Visited for a second time last night. I had some family in from the suburbs for dinner and thought it would be nice to stop there for a slice of pie afterwards. We arrived at 8:30pm and by the time we were done ordering and paying it was 8:35pm. We were told that because the shop closes at 9pm we could not stay to eat the pie that we had just purchased. We hadn't planned on staying long, probably just 10 more minutes. This was very frustrating and a little embarrassing. Telling paying customers that they can't sit in the dining room shows poor customer service. I understand that you can't stay open all night but if the sign on your door states that you're open until 9pm then you should not turn away paying customers who want to eat in your dining room before that time. I won't be returning. read more

Pie is of similar quality to Hoosier Mama, though I give HM the edge overall...their pies are taller and the slices wider, just more pie and a better deal. Main issue with First Slice is the size of the slice...sometimes it feels appropriate, other times it's kind of dinky. Once I got a slice of French Silk, but the one they gave me was notably smaller (by 20-30%) than the slices in the case. I didn't say anything but felt a little resentful. It happened again recently, and I actually asked them "Can I have a slice more like that one [in the case]? This looks really small." They honored this request without a fuss but, come on, use a template to slice your pies so pieces are the same size. read more

FUCK THIS PLACE. Seriously, they turned me away 15 minutes before closing when all I wanted was a slice of pie. I've would have been fired for trying to pull that at any of the food service places I have ever worked. I could see it maybe if I had wanted something complicated or messy but one slice of pie? Cleaning that knife would have made them get home so much later? I know people bitch a lot on yelp but seriously, I have never encountered anything like that in my life. What is the point of having a closing time if they just stop taking simple orders whenever they feel like it's time to go home and watch some Netflix. It's freakin pi day - 3/14/16. Give me a slice of pie you horrible people! read more

Stopped here for lunch the other afternoon on my own. While my food was pretty good, the service was very cold and made me feel unwelcomed. I usually don't read too much into off service since I have worked in the industry before but this was pretty bad. Not one word was said to me while ordering and my plate was slammed on the table when delivered. I really wanted to like this place, it's super cute, reasonably priced and the menu looks great. Maybe I will try their other location on Ravenswood and hopefully get better service. read more

First Slice is now open for business and was very busy over the weekend. Some what of a different concept than we thought. At first it appeared that it would be a membership based weekly meals program only; however they built out the former flower shop into a cafe. Sweets, sandwiches and coffee can be ordered and either enjoyed at a table or taken with. The staff was very friendly, when we inquired about the meals they clearly outlined the process and explained the price. At no time did we feel pressured to join. This is a great addition to Andersonville and we look forward to returning. read more

I was really looking forward to trying the pie out today... the counterperson was very friendly! Then when I saw the yummy looking pies in the deli glass I picked two... Then my nice counter guy picked two sad tiny pieces out of the upright fridge... (was it me or both plastic containers together felt extremely "light". I got back to the car and popped open the cherry pie to taste pretty good filling and slightly dry crust..(perhaps from being entombed in its sad slice plastic sarcophagus). All in all, was "ok" but definitely have had better Cherry pie. For 10 bucks for two slices... you better be some REALLY good, non-hobbit sized slices of pie. As an aside note... a friend turned me on to the Cherry pie from Patti Labelle..(store bought???) it was insanely good and universally liked... First slice might want to step up its game for a $5 slice. :) read more

Amazing pie!! Super friendly employees and on Pi day they were so prepared and efficient! Definitely going back for the key lime.

Usually I prefer cake to pie, but was intrigued to try this place for dessert after driving by it so many times. We finally visited on an early Friday summer evening after dinner. First off, it was hot as Hades in there, maybe because the store faces West and gets a lot of afternoon and setting sun. The server was kind enough to answer our questions and tell us what slices were available as some of them didn't have labels. We split a slice of the French Silk and the Coffee Toffee and opted to sit outside where it was cooler. The French Silk was rich and creamy while the Coffee definitely had a kick of caffeine...I had to wait to eat the rest of it the next day since I was afraid it'd keep me up all night. read more

I've been coming here for years. They have great customer service. Cozy cafe. I love how they give back to the community. All the dishes I've had have been wonderful. read more

I really like this spot. It's cute and cozy. Great salads and of course great pie. It's not very big but to me that's part of the appeal. They also have cookies and bars and other food items like sandwiches. I tried several pies but my favorite was a blueberry cheescake pie. Very good. I suspect I'll be stopping here quite often. read more

I ended up here 3 times so far and have been impressed every time. First time was during their soft opening... doors open to let air in and the customers just came flooding in! The peanut butter chocolate pie is spectacular. The second time was for dessert the following week with a few friends. Everyone liked their pie of choice and the 3rd time was on Pi day. Hey sit down have lunch and just happen to be there at 3:14pm Yay for free Cherry pie! The sandwich was great just wish they put in the description that mustard is put on the bread... A mustard surprise is not my fave. read more

When it comes to a slice of pie, just like Bakers Square, you sure do not get much for your money here. A tiny piece of pie, and really not that good either. read more

I would have given this place 4 stars had I not been served a piece of frozen pie and told to wait 5 minutes for it to thaw out by the dude with all the different color painted fingernails. At least exchange it for another flavor!! My table had already ordered 2 other slices of pie that were just fine. Lack of customer service and lack of common sense is all it takes for me to never go back. To bad because I really try, and go out of my way to support local small business. Good Luck!! read more

The best. Service can be uneven in terms of speed, but they're always friendly. The mission and food are great, as are the drink options. Wish they opened earlier! read more

I've been coming here for a few years now, and I'm sad about what's it's become. The food is terrific. The pie and salads are great, and I love the lasagna and the tamales as well. The service has gone from charming and friendly to desultory, insulting, and pushy. The nice people who used to work during the afternoon definitely don't fill the evening shift. My partner and I went in to sit down for a quick dessert, because we love the pie. Without asking whether we wanted them to go, the slices were unceremoniously dumped into plastic take-out containers, even though it was still a long way from closing. The server didn't even bother with utensils, giving us the opportunity to take our pie home rather than having the relaxing dessert we were looking forward to. There are other places to have a good dessert in Andersonville, and I actually feel like a customer at those places, rather than an intrusion. I hope the owners/managers get a grip on this problem. Your food is too good to have your staff driving people to other shops. My run of spending time there is probably over for a while, until the attitudes are a bit more friendly. read more

I'm updating to say that the best item I've eaten here isn't even pie. Get a lemon bar. GET IT. Damn, this is the best lemon bar I've ever had. Save me a corner piece, though. Thanks. read more

I met a friend here for dinner, and we unfortunately didn't try any of their pies, but I will be back! I ordered the harvest salad which came pear, garbanzo beans, candied pecans, pepitas and bleu cheese. If I ordered this again, I would have left the pear off and gotten the dressing on the side. Overall it was a fairly large salad, and everything else tasted fresh. My friend ordered a panini of some sort, and it looked excellent. They have a very unique give-back program with their meal subscriptions that help to feed the homeless. I love great food with a cause. read more

I was not too impressed. I tried French silk pie and the peach blueberry crumble, and peanut butter. Nothing special.

Warning, this place is highly addictive and good for society! Wait ,besides driving you to workout to work off a slice of pie I cannot find anything wrong with this place. It's kitschy , with awesome food and better service . Great spot for a cup of coffee also and better pricing than the "big S" down the street. I encourage you to stop in for a slice ...but you've been warned! read more

Best pie I've ever had and I don't even like pie. The crust is heavenly light, the chocolate is light, the sour cherry is amazing, not your usual cloyingly sweet, but just right. Makes you wanna go there and have pie all the time! read more

This is my first time here at First slice, I will be back! Great ambience, friendly staff! The coffee is colectivo and is great, I had a cafe au lait, the milk was foamed to perfection. We over did on foodstuffs. The devious, and beautiful redhead and I shared : broccoli and cheddar quiche ( firm, light great flavor, good texure), beef barbacoa sandwich (on ciabatta roll had avocado on it which I enjoy! Good flavorful sandwich) both the sandwich and quiche came with a very delicious side salad of mixed greens and granny Smith apples. It was lightly and expertly dressed. Now for the sweets.. Wow! Great, awesome pies! We shared slices of key lime, strawberry rhubarb, coffee toffee! Yes we overdid it! The key lime was light flavorful, not over sweet delicious! My favorite. The devious & beautiful, loved the coffee toffee the best. The strawberry rhubarb was very good, with great crust, and delicious filling, you won't go wrong with any of them. We also sampled a lemon heart cookie, and a mocha walnut biscotti! Both of these are AWESOME! Light, delicious, there is a reason we overdid it! . The also help feed homeless and hungry, that is part of their mission statement. So to sum it all up, Come here, eat the food, drink the coffee, partake of the sweets and pies! If you are in the Andersonville area make this a go to place for casual atmosphere , awesome food, and wonderful pie and sweets! I know I will! read more

Ordered two pies from here (both were mini in size) but great for sharing among a couple of people. We tried the key lime and chocolate cream and both were great! This location is in harder to find location but I would come back in a heartbeat when I need my next pie fix. read more

Really really good apple pie, not too sweet generous apples. Very friendly staff. Worth a detour

This is a cute place, had dinner up north and needed something sweet, but didnt want ice cream. So yelped and didn't steer me wrong. You walk in and can tell the place is original, original floors, and their furniture are from old school chairs and desk like tables. Menu isn't extensive but what we had was good. We had a slice of the strawberry rhubarb pie and the balsamic raspberry pear pie. Both were delicious. Neither were top sweet, just enough with some fanciness in both, nice flakey crusts. I would go back if I was in the area, since I'm closer to bang bang pie, I wouldn't make the drive. read more

best pie place. love the vibe here. people are so friendly, oh and the sandwiches are amazing too, with an affordable price. and I love how they support local artists, look at all the arts on the wall! so cute! read more

So far, they have the best french silk and key lime pie I've ever had =)

Super cute spot. Yummy pies. I had the peach and blueberry. I've also had the chocolate peanut butter pie which is out of this world. I keep waiting for them to have the grasshopper because yum! read more

Best warm turkey sandwich of my life and moist, flourless peanut butter cookie that made me see heaven.

Pies are always on point, coffee is always fresh, so many different flavors to choose from and their service is great. Glad they're in the neighborhood read more

Great spot for a snack, coffee, lunch meet-up, spot to watch the world go by on a rainy day. No reservations necessary! Oh and the pie. Where do I begin? Key lime and blueberry cheesecake are winners but the top prize goes to coconut pistachio. It's so good that if you find a kinky black hair in your pie slice (as I did last night), you will only recoil in disgust for a minute before deciding to keep eating but carefully avoiding the spot of shame. No judgment, please. read more

This place was incredible. The service was awesome and the food was incredible! The pie reminded me of my grandmas homemade pie! The goat cheese and pear sandwich was super tasty as well. They were out of the pie I wanted and offered me a free slice next time they have it! I would recommend this to anyone for many different occasions! You have to go! read more

Love the vibe of this place and always a great slice of pie! Nice outdoor area and good choice of tea.

Dropped by on the way home after shopping. Service was fast and friendly. I bought a slice of creamy chocolate and pistachio pie and a slice of vegan carrot cake to go - I ate them later and I am very impressed. Both were quite excellent! I will return, gladly read more

If you're headed to First Slice for pie, don't bother. For a place that claims to specialize in pie, you'd expect that they might have a few to choose from. Nope. Not this "pie" place. I arrived last weekend and this "pie" place had only one type of pie to offer ... apple. Really?? You call yourself a pie place and the pie you have is apple? Apples aren't even in season. And good luck if you want to actually pick up a pie without ordering in advance. The apple pie they offered up was the ONLY pie they had available (and was partially eaten). I will not be headed back. read more

I had the apple pie, it was awful. You could have poured cinnamon apple sauce into that crust and received a more wonderful treat. I selected it based on the light airy look of the crust and the beauty of the Golden brown. I got my apple pie to go, looking forward to enjoying this wonderful treat before bed... I went to bed disappointed :-( read more

Just moved in the area and my landlord told me this place had divine pies. She told the truth! Me and my girlfriend wanted a second piece so bad to go, but we knew better! GREAT place! read more

The pie isn't as good as Hoosier Mama pie (where you can pick a random slice of pie and be quite certain it will be the best pie you've ever had), but this is a really wonderful, warm, cozy space with friendly people and great coffee (even great decaf). read more

I tried this place in June, and it was scrumptious. I had a slice of cherry pie a la mode and a buffalo chicken wrap. First things first, pie was just right. Not too sweet and so much filling, crust was made well too. The wrap was great, the guy at the counter suggested it and I switched blue cheese for ranch last minute. They were totally cool with that and checked to make sure I received my chips. Very attentive and all the pies look great. Especially French silk, must go back! read more

We previously bought a pie as a gift but did not try it, so the pumpkin pie we ordered for home today was our first taste. All three of us agreed it was mediocre - the texture of the filling was a little strange (too soft) and it was not nearly sweet enough. At any price this was a disappointment, for $25 a BIG disappointment. We would be unlikely to patronize again, at least not for the pies. read more

Absolutely amazing apple pie, blueberry cheesecake pie, raspberry chocolate pie, pecan pie, and key lime pie. Their cookies are also pretty good. Coffee is fresh, staff is SUPER nice and friendly. We love coming here for a quick and tasty dessert paired with a cup of coffee and taking it all on a stroll around Andersonville! Come here- you'll truly enjoy it! read more