I typically only get to this branch when I'm visiting Methodist Hospital but Five Guys being across the street is always a HUGE plus. I love their burgers. Juicy, lip smacking good. I like it simple, Well done, American cheese, raw onions, lettuce. Done. I like the fries, don't think they are that great. 5Guys is a tad pricey but thats okay. read more

Yum! Just ... Yum! Thank you for having bunless burgers and supporting the low carb community! Yes, your burgers maybe slightly overpriced, but I don't care! Whenever I'm in the neighborhood, I always stop by to get one of your delicious burgers! read more

My wife and I drove by here numerous times before we decided to enter. i had never heard of it before then. Being an avid lover of In-n-Out and burgers in general, I was looking for my fix in Brooklyn. To top it off their fries are real, homemade and Gluten Free! I was so excited to be here! I ordered a bacon cheeseburger with no bun, mustard, grilled onions, jalapenos, tomatoes and lettuce, I also ordered a regular Cajun spiced fries and a soft drink (free refills). The wait was between 5-10 minutes very acceptable, especially with the traffic this place was experiencing. For a well done burger, they definitely got it going on! And the fries, perfect crispiness, taste and spice! I ended up eating here 10 times in 2/3 weeks! i guess that means I was sold! I even went to a few of their other locations. Want a good burger? Great fries? COME HERE! read more

I love the burgers and fries. I dislike when I place an order for three different hamburgers, all hamburgers received are the same. I have stopped going to this restaurant because they have always messed up my order. read more

BEST fries ever. Haven't tried their burgers. Great service. Down ? ---the parking is no good; there is no parking. However , if you take the bus, train, taxi or walk, this is the best place for fries (except for Nathans) in Brooklyn NY . read more

The service at this place is always fast and friendly. Their cheeseburgers are delicious !!!! This place is for everybody who wants to bit their hunger quickly and for the reasonable price;) Try their Malt vinegar with fries, you definitely gonna love it!!! read more

it was supposed to be a "REAL" burger, unencumbered by fancy trappings. the burger looked frayed around the edges, and tasted like acid washed jeans. read more

I really wanted to like this place. Maybe my expectations were too high. With a name like 5 guys, what girl couldn't want to love it. Anyway can someone say EXPENSIVE as heck but I'm obviously willing to pay the price for a good burger. Unfortunately I paid it for a gross burger. Even after adding their "free" toppings it still failed as something remotely good. The fries, although plentiful, were just good at best. I tried both the plain and the seasoned. The seasoned are just fries with some cheap powder added. Nothing special here. The music was way too loud (there's a speaker above every table, i love loud music but I couldn't even hear myself think) Oh yeah, free OLD peanuts (not worth it). We would have not even seen them if it weren't for the fact that I read about this "quirk" online and searched them out. I'd say don't waste your time here if it weren't for the fact that I guess a lot of people like this place and therefore I consider it a must try. I personally will never come here again though and don't recommend it to anyone. With what you're paying, go to a restaurant and get yourself something worth eating. read more

as i walked into this five guys, i thought back to the first time that i visited a five guys, way back in northern virginia. i remember vaguely my friend telling me, "molls, get a "little" hamburger. you'll never finish a regular one." well, i forgot about those words of wisdom, because i got the regular size. which, as you should know, has two patties. yum. it was just want i wanted and i did finish it! first time for everything. one thing that i don't like about this five guys is the peanut thing. in virginia/dc metro area, where they apparently don't care about people and/or do not cave to pressure from entitled ass hole parents, you can just throw your peanut shells on the floor. but here, in park slope, there's a sign on the peanuts that says, "due to neighborhood children being allergic to peanuts, don't take peanuts OUT of five guys." really? you can't even have peanuts in the STREET? i understand that peanut allergies are serious, but come on. ::eye roll:: only in park slope. read more

Haven't been here in a really long time. Months to probably years... today I decided I will not come here again. Extremely slow service. Timestamp on receipt was 7:30pm on a Saturday. I got my food exactly 20 minutes later. Watching them prepare burgers the whole time. Staff needs to be educated on how to maintain a hygienic environment. Gloved hands shouldn't be touching anything except food and cooking tools; even an unintentional touch elsewhere is a no no. I ordered two small hamburgers with the same toppings on both of them. I even stated it that way. Explain how the employee entered a small hamburger and a small cheeseburger. Makes no sense. I only realized cuz I was watching them. I corrected their mistake. Didn't bother asking for the 60cent refund. Not coming back here. read more

One of the better burgers in Park Slope? Are you kidding me?? Let's get this straight. This is beneath a Wendy's level burger, possibly worse than McDonald's. Just awful, lousy all around. Far far from being good, and light years away from being one of the best burgers in the Slope. There really isn't much good to say about this place. The people who rated this 5 stars must have never had a decent burger in their life. No one who ever had good burgers would think the burgers here are good. It's beyond comprehension that people would consider this a good burger joint. Avoid at all cost. read more

Burgers were fine and accurate.. However, we didn't receive our milkshakes that we were charged for. Step it up Five guys.

I love five guys because its a great burger that is made to order and fairly inexpensive when talking about the NYC burger scene. You can add any condiments you want on your burger for no extra cost. Grilled onions, mushrooms, jalapenos, pickles, lettuce, etc etc etc. The fries that are ordered separate are good enough for 2 people. Free peanuts seal the deal. Just watch out for baseball season five guys as I will be stocking up to take to yankee stadium =o read more

I was pretty excited to try this last night, and when I left I felt like I got shot down and ran over... Disappointed. I was hoping for something really great like 'In and Out', which I'll never see again unless I go back to the west coast. The meat was okay, the bun was okay, in fact everything was just ok. I don't like fries, because fried yucca is so much better then potatoes so I won't even bother trying them. Once you go yucca, you don't go back. Overall, everything was bland. read more

So I went to this Branch today for lunch. Not a bad place. Very spacious and the cashier moved the line. Food was great but the two person that was prepping the food needed more training. Let's see I waited 30 minutes for them to call my order number. When I went to get my food the order was wrong. They missed the fries with both meal. So I waited another 15 minutes. Not good plus by the time I got the fries the burger was cold. Food cost about 26 dollars for two burgers and two fries. The place was a mess and needed to be cleaned. Only had 3 staff members working which would have been ok but it was lunch time and the branch is directly across from a hospital. The cashier was great but everything else needs some TLC. read more

The Park Slope location takes the cake over the Five Guys in Brooklyn Heights -- this branch is bigger, brighter, and cleaner, with more seating. Like Goodburger, it's a good option when you want fast food and need something better than Mickey D's, but don't want a full-service meal. I think I might prefer Goodburger burgers by a smidgette (like a smidge, but smidgier), but Five Guys has lower prices and friendlier environment (dig those peanuts). The fries are also undeniably good -- the regular size looks like it should be a large, and the fries themselves are crispy AND potatoey (the best of shoestring and steak fries in one). They also have malt vinegar for your fries, woohoo! (3.5 stars) read more

i love you 5 guys! i love your burgers, i love your fries, i love your peanuts, and i love the people that work there. seriously, there is never anyone surly back in the back, and they smile and tell you to have a nice day. the fountain soda is also mixed deliciously, and what a perfect spot. afterwards you can stroll up to the park and walk off the 80 million calories you just consumed. i love 5 guys all over the world. yes, you can make inappropriate jokes, but i do. so there. read more

this is one burger food place that reminds me of "In & Out" from California. it's almost like the same quality. man, they've got expensive prices here, but it's worth your hard earned money. i actually like the fried potatoes that was actually like a meal by itself; the burger was fantastic---the experience of having a meal here is almost like having a sit-down dinner with meals that have been carefully, meticulously prepared. i just didn't like how the cashier was behaving that time; she seems not to be listening very well, and she's not that helpful at all (maybe she was tired that time). read more

Hm, a very interesting burger joint. Interesting=taking your burger and slapping every single condiment and sauce you can think of on it and then stuff it in your mouth as fast as you can to avoid the guilt. Oh and who can forget the free peanuts to maintain the cholesterol spike. Mmm, would I come here again? Probably not in another few years. I rather save my heart attack for shake shack :) read more

Obama is a fan of Five Guys and now so am I! The burgers are huge and I like that you can pick from a ton of toppings to add for free. Oh so tasty! Loved the fries-- freshly cut and perftectly crispy! Dare I say it... Five Guys is better than In n Out! = O read more

Stopped in for a burger and was pleasantly surprised! It was the closest I'm going to get to an In-n-Out burger this side of the Mississippi. Can't say I was a huge fan of the fries (still think McDonald's can't be beat on that front), but I really did love my burger and toppings (grilled onions--yum!). Nice neighborhood option...and laughed when I saw President Obama on TV two nights later ordering up a bag of burgers from the D.C. Five Guys! read more

Oh, is this stuff bad for you, but if you're looking for a tasty calorie bomb, it's tough to top Five Guys. From the burgers to fries to shakes, it's all top-notch greasy goodness that is fresh and made to order. It's a little disconcerting to see the regulars (honestly, lunch has to be 2,000 calories) but if you want an occasional treat and dip into decadence, you can't beat a Five Guys meal. read more

The five stars are for the French Fries only. I have never had anything else from Five Guys...but the french fries alone deserve five stars! I order the cajun fries and they are amazing. The serving size is ginormous!!! read more

Yum. What a wonderfully delicious, calorie-laden treat for the days that I make it downstairs to the gym. Although I love the LIttle Cheeseburger, I tend to get the LIttle Hamburger due to the significant difference in calories. I know I sound like an UES bitch, but trust me, you don't want to feel overburgerstuffed. French fries are fabulous. Thick-cut, just salty enough, and I love that the portions overflow into the bags. Fantastic. I just wish they had a choice of sugar-free iced teas in addition to sodas. TIP: These guys take orders over the phone. There are fewer things more satisfying than strolling in, sashaying up to the cashier, and walking out with my burger while less-savvy patrons tap their feet. Suckas. read more

Great burger, but I'd suggest only getting 1 per month. It's delicious, but you'll end up sleepy after all these calories.

These people make a nice fast food burger. Greasy with your choice of toppings. A bit of a trek down into the Slope for me, but my brother loves them so while we was in town we did the hike. Tons of fries, your really do get a lot of fries with your order and they aren't too shabby either. Nice and nicely done Five Guys. Do they always wrap up things like its a to go order just in case? Or is it just because I came in 15 min before close? That being said, they didn't hurry me out. Nice. read more

So not worth it. The burger was boring. No flavor. And the bun was cold, as if it had come out of the fridge. Do they not toast the buns there? And the fries, we ordered Cajun fries. Tasteless as well. It's was my first and only time to eat there and will be my last. They only cook the burgers well-done. I suppose it's like eating at the Pizzeria Uno chain rather than the original one in Chi. The reviews were great, but my experience was totally underwhelming. read more

Here is the not-so-skinny of 5 Guys Burger and Fries: The burgers are the kind with a thin patty (which I like) - so thin that it kind of falls apart as you are eating it (and is yummily invaded by gobs of mayo, ketsup, fried onions, jalapenos...you name it!); you can order the "small" burger (which has 1 patty) or a regular size (which has a double patty). With the exception of cheese and bacon, all other toppings are free (which really means already included in the somewhat high price - about $7 for the regular cheeseburger or $5.50 for the smaller one - baconburgers are even more). The burgers have the McDonald's taste (i.e. fried as opposed to truly grilled) but the meat is/tastes real, the bun does not taste like cardboard, and the toppings are seriously yum. This is the type of burger experience where the toppings are at least as important, if not outweigh, the taste of the patty itself (I recommend the grilled onions). So, if you like a thin patty, sloppy-topping burger (which I do), this is a pretty damn good burger. However, since this is *not* a gourmet, Kobe beef, fancy-pants burger but just a tricked-out version of McDonald's, I consider it pretty over-priced. The fries are gigantic. They are fried in peanut oil and taste like it (which I think is lovely). They are, in my opinion, under-salted. They come in two sizes - regular and large. No sense in ordering the large as the regular tends come with a lot more fries tossed in the bag with it. My husband and I split the regular and could not finish it. There are free refills on the soda, so, again, no need to get the bigger size (or even to get one per person - just share and keep refilling). Overall, I think this is a once-a-year indulgence type place. The calories (for good or ill) are listed on the menu. A small burger with half of a regular fries and half of a soda is nearly 1,000 calories. It does make you think twice! Also, two burgers (one small, one regular), a regular fry, and 1 small soda was nearly $20. Frankly, I think half that would be appropriate - especially given how strapped for cash people are these days. read more

The burgers are juicy and delicious and the bacon is nice and crispy! The menu is simple and that works for this place, definitely the best burger out of all the fast food restaurants! read more

Love the burgers and fries. Prices are reasonable. Go there hungry. Staff is friendly and the layout is cool. If your in the mood for a burger and hand cut fries, this is the place to go to. read more

After having lunch here several times I have come to some conclusions. First of all when I go to Five Guys, Unless i'm with someone I will not order the fries. The Burger itself (if you get all the works) is filling within itself, the fries are a bit over kill unless you have some friends to help pick up the left overs. Get a normal size drink, you can keep filling it up so why bother getting the bigger one. Lastly, don't bother snacking on the nuts. You will be full only several minutes after you order and eating before wont help. read more

I love Five Guys literally everywhere else but at this location. No one was in line when I arrived but the customer before me had ordered a shake with peanut butter. The peanut butter container was empty and the cashier had informed the customer that it would take a few minutes to refill. The customer responded by asking how long it would take which is a fair question. The cashier asked what appeared to be his supervisor how long it would take to refill the container of peanut butter. They went back and forth for about two minutes discussing who was the last employee to refill. The cashier then turned to me and told me to wait and left to go refill the peanut butter w/o taking my order. I stood for 4-5 minutes with the other staff looking awkwardly at me. I turned to leave and as I exited I looked back to see the manager taking someone else's order. Healthier alternatives and better services all around park slope! read more

One of the good things that's come out of NYC requiring chains to post their calorie count has been that I've stopped eating at chains and started eating locally. I walked into 5 Guys a while ago having not been for a while and saw that the fries were 700 calories and I was out of there in a second. I'll stick to eating greasy food in places that don't post calories, thank you very much. That said, I think the 5 Guys burger is good. It's not my idea of a burger-burger, but it fits into its own special category and its unique taste is pretty good. And the fries, for all their calories, are not so bad either. But it's all too pricey!! read more

I don't know what all the hype is about....this place is expensive and not all that......and can I get some fryers and burger with my salt!!! Food was so salty my 10 year old didn't want to eat it.....and that says a lot. Burger, hot dog, one fry with 2 small drinks.....21.00 ....it was like Citifield without the Mets!!!! read more

Go to five guys only if you are ravenous; you'll not be disappointed. Two patties, with all the trimmings! Greasy yes, but damn tasty too. The unlimited peanuts are a nice touch, and I always look to the whiteboard where they write from what US state today's potatoes came from. Order the small fries. You don't need a shopping bag of fries, which is the large order. (my cardiologist's appointment is on Tuesday, but this was sure as hell worth it) read more

I have been wanting to try Five Guys Burgers for ages because people kept saying the burgers were so delicious. Some people had even said the burgers were similar to In N Out Burgers. Well, I can tell you there is absolutely no comparison. More comparable to Wendy's. And although the customer service was really great, I was really disappointed. Everything was sooooo salty. I was dehydrated while eating even. The burger was just ok and eventhough it was nice to have free toppings, I believe toppings should be free anyway so it didn't sweeten the deal for me. I ordered fries, which was a huge mistake. They were so greasy that I could only eat a couple for fear I would puke pure oil. After I ate my cheeseburger and two fries I took a little afternoon siesta and awoke an hour later with my lips stuck to my teeth due to the driest dry mouth ever. I Really don't see what all the fuss is about. Oh, and as you approach the counter to place your order, you are greeted by a security monitor displaying a "camera adds ten pounds" version of yourself which was most unflattering and probably the last thing I want to see before I order a cheeseburger and fries. read more

This is my favorite place to get a quick burger and fry meal. The burger is always cooked correctly and the fries are always good too. The strategy at Five Guys is to order the "little fry" because it's the cheapest and in the end they put more fries as well. The service is always good and I will definitely be going again soon! read more

I had the small cheeseburger and fries. Both were filling and delicious. After a bad experience of Paul's, I gave burgers another chance and I'm in love with burgers once again! They also had tons of toppings to go with your burger, such as mushrooms, peppers, onions, tomatoes, lettuce, etc. You don't get that anywhere else now. The fries were not also just any fries, they were frites, which was even better. They also offer free peanuts to go with your meal. All in all, it was worth my 8 bucks. read more

I used to work at a Five Guys in South Carolina. I haven't eaten there since 2007. It was good going back and tasting the food again. I can say that it's pretty much tastes the same as it did years ago. Nothing really was added to the menu and everything is fresh. I don't mind paying a bit more at this place. Quality is always #1 and it's always consistent. I always get mine "All the Way" which has grilled onions and mushrooms, mustard/Ketchup, lettuce, mayo, tomatoes and pickles. Always good, all the time. read more

I love 5 guys. My husband and I have been to the Park Slope location and Bay Ridge location. Super clean place, lots of space, friendly staff. The fries are Wonderful!! The burgers yummy and not fancy! Just how we like them. You can get toppings ie-pickles, onions etc... They have free peanuts too! Can't beat this place! We love it! My hubby cannot stop raving about it! read more