd was steady but not overwhelmingly busy. After patiently waiting for 15-20 minutes, two parties came in after us and were served drinks and had their orders taken, 4-5 waitresses plus the hostess came out checking on other tables who have been already served and cleaning tables without acknowledging us. We wound up leaving and the waitress had the audacity to push in our chairs right after we left. On a brighter note, thank you La Tavola for being so accommodating. read more

Hamburger was tasty but not hot. Very good roll. Fresh ingredients. Good fries and rings. Good value. But ... They short you when you order a Stella on tap. Serve it in a 12 oz. when all other tap beers are 16 oz. Service is untrained and "really couldn't care." read more

Always a great place to stop and eat. Great service, and fun place to hang out when you're in town.

Went there to catch live music. Waitstaff was great and food was even better. Cuban sandwich was legit, chicken caprese sandwich was also fantastic. Fries are good and a great Guinness on tap. Will be back! read more

The selection here is great! I love that they have indoor and outdoor seating and lots of rotating specials. I think we came on an off day because I will say the food took a really long time to come out. I think they were short staffed in the kitchen. Our waitress kindly brought me an extra lemonade for free while we were waiting. It was well worth it though. I had one of their specials, a grilled vegetable sandwich which was very good and came on really delicious bread. The real star was the mac and cheese though. The waitress allowed me to sub in a side of mac and cheese instead of fries and it was really incredible! Super creamy and cheesy and just perfect. Will definitely be ordering that again next time I come. read more

Not busy and it took the waitress a lot of time to seat us. Food was adequate. My review is more for the management than anything else! Put more people on! read more

Great place! Great Service, Food and Location! Loved the outdoor seating area. My wife, daughter and I ate here on a late Friday afternoon. We had burgers which were each delicous! (great bun!) Serivce was friendly and fast! Would deffinitly come back again! read more

Service : eh, would've been better, if the owner had turned on the AC for the workers that clearly were exhausted from the heat Food: terrible. Diner food with restaurant prices. I got a medium RARE burger, came out gray, the way they put it together, if j tried to close it it would smear everywhere because of the huge chunks of avocado, instead of doing a spread and making things easier and better to eat. Fries were greasy and diner quality. Charged me for bacon and didn't even remember to put it on so they brought me a small plate of burnt bacon and STILL charged me for it even though I needed to put it on myself, let alone I couldn't even fit more on the burger. So many places in sayville to to, just keep driving. read more

Just had a great burger and adult beverage over at 5 Points. Staff was great and the burger was perfect!

Good qualities: outdoor dining, clean bathroom, warm, cozy decor, crispy fries, cheap prices. Bad qualities: waitress was unfriendly with the personality of a piece of wet chalk, slow service, food wasn't hot or warm, food was sub-par (dry & tasteless), waitress never asked how we were doing-extremely unattentive while the restaurant was hardly busy. Couldn't even find her most of the time. Myself and my party agreed the food wasn't that good & the service was bad. We will certainly not return nor recommend to others. Live and learn. read more