Best pizza crust and combo of ingredients we've had ever! Traveling through town back to Michigan and stumbled across this fantastic pizza. And don't get me started about the "Sweet Caroline" dessert! Just wow! Their version of a Hawaiian pizza, the "Hulu", is perfect. Just the right amount of pineapple, cheese, ham and sauce. Great job by Connor too! This pizza place alone, is almost sufficient reason to move to Amarillo Texas. Seriously! read more

Highlights - thin crust specialty pizza (fire slice combo), fresh toppings, quick delivery, safety precautions (delivery person wearing a mask) Room for growth - calamari was a bit disappointing- I kept thinking it was mozzarella sticks but it was edible. Stick to the pizzas and you won't be disappointed. Next time I'm in town I want to try a panini! read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

Had a party of 11 for Father's Day. Wife and I ordered large supreme pizza, after a 30 minute wait they came back to us with a meat lovers. Had to sit and watch everyone else eat while then undercooked us another pizza. On top of that of the 11 orders only 6 were correct. Never again don't waste your time. read more

Just passing through. Staying in nearby hotel.. Found them on Yelp ... actually they were hard to find ! Haha !! They are on the back side in an ally !!! Anyways I called my order in 5 minutes to closing! The guy on the line was super cool and was very accommodating. (It being closing time and all! ) anyways meat lovers pizza and boneless wings !! Superb !!! Great dinner ! So happy with it . If I lived in Amarillo this would be my pizza spot ! read more

This is literally a Gem in the Rough! We have a difficult time finding it.. & almost gave up! We are glad we didn't. The food was yummy. The environment is on the dark side (not very brightly lit) & noisy;don't go expecting great conversation bonding! . BUT the staff was great! They were friendly & very helpful/understanding when my son spilled that LARGE cup of water EVERYWHERE! So glad we found this "hole in the wall" while we were traveling. read more

Amazing pizza and great new owner that cares about the business from his heart. The improvements have been noticed. Owners wife works another job all day and still comes in after that job to help with everything and greet guests with a smile. I absolutely feel welcome when I walk in. The wine list is perfect. Many unique beers to try. All around love this place. Happy to have them in Amarillo read more

We were just passing through and found it on Yelp. It is on the backside of a strip center but easy to get to. Our server was great! The pizza is a wood fired thin crust with lots of toppings. We got a large for the two of us but definitely could have done the medium. I would definitely recommend it. read more

We came to se a friend of ours do a live music here, and we were so surprised by how amazing the service and food was. The owners and staff do an amazing job at engaging the customers and making even new customers feel like regulars. The food is also excellent, our table agreed that it was the best pizza we've had since moving to Amarillo. read more

3 pizza's ....carryout....$80....hardley any toppings and barely any cheese on pizza. used to be my fav. not anymore

I was just passing through town on my way to CA, and found this restaurant on Yelp. I'm so glad I took a chance, because it was DELICIOUS!!! And the man who gave me my pizzas was so nice and courteous. If you like great crust, get pizza here, you won't be sorry! read more

When first coming across this restaurant it looked very good and promising. Service was good nothing bad to say about that. My wife and I were surprised they had wings for a appetizer so we ordered the 4 count boneless wings. The first 2 wings we had weren't bad at all very good to be honest, then I took a bite of the 3rd one and seen it was raw all in the middle!! When I came across that raw chicken I lost all hope for this restaurant, I've been to some bad places but I've never received raw chicken. Once we were done eating they gave us a refund on the wings since they were raw. The pizza really does look great , the problem was that picking up a slice made everything slide right off the crust. A little hard to eat but over all the pizza wasn't that bad. The calzone wasn't the best either it didn't look to appetizing but that could've just been me. So overall review I would not recommend this to anyone unless you want to try a place that really is a hit or miss establishment. read more

See all

Location is oddly located but so worth the find. Wide variety of pizza choices. We enjoyed the Hula. The crust is thin and sauce is light. A small was shared between my husband, daughter and I. We also had a Caesar salad and Monte Cristo. Left full and happy. read more

You have to be bat-crap crazy if you think this place is comparable to 575 Pizzeria. Yes, offense. For months, I've heard about Fire Slice. Its supposed to be cheaper and "just as good" as 575 Pizzeria. Well, one particular night after a long day of work I just felt like not cooking and picking up a pizza and some of those sweet-potato fries! I called in my order and they told me it would take about 15 minutes. The location of this restaurant is terrible. Look for a shopping plaza and then go BEHIND it and you'll find a hole in the wall entrance for FireSlice. The parking lot is essentially the alleyway behind this building. I ordered "The Rudy"($13) - a white pizza (no sauce) with shredded mozzarella, smoked bacon, roasted crimini mushrooms and spinach. I also ordered an order of the Sweet Potato Fries ($5) which are served with a house-made green chile mayo. The first thing I noticed about the pizza - it's small! Sure, this is a cheaper pizza, but this is ridiculous! It's already a super thin crust and it's stretched out to like, 14 inches. That's it? Also, it was HARD. They overcooked the pizza and it was burnt and blackened on the bottom. This made for a bitter and rock hard crust. Ew. The toppings were also scorched. The spinach was dried out and the cheese tasted smokey. Just a terrible pizza all around. The sweet potato fries were the redeeming factor of the meal. They were super crispy and not overly seasoned. The green chile mayo was divine! I will always pick 575 Pizzeria over this place. Always. Pros: plenty of seating Cons: awful location, pizza was tiny and really overcooked read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - "the rudy" notice the burnt underside and the overcooked veggies - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

My husband and I drive through Amarillo from OKC to get to our property in NM. We stop in Amarillo overnight to break up the drive. We stopped here on a whim to try something new. What an excellent choice. We ordered some of our favorite beers, calamari, and a small honeybomb pizza to share. The combination of flavors was superb. I never thought honey on a pizza would've been good. But it was fabulous. I love the mix of sweet and spicy. I'll be back again and next time, I'll ask for extra jalapeños. Highly recommend. read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

This is a hidden gem! We had a little trouble locating the place as it is on the back side of the shopping center. We arrived at 1pm on a Saturday and each ordered the lunch combo. I had the house salad and the wife had the ceasar both were good. After what seemed like a long time our waiter showed up apologizing and explained the kitchen accidentally overcooked the first set of pizzas and they were remaking them. I had the Tommy Boy and the wife had the Hot Mama. Both were about 10" in diameter (lunch sized) and really delicious. Because of the delay in remaking the pizza, the waiter provided free dessert. We had a mini pecan pie with ice cream and a mini pumpkin pie. Overall a greatly experience and I would be happy to eat here again. read more

My boyfriend and I have been here numerous times & it's a hidden gem. Just letting you know it's a little difficult to find as it is in the back of the building (Follow Chop Chop drive thru) When you enter the business the bar that seats about 5 is on your left the waiting area is to your immediate right and they have a party room to the right of that too. The hostess stand is in that area. They have a large dinning area as it is split into different area. I would say every table has their own privacy, which helps with hearing other conversations. All of the waitress are friendly and very attentive, shout out to Jamie & Becky. My boyfriend and I have found our favorite pizza "The Rudy" and finally tried the S'mores Calzone. We have tried a few other pizzas, the ravioli, and Caprese salad. They also have gluten free options available. I have not tried the take out. PRO - variety of dining tables (circle, square, long tables) - pizza, pasta, sandwiches & yummy dessert! - plenty of parking - happy hour M-F from 5pm-7pm - gluten free options - kid options CON - difficult to find when first looking. "Hard to find... Easy to love" read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - The Rudy - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

See all

I've been avoiding Pizza for a long time because of the calories and that it's not as nutritious as other foods but I saw they had a daily special for $7 and half price desserts on Tuesdays so I decided to try it. I've been twice now and haven't been disappointed. The girl that took my order is super nice. As of today, 7 / 18 / 20, they aren't offering indoor dining yet because of the virus but it's worth it to come in and get the take out. I just drove over to a local park and sat and ate half my pizza while I enjoyed the pleasant weather. It wasn't that hot that particular day. If you don't order ahead the pizza will take 15 or 20 minutes but I wasn't in a hurry so I didn't mind. They seem to have a lot of people that do call ahead because several people came in and picked up their Pizzas while I was waiting. I happened to come in during their closed period the second time. I forgot they close at 2 and reopen at 5 so I did some grocery shopping at Natural Grocers while I waited for 5 to roll around. Now that I've been a couple times on Tuesday so I'll have to come in on another day of the week so I can try some other varieties of pizza. And I should mention that the pizza was just as good the second day when I ate my leftovers. read more

Best pizza I have found in Amarillo. Good toppings, good crust. I had it delivered to my hotel room and it was still excellent(Not as good as when I eat there, but still excellent). I recommend the goodfella pizza. It's my personal favorite and a meat lovers delight. read more

I'm serious about pizza. I have a complicated relationship with it but I still eat a lot of it. I'm a vegetarian and I look for healthy options. Thin crust pizza can be healthy, and that's what I was going for here. Maybe because it was $35.00 I expected a little more than that. That was downright skimpy. Not worth the money. Well-cooked. But not worth $35. read more

Hubs and I stopped by while driving through Amarillo... if you're on a road trip and not exactly feeling Subway or other fast food options, give this local pizza place a try. It's a little challenging to get to, especially with the construction on 34. The sign is also hard to see, but after a few mixups we finally found it! (it's tucked behind the main shopping center...) The waiter was super helpful even though they were closing in 30 minutes. They have a great selection of craft brews... Breckinridge, Great Divide, and such. If you stop by during lunch, they have specials - $8.99 personal pizza or calzones. This place seems to having an identity crisis as you walk in... looks super divey on the outside, but decent artsy decor and comfy formalish chairs. Great place to stop by on your way through town! read more

We had trouble finding the place, and almost went elsewhere, but it's in the back where you would only expect employee parking for the shopping plaza. It looks very sketchy from the outside but it's actually pretty cute on the inside. That said, for us it was really just "ok". Our waitress was great - service was probably the best thing about our visit. Clearly we had a different waitress than whoever was previously complaining about service because our server was friendly and very attentive, our water filled many times. We ordered an 18" pizza for two adults and two teenage boys. Although it looks like a big pizza, it's really not very filling. All four of us were still hungry after the pizza. The crust is pretty thin and very crisp with no grease at all (which actually detracts from the flavor, you gotta have a little grease for flavor though you don't want the pizza dripping with it). Strangely enough even though they advertise as "brick oven pizza" they don't have a brick oven - they have what appears to be a standard metal pizza oven that's in clear view. Hmm... unless it's brick on the inside? A little odd. They also advertise their meatballs and sausage We ordered both of these on our pizza. There were a few extremely thin strips of meat, honestly couldn't tell which was sausage and which was meatball as there were so few and they were cut so thin. Although I was reassured by our server that they had black olives in addition to kalamata...what came out on my pizza were kalamata (which I would not have ordered, hence why I tried to clarify). I will give her the benefit of the doubt and assume she just didn't realize that though kalamata olives are kind of dark in color they have a very different flavor than standard pizza black olives. So as you can tell, I wasn't really enthralled with the pizza. I did like the three cheese blend on it and the sauce was ok. The price was not bad at all - $26 for our 18 inch with three toppings - but would have been better if the toppings had been more generous and if we weren't still hungry -- we ended up picking up tacos across the street on our way back to our hotel. But, they get credit for not having a generic Sysco taste even though they were way too skimpy with ingredients. We were just passing through town so can't speak as to whether the oft-compared 575 is better or worse, but to us, this pizza was just ok and not really a destination next time we pass through. read more

I was looking for a Gluten Free option for lunch and yelp popped this little gem up. I love to try new places and I love pizza! It was a little hard to find because it is behind a shopping mall, but it is worth the search! Unlike many pizza places where pepperoni is your best gluten free choice, there were so many creative flavors. I ordered the Americana which was chicken, spicy bbq sauce, cheese , onions, cilantro, bacon and more! So yummy with a slight kick! I will be back! read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

We were in town for one night for travel. So tired after driving all day so we decided to have pizza delivered to the hotel. We chose Fire Slice because of the good reviews. We weren't disappointed. Pizza was huge and so delicious! read more

This was my first shot at TX pizza lol. I'll save the "Im from NY" spiel lol but, it was good. I'm not gonna complain, it was pretty tasty.

OMG this Calzone is soooo goood!!! Wonderful ambiance, great food, wonderful selection of beer and wine picked by their level 2 Sommelier, Cody! Definitely get over here and enjoy amazing brick oven pizza and all the fixins! read more

Fire Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Amarillo, Texas

Our first visit! Wow!! Great pizza! Pleasant environment! Service was excellent!! We will def be back. Thanks for a good birthday lunch for me! read more

I have been testing a few pizza shops around town to find the one that makes me think Italian, New York pizza. The Rudy I had was delicious, I would only put much less bacon on the pizza it was too greasy soaking into the box. read more

Their margarita pizza is the BEST hands down in town. Also, tried their wings (traditional) tonight for the first time and holy crap!! Sooooo good! They use a house made sauce that is just so delicious. They should make the wings an entree!! read more

thank you agian "matt" for another wonderful evening! the food was great and the service was amazing. you consistantly knock it out of the park. this is why we frequent fire slice! see you soon! ... read more

Fire Slice Pizza, I have heard many good reviews of this place but my last few times going there have been less than what I was expecting -- I really wanted to love it because I loved the vibe and the people that worked there. The service is slow if there is more than a few tables that are busy. Everytime my server has always been nice and always gives the first ranch free, but normally it's extra and I think that's a travesty! The pizza is good, but not the best and not something I'd rave over. Even after I had my first few sub-par experiences, I kept going back because I really wanted to like it. But I am now coming to terms with myself, that it's a but pricey, not the absolute best craft pizza I've had, nor is it the best service. Though, they do deliver and my lazy self has to give them bonus points for that so overall a 3.5 star rating but I'm keeping it as 3 stars since that was my gut-feeling. read more

Sometimes we forget about the hidden gem that is Fire Slice. After Christmas Eve service we hit up the back alley pizzeria and are so glad we did. We had the best service we have had in a very long time. read more

Excellent New York Style Pizza, very very good. A little hard to find, it is behind the stop mall in what would normally be the loading dock area, but well worth the search. read more

This place was incredible, the wings, pizza, and desserts were all really good. Definitely try the Honeybomb, so great!!! They gave great customer service to boot! read more

Giving this place 4 stars. My Cesar salad had little to none parmesan. I'm used to a cesar salad having great croutons and plenty of parmesan. Dressing was very good though. Pizza crust is best I've had, but toppings for margarita pizza could be better. Also ordered a greek salad and per my wife, best greek salad and pizza she has had. Dressing for greek was outstanding. read more

Once you find it, you'll be hooked! Creative combinations featuring seasonal ingredients!

The calzone was just ok and was a bit burnt on the bottom. I wouldn't go back because it wasn't great.

Had a stop over in Amarillo and found this location. We went and picked it up and had a conversation with the owner while we waited for our food. Nice guy. We were definitely pleased with the food. My wife and I split the cauliflower crust pizza, my son had a small pepperoni pizza, and my daughter had the baked ravioli. If we stop in Amarillo again, we will go back. read more

On a business trip and craving pizza. This restaurant had so many great reviews that I had to try it. Pizza was delicious! Staff was friendly, restaurant had a great vibe. Definitely coming back! read more

Very yummy! Hard to find, it is literally down an ally behind a shopping center. Outside smelled like raw sewage, it was so bad. Inside smelled like fart. We sat in the back & it was bearable. Pizza was very yummy & pasta was ok. Atmosphere is chill & price point reasonable. Wait staff was good & quick & friendly. A great find for just passing through on a road trip. read more

This place did not disappoint! Amazing pizza and great wings too! We got the 18inch goodfella pie, the meats were finely sliced and you didn't have to add anything to the pizza it was great alone! For the wings we got their original house sauce, great light mix of sweetness and spiciness. We had to do take out due to COVID-19 but take out did not disappoint!!!! We didn't take any pictures because once we started eating we couldn't stop! It is a must if you're ever in Amarillo! read more