I've ordered from here many times and they have always been great. Today, they were extremely busy and unfortunately a couple of my items on the order were wrong. The order was brought back, they corrected the issue and gave a full refund. Mistakes happen, especially when busy but how they handled it was exceptional. Thank you guys. I will always support. read more

I've eaten here a few times. Food is always great, very consistent on the taste. Staff is friendly and helpful. Nice open area, small sit down area for you to have your food. Love both the quarter chicken meal and these new tenders are terrific. Sides are also amazing, I've had the broccoli, green beans, and coleslaw often, really tasty. read more

FIRE Roasted Chicken & Grill - Chicken Tender Platter - Barbeque Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

We have ordered from here several times. The food is always great, highly recommend!!

Pass this on a regular basis, figured let me try it out. Only positives was the chicken was hot (temperature wise) & the broccoli was decent. Besides that, not worth the $19.25 for half a chicken with two sides. No flavor, I mean besides the little bit of spices added to the skin, the chicken itself had no flavor. Chicken was fresh, so fresh it still had two feathers attached to it. Sweet potato mashed was ok, but not good. Place looks & feels tired, sorta like they're giving up. Wont be going back. It's average all the way around. I'm being generous with 3 stars. read more

FIRE Roasted Chicken & Grill - Barbeque Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

Have ordered from here multiple times during my lunch break. Their chicken is well seasoned and never dry. They also have a variety of sides to choose from and they're all delicious. The workers there are also very nice and never gave me a problem. The food is reasonably priced and portioned. read more

It was good, but nothing special. If there isn't a Boston Market local to you-- this will do.

I have to say I was pleasantly surprised today when I stopped in at Fire Roasted for lunch. There's not a lot to the restaurant, just a line to order and a few tables. Ordering is somewhat similar to Boston Market where you order chicken and a couple of sides. I wound up ordering a crispy chicken sandwich, but the sides with the chicken (especially the Mac & cheese) looked very good...next time! When I first saw the sandwich my reaction was that it was pretty small for $6+, however, once I started eating, I found it was packed with delicious chicken! Loved the pickles on the sandwich too! The restaurant is located in a convenient shopping center with plenty of parking. Service was friendly. I'll definitely be back! read more

FIRE Roasted Chicken & Grill - Another new lunch stop! - Barbeque Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

WOW WHAT A RIP OFF! 16$$ dollars for crap bun sandwich. I got the spicy chicken sandwich with two sides and got ripped off again for a 3$$ road soda. (that a soda to go). now chicken was favorable but the bun must have been purchased from Shoprite in the 99 cent section. the sides were mac and cheese and mashed potatoes. both flavorless. clearly out of a Kraft mac and cheese box with bland potatoes and topped with gravy that taste like cat piss. Will not be going back I hope they go out of business for waisting not only my time but my hard earned money. I will be going to Shop Rite and getting a sandwich the size of big foots forearm for 8$. read more

First of all getting tire of my phone battery going dead by the time dinner comes. Lol decided to order from here today and support a local business. I went through the menu and got the Grilled Chicken Platter which contained Marinated char-grilled boneless chicken breast with corn bread and two sides for a good prince of $10.80 All that I have to say was the the chicken was perfectly cooked, seasoned well and had a juicy succulent bite after bite all the way to the end. The cool thing I liked as well was that the chicken was over a leaf of lettuce and those juices got on that lettuce and I felt like I was eating a good chicken salad. For the sides I got waffle fries and some corn and I must say it all hit the spot after a long day of work and meetings. read more

First time here. Grubhubbed tonight and was pretty good. I got a chicken wrap with avocado which was hot & fresh. Had sides of macaroni and cheese along with garlic potatoes. Ordered creamed spinach but was out. With a cucumber salad side and nice size chocolate chip cookie. Will definitely go back again. read more

FIRE Roasted Chicken & Grill - Barbeque Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

Want to start by saying the food here deserves 3.75 stars. Food taste is very good , but prices are high, with unusually small sizes/ portions. The grilled chicken sandwich was tiny. As in, a third larger than a White Castle cheeseburger. The chicken wrap tasted great , but was just adequate in size. Same for the Cobb Salad. So the basic takeaway is small sizes , high prices, but great quality chicken. They are also skimpy with the sides. Certainly NO heaping portions here! If you are dining in, the decor is totally "Spartan-like" or bare bones. CANT BELIEVE NO FOUNTAIN SOFT DRINK MACHINE IN THE PLACE and just a partially filled beverage fridge tucked away way behind the counter. Also lots of wasted space in the the place . The food "buffet type " sides display counter doesn't do the food any justice . Needs to be perfect and look full all the time . I do have to say it is better than Boston Market, quality wise . My message to the owner is stop being stingy on the portions and get fountain soda ! Our bill for two sandwiches and a salad was $26. read more

I have been going to Fire for years, it has become of one of our regular spots for take out. But recently we have noticed a decline in the quality of the food. I recently got an avocado wrap with grey avocado inside (I took two bites and threw the rest out). They have started giving smaller portions, and their corn bread (which we used to love) is stale and hard as rock. I don't think we'll be going back any time soon. It's a shame because this place was really good. I hope they can turn it around read more

FIRE is a decent place to get standard American fare for a good price. The food is either delicious or average, and the meat options are quite good. We dined in for lunch and tried the 1/4 chicken dark with cucumber salad and garlic parsley potatoes, the waffle fries, and the 6 ribs with mashed potatoes and mac & cheese. Waffle fries are fine, but the mashed potatoes and mac & cheese are nothing more than mediocre and bland. The chicken was good, and the ribs are flavorful but fatty. (My dining partner liked this about them, though.) Corn bread was fantastic, and the cucumber salad and garlic parsley potatoes are both fantastic sides - I'd highly recommend them. The place is great for a bite for very good prices. Menu has quite the variety, so it's worth stopping by if you're close. read more

See all

WOW!!! WHAT A RIP OFF!!! The pulled pork sandwich I had was as tiny as junior burger from Wendy's, but with tax it cost more than 10$, no sides, no chips, not even a lousy slice of pickle. Had to wait for almost 10min for a fast food sandwich on the burger buns. The service was not good and the flavor was not great. I wouldn't recommend it. read more

FIRE Roasted Chicken & Grill - Pulled pork sandwich - Barbeque Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

Avacado wrap sandwich sooo good! I don't normally order wrap sandwiches hut it sounded so good and it was. I have ordered it 2 more times since my first visit. Thank you! read more

First time here! Easy to order online, menu was easy to follow. Food was ready on time and hot!! Place super clean and organized. Now the good. It's kind of like a so much better Boston Market. Food had much more flavor! I got 1/2 white, steamed veggies, side of Mac n cheese and cornbread. All was excellent, really good. My only complaint was that I wanted more bbq sauce. Would definitely come back again!! read more

Love this place. We go there for takeout all the time but they do have a few tables if you want to eat in. The rotisserie chicken is so delicious. It is crispy and juicy and perfectly cooked. The ribs are also incredible. They are seasoned to perfection and cooked beautifully with lots of meat on the bones. The side dishes are also delicious and freshly made every day. We also ordered for the first time a salad with cranberries and walnuts and it was unbelievable. When you order the food it is ready within 15 minutes. Don't miss this place if you love chicken and ribs and now they have fried chicken which I haven't tried yet but it looks delicious. read more

I haven't ordered from Fire Roasted in a while so when I picked up my meal I was shocked by the price increase. The #8 family meal used to be around $40. Now it's about $56!!! Quite a jump. The roasted chicken is alright. Nothing special. Definitely over salted. I would say that it falls somewhere in between average supermarket roasted chicken and Costco roasted chicken. Costco being a much better value, of course. The baby back ribs are average at best. Over sauced. Nothing original. The biggest issue are the sides. The mashed potatoes are 100% from a box. Watery and over salted. The steamed veggies were super basic and bland. Broccoli, cauliflower and carrots. The macaroni and cheese is definitely pre packaged. Almost like Velveeta. The corn bread was pretty weak as well. I don't understand why a place like this wouldn't make the sides from scratch. It's not rocket science. Mediocre quality and high prices are not a good combination. I doubt that I will return. Sorry. read more

I placed an order to be delivered from here and was not impressed. Their menu is identical to another restaurant in Wayne. I ordered half a chicken, stuffing, rice and string beans. The best part was the mini corn bread that comes with each meal. The sides were good, but the chicken was not cooked through. I can eat a medium rare steak but my chicken has to be cooked through. It still had pink parts in the inside and the skin was soggy Will not order from here again. read more

Ordered delivery through Yelp for lunch. We only live about 5 minutes away but somehow this delivery took over an hour. We ordered spicy chicken sandwiches which were decent; breaded chicken which seemed soaked in buffalo sauce, with a nice potato bun. The corn bread we ordered felt like it just came out of the freezer or a very cold fridge. Ordered a side of steamed vegetables, which were 90% raw still, which included what looks like cauliflower with spots of mold on it. Mac and cheese was decent as well, but tasted similar to what you'd get in a box. We've previously ordered from here in person, as well as through Uber Eats, for dinner and had no issues and really loved the food. (5 stars both times). Not sure what happened with today's order... read more

FIRE Roasted Chicken & Grill - Moldy cauliflower - Barbeque Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

I decided to try their fried chicken and it was very salty. No flavor and to my dismay after eating, it didnt take long and I had diarrhea. I will never go back again after being very sick. read more

So you think a place with chicken in it's name would know how to cook it. My daughter got takeout tonight and her chicken was not cooked all the way. So gross. She also said there was a hair in her food. Proceed with caution. read more

FIRE Roasted Chicken & Grill - a close up of a chicken and beans dish - Barbeque Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

Always a good meal. The family package prices are best- the chicken awesome. Also- their burgers are fantastic. I just feel like their sides are pricey for the portion size if you wants fries with your burgers and sandwiches. Bulk those puppies up! read more

Decided to try this place for the first time. This is definitely the last time as well. Paid $10 for an Avocado wrap that was barely 6 inches (32oz Hydroflask in picture for reference). First bite had way too much chipotle mayo in and no avocado until the other end of the wrap. The wrap itself was a 3/5 for taste, but I would give this a 0/5 if I could for the portion to money ratio. For the price I paid, I should've just went to Panera instead which is in the same complex. I feel like I got robbed and I'm still hungry... read more

FIRE Roasted Chicken & Grill - Avocado Wrap - Barbeque Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

I was in the plaza around lunch time and decided to try this spot out. We had the family meal that includes a whole chicken and 2 large sides. The chicken was moist and super juicy. For the sides we ordered the waffle fries and Mac and cheese. The waffle fries were crunchy and were really tasty. Overall this is similar to Boston market but fresher with better side options. I would recommend trying if you happen to be in the area. read more

It's pretty good, nothing to write home about. Chicken is the best thing, really well seasoned and tender/juicy. Ribs- "meh" standard treatment of "babyback" ribs with commercial BBQ sauce . Sides = out of the red n white "baked beans" canned, corn bread white and blue boxed mix level. Cole slaw.... eeeeww, too wet, too big of knife work, and blah flavor. Good thing is staff is bright eyed and bushy tailed to help. Need a soft drink fountain ( best investment for any quick food place) read more

Looks like this guy got greedy. Price has almost doubled, smaller portions, and horrible slow employees who can careless about your wait. Go elsewhere read more

I've been to the other location in Cedar Knolls but it was my first time at this one. I love the whole industrial look. They have chicken roasting over fire in the front window. Seating is limited. They must have opened recently because it wasn't too busy for lunch. I recently started a low carb diet so I couldn't get any of my usual favorites. The chipotle burger and ribs are a must if you aren't worried about the calories. But today I settled for the 1/4 dark chicken and a double order of broccoli. I'm a huge fan of their garlic broccoli and the chicken was juicy, tender and not overly salty like rotisserie chicken tends to be. I absolutely LOVE their fire sauce. Combined with the chicken, I was in heaven. Just a warning, it's got a kick. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking to get a quick great tasting meal. read more

See all

Excellent lunch choice. I compared it to Boston Market and enjoyed it. The half chicken platter is probably the better deal. read more

FIRE Roasted Chicken & Grill - 1/4 dark with two sides (sweet potatoes and Mac and cheese) with corn bread - Barbeque Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

Honestly really good every time! Mac and cheese is delicious, sides and wraps so good! A great addition to this area, very different and it tastes good as take out and stays fresh. Big fan and didn't think I would be! read more

LOVE this place. I come here probably a few times a month at this point. They have great choices in sides to go along with the roasted chicken. Kids meals are awesome too! They get two chicken drumsticks with one side AND cornbread. Can never go wrong here. Plus get the freshly baked cookies, they are AWESOMEEEE and scaringly addicting. read more

Excellent Rotisserie chicken and great Mac and cheese. Will definitely try again sometime.

Pleasantly surprised by this place. Ordered a rotisserie family meal (great price for a family of four) and the chicken was tender and moist. Mashed potatoes & mac n cheese were pretty good. I would compare it to Boston Market except I found the chicken had better seasoning here. I will definitely order from here again. I'm not too crazy having only cash or PayPal as pay option when ordering online. I suggest credit cards be an option. read more

Never got a chance to try the food, We ordered food and then found out they use postmates. 1 1/2 hours later postmates canceled the order (no drivers) you think Fire would delivery to help the customer ??? Called them got a person who can't speak good english - He was clueless. So for that reason good-bye Fire. read more

Excellent Homestyle Rotisserie Chicken with all fixins! $10.75 for a half chicken, two sides, and corn bread muffin. Cant beat the price for Good home cooked food. Not overly seasoned or salted. Nice Big Portions. read more

FIRE Roasted Chicken & Grill - Half Chicken, stuffing, mac and cheese, corn bread. Big Holmes got the same with mashed taters. - Barbeque Near Me - West Caldwell, New Jersey

The fried chicken was very salty. The mac and cheese tasted like it came from a box. The creamed spinach and corn bread was good, but the main parts of the meal were not. read more

Not too bad, but nothing amazing. First the vibe is kind of weird. Like someone's carpeted living room. Also you see the sides out but the sandwiches, wraps etc are all made in the back - would be a nice touch if you could see the food being prepared. I've had the chicken sandwich. Fried. The crisp exterior was loosely attached to the meat, so it was essentially falling off. Had Mac n cheese on the side which was very liquidy. They have a good variety of options though, and I haven't actually tried the roasted chicken pieces. read more

My whole family loves it here! It reminds me of a much better Boston Market. We love all the sides but sweet potatoes may be the best. The cornbread muffins are moist and tasty! Wish the sides were bigger portioned but you get enough meat that you will be full with some leftover. The BBQ sauce also amazing. 1/2 chicken and steak wraps are our usual order. read more

Amazing spot to grab a quick bite to eat. The service is great and the food is quality as well as healthy. There roasted chicken is incredible and maintains a lot of moisture. There sides are also great as well. They deliver too. Great spot and hope it sticks around as there are a lot of competitors near by. I think this blows them all out of the water. Definitely a must try if u live in the area and haven't been here yet. read more

This is a place I'm happy exists for the Caldwells. Speaking strictly to the rotisserie chicken and sides, this is essentially a non-chain Boston Market, and I mean that in a good way. The chickens are cooked well and at $10 for half a chicken, two sides, and cornbread, it is pretty reasonably priced. Factor in the hefty servings of everything... well, let's say you won't be snacking after the meal. For the sides, I really enjoyed the roasted garlic potatoes and creamed spinach (again, straight out of Boston Market). Garlic string beans were pretty tasty too. The cornbread here is in muffin form, and is a dense little critter that's pretty moist as well. It's a great option when the rotisserie chicken craving hits. read more