I wanted to come back and update my experience and recognize when a place really steps things up. I've had a couple of not-so-great visits in the past, but my last visit was a completely different story. First off, the service is absolutely terrific--attentive, friendly, and genuinely welcoming from start to finish. It made a huge difference and really sets the tone for the meal. The burgers deserve special mention. Few fun and different options to choose. They were cooked perfectly, juicy, and packed with flavor--exactly what you want when you're craving a solid, satisfying burger. You can tell there's attention to consistency and quality. What stood out just as much is that management clearly listens. It feels like they take customer feedback seriously and are making a real effort to improve and make things right, which goes a long way. Overall, this last visit completely turned things around for me. It's great to see the improvement, and this is definitely a spot I'll keep in the rotation. read more

See all

Absolutely phenomenal bartender he was so helpful Welcoming and friendly Waitress noted allergies and immediately obtained drinks with a smile! Good cooked to temperature Presented Beautifully Restaurant clean, bright, light, accessible Menus varied with autumn options including festive soups sandwiches meals and outside seating with music at night. A must Try w shopping along this main road. Enjoy read more

Five Points Cafe - Lunch - A wrap sandwich filled with vegetables and cheese, cut in half, served with French fries and ketchup on a checkered paper-lined tray. - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

See all

Five Points Cafe is a casual, crowd-pleasing stop for comfort food in downtown Sayville. If you're in the mood for hearty burgers, laid-back drinks, and friendly service in a lively setting -- especially with outdoor seating in warmer weather -- it's hard to go wrong. It's a great choice for weekend lunches, casual dinners, or a relaxed evening with friends and family -- just don't expect fine-dining finesse read more

My husband and I have lunch at this wonderful establishment. We have gotten to know Selena and Maria. They are absolutely wonderful! There services are so very genuine. They are warm, friendly, and authentic. I cannot say enough good things about them. We have all become acquainted with one another and the smiles just greet us upon entering. The food is delicious, always fresh. The chef is well versed in culinary delights. The atmosphere goes hand in hand with the service. A truly special time is to be had at Five Points! read more

Came here during the week to try something new, what a pleasure our waitress was wonderful. We got a nice greeting walking in. There is indoor seating and outdoor,love music when we were leaving The food was good I had pulled pork sliders someone else had baked calms and said they were great! Definitely a place I will return to. read more

Nice place. Went on a Saturday and they had live music. Guitar player was great and the crowd enjoyed his musings. Food also was good as well. Drinks were very good and service was prompt and attentive. The only minus was they ran out of Guinness after I had my first! Looking forward to going back soon. read more

It was okay. The chicken fingers and fries were more food-truck-style. They have a good amount of appetizers but didn't have fried calamari. My husband said his meal was good. The dessert options were slim to none and nothing appealed to me. read more

Five Points Cafe - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

See all

Had a great Cali burger here w live music to boot on a Sunday nt. Burger was cooked to perfection and service was great. No complaints. Nice outdoor seating surrounded by trees. read more

See all

This place is awesome! We loved the special arugula salad-100% fall fave! And those zucchini sticks were like a meal unto themselves! Great service & a friendly atmosphere. Can't wait to come back! Bonus-checked in and got 10% off our bill! If you do too, be a dear & leave it for the sweet wait crew! read more

Five Points Cafe - Delicious super hot (not spicy-just lovely & warm on a cold night!) - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

Great food, and a diverse menu with something for everyone My only advice is to avoid when they have live music, it is just two loud to even hear yourself or anyone else Y read more

Great service. Great food and well priced Love the tuna tacos! Nice wine choices. Can be a little noisy but overall great atmosphere.

Cute place in downtown Sayville. Friends chose to here to meet for lunch. Drove 20 from 22 miles away. Service was good. Menu is nothing special. Salads, wraps and burgers. The Mexican Street corn shrimp appetizer was unique and delicious. Nacho platter had cheese sauce not real melted cheese. To me it's just not the same without real cheese. I had the Downtown salad which features feta, cranberries, roasted tomatoes, grilled chicken and balsamic. It was more lettuce than anything else. Definitely could have used more feta and cranberry. Not enough chicken. But it was very tasty. Beautiful day in November they had the front wide open. Outdoor dining was full so we ate inside. Looks like a great place to have drinks and listen to live music. I enjoyed our time here, but nothing special to bring me back from so far away. Seems like good local spot though if you live nearby. read more

The food was served hot and quick. The service was attentive but not intrusive. Parking is a few blocks away in a public lot. The large pretzel seemed microwaved. It did not get chewy but was unusually sweaty. Perhaps it was steamed. read more

Haven't been in years because thought food was just ok. Went tonight. Burger was overcooked, asked for medium rare, came well- done and no flavor. Waitress seemed bothered to have to take our order. Never came back to ask if we wanted more drinks, or to ask how everything was. If we return will not order a burger. read more

everything was amazing! the service was very fast and the energy was positive and inviting. my fiancé and I went for a dliner theater package from the sayville movie theater and the food was incredible! so worth it. will Deffintly be purchasing this package for my parents. highly recommend the street corn shrimp:) read more

Selina runs the restaurant so well. I go there every day. The staff is great and top notch. Been going there for years. It's like my home away from home. By the way she is also a great bartender. read more

Absolutely terrible. Not worth the money. Chicken burrito that was mostly rice. The size wouldn't fill a 10-year-old. The side salad consisted of iceberg and a small amount of romaine lettuce and 2, I said 2, small half slices of tomato. A complete and total rip off. read more

Excellent Burgers Attentive Staff Outdoor seating available Good background music Relaxed atmosphere read more

I love this place! Cozy atmosphere, excellent service and delicious food. We ordered the fried pickles which were extremely flavorful and crunchy. My toddler got French fries which came out quickly and were well seasoned and crispy. My husband got a Turkey burger with sweet potato fries - the burger was well seasoned and the sweet potato fries were well cooked and crispy. I got the Cobb salad - it was a large portion and delicious. I will definitely be coming back here. read more

Five Points Cafe - A fresh salad featuring grilled chicken, cherry tomatoes, sliced hard-boiled eggs, avocado, and shredded cheese on a bed of lettuce, served with a side of creamy dressing. - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

Local pub, best wings and burger's with great service and location highly recommended for a pint or two.

We went during lunch time. I had the southwest chicken salad which came in a tortilla bowl. It was delicious! I asked for the dressing on the side. Hubby had the bacon cheeseburger with fries, it came with a slaw as well. The burger was huge! Good food. Reasonable prices. read more

Five Points Cafe - Bacon cheese burger - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

See all

everything was delicious. i ate the nachos with no jalapeños because i only wanted a small snack. my date had a cheeseburger and it looked really good the first thing you notice is how big the bun is. then the staffs shirts say best buns in town and it's so true! drink was delicious but i forgot the name of it. i would totally come back. read more

Five Points Cafe - nachos, - A plate of nachos topped with melted cheese and chili sits on a paper-lined tray, alongside a colorful fruit cocktail garnished with orange and cherry. - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

See all

Haven't been here in a while but always loved it. Stopped in for dinner with 3 kids and my boyfriend. First off they had live music which wasn't bad but it was SO so loud. This is 6pm and a small space, I legitimately couldn't have enjoyed my food even if it was good because it gave me so much anxiety. We Ordered salmon and the asparagus smelled like gas from the stove and completely killed my appetite - no flavor at all with the hot honey sauce. Kids chicken fingers seemed like they were fried in oil that hadn't been changed in months. Super bummed at the quality of the food here as I've always had a good experience before. Won't be coming back read more

No stars! I was treated so horribly at this place the Friday night manager spoke to me in the most disgusting way. I told them that the brussels sprouts were raw. I may have read it wrong on their menu, but I did not like it. They refused to take it off the bill saying that it was 2024 and people are trying to make money. Absolutely disgusting how they treated me and my friends. I highly recommend you do not come to this place it's horrible not to mention there's dead yellow jackets in the windows. Very dirty place. read more

- inconsistent service: some are amazing! definitely average/above average overall - beautiful patio with good ratio of space heaters - unique and pretty building - this place fries everything absolutely flawlessly, so if you need the perfect fry or onion ring... or other appetizer, all your dreams will come true - five stars if you're looking for an upbeat but relaxed place to enjoy well-priced drinks and snacks - creative and worthwhile seasonals/specials - live music is above average and enjoyable - the produce is top notch fresh - grilled items are just perfect - wraps and salads are great and consistently good - the burgers are below average in terms of not picking this place specifically for burgers - the rating here overall seems low because you get a quality meal, service, and environment read more

Five Points Cafe - southwest salad - A salad featuring grilled chicken, sliced avocado, black beans, red peppers, and onions served in a crispy tortilla bowl. - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

Five points cafe definitely does not equate to five stars. No clue where to begin but this place commits robbery every time a customer buys food here. Low quality food for high prices. I asked for a medium burger and got well done. On top of that I got the wrong burger which isn't a big deal but it just didn't taste good. I ordered waffle fries as an upgrade and the portion was small. Service was good but that's the only positive read more

I am massively disappointed in Five Points Cafe. To start, I give them the two stars for the music games they have going on. Tonight they were doing song bingo. It's a fun way to interact with people. We have passed by many times before and see different music games happening and it's always looked really nice. I won't return though because both the food and drink were terrible. I ordered a watermelon cosmo and a steak sandwich on the gluten free bun. The cosmo tasted purely artificial and the morsel of watermelon on a skewer atop it was disgustingly old tasting. The steak sandwich was no better. Why ask how the patron wants it cook if it's going to come out so well done it's gray? The meat was so tough I literally couldn't bite most pieces and got a huge chunk of fat. Attempting to eat this sandwich was practically embarrassing and I eventually gave up and just ate the $3 gluten free bun. Honestly if they at least made a good drink I'd come here to sit on the patio and play some music games, but I can't justify coming back when both are so bad. read more

Love, love, love this place. It's such a cute place to have lunch! Right on the main street of the town, and no parking lot. There's an outside area for seating and inside. Inside has tables or you could sit along the bar. They have a decent size menu. Anywhere from appetizers to salads, sandwiches, wraps, etc.. I went with the Parmesan Crusted Chicken Sandwich that came with a side side of either fries or salad. Salad was delicious! I didn't expect the meal to fill me up but it did. It was around $15 for the plate, a little on the pricey side but the food was great and service was fantastic. read more

Stopped by for some hamburgers. Had the patty melt and the downtown. Both were excellent. Perfectly cook. Fries were crispy and fresh. Service was on par and friendly. Live music was a plus. Glad we stopped here. read more

Been coming here for a while and the food has gotten better. They have a nice clean dibing area with helpful staff. outdoor dining is available both sheltered and open, whichever you and the weather prefer. They have live entertainment nightly. Mostly folk music from local artists. Would rate hire but the management doesnt seem to understand that, as a small space, having overly loud music makes it absolutely impossible to order a meal, have any type of conversation, or enjoy your meal. Especially on Thursday nights when they have some guy who must be totally deaf playing a freaking trumpet full blast in a room that truly measures 20 by 20 feet. We came in and were ready to walk out of this musical nightmare when offered external seating. Soon the area was filling with orher annoyed patrons as well as others who would walk in, hear the racket, turn and leave without saying a word. read more

1st time, long time. Burger overcooked. Asked for it medium, got it well done. And it lacked flavor. Hardly any sauce was on it. Not worth $16.50. But I can see this being the new norm now. By that I mean quality in restaurants going down while prices go up. Between, masks, table spacing out, 50% capacity etc etc . Quality will suffer read more

Five Points Cafe - Downtown burger - - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

See all

Food was ok and the service from out waitress who's name i think chole or something like that was horrible. She only came twice(once to take our order and the other time to give use our check). She spent her time hanging with her friends at the table next to us doing rounds of shots(6 or 7) and taking selfies with them. It took like 20 mins to get her attention to get the check. The poor other waitress was busting her ass overtime to cover her tables too since she was too busy doing shot and hanging with her friends at her table read more

This place has some of the most creative burgers i have ever tried. The new flavors of the week and month are usually very original. The inside is great at night. We actually prefer the bar to the tables since the bartenders are usually engaging. The best however is the outside when they have live music. You must try the steakhouse burger with sweet potato fries. Oh and they never give you enough coleslaw. read more

Been to Five Points a few times before but this is the first review. I've never been really impressed with the food, but the location is nice with some decent outdoor seating options so we gave it another try today. Today started off rough, 20+ minutes after sitting before a waitress came over (was not busy), no soap in the bathroom, hand dryer didn't work, & the food really wasn't anything to write home about. The burger was alright, relatively small patty buried under tomato and onion on a bun twice it's size. The fries were the best thing about the meal today. The wrap was alright (better than the burger in my opinion) but for almost $15 I expected a little bit more. Overall, I will be in no rush to come back. Our waitress seemed like she hated life, the food was mediocre at best, and the overall service was just really lacking today. read more

Rationing chicken like its World War 2 at this place. Chicken was dry and overseasoned. Should have went to the deli down the street. What a joke. read more

Five Points Cafe - Cajun Chicken Sandwich - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

Had a great meal here. Service was excellent. Food was good. I had the shrimp Po'boy, which was great, but very light on shrimp. The role was outstanding and the dressing was as well. Wife had a chicken rice bowl, which was super. read more

This place was pretty good! The burger I got was a bit burnt. The outdoor seating and live music was nice! A chill vibe. All the food was average - not bad but nothing to rave about either. I'm not sure if our server was new because she would just answer "I'm not sure, whatever it says on the menu" when we asked questions about a drink and if there were any specials. read more

Nothing special. Over priced. I had a Brat for Octoberfest $18 with a dried out pretzel bun falling apart dry. Mac & cheese $14.50 NO FREE soda refills $2.75 each. Flies and other bugs flying around (2 days in a row!!!!). The lock on the mens rest room is in need of adjustment. All-in-all we will not be returning. TOO EXPENSIVE. This is not Manhattan. read more

Great all around. Love the outside section when the weather is nice. Great live music choices as well.

Overall a great experience! We walked in on a Wednesday night, there was live music and spots at the bar, while still having a good flow of customers with tables and takeout. The live music was perfect, not too loud that you couldn't have a conversation! We ordered a Buffalo chicken wrap and chicken fingers basket. We enjoyed our food, service and the ambiance! Our bartender was attentive without being overbearing, knew when to ask us for another drink and when to check in! We will be visiting again, next up is burgers! read more

Five Points Cafe - Chicken fingers - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

See all