We were looking for a good burger Friday night and decided to try Five Points after seeing them listed in Newsday's Best Burger listing. We were not disappointed. We shared the mac and cheeses appetizer and it was delicious. Our burgers came out cooked perfectly, mine medium rare and hers medium well. The meat was seasoned perfectly and the grilled bun was very good too. The fries weren't hot, so not very good. For the price, you can't go wrong. We will definitely be back. read more

Came here for dinner tonight with high expectations as last time my wife and I tried but it was a 45 minute wait. Place is small and cozy which makes for a nice ambience. Seems to be very kid friendly. Ordered the onion straws and was very disappointed. They were tough, dry, oily, and not even hot. Seems like it was made ahead before our order was put in and left to keep warm until someone orders them. Seems like a logical idea because it is a burger topping but seriously, someone should be checking the quality before serving it. Service is blah. Im not expecting a fine dining service but the waitress didnt seem to care about being a server but just to take the order, bring the food and then bring the check. She obviously saw that we didnt even touch the onion straws but did not ask if someone was wrong. Burgers arent bad here. Seems like the same meat and bread with just different toppings. I give the burgers a 3 star rating. The rustic looking country white bun isnt bad at all. Im more of a brioche or softer style burger bun kinda guy. Coleslaw was more than lacking flavor, it lacked soul and seasoning kinda which summarizes my first and possibly last experience at Five Points Cafe. What makes this place survives is because its possibly the closest burger joint in Sayville and Long islanders seem to love to support the locals which is nice. I wish you the best Five points but eventually people will want better product and service. read more

Five Points Cafe - Onion straws - Burgers Near Me - Sayville, New York

Friendly staff and good food. This is a family restaurant with a small bar and a great happy hour. In fact, I have eaten there 2 to 3 times a month. Salads are great too. Further, there is outdoor seating when weather is good. read more

First time going to this place after reading a lot of good things about the burgers of late. Because of the press we went around 5 with the kids (4 and 5) and got a table right away---but going a bit later would have been a wait. My wife and I both had burgers which were excellent -- Cali and a bacon cheese...She didn't like the over sized bun...it didn't bother me. The kids enjoyed the mac and cheese and hot dog. Our server was nice and attentive. We will be back. read more

.My burger was cooked to the right temperature rare . But was very dry not sure what type of beef they use but not a fan . My husband wanted his medium rare.and it was well :( . Kids burgers also came out well and dry . Beer taps need a cleaning . Desert was delicious had the salted Carmel cake . Service was good . read more

I really enjoyed the atmosphere and the service was very good. There was live music which was way too loud. Near impossible to have a conversation with the people sitting across from me. The burgers was pretty good except the buns are way too big. They take away from the flavor of the burger. read more

I eat here quite often and find the food good. That being said the chefs temperature of cooking the burgers varies. Its uncomfortable, lots of kids, small space and they have plastic cutlery. Also some nights they have live music but its so loud you walk in and walk out. Imagine a concert in a space as big as your living room. Its best to go at lunch or late. read more

Really nice wait staff. The food here is pretty darn good. I only wish they had delivery!

Food and shakes were great! So glad they are finally open!

I had a rude waitress who left us sitting there forever. The hostess had to come over and take our order. Food wasn't too great. SO GREASY. The waitress didn't even come by until we were done. I asked 2x for a new drink because there was a bug in it. Never got a new drink and they charged me for it. Will never go back. A shame because sayville is such a cute town. read more

I went here for breakfast with a friend and couldn't ask for better service. I had the California omelette and it was fantastic. The food's portion size was accommodating for someone looking to have a big breakfast. read more

Came here after seeing a movie, didn't expect much but the burgers are really great! I'm defiantly coming back!

After many visits I will finally wrote a review. First service was good, and food is delicious. They are a great burger joint. Full open bar as well. Sit inside or outside on a beautiful Patio. I will be back soon! read more

the place didn't blow me away but I would come back. I ordered the crab cake sandwich which was good and had lots of crab in it. but the best part was the outside sitting area. only down side.. there really wasn't a lot of tables outside. so my boyfriend and I made sure to wait an extra 10-15 minutes so we could.. and it was worth the extra wait. although the restaurant was close to the street it was still quite and nice. read more

Upped them to 4 stars. Service quality has improved the last few times that I've been there, and the burgers are delicious. They have daily sandwich specials that are generally kick ass and the beer is ice cold. The place seems to be thriving and features live music a few weeknights and on weekends. read more

Although I liked the outdoor seating and live music (as long as you're not one of the first tables next to the speaker in which case forget about hearing what anyone else at your table says), I was appalled by the burger. The meat was good but the chef decided to make it an obesity burger - there was a thick layer of blue cheese topped with a generous portion of fried onion rings on a very chunky bun. The whole thing is probably 2 days worth of calories. We also got an avocado salad and it seemed like they wanted to make it look impressive but really it was just a bucket of lettuce with a few tomatos and pieces of avocado. read more

Good place to get a burger sit outside with friends and enjoy a beer! They have live music there which is nice as well!

Extremely good service and very good burgers. French Onion soup was quite delicious as well, I will definitely be returning.

Second time going on a beautiful summer Sunday evening. The live music was great both times. The food was good but it would be great if it was actually warm when they brought it out. Second time going and the service both times was horrible. It takes forever to get your food and even longer to get your check. They literally forget you are even there. This last time I had to waive down a different waitress to get my check and waive down another one to get them to take my card. Could easily be five stars if service was better. I'd really like to try my food while it's hot. read more

Who wouldn't enjoy visiting a cafe named after a historic loc. in the city were poverty and sickness reigned? Oh, sorry, but true. A group of us singles arrived on an early Sun. evening. They don't take reservations, but I was told to call a hour in advance and they would see to a table for our large group... which they did. We were warmly welcomed. Had I known that there was outdoor seating, I would have preferred to be a part of the motorcycles roaring past in line with the people in cars (cagers) and lots of sidewalk strollers. Very cool. The burgers were big and juicy with a choice of sauces. The special sauce is not a MickyD type of sauce...no, it is a hot, spicy, smoky BBQ. My "topless" chicken came bun-less and resting on a bed of greens. It was all happy and seductively juicy white breast meat sliced and fork ready.The addition of chipotle sauce put me in hog heaven. It might take a while to get served but the food is fresh upon arrival. While we waited I noticed a handsome, well groomed, over fifty dude in jeans and a black Harley Davidson shirt. I am not attracted to any Tom, Dick and Terrance so it was nice to see him..and his girlfriend....dang-it. I am sure we all will go back. It was fun, friendly, busy, bustling and laid back. Surprisingly, the bar was empty...too early I will assume for a good throw back. Single men, please wear tee shirts announcing...single and looking...I know I will be looking. PS: A little banquet area outside for those who want a chat and a drink would be very welcome. read more

Great variety of burger items. People tend to enjoy the sweet potato fries especially the glaze, but its a bit too sweet for my liking. However i have been finding myself a fan of many of their items (so far the items i have had been fantastic). Also this place whenever i come seems to be booming with customers too. read more

My family came here for lunch on a Saturday- the place is really nice with an inviting atmosphere. The food was really good, the French fries are the best, they have a little extra crunch to them. read more

Food is good -however you know when you go to busy restaurants with great management and well -trained service people and you know when you go to a relaxed establishments with little management, poor training, and workers with little regard for customer 's experience -.here a hostess may stand around doing nothing rather than attending to ignored tables-or to find a too -busy waitress to help a table of two who have been sitting there for ten minutes- it is clearly out of some of the staffs job description to support each other -last time we were there - two tables were upset- waitress ignored a table then confused order-and another full table left after being ignored-from top down- if staff doesn't have common customer service skills- you need to teach them. read more

The food here is very tasty and very decadent!! They have delicious comfort food, the Mac and Cheese is excellent and unique. The salads are huge and the fried smores here yummy. The atmosphere is fun! Great place to go any night of the week :) read more

Big fan, like their burgers and adult milk shakes. Usually have good selection of seasonal beers on tap. Fair prices and good service.

I do appreciate that 'Downtown Burgers at five points Cafe' is listed as 'Five Points Cafe', which fits their ambience. Every effort has been made to display a comfortable, welcoming air. Their menu offers much more than their signage infers. My wife and I split a BLT and fries; washed down with an iced-tea. The sandwich was served on lightly toasted marble rye, had a stack of 6-8 slices of carefully-prepared Applewood bacon, a spread of mayo and the requisite slices tomato and leaf-romaine lettuce. All of which is not remarkably special, but considering the lunch choices served up by the local eateries, the 'Five Points Cafe' should be a consideration to help satisfy your "I need some lunch now, belly-grumble". One small note: You'll receive your beverage in a thin plastic (throw-away) cup. I'm not sure the reason for this choice. ???. Enjoy! read more

Since this place is called Downtown Burger at Five Points Café and they spotlight their burgers we were expecting them to be great. They were fine, but nothing to write home about. The fries were good but the mac and cheese was just so-so. Very casual menu, mostly burgers, sandwiches and sides. They have a good selection of beers and cocktails. The service was polite but somewhat slow. read more

Since my last review I have been back a couple of times and things have certainly been better. Food is always good. Service is sometimes suspect. read more

The best burgers in town. They even offer gluten free buns! They often have love music outside, and the outdoor area has a nice atmosphere. Inside is a bit small, but that's never really been a problem. read more

First waitress wasn't great but the second was. Food and drinks were good too. Nice atmosphere. Had live music too. Burgers and fries are great. Try the Lynchburg lemonade read more

Went for early dinner on a Tuesday. The patio was pretty empty and we got a table right away. The service was good and the food was tasty too. We brought a dog as their patio is dog friendly. Would go back in the future. Parking is located behind the building but I can see how it would fill up fast. read more

Have eaten here in the past and it was good. Tonight it was horrible. We ordered apps and burgers and were told by the waitress that our food was ready before our appetizers came out. She offered to cancel our wings. We still wanted our apps and specifically requested that they not hold our food in the kitchen while we ate our apps. They did. The fries were cold and the burgers were dry. And the service was not good. We will not go back. read more

Definitely a nice variety of burgers and sandwiches. I opted with the chicken burger which though had a great bun, the chicken patty itself only had a little taste. Also, the service was lagged as our waitress only checked on our table once during our visit (besides taking our drink in the beginning and when placing our order). read more

The worst breakfast I've ever had. The omelettes are cooked in a pan from an infomercial and have pancake batter in them. The sautéed spinach was made in half a gallon of oil. The butter for my toast was frozen. The cold coffee came from a pot sitting on the counter. The cooks could be heard swearing in the kitchen. This place sucks. read more

I am a returning customer, I come here a lot for lunch and dinner. I love the atmosphere here! I really enjoy the live music and the bar. Food can be better sometimes, but for the most part it's good. Gia is such a sweetheart, and makes great drinks!! She goes above and beyond to give you a great dining experience. She's amazing! read more

Overpriced service poor, sat at an outdoor table for 15 minutes before a waitress even appeared then she told us we had to wait. I should have realized then that this place was not good. They serve with plastic forks and knives. A burger fries and a fish and chips with 2 sangrias cost 55.00 with a tip that i should not have given her. Wow wow what a rip off. Then they say they have the best buns in town the hamburger bun was stale and the burger tiny. Go to crickets down the block it is a better value. This new place is a poor overpriced restaurant. If this is sayville chic I wonder what this town is turning into. read more

Okay, so they change the prices, but didn't change the website. So I ended up paying $6.00 more. I'm kind of pissed off, but I would have gotten over it except the cobb salad was really weak and my burger was way over done. The prices use to be awesome, but they raised everything $3.00. My first experience with this place was when it first opened. That time I ate inside, and to be honest the service sucked. I can't even remember what I ate that time, so it couldn't have been that great. I gave it a second chance because I'm local and like the idea of the place, but raising prices and not updating the website a big big big fail!!!! So, I wish them success, but hope that they better prepare for price changes in the future. read more

This is a family friendly place. With the best salads and hamburgers in town. Depending on weather, outdoor seating is available and live music is inside. If you are in Sayville, stop by for lunch, dinner or just a drink. read more

Update: This time I got there at 3:30 pm and ordered their downtown burger. it was excellent and cooked as I ordered it. My wife's order was fine too. Service was great as it was last time. I changed my rating to 5 Stars Original review: Got there at 3pm. My wife ordered the. chipotle chicken salad which she did enjoy. I ordered a bacon cheeseburger medium well. It came to me as well done, the bacon was super crisp (too crisp) and the bun was a bit dry and stiff. I was very hungry and did not send it back. For 13 bucks, it was a poor choice I made. I expected a burger place to have great burgers; wrong. The fries were great though. The waitress was friendly and the service was prompt. Maybe getting there at an off time got me a pre cooked standing around for a while patty waiting to be finished. Feh! I will try them once more at a busy time to see if its any better when they are really cooking it up. ONCE more, and hopefully my review will be better. Am I a glutton for punishment? I guess so :-) read more

Waitress was great service ie ordering time to get food etc. Was not good took over 25 min for a burger 2 sandwiches and order of wings then 1 sandwiches came first 10 min the rest was served. And place was not busy read more