The waiting time after ordering, waiter's service, the food, and atmosphere, everything was great! Except, I thought the price was too high. I would love to go back but am not sure when I can afford next time. read more

Five Points Cafe - Buffalo and blue cheese burger, without fries costed like 13.00. - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

Service : eh, would've been better, if the owner had turned on the AC for the workers that clearly were exhausted from the heat Food: terrible. Diner food with restaurant prices. I got a medium RARE burger, came out gray, the way they put it together, if j tried to close it it would smear everywhere because of the huge chunks of avocado, instead of doing a spread and making things easier and better to eat. Fries were greasy and diner quality. Charged me for bacon and didn't even remember to put it on so they brought me a small plate of burnt bacon and STILL charged me for it even though I needed to put it on myself, let alone I couldn't even fit more on the burger. So many places in sayville to to, just keep driving. read more

Always a great place to stop and eat. Great service, and fun place to hang out when you're in town.

Went there to catch live music. Waitstaff was great and food was even better. Cuban sandwich was legit, chicken caprese sandwich was also fantastic. Fries are good and a great Guinness on tap. Will be back! read more

Not busy and it took the waitress a lot of time to seat us. Food was adequate. My review is more for the management than anything else! Put more people on! read more

Just had a great burger and adult beverage over at 5 Points. Staff was great and the burger was perfect!

Simple affordable delicious and friendly. Not a fan of instant coffee bit everything else was great. :)

If looking for a good burger try five points. Service is ok. Nice to sit outside only complaint they have singers a man and woman. The woman was awful hard to sit through. read more

This place is terrible for a few reasons... 1.) the service is TERRIBLE. We saw our waitress once every 30 minutes. 2.) the burger was SO dry and well done I could barely swallow it. 3.) I had to send back 2 Blue Moons because the beer tasted like it had soap in it. The reason I'm giving this place 2 stars instead of 1 is because their Mac & Cheese was pretty good. My recommendation is to stay away. I will never go here again. Go to Perabell which is in Patchauge (not that far) and is SOOOO good. read more

This place is a great spot for a beer and a burger. The drafts are always cold and there's a good burger selection on the menu in addition to some good sandwiches. Bonus is the outside eating area when it's nice out and live acoustics on the weekend. Minus one star because the buns are a little on the dry side and too big. Must try the sweet potato fries with the dipping sauce, I think it's like crack in a small cup...... if I did crack. read more

I like this place. I usually get takeout, but have also eaten in the dining room and at the bar. It's a casual, friendly atmosphere. Good beers and burgers. My current go-to is the pulled pork sandwich. Yum! My only real complaint is that the layout of the dining room is sort of awkward. When you walk in you're practically standing at someone's table. If you're sitting at that table and it's chilly out you freeze every time someone opens the door. read more

The burgers here are amazing! The place isn't huge but they have a great atmosphere and the staff is outgoing and friendly. Highly recommended if you are in the area! read more

Ordered the avocado & tomato salad - the avocado was black and completely inedible. My family's food was delicious, but maybe stick to the burgers when you order. read more

Brunch Review: I'm giving 4 stars based on the food and the prices. The service on the other hand I'd give 2.5-3 stars. Pros: the food was delicious. Good size portions and affordable prices Cons: the food took forever to come out, 3 out of 8 meals came out incorrectly, service was slow and pretty terrible. We were constantly waiting for drink refills and condiments. On top of it, the place was empty. I will be returning for brunch. Warning: if you have no patience, do not go. read more

Two of our party had burgers and two had sandwiches, the burgers were both under cooked, the sandwiches were good, not enough dressing but they brought more. The waitress was very good. Drinks were cheap, but the singer was too loud and not that good. Will go back because it's close to where I live and my friend said it was an "off night". read more

Amazing restaurant!! I've tried almost everything on the menu and don't have a single complaint. Staff is so nice & attentive!

The food is very good the only down side is It is very expensive for a burger joint. The outside patio is very nice in the summer especially when the are having live music. read more

I actually like this place. The food, especially the burgers are very good. Nice atmosphere as well. Unfortunately the service is terrible. The running joke at my house is if you're not really hungry yet, let's go to Five Points. Sadly I think this afternoon's experience was the very worst. Drinks were mixed up and we had to ask the hostess to find our server to get the check. If you don't mind waiting for your order or a refill on cocktails have at it. read more

Thursday afternoon, 1200, (about 20 minutes ago)wife and I walked in and waited at the hostess podium for a good minute or so. A women, presumably the hostess, stood behind the bar approximately 10 feet from us texting away on her phone, without looking up once. Place is empty, wife and I are TALKING, there was no way we weren't audible to her. This woman was clearly devising a plan for world peace, because at no point did she look up. I turned to my wife and told her we're leaving in 10 seconds if we don't get seated. Needless to say, walked out. It's disappointing, the place looked nice and many of the reviews are positive. Guess I won't find out. No chance I was gonna stand there while miss fast fingers types away and the wife and I are relegated to the "pay no mind" list. read more

I have been coming to Five Points since the first week it opened. I can't say enough good things about their burgers, sweet potato fries, and the sweet potato fries dipping sauce!! The burgers have a nice little twist on each one and are one of my favorite places for a good burger. Having a lot of family and friends with gluten allergies, they are extremely accommodating and even offer a gluten free bun for a burger. I now live in Boston and when I come home to visit, I always make it a point to come here. You guys rock!! read more

The food was okay. The fries were really good but the burger was over cooked. The toppings were fine but the burger being overdone made it taste off. It may have been a one off so I will definitely give it another shot. read more

Positive thoughts first: food was delicious and came out fast, huge portions, great drinks. NEGATIVE NEWS TIME. My friend and I told the hostess we wanted to sit outside and she put us down to sit inside which had a wait time which really confused us. We asked for separate checks (mind you, it was justttt my friend and I) to make splitting the bill easier for the waitress later. It was my idea to check in on yelp for the discount and she said later AFTER SHE CHARGED THE CARDS that she can only apply it once per table (IT DOES NOT SAY THAT ANYWHERE ON THE DISCOUNT) and then gave the discount to my friend. Ummmmm hello we BOTH checked in AND made your life easier. Won't be back purely for customer service reasons. KISSES. read more

Two years ago, I really loved this place. I feel like it's definitely gone down over time. I revisited this place on a nice day and sat outside. It wasn't crowded on the patio but looked busy on the inside. Our waitress was polite and friendly, but definitely busy. We hardly saw her, and had to go indoors for napkins and silverware. Also had to wait quite some time for refills. I can't blame the waitstaff if they're stretched thin, but it does make a difference to the diners. Now the food is what really earned this rating. It was... mediocre at best. I had a veggie burger, which in the past, I always enjoyed. But the taste fell really flat this time around. There was no seasoning or sauce on it, leaving it dry. My husband had a chicken sandwich which he said was bland. I'm not sure what happened to the menu lately, but I'm really disappointed with what transpired. With so many casual options around, I don't think I'll be back for quite some time. read more

Id say 31/2 stars if I could, Food was real tasty albeit a small restaurant .Nice waitress. Not crowded when we went food tasted fresh and full of flavor. We had wings ,pastrami sandwich with sweet potato fries, blue cheese burger with onion strings on it with a side of fries. . A couple glasses of Riesling and a couple of Stella's.They have a small bar area place appears larger than it really is. We definetly will be back and do recommend .. We also got a 10 percent off discount by doing a check in with Yelp. read more

Great food. Great atmosphere. Love the live music outside during the summer. Would recommend!

First time visiting Five points cafe this week. It was actually our second choice (first choice was closed). And I am sooo glad we did !! The Ahi tuna tacos were DELICIOUS!! The White sangria was good too!! Can't wait to go back :) read more

Great place on the corner of Main Street. While the inside is smaller, they have a great outdoor setup that is lovely over the summer. The service is good and the food is enjoyable. They have a lovely white sangria that me and my friends always enjoy! Perfect casual summer spot. read more

Tucked behind a row of hedges in the middle of downtown Sayville (Friendliest Town in America) lies Five Points Cafe, a favorite for locals and visiting tourists alike. The casual atmosphere is welcoming and comfortable, with something for everyone - TVs for sporting events, live music, open-air seating, a fully-stocked bar, and a variety of draft beers, both classic and craft. The menu is updated seasonally, with fresh specials weekly. Highlights include their nachos with house-made chili, the Downtown Burger, and the lineup of Adult MilkShakes. Service is prompt and friendly, with each member of the staff saying hello or offering assistance as they pass by. Both food and drink are reasonably priced, with generous portions and pours. The only negative is the popularity of the bartenders (coughHarrisoncoughcough), as we are not always able to get a seat at the bar. On these occasions, we are always offered a table and drinks while we wait, and the staff is extremely accommodating. Five Points Cafe earns all five of its stars. I will continue to patronize this fine establishment, whether it's for Sunday football, weeknight musical acts, or drinks and dinner with friends and family. read more

I want so bad to give this place 5 stars but the last two times ive been in there my sweet potato fries were served cold to me. Thats a deal breaker. Once is one thing but twice in a row has me at 4 stars here. Otherwise awesome spot to be especially if youre local. read more

Great service. My husband didn't really like his burger unfortunately, but we still like this place.

Delicious, great atmosphere, and fairly well priced! Five draft beers, an appetizer, three entrees, and two desserts for $95. Always recommend the burgers, especially one voted 'best on Long Island.' However, the sandwiches are great and always fresh as well! No one left the table hungry or disappointed. Anyone with sweet tooth, the fried s'mores are INCREDIBLE! read more

I've been going to this burger cafe for years. The food is always great. Tonight we went there on a Sunday eve at 7:45 and the waitress treated us like we were a huge imposition! I asked her if they were closing cause the board was erased and no one greeted us. She said no no the kitchen is open until 8:30. There were customers seated and eating. She took our order and then very loudly was yelling at the kitchen people " I told you to keep the grill open!." We felt so awkward. On top of it she was snotty and was shutting off everything and telling staff they can go home and rushed us. We left there at 8:30. There were some people at the bar and they questioned the same thing...and I felt sorry for the young couple walking in while we were leaving... read more

Nice casual atmosphere. We sat outside on the patio, and they had a singer playing the guitar. Having the music outside was perfect, it wasn't overly loud or obtrusive. Our waitress was nice, although a little on the slow side. Our table ordered burgers and grilled cheese sandwiches, everyone left happy. read more

I came here with my husband and 2.5 year old son for the first time this evening after hearing some positive feedback from friends. It is definitely a kid-friendly place and he really enjoyed watching and listening to the live music. Since it was our first try, my husband and I ordered burgers (BECAUSE IT'S A BURGER PLACE)... Positives: We thought the buns/toppings/meat quality were very good. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive. I also got a $3.50 glass of wine, which was a nice surprise (Wine down Wednesday special). Negatives: Burgers were cooked more well done than medium, which we had requested. Some restaurant employees seemed to lack the hustle you'd expect to clear tables and seat customers promptly. We are new to the area, so will probably be exploring more of Main Street before returning, but it was a nice experience, overall. read more

Fantastic burgers and good live music for a Thursday night. Had about a 20 minute wait since the place is tiny, but it was worth every second. read more

I took my mother and my daughter in law and two granddaughters here on Mother's Day for lunch. I had been here once before and had a good burger. We were there at noon and were seated on the patio. It took almost an hour to get served . The restaurant was not busy as the brunch crowd had gone. I twice asked what was going on with our order. When the good finally arrived, my "crab cake" looked more like a veggie burger and had no flavor whatsoever. I will not be back . read more

We've been here before and I can't believe they were able to make it better. The service was great, the atmosphere is wonderful and the food is exceptional. There is a lot of care put in to the details of every meal and it shows. read more

A great burger spot in Sayville. They have live music and outdoor seating in the summer. Food never disappoints. Just wish they had more craft beer options---they just had the standard bud, bud light, sam adams, etc on tap. Great place! read more

I gave it a three because I haven't eaten there yet. But if you like craft beer, don't bother they didn't have an IPA and the beers on tap where the run of the mill stuff. Bud and Guiness. read more

We were looking for a good burger Friday night and decided to try Five Points after seeing them listed in Newsday's Best Burger listing. We were not disappointed. We shared the mac and cheeses appetizer and it was delicious. Our burgers came out cooked perfectly, mine medium rare and hers medium well. The meat was seasoned perfectly and the grilled bun was very good too. The fries weren't hot, so not very good. For the price, you can't go wrong. We will definitely be back. read more